News
US to help Israel buy 4 more Iron Dome interceptors
Reuters
Published: 26.05.11, 07:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. IDF ground forces will also
stephen in New York   (05.26.11)
be in play, but next time doctrine and equipment will be appropriate to the mission. Iron Dome will not have to intercept 40,000 missiles. Hezbollah expects to fire missiles for weeks or months, but will have less than a week and will forfeit Lebanon south of the Litani.
2. Duh? Need more like 40, not 4....
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (05.26.11)
When the Pals unilaterally declare a state and get the perverts at the UN to approve, odds are that the conflict will spiral downwards into another violent series of confrontations. Not just "intifada #3", but Hezbollah will chip in from Lebanon to "help" their "brothers" (help them become martyrs is more like it). It's gonna be ugly, and probably protracted. And with Hezbollah firing from Lebanon and Fatah+Hamas firing from both the West Bank and Gaza, we're going to need a lot more that 6 batteries in total. Unless, of course, the Palestinians return to the negotiating table and work for peace through dialogue. But we already know that it's hard to keep a Palestinian terrorist down, and if they can't free their convicted murderers from jail in a Shalit deal, they're more than happy to add to the ranks and create lots of martyrs.
3. Correction to my #1
Stephen in New York   (05.26.11)
Iron Dome and David's Sling will not have to intercept 40,000 missiles.
4. While the min of finance is pinching
jason white ,   afula, israel   (05.26.11)
pennies, the enemies have increased their stockpiles of rockets and missiles. The knesset should order the min of fin to give enough money to the min of def to purchase a dozen more batteries. They should also order more rocket systems and missiles,purchase more fighter aircraft and bombs and missiles and order more artillery and ammo, as well as more armor.Now is the time to start to increase our firepower and make the I.D.F. more lethal.
5. Why the occupation will never end
Dov ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (05.26.11)
In case you were wondering why the occupation will never end, you have your answer right here. Israel depends on weapons development to survive economically. And what better way to test weapons than living test subjects...
6. #5: "Dov"---
EZ ,   US   (05.26.11)
Just bow much of Israels GDP is from their defense industry...since you said "the answer is right there". Also, you stated "live subjects"...which seems appropriate for someone with your line of reasoning. Uh, since when are ROCKETS considered "live" subjects? The rockets and mortars Hamas and Hezbollah fire are intended to kill innocent people and are hardly "live"...they're metal objects. We USED to simply blow the heck out of the area where the pals fire from, incurring collateral damage but we're just a tad more sophisticated a d CHOOSE to SPEND tons of money A: to save the lives of our civilians. And B: avoid collateral damage. The question isn't one of "occupation"...since we LEGALLY defeated the Arabs in multiple wars and since they balked at a pal state, THEY NEVER HAD ONE TO BE OCCUPIED...there goes your left wing "occupation"theory, right out the damn window "Dov". So, what's your suggestion bubbie? Give them something they turned down and still murdered thousands of Israelis over? Who started all of the wars and terror (be honest Dov boy...no propaganda, just the truth)? You have some serious issues and it's people like you who get people on both sides killed...with your propaganda bs. Shame on you. It would be nice if you lived in Iceland.
7. Hey Dov, snap out of it, bro!
HaifaGuy   (05.26.11)
8. to No.5: Just to remind you, this is a defensive system
Tomas ,   Slovakia   (05.26.11)
So maybe it's better to say that the Arab attacks on Israel will never end. What are Arabs without Israel? What unites them more, or at all? What is the vital excuse for all bloody dictators and fanatics? They absolutely need Israel, their eternal boogeyman...
9. Guys - "four interceptors" means "four missiles" - not a lot
Scott ,   USA   (05.26.11)
10. to #9
Gili ,   Tel-Aviv   (05.26.11)
Scott, in each interceptor there are approx 20 missiles so do the math 4x20=80 missiles. these interceptors won't shoot only one missile and of course the IDF will reload them.
11. I know the Iron dome works
Vicky ,   Ashkelon Israel   (05.26.11)
Its so much nicer than having to dive for the shelter, but it don'e ' arf make u jump! Put them all around Israel and along the Mex ican border!
12. During Cast Lead & Lebanon Iron Dome would have been useless
zionist forever   (05.26.11)
Hamas have around 30,000 short - medium range rockets. Hizbollah is believed to have more rockets than most countries. If this had been in use during Cast Lead or Lebanon within an hour we would have used up all of our $50,000 apiece interceptors in the entire country. For Israel if you just want to shoot down the odd rocket here and there its fine but under combat conditions its a total waste of money. The best defense is and always has been a good offense and we should not become to reliant on Iron Dome and allow it to be used as an excuse not to carry out a Cast Lead 2 if the rocket fire increases significanty. Its very kind of the US to buy these extra batteries but if there comes a time when they US i no longer wants to spend any money on Iron Dome batteries Israel should not invest to heaviy in it. There is valuable offensive weapons the IDF would like to have and should not be sacrficed so we can keep spending heavily that has no value in a major conflict.
