News
Minister: Ethiopians should 'say thank you' for what they got
Omri Efraim
Published: 11.01.12, 13:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
31.  Ethiopians
Ralph ,   caesarea   (01.11.12)
This is pure racism, Israel will change when will have ministers from Ethiopian communauty.
32. #27 - One can tolerate the French, but never accept them.
Henry from New York ,   USA   (01.11.12)
That's a sad truth of the world.
33. Mrs Landver should set the example & thank Israel for...
(01.11.12)
what she's gotten. Which is a great deal including an Israeli diplomatic passport. Sadly she may hold an Israeli Diplomatic Passport but to me she's still nothing but another racist from Leningrad!
34. @9
Ralph ,   Caesarea   (01.11.12)
Israel paid a lot of money for Jews from Rumania, I don't think thy receive less than the others. Not everything is clean in our beautyful country.
35. Israelis just love pissing on eachother
Al   (01.11.12)
Reminds me of a story. There was a Jewish women screeming and yelling from her balcony. A man passed by and asked, to whom she was screeming and yelling to. She answered. "Mein man zol er zein gezunt" Yup we just love screeming and yelling like some 2 year old.
36. @34 ur 100% correct @9 please read 34 and also
(01.11.12)
we paid for: 1. the Romanians 2. the Russians 3. the Yeminites 4. the Displaced Jews of Europe after WW II 5. the Latin American Jews who were saved from various dictators 6. and of course for the Ethiopians how come groups 1-5 don't have to say "thank you" and group 6 does? Is it because the Ethiopians are black? no? are you sure?
37. I agree with the Ethiopians.
nibor ,   israel   (01.11.12)
How dare Jews behave like that. What do they think we are, a nation of Goyim?
38. As someone hastried to point out,
exUK ,   Tel Aviv   (01.11.12)
Yes we did help these people from Ethiopia,but they should not be made to suffer or be second class citizens because of it.And own up;the real reason that we rescued them was to increase th'Jewish Demodraphic' at the expense of indigenous Arabs.Also lots of Russians were 'led'here by paying intermediary countries to not 'advise' them that other options may have been open to the,again for demographic reasons.But if an individual wishes to come,it is sometimes made difficult to 'prove their pedigree' not so with 'bulk Aliya'.Yes Israel wants any Jew but bulk Aliya is demographically more beneficial to the state.Housing shouid never be denied ANYONE Jew Arab,Russian,Ethiopian.If we are good enough to be admitted for whatever reaso,we should all have equal rights which may not be rescinded like the E Jerusalem proposals.
39. FM Mr. Liberman ought to have a word with the ladies....
(01.11.12)
from his party (Israel Beiteinu) because clearly they are not understanding what it means to be Israeli FIRST. The Ladies of Israel Beiteinu (given their actions and words this week) seem to be stuck in a very ugly non-Israel (well they are both Russian born) sort of thing!
40. next elections we'll say thank u real good to Israel Beitanu
(01.11.12)
This party will become history!
41. Absorption
citizen ,   israel   (01.11.12)
Sofa Landver, who loves to breath the smell of petroleum companies, thinks that to be Minister of Absorption is to inhale and exhale Ethiops.
42. @9 Israel had to give more because USA Jews didn't want them
(01.11.12)
them the Ethiopians I mean. But on the other hand USA Jews bent over backwards to get Russian Jewry to the USA. Now why was that?
43. Cure for Ethiopian woes
Dunash   (01.11.12)
Chabdniks claim that the Lubavitcher Rebbe warned decades ago that Israel would one day have sore reason to regret allowing 200,000 Ethiopians in to Eretz Yisrael The fact is that skin colour counts for something, and that some Whites don't get on with some Blacks.. Forcing Ethiopians to live cheek and jowl with Russians is a recipe for disaster. The Ethiopians should live happily altogether, without any Whites, in their two large own towns to be constructed on the West Bank as bulwarks on Israel's borders, to be called "Kochav Kush" and "Kfar Etiyopia".
44. Fire this idiot!
Amit ,   Los Angeles   (01.11.12)
The right of return is not conditional on one's heritage. As CITIZENS of Israel, the Ethiopian community deserves the same rights as everyone else!
45. #35 - is that Yiddish or a pidgen of German?
Henry from New York ,   USA   (01.11.12)
Yep Israelis need to bring back that old spirit of comradery that got them through the 20th Century.
