News  World News
Muslim lesbian couple fight Canada deportation to Israel
Ynet
Published: 18.03.12, 20:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
28 Talkbacks for this article
1. islam religion of peace & love!
Maor   (03.18.12)
2. What do these Arab want?They mutilate
Israeli 2   (03.18.12)
their daughters and expect them to be straight? Besides, why focus on females? If their men are gay, there would be no honor killings. How cowardly and hypocritical.
3. #2, not isolated to women
Jacob ,   Holon, Israel   (03.18.12)
There are honor killings for gay men, I remember there was an attack last year where a family tracked a man in their family who ran away to tel aviv and tried to abduct him back home to kill him but was stopped by passers by. It probably happens a lot more for gay men
4. These two gals just applied for liquor license...
Al   (03.18.12)
and they got it thanks to the suckers in Canada. Hmm I got that the other way around... Oh never mind...
5. Clarification
Marty ,   Toronto Canada   (03.18.12)
I wish all of the media that pick up on this piece clarify that the women are MUSLIM and that the danger to their lives is from their FELLOW MUSLIMS. The title of the article in the Toronto Sun is deceptive - until one reads the article, one has the impression that the women (Arabic sounding names) would be put to death by Israel rather than their fellow followers of the "Religion of Peace".
6. Pretty stupid to publish their real names
Stupid YNet ,   Israel   (03.18.12)
The "family" will find them no matter where they live.
7. Watch: Won't be long before Israel-bashers spin it
Mikey ,   SomeWhere OverHere   (03.18.12)
Israel-bashers will soon spin this against Israel and highlight that gay *Israeli citizens*seek refuge in Canada b/c of their sexuality, and will ignore the fact that these women are endangered by Arab-Muslim society within Israel. When an Arab-Israeli Christian was arrested last year in Georgia, USA, as a serial killer, the Israel-haters ignored the fact he was Christian Jewish and raved about Jewish murderers. When an Arab-Muslim couple was arrested in East Jerusalem for abusing and enslaving a foreign worker, I saw talkback comments about how this was emblematic of racist Zionist society!
8. # 5
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.18.12)
What needs to be clarified is that Israel will not kill these muslim lesbians but Arab muslims living in Israel will kill them.
9. # 6
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.18.12)
Exactly my thoughts.
10. # 5 Marty
Maple Syrup ,   Sugar Bush   (03.18.12)
I agree with you 200% but what do you expect? we are experiencing the bias shown EVERYWHERE in the West where Israel is concerned, so don't lose too much sleep about it. Al in # 4: you just wish you were living in a free country like Canada or Israel or maybe you just wish you were not Muslim...you know more freedom and all! About that couple, as much as I think the same sex phenomena is not really normal, let them live their lives as long as they don (try) to hurt people around them. Also there is a bright side to them; they won't procreate like mad and raise 1/2 dozen of babies to become suicide bombers. So in the end, it's all good! I wish them luck.
11. Toronto Sun
Ellen ,   Netanya/NYC   (03.18.12)
I just went and wrote a letter to the editor pointing this out. If enough of us write than maybe one will actually be published. Israel is gay friendly--not Israel's fault if their relatives are potential murderers.
12. The real problem
Marcela Araújo ,   Brazil   (03.18.12)
I am not lesbian... So I do not know how is the daily lives of these people. But I believe they would have no problems living in Israel. The real problem are the threats they received. But this can be solved by the police. So I do not understand why this controversy...
13. # 10
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.18.12)
Be surprised to know that Al lives in Canada & is not muslim, in fact Al is very much a Jew.
14. one correction. Islam mean surrender not peace
Golan ,   modiin   (03.18.12)
when you "convert" to Islam you surrender to Islam. You do not convert. You do not need to know anything about Islam or receive training or anything. You simply say a sentence in front of two Muslim men three times and ipso facto if you "unsurrender" you can be slaughtered.
15. Any threat comes from their peace loving brothers & sisters
PETER SM ,   AUSTRALIA   (03.19.12)
and there are plenty of those in Canada.
16. better keep away from toronto gay rights group will be kille
ralph   (03.18.12)
for saying what they are claiming. it cannot be true must be a a propaganda ploy by isreal. i mean a nice jewish girl just was granted a degree saying israel discriminates and our famous leftist judy what's her last name holding conference at ryerson on apartheid israel.
17. #10..hahahaha you havent got a clue what a liquor license is
Al   (03.18.12)
Let me spell it out for ya... Oh never mind... Go back to sleep. Geez what I have to deal with .
18. Israel is more tolarant than Canada
Myriam El-Bitar ,   Ottawa Canada   (03.18.12)
This would be a legitimate concern in Ramallah or most of the mainly Muslim communities however in TelAviv there are many places they would be welcomed. Israel is the only mid-east country that would NOT persecute them
19. But, um, Israel is not an Arab or Muslim country
Serge ,   Montreal, Canada   (03.18.12)
Why don't they live in TA or somewhere else where these Islamic murderers do not live? Is the idea that they will have a vast network of Islamic spies with guns, ready to shoot immediately if they glimpse them? Once somewhere starts a vendetta against you, you have to leave the country? It is a perplexing problem, I guess.
20. Indeed
Anna Giladi ,   Haifa, Israel   (03.19.12)
"Forbidden in Israel", "killed if in Israel", right. Because Israel only happens to be the only gay-friendly country in the Middle East. If they live in Haifa, Tel Aviv or any other mixed city, they will be just fine as long as they stay among Israelis rather than Muslims. Misleading article. Very disappointing.
21. Israel not Arab or Muslim country
Adar ,   London, UK   (03.19.12)
22. Yet again Ynet shows its disdain for Israel
Arie ,   BaGolan   (03.19.12)
ONLY towards the end of the article does Yediot show that the fear they face is to be "honor" murdered by their muslim families. The bulk of the article attacks Israel and attempts to show Israel as "intolerant" and "dangerous." More of the Yediot push to displace haaretz as the most Anti-Jew media in Israel
23. Liquor License
Shlomo ,   Chicago, USA   (03.19.12)
My father-in-law described his neighbors for those of us who understood what he meant as Timex, using clean language in front of the kids!
24. Nothing important is happening?
Doug ,   U.S.   (03.19.12)
25. Canlii.org; 2012 FC 298.
Serge ,   Montreal, Canada   (03.19.12)
The court decision is easily found on canlii.org. Just type in one of the names of the parties to the case. Or: 2012 FC 298. It is an interesting read.
26. LGBT groups & Israel...
Abie Dee ,   New York, US   (03.19.12)
And despite the fact that these lesbians are not safe among their Muslim family members, some LGBT groups continue to bash Israel. Of course they would be much more effective if their protests were aimed at Muslim countries, but in the end, i guess their hate agenda is stronger than their political agenda.
27. Misleading!! (accidently?! )
Avi ,   Los Angeles(Israeli)   (03.19.12)
I am from Israel, currently living in LA. Tel Aviv is one of the places u would rather live if you r gay, I grow up there!! This article and specially the headline is misleading (accidently??!!) the poor girls would be persecute by their muslim family, a minority in the country that does NOT represent the country of Israel!! wish for the girls to get the visa they need.. and for Ynet to be more accurte!!
28. Think about it!
Rima ,   Israel   (03.19.12)
They are Israeli citizens who are threatened by Israeli citizens. They reported the threats to the Israeli law enforcement system and should be protected by the Israeli law enforcement system. So what we have here is a case of discrimination by the Israeli government and law system who loafs when the lives of Arab women is on stake.
Back to article