News  Magazine
Analysis: US thwarting Israeli strike on Iran
Ron Ben-Yishai
Published: 29.03.12, 14:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
141 Talkbacks for this article
91. The modus operandi of COWARDS is to
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (03.30.12)
plant a smokescreen of misinformations...THAT'S the American policy on Iran since the days of the hostage crisis and Jimmy the wimp Carter !
92. Israel must act for Israel
Millionär?Ichwünsche ,   Ulm, Deutschland   (03.30.12)
I find it so ironic that Israel is always being held on a rein by the USA, because the idea is that the USA will always protect Israel. But when it comes to Iran, Israel must wait until the US elections are over later this year before they can act. But by then, it may be too late. By then Iran may have the A-Bomb. It seems to me that if Israel acted now to defend itself, it may end up protecting the Americans later on, because American time wasting will threaten American security plus Israeli security. Perhaps now Israel is the more mature and intelligent country, and in defending itself as it should, it will come to be seen as the saviour of Western security years later. America is powerful for sure, but i trust Israeli brains more. Israel must do what is right for Israel. Don't wait for anybody else, and don't trust anybody else. Martin (German), and a fan of Israel.
93. Israel Betrays the US All of the Time
America The Beautifu ,   Indianapolis USA   (03.30.12)
Betrayal implies that there was some amount of trust between two parties. The USA does not trust Israel anymore than it does Iran, therefore there was no betrayal. Israel needs to fight its own wars with its own money and own weapons. Stop putting the US in a position to always have to stick our necks out for you
94. Only IsraelStopping Israel
Mark ben Josef ,   USA   (03.30.12)
So if you want to attack, do so. It is entirely an Israeli choice. Nobody is holding up Israel, but Israel. Show the US what pussies we are.
95. TRUST
David ,   TN, USA   (03.30.12)
We the people have no trust in this so called presidential regime. He has betrayed us, the American people. We know how you(Israel) feel, and I have been trying to say this for four years. No one can trust this obama, nobody. And he calls himself a Christian... Please lets vote him out, and save America.
96. Strike Iran
Naphtali ,   Seattle,WA   (03.30.12)
US must support Israel in striking Iran.
97. US Policy Change Towards Israel
Martin Alan Baker ,   Lindenwold, NJ USA   (03.30.12)
The President is doing what he was put in office to do: make a final and complete break with Israel. Previous US Administration moves were subtle - condemnations of various Israeli actions - starting with George H. Bush. The destabilization of Iraq (under the ruse of "WMD's") created another radical Islamic state in order to put more pressure on Israel to change its policies. I suppose the rationale behind the strategy was that it is far easier to pressure one state (Israel) as opposed to many (the Arab nations). I imagine the next step will be sanctions against Israel if the strike is accomplished (as it must be accomplished).
98. #90. USA Protecting Israel From Itself
Millionär?Ichwünsche ,   Ulm, Deutschland   (03.30.12)
And so what is the world going to look like if Iran becomes a nuclear power? Do you really want a nuclear armed Iran controlling the Straits of Hormuz? If you think the price of oil is high now, just wait until Iran starts to disrupt oil supplies from the Gulf. Also, Israel is not a sh*tty little country. The Jews have suffered terribly in history, and all they want is just a little strip of land to live peacefully on. Its not too much to ask for i don't think. We should support Israel in this time. Their interests are the same as ours. Martin, Ulm, Deutschland.
99. Nr 62,
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (03.30.12)
I Quote you - But Ron Ben Yishai is the analyst and as such he could have shed some more light on things we do not know...analysis or at least opinion that is. Israeli 2 (03.29.12) I Quote the Article - I have no intention of detailing or even hinting to the options which the US government aims to eliminate by exposing them in the media. A large part of the reports stem from false information or disinformation, and there is no reason to reveal to the Iranians what’s real and what isn’t. Comment - As you has understood, He probably knows and understands more than in the Article but will not elaborate any deeper in analysises because of the above God bless !!!. Arn.Sweden.
100. Americans, you just don't get it.
Am Israel Chai! ,   Haifa   (03.30.12)
You start wars for your personal interests all over the world and no one can stop you or say anything to you. Israel's wars are existential. We are trying to stay alive...ever since the Holocaust. You worry about higher gas prices for your SUV's. We worry about staying alive to see another sun rise another morning and our childrens future. By the way, is freedom of speech only for American's and Iranians?
101. Wonder who exactly is leaking here
cat ,   Greenwood   (03.30.12)
Everyone is against going to War in Iran & they don't think it's truly necessary, The Pentagon, Intelligence Depts., The Military, the Admin, & the State Dept. Their all on recortd saying this & they've all visited Israel recently & I'm sure explained this to Bibi/Barak. You really need to listen as all of them seldom agree on a single issue.
102. Perhaps the joke is on you
Matt   (03.30.12)
103. US Protecting Israel
mkk22011 ,   India   (03.30.12)
What US is doing is just ensuring that Israel is protected from the rage of Iranian nation!!!
