Jewish Scene
Bibles rescued from Syria in secret op
Uri Misgav
Published: 05.10.11, 14:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
31. #29 Andy, 6 out of the 7 winners are Jewish
observer ,   Egypt   (10.06.11)
So, Christians are no better than Muslims. Alfred wouldn't have started the Nobel Prize for a thing like Jewish science.
32. #15 so you say after stealing log book record of properties
observer   (10.06.11)
The discoveries made by the new archaeology discredited a great exodus in the 13th century BC. Moses could not have led the Hebrews out of Egypt into the Promised Land, for the good reason that the latter was Egyptian territory at the time. And there is no trace of either a slave revolt against the pharaonic empire or of a sudden conquest of Canaan by outsiders. Ben Gurion declared; "Why should the Arabs make peace? If I was an Arab leader I would never make terms with Israel. That is natural: we have taken their country. Sure, God promised it to us, but what does that matter to them? Our God is not theirs. We come from Israel, it's true, but two thousand years ago, and what is that to them? There has been antisemitism, the Nazis, Hitler, Auschwitz, but was that their fault? They only see one thing: we have come here and stolen their country. Why should they accept that?"
33. @ #29 Andy
Rob Soran-Schwartz ,   EU   (10.06.11)
Observer's comment is easy to understand, apparently except for those who reach their limits with counting Jewish blood cells among Nobel prize winners ...
34. It made my day
Rob Soran-Schwartz ,   EU   (10.06.11)
The right story for the High Holidays. 16 years old, religious, with the wrong picture (new book ...), and as inflated as a Jewish/Israeli story can be. It made me laugh, this Mossad "coup d'art": the greatest, most complex, ultra-secretive, hugely expensive intelligence operation ever staged by the state of Israel for a number of very old books a rabbi already confused with G0d :-)) Ridiculous. BTW: I may assure all those interested: It never was too difficult to smuggle antiquities out of Syria. The proof? Thousands of objects brought out of Syria without Syrian knowledge ....
35. These aren't bibles ...
Rob Soran-Schwartz ,   EU   (10.06.11)
Bible is a term that refers to the common/shared portions of the Tanakh (Jewish canon) and the Christian biblical canons (New Testament)
36. #12??
joan ,   haifa   (10.06.11)
She's rightly referred to as Judy Feld Carr in the article *here*. What's the problem?
37. Awesome!
Steve B. ,   USA   (10.06.11)
Praise the true G-d of Israel who was instrumental in the safe passage of these holy books. He surely guided the individuals who dared so much to bring the Truth home to it's rightful resting place...and not among the heathen. G-d bless Israel and the Jews only Jerusalem! A Christian Zionist
38. "Stolen" Bibles.
Jimbo Salsa ,   Mexico   (10.06.11)
Observer, we just recovered that which is ours. Those books were stolen from us. Recovering stolen property isn't theft.
39. Observer: Ignorance is Bliss
Steve B. ,   USA   (10.06.11)
You are without doubt one of the least educated persons I've ever had the displeasure of reading; however, what can expect from someone who is brainwashed into believing in a cult like Islam (false moon god and a pedophile for a false phophet). Read some real history, and not the crap (Koran/hadiths) that you are forced-fed by a bunch of intolerant, ignorant bigots who have no ability for rational thought nor reasoning process. Now, as a Christian, I will pray for your lost soul so that you will come to the true G-d that is found in the Judeo/Christian scriptures. G-d bless Israel!
40. antiquities trafficking is an economic issue
observer ,   Egypt   (10.06.11)
Frankly if people have no food in their mouths, and they see a source of income they will probably take it. If there was no demand from the West, the price would drop. it works like the drugs trade: if there were no consumers for the end product there would be no suppliers.
41. Chumash or Tanakh?
Mike ,   Palos Verdes USA   (10.07.11)
I don't think ynet wd describe Torah scrolls as "Bibles". These are presumably bound books. And since 1995 they are in Israel. Good idea.
42. It is not stealing if it is your to begain with.
Bob in SC ,   USA   (10.08.11)
These Holy Books were in Damascus for the use of the Jewish faith, they were secured and preserved by people of faith and were not the property of the Islamist in Syria or the Syrian government. Because of the Islamist these Holy Books had to be smuggled out due to Islamist and their wonton distruction of items of other religions. Thanks to these brave people the WORLD now has for view some of the oldest Biblical material availble. Thank You.
43. #7 so why it's been "transplanted" in "James Bond-style"
fred ,   canada   (10.09.11)
#7 so why it's been "transplanted" in "James Bond-style" in a secret op.. they should ask for it. as simple as that.!!!
44. #26, maybe they meant "from Syria to Israel" (EOM)
Michele ,   Minneapolis   (10.09.11)
45. Stolen?
Yaacov ,   Tel Aviv   (10.09.11)
Take back something that belongs to you is not stollen
46. # 32 stealing books and land
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (10.09.11)
observer ! The Syrian regime was and is among the most barbaric and cruel governments on earth,it countinuesly persecuted the Jewish community in Syria,Jewish homes were marked,"Mosawy" (Jewish) so,you, believe that those holy Jewish books belong to the Syrian regime ?.thats insane,concerning Israel,again,the Jews in Israel have more rights over the land of Israel, than the muslims over Egypt,the Jews in Israel speak the language,practice the religion and culture of the inhabitants of the land 2000 years ago,while the muslim invaders of Egypt destroyed the great Egyptian civilization,enslaved the real Egyptians,the christian Copts,changed the religion and language of Egypt,and turned Egypt Into a basket case.
47. #1 Observer You Might want to Learn your Own Quran before
meir elazar   (10.09.11)
addressing our Holy Books. The Quran clearly addresses The Land of Israel belonging to the Children of Israel in Surah 5 sentences 20-21. Today the Arabs are trying to rewrite History with Monkey Boy Ahmadinejad denying the Holocaust, and your feeble attempt to deny the Exodus, etc. Please note that the Moabite Stone clearly corroborates the battle between Mesha and Omri as documented in Kings 2 Chapter 3. Furthermore, there is a despicable attempt by the Arabs to destroy archaelogical evidence of our history in Israel on the Temple Mount and other places. Please document which archaeological evidence you are citing regarding the evidence. I seriously doubt there is ANY credibility to your claims. But at the same time I seriously doubt that you are man enough to stand by your claims and cite any credible source.
48. Look y'hear
Moragh   (10.10.11)
If you are in a hurry to get rid of God's Word (referring of course to the original Bibles), I will gladly pay the postage and cost of sending them to me . What I wouldn't give to read just one page from them. How wonderful that you got them out of the hands of muslims from Syria.
49. Display Wednesday night - on a hag?
David ,   Shiloh Israel   (10.10.11)
50. Bibles to ISRAEL & USA
Haiep Reth ,   USA   (10.11.11)
Praise To THE LIVING G D He keeps His Word and spreads His Word like wildfire! Thank You Father
51. Rightful Owners!
Aloha-Greg Keleko ,   Merrillville, In. US   (10.17.11)
Not Stolen!....Re-captured and returned to it's rightful homeland and people.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article