13. 2-I'd have to agree with you.
Ypip ,   Canada   (05.26.11)
We also need to carefully speed up David's sling.
14. Iron dome won't protect you...
Marco ,   Spain   (05.26.11)
from devastating blows by Hezbollah... Hezbollah is more than a match to whatever shield you may using to give yourselves some false sense of security...
15. #11 Vicky, Ashkelon Israel
Marco ,   Spain   (05.26.11)
I promise you Vicky, when it gets real hot and Hezbollah missiles are falling all over the place, the I.D.F crew manning those Iron domes will be the first to run for cover...
16. Marco
zionist forever   (05.26.11)
I agree Hizbollah are more than a match for any defense system because they have more rockets than we could ever have Iron Dome batteries. What needs to be done if there is another flare up with Lebanon is for the politicians to stop trying to micromange the war and let the generals decide on tactics. Basically though no holds barred. Bomb the hell out of southern Lebanon till the whole are is a giant crater. Give the ground troops whatever they need to fight and give them the time to finish the job quickly. We want a quick and deadly war, it must not be dragged out for weeks or months which is what Hizbollah would like to see happen. Hit hard and get out and keep hitting them until they are down and out.
17. #11 Marco. I can also promise that
vicky ,   Ashkelon Israel   (05.26.11)
as in past history that is the last thing our boys have ever done. Not like you spanish when was the last time you won a war?
18. @ zionist forever
Sheik Rattle & Roll ,   USA   (05.26.11)
We have to agree to disagree. I agree that the system can't protect Israel 100%, however it can protect strategic targets such as command and control sites and airfields etc. The day will come when the playing field is level when Hezbollah and Hamas will have accurate missiles that can pin point airfields and other strategic sites that can make them combat ineffective, so this shield is needed even if it's capabilities are limited so it can buy time to utilize very strong offensive capabilities.
19. @14 the moron
(05.26.11)
you forgot what out airforce did to lebanon in 2006. it is not only these missiles, but the israeli airforce will obliterate lebanon. who will come to its aid if hizbulla starts anything? none will come. no arab nation will come to lebanon and hizbullah's aid like no arab nation and iran never came to hizbullah's aid during 2006. these arabs always talk big, but when it comes to action, israel vaporises them in the air and on the ground and this is why no arab nation wants to go against israel in the air or on the ground. southern lebanon was left a glass parking lot in 2006. nasrallah had to go before the lebanese and apologize that he didn't expect such retaliation and that had he known, he would not have started the war in 2006. if he wishes to see a 2011, then be israel's guest. the israelis warned lebanon that hizbullah is now part of the lebanese government and anything that they do will be on lebanon' s head. this time not only southern lebanon, but its entire area.
20. @15
(05.26.11)
hizbullah courageous???? then why is your favorite person, nasrallah, still living in an underground cave??? because he is so tough and brave?
21. 18
zionist forever   (05.26.11)
I do agree that in terms of protecting strategic military sites etc Iron Dome does have a use during a war but it cant protect the population in a war because they have more rockets than we can ever hope to destroy. If we want to stop the odd rocket fired from Gaza and protecting a strategic military site its fine but anything else its no use and we should not try and kid ourselves this is the magic bullet.
22. #21 Zionist forever
Marco ,   Spain   (05.26.11)
You leaders are so out of touch with reality, that I would worry if I were a Jew living in Israel. In his latest speech before the U.S congress, Netanyahu mentioned that Hezbollah poses a threat to Israel with its 12 thousand missiles. Even my grandmother knows that Hezbollah owns more than a 100 thousand missiles today.so how come your politicians are out of touch with reality?
23. #Marco
Gili ,   Tel-Aviv   (05.27.11)
you do know that one Jericho missile can wipe out the entire southern Lebanon not to mention the fact that if we want to finish the story with Hezbollah we don't even need soldiers, Hezbollah are lucky for having Israel around by the way we own over 3,000 Jericho rockets with ability to strike any place around the globe with with ability to carry over 1,000 Kg nuclear warheads, not to mention all our other abilities, i hope the terror cells won't be stupid enough to drag Israel into a balistic war because it will be their end in less than 3 days.
Back to article