News  Magazine
PA rewriting Jewish history
Giulio Meotti
Published: 11.10.11, 15:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. which is why we should annex every site we still control
ralph   (10.11.11)
which contains jewish history.
2. Ebla tablets, classical denial tablets evidence proto hebrew
ralph   (10.11.11)
written language not arabic. further prooof we were there in syria also. scared the shit out of the syrians when finding was first announced. they feared now israel would justify more land in syria. which we should demand be returned to us. its ours not theirs. when are we going to start yelling and screaming. why are we so quiet? this impresses no one.
3. trying to ""rewrite"" history
tiki ,   belgium   (10.11.11)
Makes it ""rewritten"" history, not the history. It's like a 50 year old woman having a face lift, trying to look 30. It won't work, she still be 50.
4. Wow, finally Palestinians are taking charge of
Edithann ,   USA   (10.11.11)
their land. DNA and testing can tell if bones are Jewish or Palestinian... I bet it was a Jewish/Nobel Prize winner who developed that test... Hahahahah. TATA
5. National Geographic magazine ran a “Travel Palestine” ad tha
Maurice ,   Montreal   (10.11.11)
I will cancel my National Geographic channel and will never buy any of their publications again! All Israel supporters should do the same.
6. Muslims base the Koran on the Bible.
noa ,   israel   (10.11.11)
7. to #4 not just DNA, but burial form.
ghostq   (10.11.11)
8. lies and lies
Victor Gerbi   (10.11.11)
According to this extraordinary article, Arabs are spreading lies and the nations believe them
9. so if they find proof jews lived there before islam...
Yonatan ,   Tsfat, Israel   (10.11.11)
So if they find proof that jews lived on the land before Islam, they would accept it, or would they make that out to be a conspiracy by the zionist.
10. They'll be able to enjoy their propaganda victory in Jordan.
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (10.11.11)
11. #4 tata
solomon ,   bklyn   (10.11.11)
No, the "Pals" are stealing land. The arabs are from arabia (get it?) and only came in the 600's AD. But what are facts to you, right?
12. "Ebonics" of 'pal ' culture
Bad assed Jew. ,   United States   (10.11.11)
the pals can try till they die but, everyone but them knows the Jews were in Israel for over 4,000 years.
13. Good Morning Israelis
Yaacov ,   Tel Aviv   (10.11.11)
Do you know what is the origin of "Palestine"?
14. They can try as much as they want...
Keren ,   IL-BR   (10.11.11)
They will keep failing ,because to deny Jews existence is to deny the existence of all humanity,and of course,all humanity can not do that( they have tried already ,many times, with no avail, because Jews keep regenerating,no matter what, for as misterious as it can seem). If we and our history do not exist,well...who exists then? Who are all peoples in the world if taken out of Jewish context and history? Answer somebody ,please.
15. Truth exposed! Let's stop lies
Baruch sayed ,   Ny   (10.11.11)
16. Balestinian muslims discover America
Rehavam ,   Israel   (10.11.11)
Build Pyramids etc. Read all about it.
17. revisionism
chaim witz ,   guatemala   (10.11.11)
This is what happens when an enemy declares war on you but you do not declare war on him.
18. #4
lisa   (10.11.11)
If it weren't for Jews, you wouldn't have medicines, health, mobiles, applications: SCIENCE AT LARGE!!!! MORON!
19. Antisemitic priest send to' Holy Land
Anna M Sedda ,   Rome-Italy   (10.11.11)
Unfortunately in just 5 years of study antisemitism and antijudaism anyone can be' a "priest";most of the vatican priest preach the "replacement teology" that makes priest feel better than Jews...let s say that the Middle Age Vatican sponsored priests are still a lot,and the more you are antisemitic,the more chances you have to be the archbishop of Jerusalm... In Rome it s fashionable to be antisemitic and antiZionist....it s just part of some old catholic and does not die ,jet....
20. They are learning from the Israelis
(10.11.11)
That's how we've been using archeology in Israel. To enforce the claim over the land by means of history. It's really quite known that the archeology department is a political wing. Nothing surprising here. What the PA is doing is obvious and why shouldn't they do it? Wake up people.
21. Doesn't Israel have control and have to issue permits????
Unbelievable Idiocy ,   Israel   (10.11.11)
Why are revisionists digging in Israel with foreign money? Unbelievable. This would hapen in the US?
22. "Rachel’s Tomb is the Bilal ibn Rabah mosque"
Jake ,   USA   (10.11.11)
...that one had me ROFL
23. It's time!
Steve ,   USA   (10.11.11)
It's time for the Temple Mount to be excavated. Enough pussy footing around with the Arabs. Flatten the two 'modern era' mosques on the site and resurrect the Temple. All I ever hear from Arabs about 'history' is the same garbage they were spouting years ago. They now believe their own 'myths'. Unbelievable! Used to be quite funny to hear the 'stories' they'd spout about 'what really happened'. Now not only do they believe their own garbage, but of course now the anti-Israel, anti-Jewish UN and anti- Semitic factions of Christianity (mostly in Europe - though in the US also) believe the crap also. Or at least it fit's better with their ideology. Raise the mosques and send in both Jewish and gentile archeologists to document their finds. Just like every other excavation in Israel, this one will show positive results (Hebrew, Israelite, Jewish) also. Let the Arabs dig in Saudi Arabia for any remnants of their ancient path. How long do sheepskin tents stay preserved under ground?
24. PA rewriting Jewish history
Tom Hough ,   Natchitoches, LA   (10.11.11)
The land of Israel is not naturally as rich as either the Tigress and Euphratese or the Nile Valleys. Israel is an example of what a wasteland can be when it is the land of an idustrious people under the blessings of G_d. While cities existed at the time of the Hebrew conquest they flourished under the Jews. Muslims have from the bigginning stolen what belonged to others and then claimed it as culturally theirs. Just as the accomplishments of the pre Islamic Egyptians and Babylonians became the acomplishmsnts of Muslim Arabs the accomplishment of Jews are becomming the acomplishments of the Arabs through deceptive archeology.
25. rewrite history
moron ,   galut   (10.11.11)
cancel oslo
26. PA rewriting Jewish history
Johannes ,   Oslo, NORWAY   (10.11.11)
Jeremiah 12:14 "...my WICKED neighbors who seize the inheritance I gave my people Israel..."
27. Muslims base the Koran...
NN ,   Norway   (10.11.11)
In their wickedness they have distorted the Bible!
28. #4 Edithann,USA
Malone ,   Hfx   (10.11.11)
I have seen some of your posts in the past,not impressed..I picture you as an older,lonely, hate filled person,that doesn't like Jews or Israel.and expresses by inane comments,highlighted by childish "hahahahas" and your trademark idiotic "tata"...may you stew in your own bile,Edithann.
29. More Muslim Lies about Jews and Israel
DrJLD   (10.11.11)
They are nothing more than liars. The old testament is at the heart of their beliefs, yet they lie about ancient Israel and Jews. Their arrogance of Islam and the willingness of the West to buy these lies is enormous.
30. #4 Edithann - Let's test your bones
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (10.11.11)
to see what you are Let's see if your laughing afterwards
Next talkbacks
Back to article