Business
How did American Jews get so rich?
Tani Goldstein
Published: 26.10.11, 15:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
63 Talkbacks for this article
1. three reasons for Jewish wealth
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (10.26.11)
1. hard work 2. hard work 3. hard work
2. No more US taxpayer money to Israel
Besalel ,   Great Neck   (10.26.11)
As an Israeli and a Jew and an American I believe the time has come to seriously reduce the foreign aid received by Israel (and Egypt). While military aid to Israel must continue as it benefits the U.S. in many different ways, I think the time is ripe to ween Israel off the U.S. financial aid milk. This will be beneficial to both countries whose alliance and friendship is based on common values. Canada and Israel should be treated the same. The U.S. aid to Israel should be limited to military and diplomatic.
3. freemason
jhonny ,   norway   (10.26.11)
freemason
4. the ahrabs are much richer!
(10.26.11)
5. who supports the freed terrorists?
jew   (10.26.11)
from the gilad shalit exchange? !
6. Great story
Me ,   USA   (10.26.11)
I am a Christian and support Israel, Zionism (hey, God came up with this movement) and Jews 100% in principle, and also do my small part financially. I guess I'm on the right side (can't go wrong if you follow the Bible—God's word to humanity). It's interesting to note that while the Jews have contributed so much to world civilization and made the world better in the sciences, arts, business, medicine, etc, the same definitely cannot be said of the 'Religion of peace' ... or more aptly, the Culture of Death.
7. very interesting
The Real Joe   (10.26.11)
This article was very interesting however the fear of American donation decreasing is overrated true some Israeli museums might lose funding however there are enough rich Israeli's to fill that gap the medical and religious organizations will can from the growing orthodox representation in American Jewish life
8. @Besalel #2
P   (10.26.11)
Total US non-military aid to Israel is in the vicinity of $25-30 million annually. This is a trivial amount compared to the total Israeli budget. I agree with you that this should be eliminated. I would also like to see the military portion start to be lowered.
9. American Jews - please help now Africa!
Jouko ,   Finland   (10.26.11)
Africa is extremely poor continent but pouring out money does not help! Africa need the jewish entrepneur -spirit, hard work, hard study and before all jewish spiritual values. Please jews - Africa needs most of all the God of Jews!
10. Go see the poor Jews
Michael ,   California, USA   (10.26.11)
Very many elder Jews in America are poor, some very poor. They live out their years in Old Folks homes after giving the inheritance away to their children. So many of them, it breaks the heart.
11. Arabs are richer....maybe...but....
Richard ,   The Hague Holland   (10.26.11)
they are poor in all other relevant aspects of life.
12. Good because circumcission gives us a good head for business
Alan ,   SA   (10.26.11)
13. salma is not poor
observer   (10.26.11)
14. @ 1
(10.26.11)
ahrabs also work hard!
15. Those who do not identify with the faith, are NOT Jewish
Jake ,   USA   (10.26.11)
Henry Kissinger is a good example of a self-hating Jew that gives us all a bad name. George Soros has done more to harm the Jewish people than most anti-semites could ever dream of. Many of 25% of 400 richest Americans have not been affiliated with Judaism in any way for several generations. This would require them to convert if they were to renew their faith. Thus, they are not Jews, they do not represent the faith, and real Jews should not have to grovel before the angry masses and defend these apostates.
16. Totally sick article
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (10.26.11)
This is something you would read at Stormfront.
17. SECURITY!!!!
Keren ,   IL-BR   (10.26.11)
Today,very rich Jews should focus their aid in Israel´s security only. It is in our interest;it is in their interest. Let us have in mind our history.May it never be repeated,but preventing is always very wise. Not only American Jews.Jews around the whole world who have great amounts of money,should support Israel´s security in order Israel gets rid of the pernicious foreingners |"aid". Never forget:it is in our interest;it is in their interest;it is in the interest of all Jews in this world.
18. Collective wealth of Arab Oil Sheiks is far greater.
Chaim ,   Israel   (10.26.11)
While a considerable number of American Jews are thriving in a free market system; it would be remiss not to point out the collective wealth of the Arab Oil Sheiks is far greater than that of American Jews. Moreover, while U.S. Jews must constantly compete for their achievements and success; the Oil Sheiks need merely turn the oil spigots on and off whenever they like.