104. Jews and WWII
john ,   Beverly Hills, CA   (03.30.12)
many jews supported hitler, just remember that. In other words to assume people cant make mistakes is silly. Israel must do whatever it takes to make sure it survives, remember, jews have had and lost israel many times, and everytime they had it they where convinced this time we really have it forever. Learn from history, and remember, you will never find a man named hussain that will care if israel lives or dies. If obama wins again, the true anti jew pro commie colors will come out.
105. God bless America !!!
Observer ,   Israel   (03.30.12)
106. Trusting Obama/Who threats whom?
Ed Zahn ,   Germany   (03.30.12)
Hahahaha the good old Gearge Orwell would remind us of the fact that among us equals,still there are some more equal. Read:" the wolf and the sheep."
107. ...to be reelected.
Ed ZAhn ,   Germany   (03.30.12)
He will allow Iran to obtain the BOMB for the sake of his re-election. ### very true ! Same as long ago another president allowed Israel to get the bomb(s) !
108. A ladder for the big mouth Bibi
Cosimo Medici ,   France   (03.30.12)
After so much bluff and bluster, or as the Americans say ,smoke and mirrors a ladder is offered to the loud mouthed demagogue.Lets hope he takes it.
109. #108 looks like your hopes will be dashed
(03.30.12)
better luck next time
110. america's supposed sabotaging of israel
milton david frank ,   qazir israel   (03.30.12)
I live in Israe.I don't see anywhere that Israelis voted for Obama,aside from absentee ballots.Obama isn't the prime minister of Israel.He isn't the president of Israel.He owes you or us nothing,and this is really the crux of the biscuit.You wake up every morning thinking of what Obama is doing to you.Grow up!You want to live in America and vote Obama out of office,go right ahead.In the meantime,how cheesy,and reminiscient of Bush's leadup to the war in Iraq,that you say you have all this info,but will spare us ignorants the gory details.Please go back to New York,New Jersey wherever you caame from.
111. # 107 Not the same......
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (03.30.12)
Israel is not a threat. When is the last time a Jew rioted and killed over a teddy bear or a cartoon? Israel and Muslim countries have nothing in common.
112. Stike will happen. Obama just voted himself out of office!
(03.30.12)
And Hillary: study the fine art of knitting because soon, your ugly face and crooked, treacherous smile won't be decorating the State Department halls anymore!
113. #60 Excellent post
esnuffnstl ,   USA   (03.30.12)
Very well said, Rob. It's especially true that Israel is losing both the "friend war" and the "enemy war." Iran doesn't need to develop nuclear weapons in order to harm Israel. All Iran has to do is drive a wedge between Israel and its last remaining ally on the planet. Perhaps Iran has been playing Israel all along with this intention in mind. Some on Ynet think Israel can go it alone in the world (and possibly be better off for it.) They might get their wish. I'm not sure how Israel will fare without the US, especially without US protection in the UNSC. Much of the world is itching to sanction and punish Israel and only the US veto at the UNSC stands in their way.
114. #83 Free speech, George?
Roman ,   Lod, Israel   (03.30.12)
Incitement to violence, calls of utter destruction, calls for genocide, calls for mass expulsion, by the *official leadership*, both national and religio-national, of Iran, is *not* "free speech". Nor is the covert and not-so-covert war you may have missed in the past few *decades*. We had Iranians at our borders, operating hand in hand and training Hezbollah. And they arm them and cooperate with them to this day, along with their cooperation with the military arm of Hamas. And yet you call one "free speech", and Israeli leaders' responses to said "free speech" to be dangerous threats. Oh, just stop it, please. Iran's regime had a *hidden* nuclear program. They have bought information and equipment from Khan's nuclear proliferation network, and only after *that* was revealed the Iranians agreed to international inspection on their program at all - inspection they have since made a laughing stock of. So let's recap. Iran broke the Non-Proliferation Treaty, which they signed. They had a *hidden* nuclear program. They *still* hide or obfuscate much of it. Their leadership officially considers Israel to be an illegitimate non-entity, and recently that particular line has been very loudly declared, more than once, with no "mistranslations". We did not start with the saber-rattling, George. But through people like you, we're certainly blamed for it, time and time again.
115. A lesson to be learned by all American voters
Izzy ,   Austin USA   (03.30.12)
You're completely right. Too bad we can't seem to convince the sheep-like majority. All he cares about is holding onto his own power.
116. #89 MOL - All theory,no substance
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.30.12)
It's in all the news, Obama is having the U.S. Dept. of State leak the most intimate aspects of a a potential attack to Iran
117. #90 World Whatever
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.30.12)
The U.S. acts only in its own self-interests Now be a good little fellow, have mommy wash your mouth out with soap Nobody cares if you wish or not, you're just a shmuck that claims to a Citizen of a thing called "World"
118. #114: There is no free speech in Israel
George ,   San Francisco, USA   (03.30.12)
They will not print my detailed response to you. Everything you say is false. But, I am not going to waste my time responding to you again.
119. 74 we're paying at the gas pump cause Obama is a morron
(03.30.12)
120. Simple Solution: Nuke Iran
Avi ,   USA   (03.30.12)
Israel should not waste time and play games with Obama on their survival. it's time for a few simple nuclear tipped Jericho Missles and believe me more lives would be saved in the end. Tell the Obama that if he keeps releasing sensitive imformation then the only defense left for israel will be to use Nuclear weapons.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article