News
US fears uncoordinated Israeli strike on Iran
Alex Fishman
Published: 31.10.11, 10:24
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
142 Talkbacks for this article
31. To: No. 9
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.31.11)
Israel is better than the United States armed forces. Remember Somalia? Yuk!
32. To: David at No. 19
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.31.11)
She doesn't have one. Her mother has tiny feet, though, either in Jerusalem, Jaffa or Akko. Depending on the day of the week, she purports to be from all three places. Three-in-one slime, I guess.
33. To #7, thank you
Oleg   (10.31.11)
so Salma, since according to you Israel is too coward to attack Iran , you saying Israel should be brave and attack Iran. You are supporting then the military strike on Iran. Good for you. I do too.
34. To: 21/22/23/25/30/31
Mark of Lewiston ,   USA   (10.31.11)
I'm fine with leaving the maths to others when they are not trying to paint targets on US kids and ships. I'll also be happy when the people who want a war have a few hundred thousand of their own troops in the Gulf sitting on ships or in Afghanistan and playing target like US Marines or Army and sailors are doing today. Haven't seen any Israeli troops or ships in the Gulf. As for Obama, Jabo mistakes Obama for John McCain & Charlton Heston. McCain is the one who thought Obama was the Mahdi. McCain is the one denouncing Obama for not sending troops into Libya and Syria. And I do know a little about Japan, I was born on a military base there. Our people went in there within days of Nagasaki. Hiroshima was a bit warm, too. It did take time to cool both off before it became safer. Big industrial places now, Ben.Have you been to Yokohama or Tokyo, yet?
35. Obama's thoughts.
Vlad   (10.31.11)
He remembers the Cold War with the Soviet Union, and thinks that Israel and Iran will not attack each other for fear of each other. He actually might be right about that one: Iran may be a fanatical Islamic dictatorship, but it is not suicidal. The main existential threat is from the mere threat of nuclear annihilation. Think about it: Will our economy survive? Tourism might dry up and people may start leaving if Israel is placed under the shadow of nuclear annihilation. Hamas and Hezbollah will grow bolder, feeling they have the backing of a nuclear power behind them. Israel has the option of destroying the Iranian nuclear program via 42 Jericho missiles, but it will face a barrage of missiles and rockets from Iran, Gaza, and Lebanon, which will be at least partially stopped by the Iron Dome, Magic Wand, David's Sling, and Arrow. The second option is to send in the Mossad to plant explosive charges and blow up Iranian nuclear facilities, then deny everything.The third option is to resume production of nukes at Dimona, make it public once we have 1,000 nukes, and openly warn Iran that if Israel ever had any indication that Iran was about to launch a nuke, Israel would carry out a pre-emptive nuclear attack. Over time, we may see the situation stabilize and return to normal. However, I would prefer method two the best.
36. #34, Mark, you have no idea of what you
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (10.31.11)
are talking about...we are talking about some precision strikes...hello !!!
37. #34, You witnessed the recovery in Japan.
Michael ,   California, USA   (10.31.11)
You know of what you speak. I also visited Japan and the immensity of recovery there after Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs is astonishing. More recently, from what I read and hear, Japan is also recovering very well after the arthquake which damaged the Yokohama nuclear power station. Another nuclear reactor to look at after a very serious damage is Chernobyl, in Ukraine. A recent PBS program here showed a long documentary on what the recovery is around Chernobyl. While people are still kept out from returning to a wide area around the damaged power plant, flora and fauna have recovered astonishingly. In many ways, the accident in 1986 at Chernobyl is a distant memory now, but not the memory of those who died. So, after nuclear disasters, there is a way for nature to recover. Naturally, for people to come back to the area of a disaster, it is necessary for people to survive.
38. #14 Mark - I didn't go by accident of birth
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (10.31.11)
I was stationed in Japan, Regular Army, etc. You are all theory, sans practice You one mentioned that somebody or other had employed, what was your job filling jot air balloons? You are the voice of vast non-experience
39. #34...M of L
Malone ,   Hfx   (10.31.11)
What exactly is your point? No one cares if you were born in Japan..no one cares if Ben Jabo has been to Yokohama or Tokyo..as forthe few hundred thousand troops in the Gulf,your "idiot in chief" sent them there,so why should Israel? PS...obama is a complete,total incompetent,in caseyou didn't notice..he should dress up as POTUS tonight,Halloween,he's been impersonating the role long enough>
40. Rettenmoser, the Persian matter is going to require.......
Cameron ,   USA   (10.31.11)
a great deal more than "some precision strikes". Only a sustained & comprehensive bombing campaign can bring the drive for nukes to a halt. The Yanks are necessary for that effort, and would only be successful in a temporary sense at best. Regime change alone will really bring the Persian obsession with nukes to a definite end.
41. Go for it, Israel!
Pop ,   Miami, Florida   (10.31.11)
and get a surprise you may not expect.
