News  Magazine
Is BDS campaign working?
Giulio Meotti
Published: 31.08.11, 10:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
136 Talkbacks for this article
31. Unworthy article
mba ,   Israel   (08.31.11)
Truths, half truths, and deceptions: summary of above article. Those who believe in gobalization, market economics, capitalism (piggish at times), and that money is the beginning and the end can't complain about boycotts (for whatever reasons). Also, please stop going between anti Israel and anti Jewish - make up your mind, it isn't the same thing. Boycotts are part of the rules of the game and we have to learn to play by them (can't always change the rules to suite us). It's ridiculous to use the boycott of agriculture produce as an excuse for the closure of Agrexco, even an a minor reason. For years this quasi governmental firm has been mismanged with no transparency at all - good riddance and hopefully something worthwhile will arise from the ashes. Veolia is alive and well and still a very presense in Israel.
32. inaccuracies
L. Smith ,   Devon,UK   (08.31.11)
The report is innacurate in that it reports the international boycott as 'against jews'. It is not, and the reporter isfully aware of this. BDS movement is against the current policy/regime that allows settlers to build on Palestinian land whisle denying equal opportunity and rights in Israel to Arab citizens. Itis against the occupation of Palestine and the ongoing violations of Human Rights that Israel chooses not to address. Many Jews, both within and outside Israel, support BDS. As long as people like the author of this article and those who support its content DENY the reasons for BDS, you are part of your own problem and not the solution.
33. ISRAEL should buy more stock of boycotters
(08.31.11)
.....get on the board and confront them.
34. if only they knew.....
mary ,   israel   (08.31.11)
as an inernational university student in australia, i saw this whole anti-israel thing in universities first hand, and it wasn't in just one uni, it was in most of them, the arabs are literally taking over, with huge protests going on at least once a month in the cities. The saddest thing, was listening to half of these arabs go on about israel, most of them didn't even know what they were talking about, completely made things up, and none of them had ever even stepped foot in israel. the few Christian arabs i had met who had been to israel (especially the lebanese) absolutely loved israel and respect us. The amount of times i saw these arabs and other anti-israel protesters screaming at jews walking past, or cursing and arguing and insulting respectable jewish uni lecturers to their faces, broke my heart, especially when these teachers showed unconditional respect to all students equally. And australia is a place which supposedly prides itself on multi-culturalism. Even many products i have seen here which are israeli, like beauty/dead sea products and jewellery, many people will not buy. But many people here are unaware of what things are really like in israel. Although we in israel know that arabs have lied through the media and their propaganda over the years and have really exagerated things because they know they will get more attention from the world, the world only knows what they see on the news, and many news agencies overseas, don't even show our side the way it really it
35. they are boycotting israel 1933 nazi style....
Sandra ,   UK   (08.31.11)
36. Can we have an official list of boycotters?
(08.31.11)
I for one - would like to know whether any of my customer is going to shitheads like this.
37. THIS IS NOT 1930's - We will fight for Israel!
(08.31.11)
38. #21 well said!!!!!!!!!!!!1
(08.31.11)
39. 1933 the nazis orgenized a boycott on "jewish propaganda"
David Rosenbaum ,   Israel   (08.31.11)
if you watched one of BDS' "boycott israel" rallies, it looks exactuall like nazi Germani. sad indeed.
40. BDS hate, and we LOVE! only love can win!
GeorgeK ,   Israel   (08.31.11)
41. Smith So when are you going to BDS Arabs? Or
PETER SM ,   AUSTRALIA   (08.31.11)
do you choose not to see the plank in front of your eyes ? Tell us your REAL problem.
42. to #6
Osher ,   Naharya   (08.31.11)
I didn't know that ben gurion university is located in occupy territories. Oh and you know what? rockets on Ashdod and Beer Sheva or Eilat attack, that's not because we are jews, that's also because of the occupation: It is well know that jews occupy Gaza strip and they should go out !
43. Seems
Jarda ,   Czech Republic   (08.31.11)
that things are going well.
44. put things in prespective!!!! when peace comes buildings
@32   (08.31.11)
can be destroied!!! people who got killed from the palestinians' terrorist attacks can't come back to life!!!
45. Death Sentence
Norbus ,   Jerusalem   (08.31.11)
Boycot practioners are effect ively passing a death sentence on Israel. Israel has not been under greater existential threat. coming from 1. Old FUEV driving UN hostility for Germany's extreme right 2. Iran, Hezbullah, Syria, Hamas Fatah &co 3. Ikhwan al Muslimin in Europe Saudi & rest of Islam , Time for National unity. History will curse Obama, BiBi, Livni, and all the little politicians vying for more perks.
