News
Congress votes in favor of PA aid suspension
Associated Press
Published: 08.07.11, 07:58
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
53 Talkbacks for this article
1. Very good decision........
Asher ,   NY.USA   (07.08.11)
2. i dont get
MIke ,   Phila USA   (07.08.11)
why they r getting any money in the first place. the school districts in my state had their budgets reduced but they got money for terrorist in palestine?
3. The US
Tony ,   Ramallah   (07.08.11)
The US is Chapter 11.. All foreign aid is being suspended eventually. This is just an excuse. Of course we all know the US Congress is prepared to suck the country dry and wipe out Americas middle class all for maintaining Americas shameful aid to Israel without which Israel wouldn't exist
4. Confused
KEN ,   LONDON, UK   (07.08.11)
On one hand we hear that recognition of the palestinian state by the UN General Assembly equals nothing and on the other hand the US Congress threatens to stop Aid and Israel threatens to stop transfering the tax money paid by the Palestinians for imports to the Palestinian Authority areas.
5. it's about bloody time
(07.08.11)
6. Aid
Joe   (07.08.11)
Why dont the activists send cash and help the Palestinians if they so worried about them
7. To #3 Tony
M.J. Eizen ,   Petah Tikvah, Israel   (07.08.11)
Your comment is absurd. Israel can get by very nicely without the 3 billion a year it receives in US military aid, 80% of which is spent on buying US military gear. On the other hand, Ramallah, were you live is a beggar nation, which cannot survive for 6 months without handouts. You must be very proud to live there.
8. Tony: cute. Wrong, but cute.
(07.08.11)
Relieve me of my ignorance and tell me exactly what the Palestinian Authority manufactures, produces, exports, what it does to earn its keep. No one is BDS-ing the PA because there is nothing to BDS. 80% of the "workforce," or some other ridiculous percentage, in the Gaza Strip gets paid by Hamas, and I don't want to know for doing what. In season the Gaza Strip exports flowers and strawberries. And out of season? Israel gets billions in aid, agreed, but has to spend it on American military materiel. The PA gets billions in aid and spends it on -- what, exactly? Certainly not on the infrastructure. So where is all the aid money going, exactly? The PA economy isn't thriving because...? Do you have any answer that doesn't involve blaming Israel or American Jews or someone other than the Palestinians themselves?
9. #3 Tony and his LIMPY tired foreign aid RANT
CK Tan ,   Singapore, Singapore   (07.08.11)
So Tony REGURGITATES the tale of US's "shameful" aid to Israel. Missing from his PATHETIC whining is the FACT that the MAJORITY of that money goes BACK to the Americans working in the defence industry etc. In addition, US gets Israels' cutting edge tech KNOW-HOW for its OWN USES. Comparatively, over US$143b of US taxpayer's money was SPENT for Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan in 2010. And what BENEFITS do these 3 countries GIVE BACK to the US in return for the aid? NOTHING. Also, the INVENTED people called palis received TONS of foreign aid too. Their most "NOTABLE" contributions to HUMANITY are the SUICIDE VEST and their DESPICABLE use of children and other civilians as HUMAN SHIELDS. CLEARLY, Tony is also OBLIVIOUS that TOTAL foreign aid constitutes LESS than 1% of the US's annual budget (UK media). Which SIMPLY means that Israel's portion is a itny FRACTION of that "less than 1%". But hey, FACTS are of course NOT important to Tony and his mindless PARROTING.
10. no 3 and no4
gdfathermax. ,   tel aviv israel   (07.08.11)
what don"t you understand? israel doesn't need $3billion a year to spend on american arms, no7 you are absolutly correct. the palis are a beggar nation. nothing would exsist without the billions they get in donations. they lie and cheat the whole world whilst planning to destroy israel one way or another. they are nothing but garbage.
11. Aid to End Anyway
Mark ben Josuf ,   USA   (07.08.11)
US aid will end anyway. The US spent the money on other stuff. Congress doesn't want to pay our bills anymore. If a deal is made, aid ends. If a deal is not made, the aid won't be worth toilet paper - the dollar will crumble. August 2 is the default date. Aid ends or is worthless, Congressional choice. Nobody knows which will happen.
12. Show as the money!
dezi ,   Israel   (07.08.11)
Very good!Known USA contribucion to the Palestinians in the past decade more than $10 billion,the highest per capita aid transfer in the Foregein aid anyvhere.Significant portions of this money,intented to provide a new infrastructure,have not reached the intended recipients.If this money not gone to whom was intended,ther where has it gone?
13. #3 TONY: 3 Bn of US Aid out of 240 Bn of Israel GDP
lol to tony ,   FRA   (07.08.11)
this amounts to ....1.25% only. Really Israel couldn't survive! However, this is right to mention that this help is really useful for Israel to maintain high-tech gears in cooperation with the US. I am not sure it will be the same for the US help to the palestinians which equals to around 20%-25% of palestinians gdp...
14. ken england
chookie   (07.08.11)
we are confused is england not now heading to be a caliphate? what are you rabling onabout.? go have tea with rebekkaand discuss the newspaper industry with her
15.  Will this stop Obama from helping his buddies - the muslim?
Lednah ,   Europe   (07.08.11)
16. A nation of beggars cannot sustain itself by TNT belts alone
Sims   (07.08.11)
To Tony # 3, Absurdity is an understatment. You, your family have been begging for much longer than 70 years. Without the ' aumone ' you couldn't survive. Your grand parents, your parents and you have been streching your hands out in order to eat. The accepted way of life by your kind passed on from generation to generation. All the while your rapacious leaders " swim in the gold stolen from the infidels who send it to you so you will have bread on the table. You are a sick crowd, and cannot stomach the fact that Israel can make it on it's on. You couldn't do it in a million years. Why? Because your allah forgot to distribute the only commodity that would have made you an equal BRAINS !