46. Coincidence?
PaulZion ,   Israel   (01.11.12)
I wonder if it is a coincidence that 2 Knesset members of the Yisrael Beiteinu party are involved in controversies in the Knesset. maybe, just maybe it is a sign of their political culture and manners. Then again, I am not really surprised. Look who leads them - a man who admires and makes excuses for that tyrant, Putin. While I abhor racism and feel that we could all to better to absorb the Ethiopian Jewry into our "melting pot", this issue is not so clear cut. The people who own these properties do have a legal right to decide to whom they sell or rent their properties. If they are racist as private citizens, I do not believe that a law can be passed to force them not to be. Democracy still allows freedom of thought and speech, and however much we may disagree with their views, they too have the right to say no to someone who wants to buy their apartment. Applying social pressure to force them to change their minds is another matter. Maybe that is the way to go.
47. Summing up the talkbacks:
Dan the Jafa ,   Auckland, NZ   (01.12.12)
"Here in Israel we hate racism and Russians".
48. #47 A good many of the Russian's
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.12.12)
aren't Jews & never were People gave false testimony to sneak them in
49. #27 Most Russians are white
Talula ,   Israel   (01.12.12)
And so are the Ashkenazim - Ethiopians are black - they have to live with that terrible stigma that comes with being black. Israel has become a racist nation within our four walls - look what the Sephardim have to tolerate? Why? because their skin is darker than ours. They are turned away from night clubs for crying out aloud! Even SOLDIERS that come home for the weekend. The Russians on the other hand have broughr a whole load of problems over here with them - problems that didn't exist until they arrived.
50. Ministry of absorption
andres ,   Herzelya Israel   (01.12.12)
If anyone have been in a office of the ministry of absorption will find that 90% of the workers are from Countries of the ex Soviet Union
51. @49 what is the terrible stigma of being white?
Luke ,   The Bronx   (01.12.12)
"they have to live with that terrible that comes with being black" LMAO. it's some crazy a-- stupid a-- people in this world thank G-d for humor and a little tolerance. The terrible stigma that comes with being black, now just where did that come from.
52. Who ever does not like what the minister had to say...
Sarah B ,   U.S.A./ Israel   (01.12.12)
Can get the hell out, Ethiopian or otherwise...
53. Racism or Culturalism?
David N. ,   Haifa, ISRAEL   (01.12.12)
We may say Ethiopian, but if they are Jews, then they are Israelis, end of story. Whether their community converted in the distant past, or are a remnant of ancient Israelite, doesn't matter. Many of us are not Sabras, but that doesn't mean we are not Israelis, in essence, by birth. Now can we all calm down and accept that the great return of Israelites from all over the world, whether convert communities or not, is not simple or easy, and that problems are natural. When we see a problem, let us reason together. Talkback name-calling and insults is just the sort of strife among brother Israelites that did us no good in the days before the revolt against Rome. And stop confusing ISRAELI and SABRA. We Jews are all Israelites. None of use needs to be ashamed of gentile customs and habits which we have that are inoffensive to the faith of Israel, but on the other hand, none of us should even try to live primarily in our exilic past, either. Our identity is here, as Israelis. Those who are not Jewish, well, I wish you a good life whether here or back in your own home. I am sure that we all have given offense unintentionally to each other, and sometimes intentionally. But in the end, let us work together as Israelis, and stop this nonesense of calling every glitch in the adjustment of Israelis from Ethiopia racism. It is clearly a clash of culture far more than it is genuine racism. Genuine racism, say American style where many whites still believe that a black man is genetically inferior, is not that common here, and requires a far stronger, harsher response. The object isn't blame and insult, but understanding and solutions.
54. to #11 and 12
jason white ,   afula, israel   (01.12.12)
11- I do not know why I was not hired in my field and russians without my qualifications and experience were. Also I did my national service and was one year in the standing army of the I.D.F. The government did not subsidize my salary. I live an Amidar apartment and no one gave me a new immigrant mortgage and a money to pay it off. 12- Yes, I have been here for 36 years. I came in May,1975. You can try doing the math. I never said I was a "king", but coming from the U.S. was close to royalty. Through hard work and capitalism we were not a second or third world country. Do you understand a s.o.b. What hell hole did you come from?
55. to #25 I hate the way losers are jealous
jason white ,   afula, israel   (01.12.12)
of those of us that earned our money. I do not want to pay one cent for anyone who comes here with no money in his or her pocket. I do not want to pay money for welfare of able bodied people, pensions for elderly immigrants or draft dodgers in yeshivas. I do not want to pay my tax money to prisoners families either. You want to pay, go ahead. You are dumb enough to want to support others. Oh and say hello to your imaginary friends in the Judean Peoples Front.
56. Look to the Bible
RC ,   USA   (01.13.12)
People should read Numbers 12 and Amos 9:7 and ponder over it.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article