News
Watch video documenting abuse of Givati soldiers
Yoav Zitun
Published: 29.03.12, 20:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
1. Behaviour unbecoming of soldiers.
me ,   here   (03.29.12)
Cowards, beating their comrades in arms, who are blind folded. Think they are tough, do they?! LOL. It could have been worse, though, but the experience for the blindfolded guy must be one of insecurity and helplessness. - Disgusting! Aren't soldiers supposed to work in teams and help and support each other, or am I completely in the darkness here?!!!
2. pretty stupid behavior as is all hazing.
Barney ,   USA   (03.29.12)
3. givati
zeboss ,   tel aviv   (03.29.12)
oh come on... kun fu slow motion for young boys in need of tenderness/ bleached version of master and servant. Ad fundum sale bleu! was another story back in the days when I was an university student i europe... chikens///
4. These are not soldiers are only kids
David ,   Be'er Sheva   (03.29.12)
The officer in charge of this unit must be punished....soldiers do not become worriers with this....but with respect and honor to be soo.
5. Please. I dealt with worse when I joined a fraternity
Biilyboy   (03.29.12)
6. Criminal behaviour
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (03.29.12)
This is criminal behaviour. As the attorney Ilan Katz said, it is the commanding officers that should be charged, not the soldiers!!! Either they are aware it is happening and do nothing or they don't know about it, but should!!
7. man who cannot speak it is the beast that beat
daniel   (03.29.12)
8. The entire chain of command must be held accountable!
(03.29.12)
9. Givati
a Christian ,   USA   (03.29.12)
This is disgusting. I would not have imagined that this could take place in a Country that I love!
10. Mixed feelings after watching the video
Arnold ,   Canada   (03.29.12)
Initially I was upset reading the report. Then I watched the video. I looked at the blindfolded soldier and imagined he was Gilad Shalit. The life of an IDF soldier is not one of peace and tranquility. At any time like Shalit they can be kidnapped and treated much more harshly than seen on the video.
11. I have two words that will cure it
BENJABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.29.12)
MISHPAT ZVAI
12. typical israeli solders
moshi ,   israel   (03.29.12)
13. Russian brutality is spreading to the IDF with more Russian
Rivkah   (03.29.12)
aliyahs. One good reason not to help the IFCJ in funding Russian aliyahs to Israel. They are a violent people and culture. They are why people have to pay six months rent in advance in case Russian renters tear up an apartment. If soldiers want to play boxing for a sport, that should be voluntary not coerced like this. What bullies do is to cause their victims to hate which turns the victim into a bully.
14. This isn't anything to be horrified by.
Scott ,   Tallahassee   (03.29.12)
This video hardly captured my attention. I couldn't walk for two days after my 'goodbye' from my unit. While getting hit with rods is certainly extreme, the soldier's peers are just giving him a toughening up that the IDF is no longer allowed to give thanks to all the mothers and women that have taken over the military.
15. Cowards
Michael Pielet ,   israel   (03.29.12)
These cowards will never fight our enemies. Cowards only run away. Put these cowards in jail. Then throw them out of the army.
16. Forbidden To Hit!
Sam ,   Israel   (03.29.12)
G-D has said in the Torah its forbidden to hit another Jew! You should be ashamed of yourselves behaving like the rest of the world! May G-D have mercy on your souls!
17. rivkah is an idiot
(03.29.12)
18. I don't forget my classmate's behavior with myself in......
saied   (03.30.12)
Elemantary school.all the time i was being beaten by them.i forgot the name of my elementary school's friend,but i can not forget the name of assiliant on myself.it was very painful.i like to find them,not to revenge.to ask them whay you were beating me and laughing on me?
19. I'm in shock: I thought there were REAL beatings.
EZRA THE PROUD JEW ,   USA-ISRAEL   (03.30.12)
This is a total joke, not abuse!!! How stupid and 'politically correct' can people get!? Hazing for a fraternity in High School makes this look like a bunch of little girls. Try taking a baseball bat to the butt from huge guys who take a running start...20-30 times. They hit everyone in the upper back and arms, NOT near vital organs. This wasn't abuse; it was a silly ritual that soldiers do. In the US Navy when you get your crow; every other sailor that has a crow is allowed to belt you on the same arm repeatedly throughout the entire day. Thats a tradition a few hundred years old! Your whole are is completely black and blue for a week and half afterwards. I think everyone overreacted like a bunch of babies. NO ABUSE HERE: JUST HAZING. ITS THE ARMY FOR G-D'S SAKE!!!
20. Can't anyone see it is NOT real?
Israeli 2   (03.29.12)
This is just a show on stage. Even the beating is not real. Why are Israeli soldiers filming rheir own "THING" and "GIGS" beats me. They film their dancing, their beating, their training....what else? Perhaps it is supposed to be funny...that's all.
21. LOL, I had worse in summer camp!
Ron ,   Boston, USA   (03.29.12)
I hope those blindfolded kids know that this so-called hazing is going to be the easiest part of getting that purple beret.
22. Typical Arzim!
Phoenix ,   Israel   (03.29.12)
Usual Arz behaviour.
23. STRUCTURALLY investigate and sort out this unjewish SHANDE!!
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (03.29.12)
24. What's All The Fuss About?
(03.30.12)
First of all You talkbacker's Who Never Severed In Any Military, really are clueless !!! There is No way Any Commanding Officers should be held accountable for this MILD case of Indoctrination in this particular brigade !! Personally I've been Hit Harder in a single high school football game. I was the visa with the ball and the chvartzas's I grew up most of the time could'nt even catch me but when did it was much more Severe then what I just saw in the posted video?
25. 17: That is not HaShem's opinion of me. He calls me Solomon
Rivkah   (03.30.12)
in the ELS Scripture code matrix of my name and Hebrew birth year.
26. #13
Alex ,   USA-Israel   (03.30.12)
While I agree that this is more in tradition of Russian army I failed to notice any Russian accent in those beating and laughing. So don't bring your hatred to Russian Alia here. Russian Alia changed Israel in general, made it better and stronger. The negative effects of it simply fade as compared to its advantages, one needs to be a little shortsighted or short brained not to see that..
27. 15
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (03.30.12)
After watching the video I must say that the only violence seen is that of guys having a bit of hazing nonsense.Certainly no one was hurt in anyway.Go and watch a good rugby game in the army-then you will see a few bruises .I speak from experience.
28. Abuse
Randal ,   Little Rock, AR, USA   (03.30.12)
A dishonorable discharge and military prison time could fix this! Commanders should be first! Don't blame the privates.
29. I don't forget all the time,shi'ite's first imam maxim:
saied   (03.30.12)
Whoever that his friends leave him alone,the enemy will welcome him.
30. Seriously???
Ahron ,   Holon, Israel   (03.30.12)
Oh come on, this is just horse play. they're just patting him on the back with their hands. If you want some real rough housing, then try the US military. Pffft, typical yellow journalism.
Next talkbacks
Back to article