42. arabs
The sword of Gideon ,   ft laud USA   (11.01.11)
It is time to go down town,just like egypt,iraq,syria and anywhere else that arab terrorist hide.Israel not only has the know how,they have the will.I can't wait to see tehran smoldering,just like all the criminals in gaza. Jerusalem is the undivided capital of Israel.Lachaim
43. Riiiiiiiight
FaceIt ,   Hawaii   (11.01.11)
Sure. The U.S. has Israel hooked up to a giant computer. All the U.S. has to do is move a giant mouse, and Israel goes to war. Yep. Keep smoking that hashish, Mohammed.
44. To: No. 34
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.01.11)
Oh, please, spare us. I do not care how many children you allegedly have serving in the United States alleged military forces. We don't exactly know you for your credibility, after all. By the way, since you are obviously ignorant of where the American bombs were dropped, it was Hiroshima and Nagasaki. What does Yokohama and Tokyo have to do with anything? Do you really -- NO, REALLY -- think you can outsmart a Jew? Guess again. By the way -- yes, I have been to both Yokohama and Tokyo. Have you? I suspect not. You are a complete fraud. I've outed you. Get lost. Don't make me make you cry. I can, you know. I really can. Just go away. For your own sake. Liar! Go pursue your Arabist political agenda elsewhere. Fraud. Phony.
45. IDIOT
Dave ,   Chubbuck U.S.A.   (11.01.11)
And the village idiot speaks.
46. obama would warn Iran
Rick ,   Fort Wayne, Indiana   (11.01.11)
Of course they won't tell obama before attacking. obama is a muslim and would warn his muslim buddies in Iran of the coming attack! Snuff them all Israel, don't worry, we will be replacing our muslim president with one who supports Israel next year.
47. US fears unilateral Israeli strike on Iran
David ,   Richmond, VA USA   (11.01.11)
US has abandoned Israel. There is no reason they should not protect themselves, with or without the USA. America is too weak to dictate to anyone now.
48. No Second Chance For Israel
suzy000 ,   Virginia, USA   (11.01.11)
I know why the US officials fear this. Israel has warned America to do something and now the drumbeats are getting louder. America (Obama Administration) cannot expect Israel to be a sitting a duck....we, the majority of Americans, would never allow it. With Obama at the helm, we have no idea where he intends to lead this country...we are already on the edge of the cliff as it is.
49. #7
Paul ,   San Diego, USA   (11.01.11)
Was it Israel that waited for help when ALL her neighbors attacked time and time again? Israel is the model of courage. Salma, please get your facts straight. Try not to speak foolishness.
50. We don't own Israel...
Ben ,   Charlotte, USA   (11.01.11)
Israel has every right to do whatever they damn well please, in my opinion. If they were to strike, I think their reasons would be well-founded, and I could only supportive.
51. Israeli Delusions
ragged_soul ,   Canada   (11.01.11)
Thanks for my morning laugh. Israel cannot strike Iran without the US's help. And I cannot wait to see the response if they do.
52. too late
me ,   somewhere, USA   (11.01.11)
53. Iran
Leland Williams ,   Regan, USA   (11.01.11)
This article has it backwards. Israel has already been attacked by IRAN through their surrogates Hamas and Hezbollah. Bet on OIL shooting up to $500 Barrell in the first week. Russia will be ecstatic because then it can supply energy to Nato countries and break up the alliance.
54. You go guys
Artisanal ,   NY NY   (11.01.11)
I want to see them run, like in1967.
55. OBAMA NOT YOUR FRIEND
William Penn ,   Philadelphia, USA   (11.01.11)
Obama is not your friend, Israel. He wants to see you destroyed; wants Muslim Brotherhood rule in the Middle East. Americans know it and Israelis know it. But he will be defeated in November, 2012, relegated to the garbage pail of history.
56. #27 split
solomon ,   bklyn   (11.01.11)
You're doing it again, aren't you? The same ridiculous question that you ask about any and all topics, hoping people can't answer. Then when you get an answer, you run away. There are many, many more examples than the following, if you dare to look. But keep your eyes and ears shut. It's easier. http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,484958,00.html If you google, you will also be able to listen to Ahmed himself.
57. #50 ben- Agreed. An excellent post.
solomon ,   bklyn   (11.01.11)
#50 ben- Agreed. An excellent post.
58. Arabs worried
terwt ,   brooklyn, usa   (11.01.11)
The Arabs ..er.. UN are so worried about Israel's nuclear power, but, of course, close their eyes to everyone else, like Pakistan and Iran.
59. Obama will not help Israel!
Philabias ,   The Obamanation   (11.01.11)
I would appoligize to israel for obama's anti jewish stance. we are ashamed of the traitor aND LOOK FOREWARD TO HIM BEING EXILED TO IRAN. BUT REMEMBER YOU IDIOTS HELPED PUT HIM THERE SO YOU SHOULD SUFFER TO.
60. O'blender is a FRAUD, DO NOT TRUST!!
PJ ,   Bethany Beach USA   (11.01.11)
He is the biggest FRAUD ever perpetrated on the USA......WE despise him. He is NOT a friend to Israel, or the USA!! The stupid people who voted for him have ruined this Country. Do NOT believe anything he says!!! Thank You!!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article