News  World News
Germany: Success of strike on Iran unlikely
Elior Levi
Published: 12.02.12, 16:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. yeah, but...
tom ,   toronto, canada   (02.12.12)
did he offer any other options for stopping the iranian nuclear programme, other than oil sanctions which the eu has not even begun to implement? (i guess the "nuclear gun" is not being to their heads, so why hurry?) or did mr de maiziere also share his opinion on the likelihood of israelis surviving a nuclear attack by iran? his crystal ball would seem to be somewhat limited... to protecting germany's oil suppliers.
2. and that's why Germany supplies Iran with all necessary hard
ab   (02.12.12)
ware and computer programs for centrifuges..
3. Ridiculous
Rube Vogel ,   Jerusalem   (02.12.12)
The media reports this as if the German defense minister has done extensive research on the question and arrive at an independent conclusion. In fact, the German defense minister just read the New York Time article on the subject and is no more an expert on the subject that the local Taxi driver.
4. #2
Harold ,   USA   (02.12.12)
Germany supplies many things not to Iran only but it supplies to Israel e.g. submarines, tanks and other war and distruction eaquipment. The west especially Britain, France and the US are responsible for Israel being a nuclear power. Check carefully what Israel is supplied by foreign countries.
5. #1
Harold ,   USA   (02.12.12)
Yes he forgot to mention the embargo of Pistachio nuts to Israel.
6. What Palestinian "achievements"?
Danny   (02.12.12)
7. The Fourth Reich
Zivron   (02.12.12)
THE Fourth reich under USA supervision ought stop using Iran as its alter ego and forbid all trade with the revolutionary guards and the oil and military industries . Instead they could export potatoes and more ought become potatotoe farmers and coperative agriculturists to help feed the world.
8. Palestinian "achievement" : fooling the world and being
David ,   Israel   (02.12.12)
Largest consecutive receivers of financial aid in the world and barely using it ethically and effectively!
9. #4 Harold - FYI Jews were responsible
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.12.12)
for the USA becoming a Nuclear Power, they were foremost in the development of the Atomic Bomb Technology which the USA subsequently passed on to its allies Germany supplies destrictive devices, out a a sense of guilt, since they were responbisble for destroying six million Jews, they're trying to salve their very gulty consciences Check your facts first, then post
10. palestinian achievments??
JL   (02.12.12)
11. One way or the other: NIE WIEDER = NEVER EVER AGAIN.
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (02.12.12)
12. "The EU-imposed oil embargo on Iran will begin in July"
esnuffnstl ,   USA   (02.12.12)
Iran is already hurting from current sanctions and other (far more intense) sanctions are coming. Iran is no where near the point of having a nuclear weapon and if they come remotely close to getting one the US will bomb them back to 1950. The EU and the US are solidly behind the idea of increasing pressure on Iran to get it to send sensitive nuclear materials abroad in exchange for fuel rods. Iran is getting close to accepting this--only the details need to be worked out and a way found for Iranian leaders to save face with their people. This whole thing will probably be over by the end of summer.
13. Not if Israel uses nukes
mick ,   USA   (02.12.12)
A nuclear strike against Iran would be extremely effective and could even destroy the cancerous regime. The fallout would be the same as any incident of the Jews preventing their own genocide, and should be disregarded.
14. #5 Harold - No shortage of some nuts
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.12.12)
in the USA, you're posting BTW-There are no Iranian Pistachio nuts available in the USA, the present supply of Pistachio's are from California
15. Obama, Sharkosy and other wannabe
Paul ,   Jerusalem   (02.12.12)
messiahs, talk about change, but are useless. Only the actions of Israel to suppress the evil around the Middle East can bring change, true change.
16. #5 Add pistachio nuts to EU sanctions
Cynthia ,   USA   (02.12.12)
The embargo on Iranian pistachio nuts is a US sanction. Since pistachio nuts represent Iran's 2nd largest export product, by all means add pistachio nuts and Iranian carpets to the EU sanction list. Anyway, California growers are taking over the market and producing a better product not subject to fungus and drought like the Iranian nut.
17. #14
Harold ,   USA   (02.12.12)
Iranians who immigrated to Israel prefer the Iranian Pistachios including the former president who is in jail. I have tasted the Iranian natural Pistashio in Germany and they taste completely different than the US produce.
18. Go Israel go!
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (02.12.12)
Iran will know damages and pain. Ian's messing with G-ds chosen people. No one will mourn the loss of Iranian madmen.
19. German Advice
zvi ,   LA USA   (02.12.12)
I do not like to hear German advice to Israel on how to prevent genocide. I think Israel has the military power to deliver a crippling blow to Iranian nuclear ambitions. Also what is the motive of the minister? Is it concern for the Jewish people or OIL? I say to the German minister: Unlike in the past the Jewish people have a strong army to protect us so we do not need any advice from you.
20. Political damage ?
Pipe Smoker ,   Toronto   (02.12.12)
That's Ok with me. Cause all of Europe ( yes, including Germany) is going down the toilet very soon....soon as March !
21. #9 No, you tool of tools...
TaylorT ,   Earth   (02.12.12)
...it was AMERICANS who were responsible for the American nuclear program (thanks in large part to Germans who fled Germany.) And it was primarily the French who gave Israel its nuclear program. If it wasn't for their help, and decades of US support, you would again be without a state (just like old times, eh?) I realize all this might be confusing to a bigot like yourself who divides the whole world into Jews/non-Jews. Even on a board filled with morons, your posts always stick out as being particularly moronic. Stupid and bigoted is no way to go through life, Ben Jabo.
22. The biggest nut here is...
Arn ,   sweden   (02.12.12)
BEN JABO! You even embarrass the far-right, militant Israelis. Do us a favor and go elsewhere.
23. #21 Ben Jabo is correct
Cynthia ,   USA   (02.12.12)
Many of these scientists were European Jews who fled to the US because they were forbidden from practicing their professions due to Jewish heritage.
24. #21, weren't a lot of the Germans who fled to the US Jewish?
Henry from New York ,   USA   (02.12.12)
25. #19 German advice and oil interests
Fluffi ,   Germany   (02.12.12)
He didn't give Israel any advice. The journalist asked the defence minister about the conflict and he gave his opinion, in a German newspaper, addressed to the German public. I don't think there's anything wrong with that. In 2011only 0.8% of Germany's total oil imports came from Iran, 1% from Saudi Arabia (the whole ME made 5.3%). Germany has no significant oil interests in that region, unlike many other western countries.
26. #21 Taylor, you have zilch knowledge
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.12.12)
Jews were responsible for the Nukes, German scientists came AFTER the war, the nukes had already been dropped on Hiroshima & Nagasaki German's, Werner Von Braun among them & other Nazi's, were imported to America to help develop the Rocket programs that took the USA into space AFTER the war had ended I don't know where you get your "facts" from, get a refund, you have been gypped
27. #22 Arn - Typical of one who doesn't
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.12.12)
know his tuchas from his elbow Jews were in the forefront of American Atomic research German, mainly Nazis, came after the war to work on America's space programs Your ignorance is obvious
Back to article