Jewish Scene
'Modesty Patrol lynched me'
Yaron Doron
Published: 29.02.12, 14:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
73 Talkbacks for this article
1. Harideem terrorists
Haim ,   TA   (02.29.12)
Is this the religious lifestyle they are so keen to promote, judging and slandering others who dont obide to their warped sick life style. As spitting on 8 year old girls wasnt enough to satisfy their lust now breaking and enetering in to pensioners appartments and physicall attacking them . These people are tottaly vile and discusting.
2. SHAME!!!
daniela ,   panama   (02.29.12)
It is unacceptable that people that called themselves religious could do that. First: if they are religious they should know that there are gentiles that can convert if they follow all the steps the halacha and the rabanut harashit impose for them in order to have a proper conversion. The second things is that we, as jews, are supposed to teach gentiles the 7 Mitzvoth Bnei Noach, because in the time of Redemption, all mankind will know Hashem and His name, and gentiles will serve Him thru the Universal Miztvoth given to Noach. The third thing if those are religious people for sure they did not learn anything about: Love your fellowman as yourself. Which according to the great Rabbi Akivah is what the whole Torah is about.. Having said that, Iam surprised, sad and ashamed to have jews, and ones that call themselves religious, doing something like that.
3. Is modesty patrol legally permitted?
Ralph ,   Caesarea   (02.29.12)
Otherwise jail them!
4. Oh my GOD!!!! those sick evil bastards!!!!!
Talula ,   Israel   (02.29.12)
I always think I've seen and heard it all....... until the next news item. I want to know what the police are going to do about it. Are they going to pussy-foot around them or are they going to grow some balls and do the right thing.
5. Interesting...
shua ,   jerusalem   (02.29.12)
Nachlaot isn't a haredi neighborhood from what I remember. They do have a pedophile problem though. Most people that live there are mizrahi/national religious, students and singles that want to be near "the seen".
6. Pray these people never get a hold of guns
Charles   (02.29.12)
If they join the army they'll have access to guns. Then we'll have the identical Jewish version of Hamas.
7. Hope and pray for her recovery
rebecca ,   Modiin   (02.29.12)
and the capture, trial and hard sentencing of those responsible.
8. THEY DESERVE LIFE SENTENCE !
David ,   Montreal, Canada   (02.29.12)
9. These are hooligans...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.29.12)
who took the religion as an excuse to practice their vilenies.They belong in prison,if what the article tells is true.
10. Its up to the Israeli citizen if this goes on
Susya Bar Dror ,   IL   (02.29.12)
or not. In the next election Israel can decide if they want to be like Iran or if they wish to return to an open democratic society! I am sorry for the lady, she did not deserve this.
11. Have the area Rabbis condemned these disgaraceful thugs?
PETER SM ,   AUSTRALIA   (02.29.12)
If not they are part of the problem. Refuah Shlema Mrs S
12. If people can be beaten up...
Aviela ,   Migron, Israel   (02.29.12)
The energy should be going toward brutalizing the tens of documented pedophiles walking freely around Nachlaot. My heart goes out to a neighborhood that is going through a very, very hard time.
13. this is NOT yiddishkeit!
tom ,   toronto, canada   (02.29.12)
"the temple wasn't destroyed by the romans, but by sin'at hinam." is there not a single RABBI in the whole eidah hareidit, who will speak out against this hillul hashem? where is their outcry, their righteous indignation, when an old woman is beaten? where is the voice of the "chief rabbi of israel"? why didn't ynet ask him to voice his opinion? or is he afraid to speak out? and where are the voices of the minister of interior security (in charge of police) or the minister of religious affairs? surely this is both a "police" matter, and a "religious" matter! it is not enough to arrest these criminals, and release them after the inevitable "riots" - there must be public condemnation, from the hareidim and the non-haredim, as the torah says, "to purge this evil from the children of israel".
14. editors: please remove the photo
tom ,   toronto, canada   (02.29.12)
please remove the photo, not because i object to the depiction of women, but because it is not actually connected to the story, and it would seem that the victim has not consented to the use of her name or picture, so it only creates a false impression. most people can imagine what a vicious beating looks like, without such "visual aids"..
15. Modesty Patrol = Shutzstaffel
A ,   Belgium   (02.29.12)
I thought these things only happened in nazi Germany, and in repressive backward regimes like Saudi Arabia.
