News
'Obama is the best thing Israel has going for it'
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 19.09.11, 23:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
151 Talkbacks for this article
1. What planet does NY magazine live on?
Charles ,   Paris, FRANCE   (09.20.11)
It's even worse than La Monde, and approaching the idiocy of Liberation and The Guardian --- let alone the Israel's worst enemy, Haaretz.
2. Oh, really?
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.20.11)
Since when did an American president who is trying his hardest to force Israel to its pre-Six Day War borders and takes every opportunity to humiliate the State of Israel and insult Israel's leadership become a friend of Israel? Since when did an American president who does his best to bully Israel into negotiating with terrorists become "the best thing Israel has going for it?" That's the craven part. Here's a news flash: Israel is a sovereign state. Get that? SOVEREIGN STATE. Not an American vassal. Deal with it.
3. Ohh...I think, that the late Yassir Arafat
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (09.20.11)
also felt some "tough love" for Israel, at least he also got the Nobel Peace prize...
4. Obama will be history in two years..
Devy ,   EARTH   (09.20.11)
while ERETZ ISRAEL will be here forever. " The collective view here" is a whole bunch of crap, just a blink of a millisecond in our history as people, tied to the land of our forefathers. No need for pseudo friends with their personal agendas. STAND TALL ISRAEL !
5. You've got to be kidding!!!!!
James ,   Raleigh US   (09.20.11)
All this president has done is slap Netanyahu in the face every chance he's had.
6. I want to throw up. What happened to truth and sanity?
Kayla ,   Florida   (09.20.11)
7. to no 2
Salma, ,   Palestine   (09.20.11)
Here's a news flash for you.Obama will be the next President.Why?because the Republicans have NO one capable to be the Prez of US.Get that?
8. Majority of US Jews still support him
Mark Jeffery Koch ,   Cherry Hill, NJ USA   (09.20.11)
Barack Obama has increased aid to Israel at a time millions of Americans lost their homes and millions of Americans lost their jobs. He has protected Israel at the U.N. every single time, and intelligence and military cooperation between the two countries is at its highest level ever. He called for negotiations based on the 1967 borders with land swaps which has not only been the official American position for the past forty years but a position endorsed by the previous four Israeli Prime Ministers except the current one who came to this country last May and proceeded to lecture the country responsible for giving it more aid than any other country in the world. (including aid America gives to the top ten poorest countries combined.) Israeli's are furious our President supposedly let their friends, the dictators in Tunesia and Egypt be overthrown, but how could America prop up oppressive dictators and tyrants who deprived their citizens of freedom and gave them a life of abject poverty while the leaders lived an opulent lifestyle? How dare Israeli's criticize our government for supporting people who were living under a dictatorship and wanted freedom? You like to brag that you are the only democracy in the Middle East but yet you lambast Obama for not allowing the tyrant of Egypt to contnue denying his people freedom. The problem is that Israel is a country today that has right wing leaders who do not want a resolution of the Israeli Palestinian conflict and who cater to the settlers who continue to illegally expropriate more and more Palestinian land. Obama wants a fair and just solution to the conflict and wants a State of Palestine living next to a secure and safe State of Israel. Israels leaders do not want this. They want the Palestinians to disappear and for daring to try to work for a day when there are two States living side by side in peace the right wing here and in America are hell bent on destroying Obama. In the end they are only hurting Israel, and that is very sad. Those of you who fantasize that an Obama defeat in 2012 will end your problems with Turkey, Egypt, Iran, and the rest of the world are in for a big surprise. You will soon be left with the evangelicals in America as your only supporters. Americans are tired of fighting wars in Iraq and Afganistan and are tired of Israel demanding more than any other country has ever demanded. You are a nation of 7 million people out of a world population of 5 billion people but yet you expect the President of the U.S. and the people of the U.S. to genuflect before you. If you cannot make peace with the Palestinians who have only rockets when you have the best military in the Middle East, the world's second best airforce, nuclear weapons, planes, tanks, and state of the art weapons then you have only yourselves to blame. You fools will wake up the day after Obama is defeated and still not realize the problem is not Obama but your own right wing government. A republican President cannot and will not save you from your failed leadership.
9. It occurs to me that if Obama is ousted
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (09.20.11)
as a result of the next election (and he will be), this article is set up to "blame the Jews" for his downfall. Like the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion" insist, Jews "rule the world" and each of our enemies and would-be enemies will articulate this (false) fact. Signs of what's to come.
10. Obama is the best for Israel
k ,   US   (09.20.11)
It is the truth, do not fall for the Republican propaganda While Obama might not be gung ho Israel, I assure you he will support Israel and he wants to see peace in the area The Republicans want votes Any Jew who votes Republican is insane
11. Fundamentalist Christians
Nick ,   NYC, USA   (09.20.11)
in the Republican Party dote on Israel because they want to prepare for Christ's second coming at the end of the world. If that's what you guys want, then support the Republicans. If you want someone who's sane--albeit not the most effective person to hold office--then Obama's your man.
12. No. 9--Paranoid much?
Nick ,   NYC, USA   (09.20.11)
Obama's possible defeat in 14 months will be blamed on the Jews? Oy vey zmir! Take a pill, man.
