News  World News
EU corrects Ashton speech transcript after Israeli anger
AFP
Published: 20.03.12, 21:13
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
1. Ashton revised script
Mark Bernhard ,   Pasadena, USA   (03.20.12)
More spin control after the horse is out of the barn. How anyone believes the nonsense that she had not really equated Gaza with Toulouse when that is precisely what she said in her speech. This woman established a new level of chutzpah!
2. Corrected version
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.20.12)
Yeah, right. Ashton should resign.
3. NETANYAHU OUTRAGED ?
LAWRENCE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (03.20.12)
Well I am surprised ,I mistakenly assumed he was a robot who has no reactions .
4. PISS OFF ASHTON
DA RAP ARTIST ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (03.20.12)
5. E.U. CORRECTS ASHTONS' FACE
MR CYNIC ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (03.20.12)
Now THAT is worth reporting LOL.
6. surgical defensive actions of the IDF
Ulo ,   Belgium   (03.20.12)
Surgical...? My a**! There is a comparison, there is suffer whenever someone is killed or injured whatever etnicity - no human being is above another
7. #6 Better get your piles seen to, Ulo la
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (03.20.12)
8. Give me a break...
Tim ,   Brighton   (03.20.12)
Its like me wishing condolences to a bereaved couple for the cold blooded MURDER of their child thus... 'So sorry to hear about your child..not forgetting all the others suffering in Gaza and Sderot!' Was that simply crass? Just insensitive? A stupid faux pas? No SHE KNEW WHAT SHE WAS SAYING. it was a stomach churning pitiless disgusting and intentional remark designed to use the situation to make yet another of her diatribes against Israel Im sickened to the core...
9. #6
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (03.20.12)
CIA drones under Obama: 10 dead civilians to 1 combatant UK drones under Cameron: at least 2 dead civilians to 1 combatant Israel in "Cast Lead": 1 dead civilian for 2 combatants Israel in the last defense against Jihad attacks: 1 dead civilian for 10 combatants conclusion: Israel attacks are surgical Fatah, Hamas and Jihad are criminals for hiding behind civilians
10. fire that harpy!
ej   (03.20.12)
she's a well known israel basher and the EU will distort all the facts to make Israel look bad and the arabs look like angels!
11. Better if Ashton doesn't say anything
(03.20.12)
Or at least don't talk about us.
12. Damage control by those who 'appointed her.
tiki ,   belgium   (03.20.12)
The first version was bad, the second worse. It showed the EU was endorsing her cold & impersonal but absolutely PC message. When Jews get SHOT in front of their school (because of being Jews), she & the EU shouldn't try selling us their political correct version of shock, by dragging in children killed in a tragic bus ACCIDENT in Belgium, children killed tragicly by their own dictator in Syria & children in Sderot being terrorised by rockets, send to them with hate by the families of brainwashed children from her beloved Gaza.
13. Every tragedy stands on it's own
Avramele   (03.20.12)
There is a Jewish tradition that while attending a burial one should not visit the graves of others out of respect to the immediately departed and the family. The Talmud also teaches that to destroy a single life is to destroy an entire world. From all this we learn that no two deaths should be compared. The murder at the French yeshiva stands on its own and Ashton should have condemned it in the strongest language without drawing parallels.
14. Her remarks were made to Palestinians
observer   (03.20.12)
Firstly she deliberately minimised the murders in France by comparing them with those in Norway in which over 70 people were gunned down. Secondly she mentioned them in the same breath - whether directly comparing them or not - with IDF attacks on Gaza and with Syrian govt attacks on its own people. That alone is totally reprehensible, and no amount of spinning will get her out of that hole. However, after checking her CV online, it's quite clear that she is an opportunist ready to say anything, do anything, get to the top. When in British history has someone been elevated to the peerage for nuclear disarmament activism? Only that fool Tony Blair could pull that off - and he knew who give it to.
15. convenient
alexi   (03.20.12)
ashton conveniently adds a few words about sderot to balance the comments about gaza children. What happened to gaza children has no comparison whatsoever with toulouse and any half wit would know that. someone who is intimidated by hamas and who is collected paychecques for gutless europe would obviously make such a hateful comment. her retraction is not good enough. The EU should be excluded from israeli arab affairs and ashton declared persona non grata. She is a carbon copy of cheri booth's sister.
