News
'One-state solution' campaign promoted in West Bank
Elior Levi
Published: 07.03.12, 00:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
49 Talkbacks for this article
1. The One-State solution is the logical one now!
Don ,   Tel-Aviv, Israel   (03.07.12)
2. For West Bank, do you mean Jewish land Yehuda & Shomron?
Allan   (03.07.12)
If so, why don't you say so clearly?
3. Lots of space for Arabs in Saudi Arabia
Anna M Sedda ,   Rome-Italy   (03.07.12)
Arabia is The Land of Arabs from Palestine;Italians in Italy,French in France,English in Ingland and Arabs in Arabia....that s normal!!! What is not normal is that Arabs want Israel and Judea;Jews live there. Everybody in his own land....so Arabs in Arabia
4. One State for Two Peoples
Samer ,   West Bank   (03.07.12)
It is not possible to form a 2-state solution anymore due to the vast settlements Israel has built over the years. The only solution left is a bi-national state for Arabs/Jews living in Israel/Palestine. Of course this means Israel won't be a "Jewish State" it will be an "Arab and Jewish State for all 3 major religions." Of course the Palestinian refugees will be permitted to return to their homeland and take part in this bi-national state.
5. Pals aim to include millions of diaspora Pals
Sam ,   Canada   (03.07.12)
Everything Palestinians do has the intention of making the area Muslim majority and Muslim ruled. Whether they speak of a 1 state or 2 state solution they always mean Muslim rule. Don't let yourself be fooled by the cheap talk.
6. one state solution
daniela ,   panama   (03.07.12)
I agree... one state for jews.. and another one someweher else for palestinians.. who by the way, according to the UN 1948 is Jordan. So.. voilá.. this is the best one state solution
7. Hamas and shasta coalitions in kenneset in 30 years.
Salim ,   Jerusalem   (03.07.12)
8. Welcome Israelestine!
Robert ,   New Jersey, USA   (03.07.12)
Mr. Levi, not only are you illiterate ("loosing [sic] their faith in a two-state solution"), but you must be auditioning for Comedy Central! Is this supposed to be tongue in cheek? If this idea is the product of Palestinian 'intellectuals,' Israel hasn't a thing to worry about from Palestinians. The Arabs better pray to Allah someone there knows from which end of the gun the bullets emerge!
9. 1 state for the jews the other for arabs its jordan
ralph   (03.07.12)
10. one state for ARABS and israelis...LOL
les ,   canada   (03.07.12)
first, whith in one generation the 5 million arabs would become 8 million second, ask the fogel family how do they like their loving arab neighbours? nice dream, or NIGHTMARE?
11. 1 state has not worked for the Christians in egypt !
J1 ,   Earth   (03.07.12)
12. One state solution will eventually happen
k ,   US   (03.07.12)
but it probably wont happen for another 100 years, and I am sure there will be countless wars and dead people in the process
13. Selena Gomez & The Scene - "Love You Like A Love Song" (Musi
Marc ,   NC, USA   (03.07.12)
Stop it please this is semantics. If Israel does not give the Palestinians independane, we will need to be one state, and Israel will lose its Jewish identity anyway. Take you pick of the lesser of two evils..
14. one state with handsome jewish men !
Noor Harazeen ,   Gaza   (03.07.12)
sure one state is the only solution ! but i need to live with handsome Jewish guys ;) and you can see clearly, Irez crossing is my worst enemy ! PS: I am very famous activist !
15. @4
(03.07.12)
habibi, IN YOUR WET DREAMS ONLY. YOU WILL NEVER EVER SUCCEED!
16. YES! One State for ALL!
Palestinian   (03.07.12)
It's time to share the land with equality! Enough of ethnic nationalism! Time for integration, not separation! Separation has brought us nothing but bloodshed since partition. Enough!
