News
Early Hitler letter on Jews unveiled in NYC
Associated Press
Published: 08.06.11, 07:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
20 Talkbacks for this article
1. the typewritten words are unmistakable Adolf Hitler's?
observer ,   Egypt   (06.08.11)
2. wow
jj   (06.08.11)
hitler hated jews... you learn something every day.
3. "REMOVAL" not annihilation.
Adam ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (06.08.11)
It was wrong. Nevertheless, he wanted to deport us to here originally. Britain and the Arabs gave him one way left to 'remove' us.
4. What a crazy
Moshe R ,   New York   (06.08.11)
What a crazy conspiracy theorist, and what a pool of imbeciles have followed him!!
5. can someone explane
(06.08.11)
a typewriter , and a hand written expert !!! how does that add up ????
6. not worth the paper it is written on
countess mara   (06.08.11)
7. #1 and 5
jj   (06.08.11)
usual talkback detective work going on. from the first paragraph: "The signature under the typewritten words on yellowing sheets of nearly century-old paper is unmistakable: Adolf Hitler, with the last few scribbled letters drooping downward."
8. Nietzsche used nearly the same wording
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (06.08.11)
in his most infamous antisemitic propaganda treatise, "Beyond good and evil"....in the year 1885... Hitler was not a singularity, he was breeded in Germanys and Austrias swamp of insane Jew hatred and Antisemitism and that swamp has not dried up yet... Hitlers "Mein Kampf" is on the index in Germany but Nietzsches most evil rantings are still thaught at Germanys universities...and worldwide...!
9. To enlighten #1 and #5...Hitler put his
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (06.08.11)
signature on the letter...hello...??? kuckuck...
10. Typewriter/handwriting explanation
Geoff ,   London (UK)   (06.08.11)
Presumably, the handwriting refers to the signature!!
11. # 2 WOW msg. from jj
Moragh   (06.08.11)
hitler hated Jews...... well bless my cottn sox, that's news!!!!!!!!!
12. The Soviets also wanted their Jews in separation
Michael ,   California, USA   (06.08.11)
This is why they established a Jewish Republic, in early 1920's, I think, in Birobidjan. They thought Jews in Russia would be "happy" to move there and be among their "brothers." But only a few moved, around 20,000. And many of them didn't stay more than a few years, preferring to move back because for the hard climate and scarcity conditions. The Soviets were motivated by the need to settle the China-Russia border to keep it secure. If you know more about it, I would like to read some comments. Was Lenin also in favor of separating Jews from the Slavs in Russia?
13. There are letters like this written by Arabs today
William ,   Israel   (06.08.11)
especially among the PA leaders. Why isn't this of concern to anyone?
14. #3 and #13 are correct
Eli ,   Jerusalem   (06.08.11)
YNet seems more interested in sensationalizing OLD news. Of course Hitler was a devil. But historians verify that his original plan was to deport the Jews whom he despised. It was only when he realized that no one else was willing to accept them that the Final Solution was devised. To blame Hitler EXCLUSIVELY is to take the blame off of the world who let it happen. To try to put the blame ONLY ob him when the world knew exactly what he was doing is a disservice to history. Unfortunately, Hitler and the world proved to us why Zionism is the answer.
15. With this letter, it is as I always suspected
Mark ,   usa   (06.08.11)
that hitler formed his antisemitic views in the trenches of wwi. While, forever hard to disconnect the level of butchery towards jews by the nazis, from some deeper bias towards jews. It has been my opinion for time, the real ultimate reason was hilter also believe above all else that the role of the citizen was to serve the State. Everything, was subornative to this, you see it numerous times in his speeches and writings. So, the corpal, whether getting a chush gig behind the lines, recovering from wounds, whatever, must have had lively discusions, "if wheren't for those ten commendant, thou shall not kill, sons of abrahams, we could have an extra 500,000 or 1 M men in uniform
16. Hitler: The Ultimate Self Hating Jew
Edward ,   Savannah, USA   (06.08.11)
Hitler is the epitome' of the self hating Jew. Being Half Jewish himself, he did everything he could to eradicate that stigma. This same mentality seems to play itself out with those that would rather see Israel destroyed by making every concession with its enemies rather than to make a stand as being Jewish. I parade the likes of Rahm Emmanuel, Ehud Barak, Olmert, Tzipi Livni, the cast and characters of JStreet, the leftwing Jewish peaceniks, and anyone else that truly believes that "peace" can be achieved with the Arabs just by giving them everything they demand and expect Israel to surrender to them. Abbas has already stated that the P.A. State will be "Juden rien" which means that the only "good" Jew will be a DEAD Jew, and that applies to ALL Jews, yet it amazes me that so many Leftist Jews just can't comprhend this. As Lenin once said, these are "useful idiots" indeed!!! I hope the rest of Israel wakes up before its' leaders sell them down the road to destruction and vote in some REAL Jewish leaders.
17. #16 Ed, Hitler was megalomaniac and not a Jew.
Michael ,   California, USA   (06.08.11)
You should know that a Jew is a person who accepts the culture of his Jewish predecessors and their history as his own. I read a lot of books about Hitler and never saw it said that he belonged to the Jewish culture or accepted Jewish history as his own. Secondly, Hitler did not hate himself, was not self-hating. Actually, he thought very highly of himself, he was a megalomaniac.
18. What gave rise to an Adolf Hitler?
Anthony David Marks ,   Israel   (06.08.11)
Adolf Hitler did not invent or originate antisemitism, he capitalized on it. Most did not take his raves and rantings seriously. These are people who place more significance on presentation rather than content. Dr. Horowitz, my high school teacher at Yeshiva Torah Vodaath in Brooklyn, New York stated that Hitler rose to power on the empty stomachs of the German people. What he mean was that the German Mark became worthless and that you could paper the walls with it.. One needed to fill up a whole shopping cart with German Marks simply to purchase a loaf of bread. With the US dollar ready to crash from the massive 14+ trillion debt and Obama sending the wrong signal to the world by wanting to raise the 14+ trillion debt to fund US programs or to carry on business as usual instead of declaring a national economic emergency, we could soon see widespread chaos and the rise of another Adolf Hitler.
19. #7,9 why would L.A. group buy rights to original
observer ,   Egypt   (06.09.11)
Jewish human rights organization purchased the original for $150,000 from Profiles in History, a dealer in Calabasas Hills, Calif., which acquired the document from a dealer in Kansas, who in turn purchased it from a U.S. Army soldier named William F. Ziegler. That entitle the group of rabbis to hold the handwritten signature from any probe. ivory pomegranate with 613 seeds!
20. Rabbi Marvin Hier buys the letter
observer ,   Egypt   (06.09.11)
In 2009, he criticized Vatican cardinal Renato Martino over his comment that Gaza was a big concentration camp. A $100 million Museum of Tolerance and Human Dignity, a project of the Simon Wiesenthal Center in Los Angeles run by Rabbi Marvin Hier, is set to be built over the Mamilla cemetery, an historic Muslim burial ground with graves going back to the 7th Century. intolerance indeed.
Back to article