16. Modesty Patrol
Enoch ,   Totonto   (02.29.12)
According to the story, they used their phones. Even the "geniuses" of the Israeli police should be able to trace the calls.
17. CUT HAREDI SUBSIDIES NOW!
mea   (02.29.12)
Get these freeloaders off the society!
18. Chabad
Dov ,   Israel   (02.29.12)
I am a Chabad-Lubavitcher and to see this totally unacceptable. Absolute craziness.
19. Thanks from a Ger
Mychal ,   TN, USA   (02.29.12)
I am so sorry for this lady's pain. As someone who is currently going through conversion, I thank her for teaching other gerim like me, especially in the face of persecution. I will give tzedakah in her honor.
20. Catch them and lock them up ASAP!
Ari   (02.29.12)
21. Religious Fanatics
RC ,   USA   (02.29.12)
The Jewish Taliban at it again, they are behaving just like the Muslim Taliban. If left unchecked, soon they will start killing people in the name of God just like the Muslim Taliban.
22. JAIL RABBIS' who CONDONE THESE ATTACKS & SHOULD BE fired!.
Secular JEW ,   NYC, USA   (02.29.12)
TIME FOR THE secular/moderate/ conservatives MAJORITY TO STRIKE BACK. HARD, without mercy, without any qualms whatsoever against these insane terrorist zealots... Imagine a 70 year old JEWISH woman beaten by FOUR ANIMALS for not being JEWISH ENOUGH.... I DECLARE ANY THUG WHO BEATS A defenseless woman, a 70 YEAR OLD, SHOULD BE sexually EMASCULATED, then hung by his nose. This is the most horrific scene I have run into in ISRAEL...not much worse than the arab babies with the explosive vests...I hope the authorities won't give the leaders a FREE PASS and the Rabbi's MUST CONDEMN THESE ARTROCITIES ANd TURN IN THESE MONSTEROUS BEASTS FOR A major league legal WHIPPIN" ISRAELI's must ARM THEMSELVES AGAINST THESE narrow myopic selfish unforgiving greedy lazy hypocritical PARASITES THAT LIVE OFF THE TOIL OF all OTHER JEWS. Kick these heredi in their legal balls...smite them and get even for their atrocities!.
23. #5 You remember wrong
Joe ,   San Diego, USA   (02.29.12)
sorry =(
24. This is where extremism drives us in
Yossef   (02.29.12)
How long will we accept that, and they speak in the name of judaism ? Not in my name !
25. To Tom, #14: This is what you're worried about?
Tsvi ,   Ashkelon   (02.29.12)
and not one iota of condemnation of this vile, disgraceful act? Get your priorities straight!
26. Question????
paul ,   jerusalem Isael   (02.29.12)
Where in the story is there any statement clearly saying these thugs were Charaidim. For all we know maybe it was relatives of one of the people whom she helped convert (ie. non jews) They were masked men and the victim herself doesn't know. I have been living with Chareidim for over 10 years and have never come across this so called modesty patrol!!!
27. Prayers
Adam Neira ,   Paris, France   (02.29.12)
Prayers for the woman. The thugs that did this should be found and punished.
28. Just Wondering...
Professor Z ,   Jerusalem   (02.29.12)
This was a deplorable act and no one is arguing that. Of course no sane rabbi would condone such a thing. However I have just one observation: whenever there's an insane Haredi who commits an act of violence, everyone is up in arms, clamoring, "Where are the rabbis to condemn this?" which they should be. But when a secular commits an act of violence, no one calls on anyone to condemn it (mostly because when a secular commits an act of violence, it's not news, unlike when a Haredi does).
29. Man oh Manochewitz we have become nuts...
Al   (02.29.12)
For heavens sake...did we all become insane. One day a Yaron London putz writes articles akin to nazi propoganda, and now this. STOP IT NOW FROM ALL SIDES! Iran has Israel in its sights while you are all busy pissing on eachother. Do you want to become the next Warsaw Ghetto?
30. Haredim's responsibility
Z to Z ,   Jerusalem   (02.29.12)
If Haredim only obey what the rabbi guide say, the rabbi guide must take position when so sadly called Modesty Patrol gets out to exhibit its insanity, without any comparison. A crime is crime is a crime
Next talkbacks
Back to article