17. One state, Gaza NOT included
David ,   Modiin, Israel   (03.07.12)
...is the only solution. Let the Arabs make their Hong-Kong or whatever they wish from Gaza. Anex Judea and Samaria with all its Arabs, no "refugees" allowed. Orthodox Jews have much higher population growth so no need to worry about demography.
18. One state solution...
Futuva Mataincur ,   Israel   (03.07.12)
will end like in Yugoslavia, after the jews and arabs will start killing each other. Bi-national states are doomed, even 2 nice and close people like the czechs and slovaks decided on separation , so how can 2 people who for more than 63 years are trying to kill each other, live in the same state?
19. One state solution
Istvan ,   BUDAPEST HUNGARY   (03.07.12)
I bet the new, one state parlament's first decision will be to allow 10 million more arabs to settle, whose cousins, son in laws, one of great grandparents were palestinians.
20. join our democracy?
trevor ,   Modiin Israel   (03.07.12)
First, let us see the entire Arab world accept equal rights of sexes, equal rights of homosexuals, equal rights of religions and many other basic equal rights - and once this is achieved...we will consider one state where Muslims, Christians and Jews can live freely and without fear...however until then...sorry but not a chance
21. Annex, rent A & B to Jordan for 99 years
Yossef   (03.07.12)
give back to all the Arabs in Judea Shomron the jordanian citizenship. Gaza independent. That's the solution.
22. Two people, one state, one man one vote...
Eichman ,   Germany   (03.07.12)
Is the ideal solution. No need for all of you idiots to squabble over land and petty things. NO South African like APARTHEID either...
23. "One state euphemism for Israel's destruction
Menachem ,   Israel   (03.07.12)
The "one-state solution" is the wet dream for the enemies of Israel who seek the Jewish state's destruction through demography after war and terror failed to achieve this goal. It will NEVER happen so dream on Jew-hating losers.
24. #11, not just Jews, but christians will suffer the One STALE
mary of bethany ,   singapore   (03.07.12)
the world Christendom should oppose this stupid idea. you don't want a Arab majority to rule the Knesset one day and start turning all churches in mosques, and changing all history books into myths stories in Israel. Ask anyone Jew staying round East Jerusalem, will tell you how the "peaceful" Arab Israelis behave, and you don't want 6 millions of these "peaceful rock-showering" arab Israelis living next doors. oh, forget the liberal Tel Aviv, haha wonder how arabic will it turn into. ladies must swim in burka? One State or One Stale!
25. If Palestinians dont want to make it on their own..
Tim ,   Brighton   (03.07.12)
The only natural federations are West Bank federated to Jordan Gaza federated to Egypt
26. pals already have One State call JORDAN!
mary of bethany ,   singapore   (03.07.12)
27. One-State calls for restoration of the Balfour Mandate [End]
BUTSeriously ,   Australia   (03.07.12)
28. To: No. 16
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.07.12)
YOU are the ones that have brought bloodshed. The Jewish people have never wanted anyhthing but peaceful co-existence and mutual co-operation, but seven decades have taught us that the ersatz "Palestinians" bring nothing except war and terror. Enough! Make your way among your own people; we've had quite enough of your violence and murderous ways. You will NEVER make decent Israelis -- as you have proven time and time and time again.
29. DEMOCRACY BY THE ARABS... ???
stude ham   (03.07.12)
MORE LIKE TOTAL LAND THEFT FROM THE JEWISH PEOPLE BY THE ARABS. something the these arab foreign invaders have been doing for centuries.
30. Arabs in Judea and Samaria get residency but not citizenship
Jordan Is ,   Palestine   (03.07.12)
in Israel...meanwhile increased pressure on the rich hashemite family ruling millions of palestinians in jordan to accept that Jordan be the official palestinian state (it IS 78% of the palestine mandate land, it DOES have a majority Palestinian population, the NEXT KING is Palestinian thru his Palestinian mother)....so, residency in Israel and citizenship in Jordan/Palestine/ehatever you want to call it.
Next talkbacks
Back to article