News
Turkish list of flotilla soldiers a sham?
Sa'ar Haas
Published: 27.09.11, 00:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
25 Talkbacks for this article
1. "Valuable"? Then Sultan Erdogan should take them to court
PETER SM ,   AUSTRALIA   (09.27.11)
2. So much for the intelligence operatives
Danny   (09.27.11)
I hope they enjoyed the humus and the beach.
3. Turkey is a sham
arshile gorky ,   nyc, usa   (09.27.11)
Turkey won't survive the AKP. tick tock tick tock...
4. Hahahaha...crack Turkish intelligence....
RichInBoston ,   Boston USA   (09.27.11)
hahahaha...too funny.
5. So what, the Turkish list is like the Tanah
Michael ,   California, USA   (09.27.11)
Year is not a year, place is not a place, King is not a king, Prophet is not a prophet. Read the Turkish list as generic, mufshat, forget factual accuracy.
6. they all guilty as charged
turkman ,   istanbul   (09.27.11)
there were no sham in picking the list but it exclude the big Cahona Bibi natenyahoo his name was saved for last
7. no wonder turkey is such a looser. quiet don't say a thing
ralph   (09.27.11)
they'll never know. better a stupid arrogant enemy than a smart one.
8. THERE IS A WORD FOR IT : JIHAD
American ,   Los Angeles   (09.27.11)
and turkeyis in the center of it. There never been such a serious threat for the israel's security.
9. Does this surprise anyone?
Vlad   (09.27.11)
With such tensions between Israel and Turkey, the security forces are probably on high alert, and Turkish travellers are being monitored. Does anyone really believe that MIT could slip agents into Israel without Shin Bet intercepting?
10. Turkey caught lying... again!
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, DC USA   (09.27.11)
11. flotilla
gadot ,   herzlia   (09.27.11)
please give me the honor of placing my name on the list as an Israeli soldier,now retired.
12. turkey flotilla
joel ,   usa   (09.27.11)
the days of ottoman turks are long gone and won't be back anymore, so erdogan must shut his big mouth!
13. Turkish list a sham?
Pierre   (09.27.11)
Turkey is a sham--- Erdogan is a sham -- Dovutoglu is a sham -- their intelligence is a sham -- No need to go further down the list, too close to the gutter.
14. it doesn't matter, both lists will find way to ICC
observer ,   Egypt   (09.27.11)
when the Palestine state is UN recognized.
15. It's only about Turkish PR
Yael Schlichting ,   Raubling - Germany   (09.27.11)
Turkey only gathered a list to finally present a list and say: These are the guys we are hunting! And they are hunting our soldiers not because they had anything to do with the raid. They are hunting these men, because they are Jews! Never forget!!! As an appropriate counter action I recommend to run a campaign in western countries that advocates for victims of the Muslim regimes, inclusive Gaza and West Bank. - Torture in Muslim countries - Apartheid and racism in Muslim countries - draconian punishment, Sharia and arbitrariness - Women's rights and abuse in Muslim countries - children abuse, by teaching them hate in Muslim countries Advocate for freedom in Muslim countries. Make sure, that most of them aren't better than Iran. They only are different.
16. Please add my name, too!
Yael Schlichting ,   Raubling - Germany   (09.27.11)
Please add my name to this list, for unconditionally supporting Israel and for promoting the flotilla raid as a lawful act!
17. Think guys/gals...
idkak ,   Istanbul   (09.27.11)
There is absolutely no reason for the Turkish MIT (NSA) / Government to even publish such a list to begin with its immoral. So the list is a sham, put together by some "reporter" working for the Dogan Holding for some gain... (They own most of visual and printed media in Turkey)... Israel will deny it regardless and the media in Israel will provide the fuel for the next article in the same news network... its funny really.
18. Mavi Marmara
Tal ,   Jerusalem   (09.27.11)
We are all soldiers on the Mavi Marmara
19. #17 Your claims are false
(09.27.11)
This list was published by Zaman and Sabah newspaper, both of which are radical and pro-Erdogan papers. Sabah is owned by Erdogan's relatives and Zaman is owned by the political/religious cult that is closely linked with Erdogan's party. IHH is doing stupid things as usual, and pro-Erdogan government's puppet media is giving an opportunity to IHH by publishing this sham list.
20. I suggest a petition to Turkey PM :
Barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (09.27.11)
That each and every one of us - Israelis - sign a petition that all of us took part in the Flotilla Raid.
21. #14 - I would love to see this
William ,   Israel   (09.27.11)
A State of Palestine suing Israel in the ICC under grounds of violating its sovereignty prior to the State of Palestine existing and even having a sovereignty. How long do you think that request to the judges will last on their desk before being rejected....leaving enough time for laughter, of course. It's the same argument I heard Arabs make in justifying the massacre of Jews in 1920...because Jews pushed for a State in 1948. If time were cyclical rather than linear, you'd have an argument. But your concept of natural physics, just like justice, is simply convoluted.
22. Please add my name, too!
Harald Geersen ,   Holland   (09.27.11)
Me too.
23. list
Melody Bier ,   Emeryville USA   (09.28.11)
Simply put : "Turkish intelligence" is quite the oxymoron!
24. You make me laugh!
Michael Morgan ,   London   (09.28.11)
Of course every article on this site is 100% accurate! lol Of course the Israeli Government NEVER lies! lol Of course there is no such thing as propoganda! lol Of course pigs will fly! Dream on people.......
25. 24
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (09.29.11)
Of course you might just laugh yourself to death too.
Back to article