Jewish Scene
Jewish groups slam Argentine cartoon
Ynetnews
Published: 22.01.12, 14:24
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
24 Talkbacks for this article
1. Jewish groups slam Argentine cartoon
daniel jarovisky ,   ny, usa   (01.22.12)
I read the article with deep sadness but not shock because in many nations, Argentina is not an exception, Jews are the butt of all jokes and they get dehumanized regularly. This however is not the first time some paper or magazine publishes something like this, and life goes on. Some find it humorous or maybe many find it funny but the only ones that rise up are Jewish groups. No one else does anything and it's only a matter of time when this happens again. Governments there have not been particularly interested in waves of antisemitism. Jew hatred is taken for granted with laughs and general inertia by the population.
2. Disgusting!!
Micha   (01.22.12)
Forget calling it anti-semitic, as you'll lots of slimeballs out there picking apart semantics. Pure and simple Jew-hatred. Just wait. Jews are rising up and we will make sure these cretins have nothing to snicker about. Never again.
3. jews in argentina (trucholandia)
edy burak ,   miami , USA   (01.22.12)
argentina is an antisemitic country , for that reazon was easy for hezbollah place 2 bombs there.- the jews must leave , before is too late.- many rich jews in power or shoulder by shoulder with the government is very dangerous !!!!!
4. What else can you expect from the country who hid Eichmann
usa   (01.22.12)
Having said that I don't particularly give a damn that nations stilll hate the Jewish people this will never go away. I do wish that they hated us for the right reasons though. Reason #1 despite the political slogans, there will never be a Palestinian state which is recognized by Israel, NEVER. Hate me for that.
5. Dont cry for me argentina! and i wont for you
peggy ,   uk   (01.22.12)
wasnt it always a haven for escaping nazis? so not surprising what they do. Isnt it one of the "people go missing" countries of S.America.? No wonder the Falklands want to stay British!!!
6. But make a cartoon about the Muslims and the whole world
David ,   Israel   (01.22.12)
Is up in arms over it . In my entire lifetime ive never been able to understand why the Jews receive such treatment
7. the more things change, the more they stay the same
Mike ,   London, UK   (01.22.12)
every Jew should fight anti-semitism
8. Demonizing Argentina
Ibrahim Ibn Yusuf ,   Rosario, Argentina   (01.22.12)
This is a comic strip published by one individual in one newspaper. The newspaper has been harshly criticized by Argentinian society and forced to issue an apology. Can Argentina as a whole be faulted for the strip? Clearly not. It's not as if state-paid priests are calling on their followers not to rent houses to Jews; or as if any synagogue has been torched recently; or as if the Argentinian parliament has passed a bill singling out Jews, and only Jews, for differential treatment in migration procedures. At a moment when Jews are fully integrated into Argentinian politics, with the country's Foreign Minister --the person who represents the nation's interests abroad-- himself being a Jew, any talk of Argentinian antisemitism is simply ludicrous.
9. ANY SYMPATHY / EMPATHY I HAD
LAWRENCE OF ARABIA ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (01.22.12)
Towards Argebtina and its claim to " las malvinas" just eveporated. "I WILL CURSE THOSE WHO CURSE YOU."
10. South American countries hosted the Nazis!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (01.22.12)
Eichmann, Mengele and many of the worst war criminals in history, people who perpetrated crimes against Jews, Russian, Gypsies and millions of "Untermneschen" were made very welcome in Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and others so why all the fuss about another Antisemitic cartoon? One might ask if there is there any difference between this and a Prince of the United Kingdom or a British Conservative MP and and aide to the British Prime Minister dressing up as a Nazi for a party?
11. Argentina's antisemitic cartoon
Yishav ,   USA   (01.22.12)
Argentina is a Socialist Country and Community. They blame as Hugo Chavez blamed about all economical problems. Remember the President of Argentina is affiliated with Hugo Chavez a Socio-Fascist dictator. It's a problem in Central and South America right now. I am not impressed about it. It will come more later on. We the Jews have to protect one each other and be aware in our communities too! May Adonai keep you and be with you always my brothers and sisters!