17. Aid required to fill the leaders pockets
Samuel ,   Israel   (07.08.11)
The Palestineans have been receiving aid for a number of years.Have they any account for it?From the time of Yasser Arafat (the greatest thug) to the time of Abbas,Fayad & who knows how many more have been filling their pockets with this aid.Arafat's wife staying in Paris & reaping the fruits of the loot.Has the UN or US made any enquires as to how the aid is being spent?or how much goes in their personal accounts?
18. Republicans and Democrats support Israel
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah, Efraim   (07.08.11)
B"H Republicans and Democrats maybe signaled their strong support for the State of Israel, but certainly not for Jews: a.) Jews don't expel Jews. b.) Jews don't give their G-d given Land away for "peace", they fight for it in what the Torah calls an obligatory war!
19. I LOVE IT******* IT"S WAAAAAY OVERDUE !!
BUILDINGISRAEL ,   United States   (07.08.11)
Thanks to G-d, the US Senate and House of representatives for an historic vote showing America's full support and loyalty to the only valued ally in the ME, Israel. There is no greater and more valued alliance between two of the most powerful nations on earth. May G-d bless America and, May G-d bless Israel. ( Hasn't He in so many ways? )
20. Remember--
BUILDING ISRAEL ,   United States   (07.08.11)
'Money is the life's blood to politics.' No money, no pals.. Like cutting off oxygen to a fire.
21. to # 16
juan sol ,   san diego, USA   (07.08.11)
You think the world is stupid?... well, in this case maybe... you have sucked billions and billions of dollars, and still doing till this moment, from so many countries... it may add to over a trillion by now... but I still think this collective world stupidity will come to an end.
22. American people stand with Israel. Obama, not so much.
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (07.08.11)
The Congress more closely reflects American support of Israel than does the White House. Polls consistently show support at 60-65%, while support for Palestinians draws less than 20%. Yet Obama acts more as advocate for Palestine than fair broker, while Clinton recently offered yet another $200 million to the PA to help close its budget gap (as if we don't have one).
23. Corrupt US Congress is obedient slave to israel & zionists
christianpalestinian ,   hong kong   (07.08.11)
What is the religion of all the congressman mentioned in the above article? That says it all.
24. #13 - Your Data Smells of Hasbara
Doug ,   Rochester, USA   (07.08.11)
According to the CIA factbook, the GDP of Palestine, excluding E. Jerusalem, is $6.641B as of 2008. So the U.S. aid of $0.5B per year equates to 7.5% of GDP, not the 20-30% that you just made up. Also, once Palestine regains control of their land, water, roads, removes the Apartheid wall and checkpoints, eliminates the illegal blockade, gains control of its borders, the economy will signficantly grow and the percent aid will shrink..
25. Stop the incentive bonus
Raphael ,   Netanya   (07.08.11)
For 63 years, the self styled victims of Naqba sucked 50% of their GNP from the West. Stopping the $ tap would be a first pragmatic step towards rationals: instead of evading systematically any negociated solution, which would mean the end of the Naqba business, if the bonanza generated by their blackmail stops, the Pals would be forced to stop behaving as spoilt brats.
26. US to suspend funds for PA ,,Seeing is
DT ,   TA Israel   (07.08.11)
believing !
27. Excellent work, Congress!
John ,   Alaska   (07.08.11)
And because the US Legislature reflexts the will of its constituents, this is a statement that the US herself both supports Jewish Israel and refuses to support terrorist Hamas and Jew-hating Fatah.
28. #3 Tony
John ,   Alaska   (07.08.11)
the Jewish nation of Israel stands because this is the will of God Almighty. If the US does nothing for Israel, her rescue would come from another source and the US herself would not save herself by this inaction. As for the inhabitants of the mountain of allah, God Almighty has this for you: Obadiah 3-4. The pride of thine heart hath deceived thee, thou that dwellest in the clefts of the rock, whose habitation [is] high; that saith in his heart, Who shall bring me down to the ground? Though thou exalt [thyself] as the eagle, and though thou set thy nest among the stars, thence will I bring thee down, saith the LORD.
29. To: No. 3
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.08.11)
Good luck with maintaining your rotting infrastructure now. The best thing that ever happened to the ersatz "Palestinians" was Israel, but you wanted an ersatz "Palestine" Authority, and now you're stuck with it. Four of the six universities in the West Bank that Israel very generously and graciously built for you have closed their doors. (I guess you people don't think that education is all that important.) All those Kupat Holim clinics that Israel very generously and graciously built for you have closed, too. (I guess you people don't think that medical care is all that important.) Once the sewage system that Israel very generously and graciously built for you collapses from lack of care, you people can go back to having two or three outbreaks of cholera a year, just like you did prior to June 1967. Do you realize just how much of a blight upon humanity you are? I can't wait until you're gone. That's coming pretty soon. In your place, I'd start packing.
30. To: No. 8
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.08.11)
Oh, it is never the fault of the ersatz "Palestinians." It is because of Israel, or the United States or the clear blue sky, but it is NEVER their fault. Their so-called "leadership" have multiple luxurious homes in Europe, and extremely hefty offshore bank accounts, but the collapsing infrastructure and 40% unemployment in the PA is -- of course -- Israel's fault. Now that the United States Congress has cut them off (with the European Union soon to follow suit), it will be the fault of the United States, too. But nothing is their fault. Nothing is EVER their fault.
Next talkbacks
Back to article