Opinion
Is the world against us?
Donniel Hartman
Published: 12.07.11, 12:37
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
35 Talkbacks for this article
1. TBers instead of bashing Haredis...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (07.12.11)
can do a useful job by defending Israeli s position in the foreign media.I have seen a foreign newspaper with many anti israeli comments ,change after the brilliant intervention of one of Ynet TBer.And now most TBs there are pro Israel.The Israeli TBer seems to be very respected,and his opinion is estimated.
2. yes the world is
chaim israeli   (07.12.11)
against us and always was! wake up!
3. if we just
daniel   (07.12.11)
keep the torah the world would despise us less! end!
4. To hell with all those who hate us
Samuel ,   Israel   (07.12.11)
We should only believe in the Almighty.The Lord that neither slumbers nor sleeps,protects Israel.He will be our right hand to guide us in the path of Glory-Amen Just trust the Lord Almighty.We do not require humans or nations to protect us.Let us all join hands & love one another & have faith in Lord our G-d.
5. whom should we run to
chaim ,   Jerusalem   (07.12.11)
for help?
6. Friends
Andy ,   Canada   (07.12.11)
You will never have a better friend than Canada. Prime Minister Stephen Harper has been consistent in his support from the Francophone Summit to the most recent G8.
7. Good point, poor examples
Michael Storch ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.12.11)
I am not certain that the recent aborted "fly-in" is a good example of an improvement in relations with anyone. There were very specific treaty laws, immediate financial penalties for the air carriers, and the generally heightened scrutiny of all air passengers working for us. I know less about maritime law, but suspect it was also working our way. If anything, these incidents show why recognition of a Palestinian State could bring all sorts of surprises. Cheers,
8. Is the world against us?
Meir ,   New York   (07.12.11)
Easiest article to write: Yes! There, one word, one punctuation mark.
9. @4
R. Lilienfeld ,   Ramat Gan   (07.12.11)
Yeah, right, sure. God, and not american military, and financial aid made us reach our 63rd birthday a few months back. Also, god tends to favor those with the more efficient militairy machine and powerful allies, for both of which we need foreign countries.
10. I agree But let us give credit where credit is due
Shalom Freedman ,   Jerusalem Israel   (07.12.11)
I agree wholeheartedly with the general position outlined here. But in regard to the recent events it is important to give credit where credit is due i.e. to Prime Minister Netanyahu.
11. is the world against us?
AndrĂ© ,   Netherlands   (07.12.11)
Geert Wilders from the Netherlands is also a big fan and supporter of Israel. His influence on the government can't be underestimated concerning Israel and he already has close to a million voters.
12. Is Israel against the world?
berlonski ,   berlin   (07.12.11)
Why hardly nobody asks the question the other way round? Just read the daily Ynet headlines and you get the impression that Israel needs to position herself against the world, because otherwise it would stop being so special. Hartman's article itself reflects this. He states that not "being a nation like all others" is a big "advantage". But why? If being different is such a great value for him he should not be surprised when "the world" sees Israel in fact as something different.
13. I know it's not much, but...
Damir ,   Sarajevo, BiH   (07.12.11)
i want you to know that Israel will always have sympathies around the world. Not because political views or choosing sides in conflicts, but because of beauty of your country. You've build the most beautiful country on the Middle East.
14. Is the world against us?
Salma ,   Palestine   (07.12.11)
No, It's you against the world .
15. the credit goes to Liberman
Golan ,   Modiin   (07.12.11)
not "friends" whose past was to ignore terror and only insist on further Israeli concessions.
16. Salma @ 14, surely you jest.
leo ,   usa   (07.12.11)
17. Yes Geert and PM S Harper are a great force to have on our side. Gd bless both!
Alan ,   SA   (07.12.11)
18. There are many who loves ISRAEL,the problem
josi ,   norway   (07.12.11)
in the world is that there are SO many who wants relation with the Arabs, because of terror threat from the Arab side.
19. World isn't against Israel
BH ,   Iowa   (07.12.11)
Just the fools and dregs.
