News
Sarkozy: It is silly to talk about a Jewish state
Lior Zilberstein
Published: 06.10.11, 09:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
92 Talkbacks for this article
61. sarkozy
Yankelev, PhD, Msc' ,   Coral Springs USA   (10.06.11)
FRANCE IS HISTORICALLY AND POLITICALLY A WHORE, ADDICTED TO "DOLCE VITA" ABOVE ALL. THINK OF WW2, FOR EXAMPLE.
62. elections next year in france...
dG ,   paris, france   (10.06.11)
this guy is disgusting! he always said he is a true friend of Israel!! Is that a joke??!! this guy neved understood the legitimity of the israeli needs. It is time for him to throw the small french jewish community and flirt with the huge muslim community in France, one year before the presidential elections... Disgusting
63. FRANCE
PAULO ,   brazil   (10.06.11)
Frenchmen continue to think they won WW II... It's a desease cause by post-Napoleon generations.
64. who cares
william ,   Canada   (10.06.11)
Sarkosy,a very small man with a very big mouth,and nothing of import to say,,ever.
65. It goes both ways, Sarko.
Vlad   (10.06.11)
If Abbas wants to throw tantrums over settlements, which were never previously an issue, than Netanyahu has every right to set demands of his own.
66. France is a nation of homosexuals
Dan S. ,   USA   (10.06.11)
67. French nation...one to give advice?
Michael Durbin ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (10.06.11)
No longer. Now drowning in their imported madness, if there was a French nation, it is no more. Now in a deep hole, Sarkozy prefers that others yield their national identity as well. Our stubborn persistence to maintain our identity offends those whose own has long since faded into memory. And will sustain us through much more than this.
68. most politicians are prostitutes, what do you expect
Oleg ,   USA   (10.06.11)
from Sarcozy?
69. Sarkozy
David J ,   Minooka, USA   (10.06.11)
Is France a French state? There are millions of Arabs living there!
70. Shades of Dreyfus
Norman Gellman ,   Rehovot   (10.06.11)
The inherent anti-Jewish sentiment in France is apparent once again ala the Dreyfus incident. The anti Jewish attitude stems from the inherent Catholic position that the Jews killed Christ & the large number of Muslims now residing in France. Sarkozy obviously wants the Muslim vote to stay in power. World War II showed that the French cannot be trusted they will take any convenient position to suit their desires.
71. France, on the other hand, never fails to disappoint us
Gene   (10.06.11)
From the time of Dreyfus affair through the collaboration with nazis to the betrayal in the aftermath of the six days war.
72. Sarcozy who ? (End).
Nora Tel Aviv   (10.06.11)
73. #35 Not quite Haider
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (10.06.11)
Saudi Arabia doesn't allow Jews in. Israel allows all religions to practice their faith. Just as was outlined in the Balfour Declaration. Haider = Short circuit
74. Vichy's goberment
Jorge ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (10.06.11)
The title of the note should refer of Vichy's descendents do not want a Jewish state, it will make more understandable
75. Dissapointment?
Raymond ,   Aruba   (10.06.11)
The problem that France have, is that Israel won't bend over for the European Union.
76. Minus one
norman ,   france, Eurabia   (10.06.11)
I am french, (i'm not jew) and for sure this man is very disapointing and for years new he never failed to disapoint me with his arab policy. Maybe some money from the gulf states... ;-) And i will not fail to give my vote to him... minus one.
77. With friends like you..
Ezra ,   Florida   (10.06.11)
we do not need enemies. As they say: From the antisemites you cameth and to the antisemites you will returnth.
78. sarkozy
vlad ,   copenhagen   (10.06.11)
i think sarkozy sides here with the humane side, not with the palestinians. israeli government policy is the cause.
79. #3. France never fails to bow before tyranny.
Chaim ,   Israel   (10.06.11)
#3. Israel should not feel disappointed by the French. In order to feel disappointed, one must have expectations. There is no reason to have any expectations from France. France never fails to bow before tyranny. It's their national character.
80. And ABBAS has declared that there won't be Jews in his state
Galutia ,   SELAH   (10.06.11)
Abbas a Statesman ...my foot ! =========== better two states within one nation ..one with a muslim flavor & a jewish presence and the other with a jewish flavor & a muslim presence.... =========== but untill the messiah comes Jacob and Ismael will continue thier bickering...
81. Sarkozy and the Islamic state of France
DR ,   Wales   (10.06.11)
Silly Sarkozy ought to look around him at the Islamic state of France...
82. France glory
JORGE ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (10.06.11)
France is one of country that surrended to the dictatorial power without a fight. The France glory happens that after being under the conqueror boot, request help from USA and England. Remember 1940- 1944 and now the same
83. Sarkozy is a srial liar and criminal
Patrick ,   London   (10.06.11)
We call him the The Hungarian of the Parisian underworld and that's for a good reason....he lies every 15 minutes..so don't be surprises that he claims to be friends with israel and then act as the head anti semite in France.
84.  to 24
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (10.07.11)
"The Chained Duck" ,is that Sarkozy's favorite restaurant.Probably where all serious Frenchmen meet.
85. 38
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (10.07.11)
He will even wear a burqa.
86. Merci Sarkozy
Truthseeker ,   USA   (10.07.11)
You make me love France even more. It is way past time for a leader in the West to speak the truth and be unafraid to do so. Too many leaders in the West, includng every American president, shrink from the truth because they know the possible consequences. That makes the actions of Sarkozy even more commendable and brave. Merci Sarkozy
87. Judaism's greatest enemy is Zionism...
Robert Zibi ,   Cleveland, Oh. USA   (10.07.11)
Judaism's greatest enemy is Zionism...
88. Sarkozy
felcie ,   jerusalem, israel   (10.07.11)
Not only Sarkozy forgets his one side roots, but he also becomes an ennemy? the Jewish People have the Right on her Jewish State as the French for their State even if there are millions of Arabs from Maroco, Algier and Tunis, so they still do not want to belong to one of these states or perhaps one has to see Sarkozy as an arab leader?
89. dumb comments and Sarcozy is right.
Norm   (10.07.11)
In previous negotions such as those held by Barack, no one brought up that the Arabs had to recognize Israel as a Jewish state. This was brought up by Netanyahu because he didn't want talks in the first place. If there is peace, how are the Arabs going to dictate what kind of state Israel would be? It was a non issue until Netenyahu made it one. I notice in these pages that everyone who doesn't agree with every Israeli position is "stupid", drunk, or some other invective. Well, I guess the commentsi in US talk backs are just as stupid.
90. # 1 and # 5 hit the jackpot
(10.07.11)
Israel's security exaggerated ?. Would a few slit throats satisfy this demoniac sect?, born in blood, crime, murder, who's only " raison d'etre " is the sradication of the Jews. so they can enjoy the fruits of their hard labor without lifting a finger. Sarkozy, Obama, Camerom, Merkel are more than welcome to take them ALL. I am sure that they would mold them to their taste in order to become examplairy to the old world's charms : no cut throats, no stoning, no amputation, no stonning, no wife beating, (the rags of islamM } and of course this cursed sharia , koran, and other edits popping out daily. Simply a new dawn. Now all these changes will show determination, tenacity, courage After all when one spend Billions on them, it must show a great affection and endurring love. The dawn of a new Europe ( who doesn't give a damn ) anyway is around the corner.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article