12. Guetta
Simcha ,   NYC USA   (01.22.12)
I read that he is Jewish.....he should sue the newspaper and give the settlement to groups who fight anti semitism.
13. B’nai B’rith International & Wiesenthal Center'
Nina ,   NYC   (01.22.12)
Have they expressed their "outrage" over one of their own calling for the assassination of our President yet?
14. A fact of life: Most Cultures Hung Back With The Apes
Inetfraud ,   US   (01.22.12)
South America (you can HAVE "mighty" Brazil--ALL DAY LONG, lol!) and central America are no different than Africa: two continents lagging a thousand years behind civilization. There might be a pretty street here and there but they're so backwards and have such a pungent mentality, it would scare a vulture away. Argentina: a known German/European brood (over 95% of Argentinians are German and european: they EXTERMINATED the natives or drove them out ---Niiice people, if u can call them that) have always backed the Nazis: it was the Argentinians and Brazilians who welcomed the Nazis after ww2. Of course they'll publish cartoons like this. Afterall, these idiots are cartoons themselves. No ability to comprehend reality whatsoever. Would anyone like to tell the world what Argentina has done for it? I mean, I can answer that if youd like: NADA!!!! Moving on. We don't deal with dregs like Argentina in everyday life (THANK G-D!!! ) anyhow.
15. Cartoon
Tom ,   BsAs,Argentina   (01.22.12)
I´m a Jew. of course I did not like this cartoon. To those from the USA that slam my country, Argentina, over ONE cartoon, I say to you this: Of course Peron Let the Nazis in, we know history. but you should also know, that USA ALSO let Nazis in in order to fight Communists. So...? Not to mention that the OSS (later would become CIA) had the knowledge of Nazi Holocaust, had aerial picture of concentration camps and DID NOTHING! NOTHING! So don´t come here bashing Argentina, when the USA also had a pretty ugly face during world war 2 and after it. Oh I don´t forget that you drop 2 atoms bombs on Japan. You were the first! And to the brits that post here, well.. Malvinas will always be Argentinian. How can you claim that is BRITISH SOIL, while is far far far far far away, hey, a galaxy away, from British soil. Cheers!
16. 8. Ibrahim Ibn Yusuf
Anna   (01.23.12)
I simply can't understand how can you call ludicrous protests against the cartoons in which the author trivializes making a soap from the human beings? Nazis annihilated hundreds of thousands scientists, professors, doctors, composers, artists, ministers disregarding of their contribution to the German society and humanity in general only because they were Jews. Can you imagine Muslims being victimized in the next cartoon drawn marching to the gas chambers with the encouraging titters like: " Don't forget to leave your watches and jewelry before the entrance"?