20. the world is against the truth
cristian ,   buenos aires arg   (07.12.11)
yeshua the messiah commandments to forgive everybody of their offenses against you forgive and be forgiven,to be born again,let the people see good works,end disputes quickly,whatever causes to sin get rid of it,do not swear oaths at all,do not return offense for offense,give what people ask you and give more than is required,love the enemies and those who work against you,give to the poor to please God not to gain approval from other people,pray privately and simply not to impress other people,make the prayers be like the lord prayer,when fast do it secretly not for show,store up the treasures of heaven not of earth,do not worry about material needs,do not worry about the future,make God highest priority and he will take care of all needs,do not judge other people judge not lest ye be judged,ask God for whatever want to have seek and ye shall find,feed the hungry,clothe the naked,shelter the homeless,comfort those in distress,follow the narrow path to life enter by the narrow gate,beware of false prophets,exercise power over unclean spirits,resolve disputes in an orderly way,have total faith in God for everything,be like the good samaritan go and do likewise,love other people,eat bread and drink wine in remembrance of he,wash one another feet,be merciful,go and teach all nations,keep the commandments,be prepared for the rabbi return
21. We'll have far more friends when we end appeasement.
Chaim ,   Israel   (07.12.11)
It is human nature to like the strong, self respecting and despise the weak and appeasing. That largely explains why Israel was so much more popular before the Oslo Disaster - when we were viewed as a gutsy little nation. Many potential friends are disgusted by Israel's pathetic appeasing ways, which the left has inflicted on us. Hopefully, we will quickly end this lunacy. Israel will have far more friends when we end appeasement.
22. The world is not united against the Zionist state;
Leon ,   Ottawa, Canada   (07.12.11)
just the decent people who oppose racism and oppression. Media owners like Ruport Murdoch and Conservative politicians are still solidly behind Israel.
23. Just because ..
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (07.12.11)
The entire world isn't like the Arabs who have violated every single provision of every treaty ever signed, some in the world do follow the rule of law, doesn't mean that a vast majority isn't anti-Jew. The facts speak for themselves, the Arabs can and do get most of the world to go along with their apartheid practices and invent new 'standards' for us that apply to nobody else.
24. world against us
Niss ,   uk   (07.12.11)
the people who are againt israel which there are many in many countries they spend money on media etc grouping for demonstrations they are ready for the phone call to direct them where to go israel spend billions on arms why dont they spend on media if the media will let them and tell there point it might help to stop the lies
25. Define friendship, plz...
Gunnar ,   Gothenburg, Sweden   (07.12.11)
...Israel has plenty of friends in the World, persons as well as nations. However, quite a few Israelis need to understand that friendship is NOT the same thing as blind, 100% loyalty no matter what...
26. The World is Against Israel
Daniel Shears ,   USA   (07.12.11)
The majoy problem here is that is possible that most governments understand Israel's unique dilemma; however these governments including the USA do not do a good job at educating their publics as to why they support Israel, which inturn turns to hatred of Israel by the very people that put those governments into power. So lets make a better PR effort and educate the world. I know that whomever I have brought to Israel has completely changed any negative opinion they have had of our nation by simply being educated. In the USA, I hear more often why do we keep giving Israel money? Or enough is enough. So we need to change such small minded views since it is not just giving money but getting so much more in return.
27. Antisemitism...the gift that keeps on giving...
Mikesailor ,   Miami, FL   (07.12.11)
If it weren't for 'antisemitism' and the belief that 'the whole world, including those dastardly self-hating Jews, were against 'us', what is the point to Judaism and what holds Jews together?
28. Im with you !!
Sammy ,   Finland   (07.12.11)
29. No!
Hansje   (07.12.11)
As a person living in Europe, working exclusively with non Jews, I can tell that most of the persons I know are certainly not against Israel. What those persons are asking me if the "wall"" is necessary, if we couldn't give away some land to the poor palestinians because Israel has "300 atom bombs" and is sooo strong. Israelis, surrounded by ennemies, don't see the whole picture and are making the wrong conclusion that the whole world is against them, because of some silly vote in the UN or declaration by some lefty 'pots'. Yes, you have the famous poll's, where the persons asked, are mostly from Arab origin... So, what I can tell: the non arab or lefty population are for Israel but need some explanation. The governements are something else: they need to balance their policies. In hart they are mostly for Israel.
30. To #3 yes and no
John ,   Alaska   (07.13.11)
Proverbs 16:7 says "When a man's ways please the LORD, he maketh even his enemies to be at peace with him." You're right that your enemies will dispise you less, but that does not mean they will be your friends. It does mean that they will be disinclined to wage war against you. Whether it's because your neighbors like you or fear you, peace is a good thing.
Next talkbacks
Back to article