46. No. 16 Sarah
NYC Girl   (08.31.11)
First of all, the killings and aggression were carried out by the Arabs against Israel...which is how the so-called occupation came about in the first place. In fact, it's appalling how ignorant some people are about the history of the conflict because the truth doesn't fit their racist agenda. So perhaps you should consider educating yourself...instead of unquestioningly accepting the bullshit Palestinian agitprop.
47. "Inaccuracies"
FG   (08.31.11)
All those supporting/endorsing the campaign are 100 percent anti-Jewish racists, despite their pahtzetic protestations to the contrary. They want the Jewish state gone forever. Their campain is inherently, innately racist, the crudest form of anti-Jewish Nazism that one can imagine. hitler and the Nazis in the 1930 started exactly the same way. The protestations of Brit, Dutch and other anonymous boycotters here are just cowardly racists that has absolutely nothing to do with any "Palestinian" or "Palestine", only hateful, vicious, elimination, and genocide-minded propaganda. Am Yisrael Chai! Down with racism and Nazism!
48. AMERICANS ARE ALSO BOYCOTTING, I AM ASHAMED
(08.31.11)
49. # 16 Ignorant Sara - the Netherlands
michelle ,   Israel   (08.31.11)
Sara if cities in your country we begin rocketed on a daily basis and suicide bombers were boarding your buses and blowing your friends and neighbors up - what exactly would you expect your government to do????? Even when we so stupidly gave away the gush katif area and evacuated all our citizens from the area what did we get MORE TERROR AND MORE ROCKETS IN RESIDENTIAL AREAS. So what do you suggest - maybe you shoud educate yourself a bit more and stop being so totaly ignorant of the facts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
50. why is ynet assisting the bdsers?
walt kovacs ,   los angeles, usa   (08.31.11)
the author is not an economist, his analysis as to why agrexco declared bankruptcy is not based on fact. ahava's sales are fine, and the park slope coop is not some major retail chain israel's economy has remained stable, despite the economic downturn and unemployment remains low....while exports have never been better so please, dont feed into the bds fantasy...
51. again, they prove us that they are not pro- palestine but
Marcia   (08.31.11)
ANTI- ISRAEL!
52. the answer for BDS' boycotts & hate is LOVE!!!
I LOVE ISRAEL   (08.31.11)
53. BDS are not pro- palestine but anti- israel. THEY HATE
ISRAEL LOVES!!!   (08.31.11)
54. BDS = war crime
Brian Cohen ,   JudeanPeoplesFront   (08.31.11)
The BDS movement totally ignores Palestinian war crimes policies. Thus, the BDS movement is a de facto supporter of war crimes and its various branches around the world should be prosecuted and shut down. "Whether or not attacks actually result in civilian casualties, they are in violation of international law, which also prohibits attacks aimed at spreading terror among the civilian population. The patterns of attacks and statements by members and leaders of Palestinian groups also indicate that they have no qualms about launching attacks against civilians and that they in fact carry out such attacks intending to kill and injure Israeli civilians. Such attacks constitute war crimes. " Amnesty International
55. YES, MARK IT WITH STAR OF DAVID!!
Au. ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.31.11)
All Israeli products should be marked with star of David as we should be proud of that symbol!! Every single item made in Israel should have it! All the chips, all softwares, all Better Life eco-energy stations - everything! (Only that would ruin chances of profiting in Indonesia and UAE, but what the heck) Let them boycot it all & go back in Medieval times! Only friends of Israel can benefit from using our products :-p
56. The ugly face of BDS reminds one of Germany of the 1930s...
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (08.31.11)
...shortly after the rise of Nazism to power. We know what follow... Do we want to experience it again...??!!
57. how ironic is that? BDS founder is a TLV University student!
NY Thinker   (08.31.11)
and he calles on the world to boycott "apartheid israel"... go figure....
58. they are only looking for reasons to hate on us....
BDS need to learn ,   what love is!!!   (08.31.11)
but we will keep on LOVING!!!
59. #16 Sarah
Michael ,   Haifa   (08.31.11)
The killings and the aggression were the sins of both sides to the dispute long before the occupation, but I agree with you that the occupation will intensify boycott activity and maybe, as a result, cause Israelis to think more intelligently about the evils of occupation. There are no free lunches !
60. these european boycotters ?
Maurice? ,   WORLD   (08.31.11)
they are not european - they are arabs that started to control european forums-
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article