16. Ashton, time to go home
Eran ,   Singapore   (03.20.12)
I am wandering. When is your next rant.
17. Fire Ashton
Reuven   (03.20.12)
And tell her not to slam the door on her way out!
18. EU corects or FALSIFIES?
Bergkamp   (03.20.12)
Not the first time the Eu falsifies an antisemitic speech by the way.
19. To: No. 6
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.20.12)
Please do not confuse the acts of a sovereign state with the acts of a terrorist rabble. Israel has an affirmative duty to protect and defend its citizens and its borders. If the terrorist flotsam and jetsam in Gaza would not fire missiles and mortars into Israel, and plot massive acts of terror, then Israel would not have a need to respond. It is absurd to characterize this as an ethnic conflict -- that's almost irrelevant in this case. It is the rights of a sovereign state as opposed to the "rights" of a terrorist rabble sworn to the destruction of the State of Israel. the rights of a sovereign state are well-settled international convention. Terrorists do not have any "rights."
20. Aclever women (in this case) should rather keep her mouth sh
Adi ,   Israel   (03.20.12)
21. To #9
Ulo ,   Belgium   (03.20.12)
The UN school was also surgical, right? And still every single civilian is one too much - regardeless of how you present it...
22. EU Minister Catherine Ashton
Gabriel ,   Edinburgh UK   (03.20.12)
This is not the first anti Israel comments by this ugly woman. She really has no ide what is happening anyway, should be ignored.
23. Screw U, EU
(03.21.12)
24. Too ignorant to know Hamas bomb schools kindergartens
PETER SM ,   AUSTRALIA   (03.21.12)
School buses in Israel? If they had succeeded in their mass murderous intent the tragedy would have been enormous. She clearly is not an honest broker or just plain dumb?
25. @ No. 21
Ahron ,   Holon, Israel   (03.21.12)
Why aren't you ever this upset when an Israeli child is fired upon? You're silence betrays you.
26. Not good enough.
Maurice ,   Los Angeles, USA   (03.21.12)
There are still no parallel between Gaza and Sderot. Children in Sderot are purposefully targeted by Hamas and other terrorist groups, Children in Gaza are never the target of the IDF.
27. Too Little, Too Late. Ashton is a Jew Hater
EZRA THE PROUD JEW ,   USA-ISRAEL   (03.21.12)
Without a doubt: her ACTIONS over the past few years have revealed a completely UNBALANCED PREJUDICE in favor of the arabs and a disproportionate level of criticism of Israel. This latest statement just 'naturally' flowed from this jerks mouth; like common conversation in her everyday life. She needs to be fired immediately. This is no light matter: its a serious reflection of the throw-back mentality to a by-gone era of european Jew-hatred. She should be visited SWIFTLY by her karma. So damn sad.
28. #21 you mean the school that wasn't hit
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (03.21.12)
After the UN lied about it - they later stated that not only did it not hit the school - no children were hit either. That's the school you are talking about right!
29. #6, another moral imbecile.
rick ,   walnut creek   (03.21.12)
in the imbecilic view of #6, every death is equal to every other death. the death of the murderer is equivalent to that of his victim. one would have thought that this sort of infantile and sophmoric moralizing had been left in middle school. it is important to make distinctions based on circumstance or context. the gaza children are not murderers but they are used for cover by murderers and their proximity to murderers sometimes results in unintended injury or death to them. one has to be so morally and intellectually obtuse to confuse the cases that reason is unlikely to be of any help.
30. Ashton loose talk Inciting Hamas!
David ,   USA   (03.21.12)
This racist woman ought to call Hamas & these new Nazi hooligans in Toulouse as "terrorists " PERIOD! To say Children are killed in Gaza is INCITEFUL BECAUSE WE ALL KNOW HAMAS WILL KILL THEIR OWN CHILDREN & PURPOSELY PLACE THEM IN HARM'S WAY! She & the racist quartet have uttered too many shameful words vs. Israel (which implicates all Jews)
Next talkbacks
Back to article