News
Navy's new super-sub revealed
Udi Etsion
Published: 22.02.12, 21:03
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
31. ZAK
Moshe ,   T/A Israel   (02.23.12)
Dear Zak Any decision to build the submarine had to eventually have had the approval of the German Government and in less a part the German people. The war is over but the memories of the events are not. If you feel that Iran is tougher or stronger or wiser or braver then that is your call. I suggest sitting back lets see how things pan out and eat plenty of the finest of Belgium Chocolate because that is the only thing that ever came out of your country (other than boring people) Shabbat Shalom
32. #24
Istvan ,   Hungary   (02.23.12)
The two submarines cost, overall, around 1.3 billion euro, of up to one-third was paid by Germany...
33. May G_d bless her and all who will sail in her!!!
Alan ,   SA   (02.23.12)
Way to go!!!As the sailors say.
34. 2
zionist forever   (02.23.12)
Israel's problem has never been lack of knowledge its always been lack of money. Iran builds midget submarine based on North Korean design. Midget subs are lightly armed and designed for coastal defense only. Ideal for Iran no good for Israel. For jobs where they need something which has a more significant range and more firepower even Iran buys Russian rather than attempt to design its own in the form of their new Kilo Class subs. Israel's Dolphins are based on the German Type 209 but modified to Israeli specifications and the new ones based on the newer Type 214 they are not midget submarines. The Dolphins are just fine for Israel's needs, it gets a big discount from Germany for the purchase of the thing and no need to go to the expense of spending billions to creating a big submarine production facility. Money is the reason Israel develops so few major weapons, and concentrates on small stuff which both the IDF and poorer countries can afford as they are the main buyers of all but the fanciest of Israeli weapons. Israel can't compete with the big boys so doesn't even invest money trying.
35. #2 Mr. Kloot Zak
(02.23.12)
The Germans "donated" the submarines because they did not want to close their shipworks and have even more unemployment. In any case, the subs are a lot cheaper and give the Germans much more than the money which is being sent to Greece.
36. To: Istvan at No. 32
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.23.12)
Confiscated Jewish-owned works of art -- including many Old Masters and Impressionist paintings -- which live in German museums to this day or are privately "owned" by non-Jewish Germans are conservatively estimated to be worth approximately 3.8 billion Euro. Germany should be GIVING Israel those submarines. And what dollar or euro value can you place on six million Jewish lives? Stop apologizing for Germany. They will NEVER repay their debt to the Jews. EVER.
37. 32
zionist forever   (02.23.12)
" The two submarines cost, overall, around 1.3 billion euro, of up to one-third was paid by Germany. " In simple terms Germany gave Israel a discount and so Israel only had to pay two thirds of 1.3 billion euros. You ever been to a store where they were having a special offer on and you pay less than you would have done at any other time but your still paying much more than they are reducing it by? IWhen it comes to the arms trade worldwide there is an official off the shelf price but usually there is some degree of negotiation involved and the price you pay is based on how good your negotiating skills are. Buying weapons is not as simple as going to the supermarket where the price you see is the price you pay.
38. israelis are so afraid of critic And Iran the biggest power
babakharidshoma   (02.23.12)
Even with the help your Milk-cow , Germany, you can not do anything about Iran. Every day you become smaller and Iran is Getting bigger and stronger. The whole West and Europe and Israel and NATO are afraid of iran. They all together against IRAN. I deduce : IRAN IS A BIGGEST POWER ON THE PLANET. BRAVO IRAN
39. FREELY DONATED.......
ed ,   victorville, USA   (02.23.12)
Actually it's the USA that's saved their ass, not the Germans!
40. #36
s B   (02.23.12)
If Germany can never pay the "debt", then why pay anything? Germany should stop paying reparations NOW. Sell the subs to Israel for a 5% discount.
41. Zak of Belguim reconsider your words
Ron ,   Syracuse, NY   (02.23.12)
Germany owes Israel an "Endless" debt for the "Priceless" lives they murdered. And Israel can ask for all they want of them I feel even though it could never repay this debt. I just hope Germany is repentant for what they did to them, if not severe Judgement awaits them.
42. Looks more like a TUB to me...
Julio ,   Mexico   (02.23.12)
Its not the size of the dog in a fight...Its the size of the fight in the dog... Hezbollah (much smaller in size) beat the sh!t out of your IDF on more than one occasion...
43. More than a little truth in that observation, #42
Cameron ,   USA   (02.23.12)
The Israelis seem to have definitely lost their taste for ground operations after the pummeling they got from the raggedy Hez during that last armored drive into Lebanon a few years back.
44. A team of Israeli experts is on-site, assisting their German
split ,   US   (02.23.12)
If they're so smart why do they need the Germans for ? ;),...
45. 1 - "should keep us alert" ,...
split ,   US   (02.23.12)
Another one with ID problem ,...
46. Zakboy at no 2
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (02.24.12)
Just read the replies to your post-don't you feel the fool now.Remember that you are on a Jewish site and that means that you up against superior brain power.Ok?
47. spit 44
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (02.24.12)
To do the donkey work stupid.
48. #38 bebak - LOL !
solomon ,   bklyn   (02.24.12)
It is rare to see a post as ludicrous as yours. Congratulations.
49. #42 julio, #43 cameron
solomon ,   bklyn   (02.24.12)
You've been reading fairy tale propaganda again, not facts, as there are no facts to support your words "pummeling" or "beat the sh*t out of". Tsk, tsk. (BTW: It was such a "pummeling" that [who?] is still in hiding in a hole in the ground?)
50. #45 split re: #1
solomon ,   bklyn   (02.24.12)
#1 joe is right on. It is you that has a problem; that of fact-avoidance. It is endemic in your posts. At least you are consistent.
51. #38 Baba - Such an idiot.
Scott ,   USA   (02.26.12)
You say "I deduce : IRAN IS A BIGGEST POWER ON THE PLANET. BRAVO IRAN" Iran is so powerful that it can't retire 40 year old F-14s and has to buy midget submarines from North Korea. My guess is that you're one of those guys who think that Iran is powerful because it has the fanciest gloves and leggings in the world. Yellow, and purple, and pink with green stars. How impressive! Those funny-pants uniforms may cause some laughing casualties, but otherwise, won't help you against an army with sane leadership.
52. Yo Zak
Gehoben ,   Philly, USA   (02.27.12)
You are misiNformed Mr. Zak! Jews relying on the Germans to save them....uh.....excuuuuuuse me?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article