17. To #14 Inetfraud , and all posters here that bash Argentina.
Abu Yussef al Yahudi ,   Bue_Aires_Argentina   (01.23.12)
Your picture of Argentina and South America is wrong and disgusting. As an Argentinian Citizen of Jewish Faith, and a strong Zionist too, I can assure you that your shameful diatribes against Argentina and South America as a whole are TOTALLY biased, - Neither the people of Argentina nor the people of Brasil are APËS. like (Inetfraud) you describe us. Several Argentinians has earned Nobel Prizes (Among them a couple of Jews) for their work in the field of the science, and one of them the Nobel Price for the Peace. Besides, the army of Brasil FOUGHT bravely against the Nazis alongside the Allies in the WWII. I and my relatives living in South America, are reliable witnesses ON SITE, that NEVER we Jews were humilliated or persecuted in Argentina, Brasil or Uruguay for our Jewish descent. We can practice our religion WITHOUT any restriccions, even during the Second World War, when the Argentine Military Government of that time was clearly Pro-German. - AU CONTRAIRE always the jews were trated with respect by the gentile people here in Buenos Aires and in the rest of the country, and the same in Brasil and Uruguay, with the exception of a FEW acts of Anti-semitism without any support from the big majority of the Non-Jewish South-American Citizens.. For you, an American "Armchair Reporter" sitting in your PC some 5000 + Miles ( 8000+ Kilometers) from the place when the fact has ocurred, is easy to condemn an entire people for an isolated fact. Regarding this very sad fact of the publication of this outrageous cartoon, a overwhelming part of the Argentine People have condemned this crazy fact, and rigth now, the INADI (An Office of the Federal Government in charge of the fight against the Discrimination and the Rascism), is investigating the case with the goal of apply all the punishment that the Anti-Discrimination Law establish, over the individual(s) that has performed this grave act of provocation. The newspaper itself, has written a big apology (BTW this newspaper, Página 12, was founded by a Jew, Jacobo Timerman, ZL", and was, since the times of the infamous Junta Militar, some 30 + years ago, a fierce defender of the Human Rights, here in Argentina). Please, Jewish an Gentile People, make an accurate survey of the facts, BEFORE posting wrong statements against any Country or any Person in these excelent Talkbacks of YnetNews. Regards from Buenos Aires AM ISRAEL CHAI
18. Another proof
Joah   (01.23.12)
That Iran was not responsible for the Argentina bombing. There are way too many nazis. ex-nazis and neo-nazis in Argentina who will do the job for them.
19. #13 and what exactly does that have to do with
Isac   (01.23.12)
killing systematically 6 million Jews. On what planet are you living. Goodness get a life!
20. #8 If Arab could once start to recognize
Isac   (01.23.12)
that the Holocaust was the worst criminal act in human history. It was cruel, it was systematic and let's not forget it got approval by the majority of Arabs in the 40's. We are not talking about one idiotic person who finds obscene cartoons funny but rather the fact that there is a tendency in quite a number of countries to demonize Israel and the Jews in general.
21. To #18
Tom ,   BsAs,Argentina   (01.23.12)
Proof that Iran was not behind the israeli 1992 embassy bombing nor the 1994 AMIA bombing, just ´cos there are too many nazis in Argentina? oh really? You should see, read, watch, heard what the antisemites in IRAN with Syria, Hezbollah, Nasrallah and so on, call for the destruction of JEWS! not only Israel. Even Nasrallah, said: If the Jews (around the world) gather all in Israel, we (Hezbollah) would not had to go over the world to hunt the jews down. OH YEAH! sure, nazis did the amia bombing and not Iran. What a load of bullshit. READ HISTORY YOU BLOODY IGNORANT.
22. Argentine cartoon
Andres Markovits ,   Quilpue, Chile   (01.24.12)
Chile itself is getting increasingly antisemitic. But the stench coming from the other side of the Cordillera is nauseating. Partly is due tha they are stil shit-scared of the gurkhas or britsh soldiers. A cowardly bunch currently hidind under the skirt of their "morocha" queen.
23. Newspaper article in Argentina
daniel jarovisky ,   ny, us   (01.24.12)
To those who use the article to bash Argentina please don't put every argentinian in the same category or you're doing the same thing antisemites do by including all Jews in same pot. Argentina wasn't the only country that let nazis in exchange for the treasure they had stolen accross Europe. The United States, Britain, and other European nations as well as Arabs contributed in different ways in the extermination of Jews. But we're talking about the article that with complete impunity was published in that paper. The nation of Argentina is not to be blamed for those comedians that once again found a way to dehumanize israelites. It's going to continue to happen in many different ways, some violent some less violent but not less virulent. Governments are not going to do anything to stop and prevent this kind of racism, eventhough they always repudiate any attempt against Jews. It's the schools, the catholic church, families helping to erase the stereotype.
24. Israel
katie ,   Wilmington NC USA   (01.25.12)
Those who value life have lives of value. Who will cry for you, Argentina? Not me if you cannot esteem others more highly than yourself. Israel, may you always be blessed and may God continually make His face to shine upon you.
Back to article