13. fool profiling
daze ,   US   (09.20.11)
When I found out that 80% of US Jews voted for obama, it was a surprise. With his background and having so many friends and supporters that are virulently anti Jewish and anti Israel how could so many Jews vote for him. Well, thanks to Jews like m rosenberg, tommy friedman and this guy, benhorin, a pattern emerges. After 3+ years, they still spew the same drivel. I realize that these boobs have some kind of agenda. The hope is the rest of US Jews have come around and will vote obama out. 80% Jewish support for a guy that openly hates Jews and Israel is a very embarassing statistic
14. apology
daze ,   US   (09.20.11)
Sorry Mr Benhorin, I just noticed that you are the author of the Ynet article, not the New York Magazine piece
15. reply#8
daze ,   US   (09.20.11)
No increase in aid to Israel. That money goes to the US defense industry, keeps your uncle schmecky working. Not '67 borders, he wants '48 borders -non starter. Israel was neutral in the arab spring, they sat back like the rest of us watching arabs beat each other up. Israel is Jewish land. Israel gives as much or more in training and technology back to the US. mark you fool, your blathering post of nonsense is way too long
16. To: No. 7
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.20.11)
Most Americans would vote for a Republican chimpanzee if it means getting rid of the Moslem Kenyan in the White House. Get that?
17. To: No. 8
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.20.11)
Did your parents not know how to spell "Jeffrey?"
18. The Republicans are far better friends of Israel.
Chaim ,   Israel   (09.20.11)
Clearly the New York magazine is attempting to delude Jews to, once again, support the most hostile U.S. President Israel has ever faced. Obama's disgusting treatment of Israel and her P.M. are too well known to need repetition here. Nothing is more insulting that New York Magazine's inference that Israel is a foolish child in need of Obama's "tough love". Obama accomplished nothing noteworthy before becoming U.S. President and his term as President is an unmitigated disaster. Yet according to ridiculous New York Magazine, Israel is supposed to obey this joke. The Republicans are far better friend of Israel than the Democrats. It's time to abandon the Democrats.
19. 120% CORRECT
jl ,   usa   (09.20.11)
let's put the green line behind us, literally. let's forgo the batch of kool-air, cultic fantasies, and move forward with the greatest jewish project in history. OBAMA all the way! sovereign and am umedinat yisrael chaim in peace and sovereignty beside hamas-free palestine.
20. also, how is a talkback from SARAH B...
jl ,   usa   (09.20.11)
always to be expected in the top five. not hating, Ms. B, but how do you have SO much free time on your hands??
21. America
Truth ,   Canada   (09.20.11)
The America doesn't like any country that disagrees with it. Netenyahu had the bravery to stand up to Obama's ludicrous demands, and now leftist Jews are whining about it.
22. Idiots.
Vlad   (09.20.11)
Obama is the reason for Israel's growing isolation right now. Israel and the PA were just beginning to talk security and economics, and Israel was gradually removing its checkpoints, when Obama came in and demanded direct talks. He then demanded a settlement freeze, something never previously demanded, without understanding there was a reason why previous US governments never pushed the issue: The Palestinians immediately had to adopt a hardline stance on settlements to appease their own public. Their stance was so hardline, they rejected the freeze as inadequate and didn't begin to talk until it was nearly finished, and then Obama demanded another, something Netanyahu could not have done as it would break apart his fragile coalition government. So the talks began deadlocked, and the Palestinians thus began a campaign to isolate Israel. Obama could easily have stopped the UN bid when it was first announced by strong language and threats. Instead, he hesitated, forcing Abbas to proceed for fear of losing credebility with his own public. When he finally came out against it, it was too late for Abbas to back down. Throughout his term, Obama became notable for trying to force Israel to cave to almost all Palestinian demands, including the 1967 borders and division of Jerusalem. He humiliated Netanyahu by refusing to meet with him in public and walked out on a meeting with him while embracing despots, and imposed a de-facto arms embargo on Israel by refusing to approve most Israeli arms purchase requests. He'd be even worse if it were his second term, and he had no need to cater to the pro-Israel public. He'd fully support the UN bid. Bet on that.
23. obumma is the best muslum president the saudis ever had.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (09.20.11)
24. wow!
Taylor Jones ,   USA   (09.20.11)
Boy, am I grateful for magazines such as NY Times to 'open my eyes' to the truth, at last! It is clear that the writers are misinformed, and confused! The worry is the amount of people who will read this and agree- or worse, change their mind! "Let me be clear" - as good ol' Obama would say, he is NO FRIEND to Jews, OR Israel. How do I know? A. his body language in all photos taken with Israeli dignitaries. B. Oh, I don't know- his POLICIES. WAKE UP NY TIMES, THIS IS SO BIASED IT'S SHAMEFUL!
25. My laundry list for Obama
sk ,   New York, US   (09.20.11)
When Obama pardons Pollard, moves the embassy to Jerusalem and recognizes it as the Israeli capital, we can talk about him being the first Jewish president.
26. The collective view in Muslim WH is not the one in the US
Marco ,   Spain   (09.20.11)
27. Never again?
David M.   (09.20.11)
No wonder Jews are having problems.With delusional people like some of the talk-backs 8&10, how can we defend ourselves from the very dangerous and anti-Semitic world we live in. I guess they will wake up on a train to Never Never land, but at that point it may be too late.
28. Robert #9 - You nailed it
Stu   (09.20.11)
That is exactly what is going to happen.
29. Dont trust the NYPost. The leftist Jews are trying hard
(09.20.11)
to salvage Obama and throw Israel under tne bus.
30. democrats getting desperate
usa   (09.20.11)
Desperately trying spin obamas policies.
Next talkbacks
Back to article