Jewish Scene
Single religious woman seeks baby
Tzofia Hirschfeld
Published: 17.11.11, 13:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
18 Talkbacks for this article
1. This article misses the main point
Israeli grandma   (11.17.11)
Which is why there are so many unmarried religious women who would like to do the natural thing and bear children I suspect that the fierce campaigns in the name of modesty and segregation of the sexes fashionable for many years now, have caused a huge drop in the number and quality of opportunities for young unmarried religious men and women to meet and get to know each other. This is the normal and natural way to form a marriage union and have babies. I have been to so many weddings in the last few years where young people are even kept in separate rooms so they can not even meet in a public crowd. Hasenot and other smachot were at one time an approved way for the young adults to meet.
2. To #1
NAOMI ,   TEL AVIV   (11.17.11)
Unfortunatly thid more and more common problem is not only within the religious community . Even in the main cities it is more and more difficult for women to find a DECENT man. Men over 30's are either married, crazy or still looking to have fun, they have tons of girls, freedom, a nice single life... There is a big problem with the number of single women which is much higher than the number of single men. Any solution anyone?
3. A big cause of the fertility problems in Israel is radioacti
Rivkah   (11.17.11)
radioactive isotopes in the soil. It is likely the Muslims did this since they are putting polonium-210 and uranium yellowcake in American water supplies and wells according to Paul Williams who wrote a book about it. He is a consultant for the FBI. The American and Canadian university professors who are also affliated with the University of Cairo steal the radioactive substances from the universities and put it into water wells. Forty wells near Reno, Nevada, and many near Fallon, Nevada and Boulder, Colorado and elsewhere are radioactive. So that is what has been done to Israel, too, except that it is in the soil mostly according to Dr. Bill Deagle's interview by Texe Marrs of Austin, Texas. What must all Israelis do to protect themselves from the radioactive poison all around them? They must chelate out the radiation with cilantro in salads and also take a vitamin and mineral supplement of good minerals. The Freedom of Information Act allowed access to a report that the US Navy gave pregnant women pre-natal vitamins that had polonium-210 to see what happened: birth defects was one consequence. The backscater x-ray scanners in airports are pumping radiation into people at the rate of 400 x-ray equivalent or one MRI equivalent radioactive isotopes with ONE PASSBY in a scanner. That will cause birth defects and infertility and cancer and cataracts. X-ray induced infertility or sterilization was developed by the Nazis long ago and used on Jews and others who were x-rays as they filled out paperwork. Two x-ray beams were aimed at their reproductive tracts and in two minutes, they were sterile, from TWO x-rays. Imagine what is happening to people who pass by a backscatter x-ray machine in airports getting 400 x-rays (equivalent) with each passby? Dr. Bill Campbell Douglass II measure the radiation in the machines and that is what he found it to be. This is genocide of the American people and the radiation in the soil in Israel is genocide of the Israeli people.
4. There is a problem of freezing one's eggs and
Rivkah   (11.17.11)
being given someone else's eggs for fertilization. Same thing happens with males freezing their sperm. Often the in vitro fertilization is with another male's sperm. Explain to the couple in NYC who had a Black child even though both mother and father were White after expecting preserved semen from the White father before chemo to be used to produce a zygote. Mistakes happen. Better to marry young and have children the old fashioned way. Go to college later, women. Get a husband first and a family and then get educated later.
5. @4 actually...
(11.17.11)
the real cause of the high number of infertile couples is that so many Orthodox couples don't have a clear understanding of the rules of "Taharat HaMishpahah" and they tend to be overly careful and simply miss their most fertile dates!
6. 5: Interesting point. Well said.
Rivkah   (11.17.11)
7. First line of article is completely WRONG
Brian ,   Los Angeles USA   (11.17.11)
The first line of the article is completely wrong. " Spinsterhood isn't created by choice. People don't choose to be alone, and the fact that some women find themselves without a partner after the age of 30 bothers not only their aunt or grandmother, but them too." THE ONLY REASON THESE WOMEN ARE OLD AND ALONE WAS BECAUSE THEY WERE TOO PICKY. If you're 30 or older, SETTLE. And start your family!!