19. Work, Work, Work and Study
Noah Lev ,   LosAngelesUSA   (10.26.11)
More than 1 million Jews live at or below the poverty line. The Mormons are among the richest in the USA per capita. This article should have taken the better educated, more highly motivated, and frankly, lower family members, to use as comparisons. There are 310m people in the USA...11m illegals..and newly arrived legal immigrants..who are just entering the US culture. Protestant sects are by far the wealthiest, in terms of total income and assets. The Walmart owners, among other large chains....take in over 600b in revenue....some ot if going to the family members as stock dividends, stocks, salaries, etc. One large oil company takes in more revenue than all the 100 Jews combined. There is a significant disparity in income among Jews, the ultra-Orthodox/Orthodox among the poorest of the poor in the total population. As one gentile told me, years ago at work, you Jews go in for the most money occupation. Well, becoming a doctor, dentist, CPA, lawyer, is not that simple and It takes post graduate degrees and lots of hard study and work and financing. All the major industries have few Jews on their boards of directors.. True, Hollywood has Jews, some wealthy, in a very risky business..more movies lose money. The majority of Hollywood are non-Jews, in the crafts. Jobs, Gates, the Presidential candidates, are NOT jEWISH. Jews are being reduced by 30,000 year....many intermarry. Are they Jewish, as per this article? Hitler said, the grandparent determines..the Hungarian fascists said, the great grandfather..so I guess. What exactly is a Jew? If one doesnt practice it, is he (she) Jewish? Are the offspring Jewish (father is Jewish). If not raised Jewish..are they Jewish? 600000 have left Judaism in past 20 years. Are they still considered Jewish for this study?. There are approx 20m people who have some "Jewish blood" in the USA, just as 10% of Spain and Portugal have similar blood types. Are they Jewish? Is M. Albright Jewish? Is Jmmy Kimmel, or the children of Jerry Lewis, Jewish? Are the children of Michael Jackson Jewish? Hollywoodf is filled with half-Jews, mostly the father's side. Bill Clintons daughter is married to a Jew. Will the children be Jewish? And on and on and on. The Russian oligarths had mixed parentage..were thought of as "Jews". Were they in fact? There are many tenements in New York as well as expensive townhouses. In my county of Los Angeles..there are rich neighborhoods and POOR ones..Jews live in both. Latin Americans send over 30b year to Mexico...money earned in the US of A. Israel does not receive anything close to that, much in the form of bonds and other loans ( have to be repaid). Id like to know how much money is sent by rich Arabs to their brethren in the M.,E?. Re: Israel, anyone familiar knows the US Pres, were against it having a nuclear reactor....and only sent Israel arms when it was about to go under ( 73 War ). Many in the USA do not want any aid of any sort going to Israel, even to buy planes, etc..(money spent in the USA). Its a constant struggle. But all in all, successful Jews ( earnings) had more to do with study, hard work, sacrifice, thrift and responsbile living..than anything else. and a little luck. This article by what it doesnt say, is very misleading...and does in fact, contribute to anti-Semitism and anti-Israeli P"R. Example: Over 400b in charity was given to African countries since WW2..very little ever reached the people, and most was forgiven...Israel pays back its debts.
20. Additional reason for jewish wealth
Richard ,   New York, US   (10.26.11)
As a religious person, you must put God in the equation. In addition to your effort, God decides how much you will succeed in accumulating wealth.
21. #15 Jake-- And besides Ynet should write about Israelis
Michael ,   California, USA   (10.26.11)
I agree with you that they are not Jews even though I disagree about the definition. To me, a Jew is someone who identifies with Jewish history and culture, not with religion. Ynet is a publication in Israel, so why are they writing about American Jews all the time? The connection between Israelis and "Jews" is historical only, in the distant past, and not applying to the majority of current day Americans of Jewish ancestry. Most Americans of Jewish ancestry abhor it when someone speaks of them in separation from the rest of Americans.
22. What a Way to perpetuate a stereotype ynet.
Eli ,   United States   (10.26.11)
Good for you guys. Be proud. Especially of the headings under the pictures throughout the article. Wall Street: Many Jews, Hollywood: Many Jews. Next time you hear someone quote propaganda such as the articles of the elders of zion, you can shut up and have no opinion. Ynet should start publishing cartoon profile shots of what a Jew looks like. Big Noses, wolves teeth.
23. Rich Jews: George Soros
Tam Highpoint ,   Prince George, USA   (10.26.11)
George Soros is no friend of the Jews or Israel. He is a very greedy controlling communist and does not want anyone to get in his way. Please remove his picture from this article.
24. three reasons for Jewish wealth
Robert ,   US   (10.26.11)
1. Family values 2. Education 3. Hard work
25. nice article. same proportions in ukraine
David ,   Kiev   (10.26.11)
while ukraine is much less politically correct:)
26. they are not affiliated but...
@15 Jake ,   kiev, david   (10.26.11)
they still grown up on that famous jewish hard working/educating tradition
27. NO Israel=Disneyland! BIG ISRAEL & PRONOUNCEABLE SPELLING,
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (10.26.11)
28. #2 besalel
solomon ,   bklyn   (10.26.11)
To my knowledge, all non military aid to Israel ended in 2007.
29. #3, suggesting a link between rich Jews and Freemasons
Jake ,   USA   (10.26.11)
There are some self-hating Jews who have joined the ranks of the Freemasons. Real Jews have nothing to do with Freemasonry, because Freemasonry is akin to a religion, and we cannot be members of two religions at once.
30. Another reason
Misha ,   Tel Aviv   (10.26.11)
There's another reason - Jews are very adaptable and can consider the solution to a problem from all sides. This comes after centuries of learning the Talmud, which sharpens the brain. If you can understand the Talmud you can understand anything... Another interesting point is that whenever Jews have been allowed to prosper, the countries they lived in prospered also, e.g. the US. The opposite is also true - whenever Jews were oppressed the country they lived in remained poor, e.g. Soviet Russia
Next talkbacks
Back to article