News  Magazine
Richard Silverstein vs. censorship
Moshe Ronen
Published: 07.06.11, 17:33
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
33 Talkbacks for this article
1. What a despicable, awful human being
Phil Jenkins ,   Austin, Texas   (06.07.11)
2. His sources are newspaper reporters
Rod ,   Fargo N.Dakota   (06.07.11)
in Israel who want to get around censorship.Do you think everyone is stupid? The same thing is done in the U.S.
3. Probably would give up Israel's nukes for a fake peace.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (06.07.11)
4. What a Tool
Joe ,   Israel   (06.07.11)
The man appears to be a tool for some Israeli reporters looking to bypass the censor - nothing more than that.
5. why give stage to this hater ?
reality   (06.07.11)
shame on you ynet for promoting this hater , yeah he doesn't want to harm Israel,rigghhht, just search the net and see by yourself how he dealt with the Gaza op for example , but i guess i shouldn't be surprised that you promote leftist propagandists .
6. Fraud
Pinhas Bayit ,   Bet HaKerem   (06.07.11)
There is nothing liberal or democratic about this man. He is the worst sort of purple writer - blogger is a compliment. He is vicious and bitchy when he thinks he's not getting his own way and he'll use unattributed quotes if he thinks it serves his purposes. Don't be fooled by the association with US liberal Judaism, he's as McCarthyite as they come.
7. First line said it all
Captain Obvious ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.07.11)
"There is no place farther from the Israeli experience" than the slanted, biased and churlish musings of Richard Silverstein. Reasonable people across all political spectrums roll their eyes whenever Silverstein is mentioned. It's a shame that such a divisive individual has entered the arena of the free speech debate in Israel. But to give him credit, he does love attention no matter what the cost and you have given it to him. Bravo. Not.
8. The mask slipped off...
G. Fränkl   (06.07.11)
...from Ynet's face. As the marvelous Caroline Glick has already postulated, this paper and its online satellite, partly by providing this cr**p valuable exposure, is a nauseating, intentionally public-demoralizing far-left gutter press. Well done!
9. Yet Another American Sovereign Citizen...
Asi Leafar ,   Israel   (06.07.11)
which is just another name for law breaker! This man isn't helping anyone except for himself his blog should be unplugged.
10. My Hero
Michael ,   California, USA   (06.07.11)
I take his closing (in this article) statement as heroic: "For the future, he says he want to see a secular, liberal democracy in Israel, one that respects both the human rights and the religious beliefs of its citizens." This will not happen in the present political climate in the ME and not during Netanyahu's leadership of Israel, but those times will pass. We need to have a lot of patience and strongly believe Israel has a great future once peace comes..
11. Conservertive & Reform Tikun Olam of Jew hating
joseph ,   USA   (06.07.11)
12. Silverstein is a idiot
John cone ,   USA   (06.07.11)
He is so left wing on israel he makes peace now look like a reactionary group. He is so intolerant he censors other peoples opinion.
13. One sad, sick pup
Ron ,   OC, US   (06.07.11)
That being said, physical violence is out. At that point we become Arabs. To me he no longer a Jew, or much of anything else. He is a bum.
14. Such arrogance
citizen   (06.07.11)
Reading this article, Silverstein does not come across as someone who 'loves Israel, wants it to prosper, does not wish to harm it'. On the contrary, he comes across as someone who dislikes Israel and finds 'the reverberation of his revelations' - pleasing. Only an arrogant fool would call his blog Tikun Olam.
15. Why doesn't the Mossad pay him a visit?
jason white ,   afula, israel   (06.07.11)
One time, one .22 short to the back of the head and he can do his next blog in hell. But first chase down his sources here in Israel and try them for aiding the enemy.
16. Could he be a tool of the Mossad?
naro ,   nyc   (06.07.11)
17. why this fluff piece?
walt kovacs ,   los angeles, usa   (06.07.11)
did ynet even bother to peruse dickie's blog? the man hates israel, israelis, observant jews and anyone who does not share his myopic world view. he cannot read or speak hebrew, and has a limited knowledge of judaism (he has compared purim to "april fools day") he goes out of his way to excuse the terrorist groups of hamas and hezbollah and supports the bds movement
18. where does
Yael ,   Israel   (06.07.11)
censorship come into anything? He's not an Israeli citizen so, of course, Israeli censorship doesn't apply in any form. Slow news day, much? I would suggest the government seek out and prosecute his sources that are citizens, however.
19. These people are protected.
(06.07.11)
20. Doesn't he look like the dork everyone hit
jason white ,   afula, israel   (06.07.11)
in the third grade? And made him spill his books in the school hallway? He has that look, dorkism.
21. His rightwing blog should be called Tikun Hamas
Don Draper ,   Toronto   (06.07.11)
Why are advocates of the Hamas reich wing agenda vs. Israel represented as liberal zionists who love Israel? Are you kidding?
22. It seems his blog is blocked by Israeli Internet carriers...
Orly ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.07.11)
...unless it is just overloaded due to the publicity of this article. But I can't manage to access his site at all. Big Brother is always watching. The ministry of truth, which deals with censorship, is always one step ahead. We have always been at war with Hamas and we have always been at peace with Fatah. I love Big Brother.
23. Silverstein
Roy ,   USA   (06.08.11)
Beneath the veneer, just another confused ,peculiar, leftward-leaning crackpot.
24. silverstein is Very buddy buddy with
pinchas ,   Boston   (06.08.11)
larry derfner, the uber-leftist and self-defined "atheistic post-Zionist" writer for the Jerusalem Post. If you've ever read the derf's dirt ( very much like that of Gideon Levy and co. at haaretz) you will realize what a potz Silverman must be. birds of a feather flock together...
25. SIlverstein is the king of censorship
Carrie ,   USA   (06.08.11)
Silverstein routinely deletes any pro-Israel commentary and only allows comments that are critical of Israel and pro-Hamas on his blog. It seems this reporter did not do his homework. You are painting this guy out to be a martyr, when in reality he is working against Israel 24/7.
26. Silverstein-cheerleader for Hamas.
JR ,   USA   (06.08.11)
Silverstein is an enemy of Israel!!! I would not trust one word this guy says.
27. Orly, Jerusalem, He is coming in fine here
Michael ,   California, USA   (06.08.11)
Try this link: http://www.richardsilverstein.com/tikun_olam/ Maybe he is turning his computer off once in a while? Keep in mind his time zone is 10 hours behind Jerusalem. Try early in the morning Israel time, when you wake up.
28. Michael, California, Thanks...
Orly ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.08.11)
I dunno, that's what I was trying last night, but now it does work - even here.
29. He makes a lot of wild statements
Rayne   (06.09.11)
Richard Silverstein writes some good stuff. But he is unfortunately prone to making sweeping, not-too-intelligent generalizations to further his cause. A single right-wing soldier represents the mass of Israeli youth. The induction of two migrant workers into the army means Israel are sending Africans to battle. He has the potential to be a good journalist, but often gets in his own way and is undermined by his own agenda and often his own ego.
30. Taming Korach
Justin White ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.09.11)
In typical Silverstein fashion, this fraud is the antithesis of a truth-teller. Using the facade of his “Jewishness” as a weapon, Richard disdains his religion and has spend decades in a tirade again against anything he perceives as being “Orthodox.” I argued with him back in 2008, only to have him CENSOR me when he realized he couldn’t hack it with someone more knowledgeable than he is. Some hero!
Next talkbacks
Back to article