8. polygamy under the right conditions?
curious ,   history   (11.17.11)
9. Religious Single Mothers By Choice
Marne ,   Jerusalem   (11.17.11)
Thank G-d the religious community is more open and accepting that Rabbi Burstein and Tzofia Hirschfeld. More and more rabbis are giving heters for women to have children on their own and as a single mother by choice, I have found the religious community to be supportive and welcoming. Most of us would have love to have a "traditional" family of two parents and children, but Thank G-d there are other alternatives and we don't have to give up on motherhood because we haven't found our basheret. Having a father figure doesn't guarantee stability nor a positive family atmosphere. A loving home, whether with one or two parents, is what will shape a child positively.
10. #8
i ,   jerusalem   (11.17.11)
It seemed to work out ok for that guy in T.A. with 35 wives/cleaning ladies.
11. #5 talking out of his hat again
observer   (11.18.11)
Can you actually present data to back up that ridiculous claim? Of course not! You clearly do not live in a haredi society nor have any experience with the subject. Just another excuse to sling mud.
12. "Eh, I guess I'll settle for you so I can have babies alrea"
M. Martin ,   NYC/Tel-Aviv   (11.18.11)
OK, Brian, so women over 30 should settle. Would YOU like to be the man a woman is just settling for? Would YOU like to be married to a woman who doesn't want to have sex with you except to conceive children and then when that's over will only do it if you beg and plead for it? What happens if while married to you and having the kids she meets someone she REALLY likes and decides to have an affair with him? lastly, would YOU like for your wife to leave you eventually saying she not only never loved you she was never even remotely attracted to you in the first place and was only with you to have kids? These things happen to real men whose wives have settled for them because the clock was ticking and they wanted kids. Then often times the wife cleans him out financially in divoirce court (to support the kids she entered into a loveless marriage in order to have). Perhaps something like this has happened to you or one of your friends. Be careful of what you wish for...
13. 12 M. Martin, NYC/Tel-Aviv: You brought up some
Rivkah   (11.18.11)
good points. When people marry, realizing they will not have what they want but have to settle for someone less than ideal, they must resolve in their hearts NOT to allow a root of bitterness to develop because of that but to thank HaShem for a wife/husband. The Holy Scriptures warns that a root of bitterness in the heart leads to whoring (for males and females), so the root cause of a lot of the problems you mentioned is bitterness in the heart. The disappointments must be turned to HaShem so He can make lemonade with lemons in the marriage which he is well able to do.
14. There is a clock
Sigmund   (11.19.11)
There is a clock and the youth especially jewish youth need to get into the multiplication game for national security reasons ,A number of marriages are made in heaven for the jews indulgence is a luxury ill to be afforded.Single girls need to look at one month stands with good as it gets servants of the relm.
15. re:#2 Naomi "Decent man" aka Wealthy
Joe ,   US   (11.19.11)
When women complain they can't find a "DECENT" man over 30 what they're really saying is they can't find a wealthy man with no past (friendly exes and no children) willing to financially support a woman he barely knows while she lives her dream of popping out babies for a couple years.
16. No one says the obvious. Stop interfering Rabbi.
Josh   (11.19.11)
If men and women were allowed to see each other and talk and be a regular society, I bet the number would drop. But the Rabbis are taking it in the other direction. There is nothing more to be said about good old fashion attraction and love being allowed to bloom. I found a girl I liked and the Rabbis separated us. I guess I didn't deserve a reward from the Rabbis. Fact is that Torah doesn't require you give all your women into seclusion so that Rabbis can pass them out as rewards for listening to him as if he were in fact a prophet. Apparently the Rabbis are not rotating their human traffic type stock of women that they have managed to take into secluded custody. Jews being oppressed by false leaders that add to Torah. We Jews know its a mitzvah to prevent additions to Torah. So much for doing mitzvahs.
17. Decent men?
Yosef ,   Rehovoth, Israel   (11.20.11)
There are countless decent men out there Naomi and others like you. You just rejected us and now you cannot find us becasue we are either no longer looking at you or married with children.
18. If you want to have children.......
American Sabrah ,   Israel   (11.20.11)
Then get married. If you want to get married, then try sexual abstinence and refrain all physically affectionate contact.Premarital sex is one of the primary reasons why people delay marriage. To all the Jewish mothers out there, your future daughter in law doesn't have to be a carbon copy of you. She'll still make your son happy. Parental interference can be more of a hindrance when finding a suitable match rather than a help.
Back to article