News
Palestinian man jails daughter in bathroom for 9 years
Elior Levy
Published: 22.01.12, 01:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
28 Talkbacks for this article
1. Where are the "human rightists" diatribes
PETER SM ,   AUSTRALIA   (01.22.12)
2. father
Yisraeli   (01.22.12)
I hope the father gets locked up in prison at least the same amount of days that he imprisoned his daughter.
3. Eeewww.
Vlad   (01.22.12)
4. Probably not an isolated incident.
SG ,   Teaneck   (01.22.12)
5. sick
Nechama Wachsberg ,   passaic   (01.22.12)
what a chaya to do that
6. That name doesn't sound Palestinian...are you
Edithann ,   USA   (01.22.12)
sure it isn't Jewish? Arabs are too socially connected to have something like that going on and for so long..... I think it's the usual 'hate Arab' crap Ynet puts out all the time! TATA
7. Not nice at all ,terrible crime !
Ali Clark ,   Scotland   (01.22.12)
This is stomach churning crime terrible by anyone's standards. I think the headline demeans Fritzl's victims .Any excuse to paint ordinary Palestinians in a bad light!
8. Why did it take so long to find her?
Israeli grandma   (01.22.12)
There are crazies in every society, the question one must ask here was why this poor girl was imprisoned for so many years? Where was her mother, siblings, aunts while this was going on?
9. #6 too socially connected for inbreeding...hahahaha
(01.22.12)
10. to # 6
Ellen ,   Netanya   (01.22.12)
Give it up. The article says the Qalqilya Police, not the Israeli police. Qalquilya is a city under the full control of the Palestinian Authority!
11. @ #6 Yosef Fritzl is an Austrian who did the same crime
Hana ,   USA   (01.22.12)
in his country and was caught in 2008. Maybe you should actually read the article before you decide it must be the Jews' fault.
12. no similarity to rapist Fritzel here
observer ,   Egypt   (01.22.12)
13. #6
(01.22.12)
according to you, "arabs are too socially connected to do something like that..." my question is: are arabs too socially connected to execute their daughters and do honor killings of their wives and daughter as well? gee, woman, how stupid can you be.
14. @6
(01.22.12)
arabs have committed crimes like honor killings for centuries...in israel, in the maghreb and in the west bank and even in the usa for decades....i guess they are really very much socially connected, aren't they? the only connection arabs have to humanity is to let their terrorist sons committ suicide. it's the only kindness they exhibit through their, oh so lovely, social connections.
15. just a note for all of you
golan ,   modiin   (01.22.12)
If this was in an Israeli home anti-semites would say "that is Zionism form you" if the man was Ethiopian the racists would say "that is Ethiopians for you" if it was a Haredi man the hilonim would say "that is haredim for you" If it was a hiloni the Haredim would say "that is hilonim for you" but it was not. This is a sick individual and not a cultural, ethnic, political, or Arab thing.
16. Seriously?
Yossi ,   Raanana   (01.22.12)
If a Jew even walked into Kalkelia he would be lynched. Do you think there would one living there?
17. to 15
(01.22.12)
i think the girl need ed a social help but the arab culture find it is not right to aske a social help by rule so they depend on a grandfather or grand mother it is sad but it is the fact i think this girl was not been in bath room for all the time but it is a sort of punishment when the girl want to leave the house without a permition // i think the girl needs social and may be medical help and in this the father is wrong it is not shame to visite a psychatri specialist specialy when the problem is not so big it needs a social dialouge
18. Antisemitic idiot!
Casey ,   South Africa   (01.22.12)
Josef Fritzl is a man who imprisoned his daughter for ~20 years from Austria, they're comparing the Palestinian man to him. Hopefully the Palestinian didn't procreate with his daughter like Fritzl D:
19. #6 Edithann - I guess it sounds more
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.22.12)
Palestinian, when you read about the mother holding the daughter while somone cuts the childs throat for damaging the family honor
20. arabs
ron ,   toronto, canada   (01.22.12)
Why don't you people stop calling those arabs "palestinians"? There is no such thing and people keep labeling them like they are a nation. They are arabs from around the muslim world.
21. 6. That name doesn't sound Palestinian...are you
rob ,   toronto, canada   (01.22.12)
What is a palestinian name? No such thing. They are arab names because they are ARABS.
22. # 12 Poor observer !
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (01.22.12)
why do muslims defend monsters like this ?.in Israel and in other lands of the infidels the father will be ostracized by society and thrown in jail for life,in this case the man will be freed,because under sharia law,the father owns his daughter, as piece of property, like he owns his donkey,his cow,so, the father has a right to do with her whatever he pleases,if the girl testifies against her father,her father has a right to kill her,as a rebellious daughter,and you believe that the sharia laws are superior to the laws of the infidels.
23. He didn't kill her
Atom&Yves ,   LandOfTheFree   (01.22.12)
So, I guess that's 'progress' in the Arab world.
24. #6 YOu obviously are out of touch with extreeme Muslims
Rochelle ,   Durban, S.Africa   (01.22.12)
25. women imprisoned for 9 years
barry1817 ,   hawthorne ca.   (01.22.12)
I thought we were to accept what others do, and not cast judgments??? But where are the feminists, or do they only complain about Christians, while ignoring all the human rights that are violated. And these are the countries and people that populate the UN and want to dictate to us, how to handle human rights. It is a joke, perpetuated on us by the useful idiots of the lame stream medai
26. Palestinian Bathroom Lockup 9 Yrs.
Pat Johnson ,   San Francisco USA   (01.22.12)
I guess this is permitted under sharia law!!!!!!!!!!!!!
27.  Palestinian man jails daughter in bathroom for 9 years
Jack ,   Eastern USA   (01.22.12)
"Comments containing incitement, slander, racist slurs and inappropriate language deemed to violate our terms of use won't be published. " There goes my comment on Islam being a peaceful religion.
28. Th reason for the long time it took may be:
took time   (01.23.12)
This was up to the Palestinian police, not the Israeli Police. They work differently. In addition, the Arab society tends not to involve police in their neighbors' business. could also be that the father threatened the lives of relatives who were aware of the situation.
Back to article