News
Israel asks US for $700 million in military aid
Ron Ben-Yishai
Published: 04.04.12, 19:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
70 Talkbacks for this article
31. #16 You are full of it, FYI, no one can stand you BS or you
get sara b of ynet   (04.04.12)
32. Sarah of #27
Cameron ,   USA   (04.04.12)
So, any future Israeli ability to protect their cities & populace in the emerging missile era will be dependent upon US generosity with financing and coin? SHOW A LITTLE GRATITUDE
33. Expedite the shipment of missles
jjonz ,   San Jose, US   (04.04.12)
Send them to Israel at mach 4.
34. money for magic wand yes but no for iron dome
zionist forever   (04.04.12)
I have no problem asking the Americans for more money to spend on Magic Wand because its based on a missile Rafael is co developing with Rayathon so there is something in it for the Americans and Magic Wand is a designed to shoot down cruise missiles etc whilst Iron Dome does not. We should not though be asking the Americans for more and more money to spend on Iron Dome whose uses are limited and there is no benefit to American taxpayers. If we want to do something about the rocket attacks the solution is not Iron Dome its Cast Lead 2 and allowing the IDF to run it their way, no unilateral withdraws so that Livni can get down to election campaigning.
35. Americans, stop whinging!
Harrybaby ,   Canada   (04.04.12)
That is the price for participating in Israeli technology. This is not a present or charity. The Chinese would be just as happy to participate in the technology. The fact of the matter is that all the US drone technology was born in israel and imparted to the US in the same way. The article is misleading.
36. got to be KIDDING ME...
chris wilson ,   fayetteville NC USA   (04.05.12)
I really grew up in a southern family in which we were told Jews were picked on and we should be kind to them.. But frankly I am so angry right now I am about enraged. ISRAEL CAN PAY FOR ITSELF. THIS IS DISGUSTING. My country is now trillions in debt for stupid wars and occupations across the mid east, and now we are supposed to foot the bill for ISRAELS national defense??? What insanity is this? I frankly wish Iran the best at this point, and I mean THAT.
37. Americans, stop complaining.
Devorah   (04.04.12)
The Obama family's vacations have cost the U.S. taxpayers tens of millions of dollars. Their 10-day trip in Dec. 2011 to Hawaii cost $4 million alone. And these are just vacations, not to mention Michelle Obama's extravagent shopping sprees on the U.S. dime. What has the U.S. taxpayer gotten in return? NOTHING but an economy that tanks more every day. Israel guarantees an 80% payback on U.S. investments (incorrectly called "aid") and has never defaulted. Moreover, the technology the U.S. receives from Israel has no price.
38. To # 1
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (04.04.12)
Our tax money goes to a bloated government who gives it away to countries that hate our guts and often don't need it. LIttle of it goes to our citizens. Most of it goes to create even more and bigger government. If some of it goes to Israel at least it's for a good cause.
39. Cameron # 32
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (04.05.12)
Gratitude is a 2 way street. Israel can get by without us if they have to. You need to read Sarah B's entire post. Not just the part in capitol letters. Hopefully you will be able to understand it if you do so.
40. # 31 HEAR HEAR ,WELL SAID
DA URBAN POET ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (04.05.12)
41. #19
nadya ,   California, USA   (04.05.12)
Sorry to inform you that I'm not an Arab. Secondly, I'm not a racist as you are and I don't think Arabs are the scum of the earth. And last, I stand by my statement in #4. You are blackmailing the U.S. by threatening to go to war with Iran. The whole world is against this crazy idea. If you insist on this, do it yourself, at your expense and don't drag America into it. You're deluding yourselves to think that America supports entering another war.
42. To: No. 32
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.05.12)
Do you really need me to recount how much the United States reaps from its investment in Israel? Facial recognition software presently in use in all major American airports; chemotherapy protocols; software technology unparalleled anywhere in the world; improvements to American military materiel .... the list is quite long. But you needn't worry about U.S. generosity with financing and coin -- Israel is a nuclear power.
43. Once again out comes the hand...
Paulb ,   Australia   (04.05.12)
But we get told Israel can defend itself without the help right?
44. #16 Sarah B ,You go girl!
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (04.05.12)
Give 'em hell. Your right, no one can stand these SOB's, even their fellow muslims, who, at the moment, are too busy murdering their own unprotected, protesting, poverty stricken, ignorant masses. Notice not one of these anti semite on this board never mentions that? Orchestrated as if by design ( by the same dummies who expect some nut case to believe their bullshit.
45. IF a word G-d knows well.
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (04.05.12)
He knows His own and loves them anyway. I suggest you do the same. He gives us enough time to see the errors of our ways.
46. Biggers? What's "Biggers?
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (04.05.12)
47. USA pays defense bill. Israelis have subsidized free HC
allen beechman ,   myrtle beach   (04.05.12)
Now, I see how every Israeli citizens gets free universal Health Care, while USA citizens go without HC in many cases. The USA is paying all the costs of the Israeli's for their Nations defense, they come asking for bonus billions (not really asking, TELLING their puppets what to do in our govt) and then with whatever portion of the US money that they do not spend for their own defense costs, they give their citizens free HC, while the americans who paid Israelis bills for them UNWILLINGLY, get the shaft.
48. ENOUGH THROWING GOOD MONEY AFTER BAD
US   (04.05.12)
Israel: grow up! NO MONEY FOR ISRAEL!
49. COMPLAINING? I'M VOTING RONEY
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (04.05.12)
AS WILL MOST AMERICANS. OBAMA SUX, AND BLOWS, HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE? HIS ASS SUX WIND, EXPELLED BY HIS MOUTH.
50. LOL good retort Eaglebeak
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (04.05.12)
He can read?
51. Beggers
Michael ,   USA   (04.05.12)
52. Israel isn't popular in America
Michael ,   USA   (04.05.12)
...but Jewish money is popular with our politicians.
53. God you're so annoying, Big Mouth. Tedious and repetitive
get Big Mouth ,   off Ynet   (04.05.12)
54. Don't start playing lackey, Eaglebeak
Cameron ,   USA   (04.05.12)
Indeed, gratitude is a 2-way street. The very thrust of my comment. Israel would be a true isolated, pariah state without the sheer weight of political, economic, and military coverage we extend on their behalf. The requesting of the 700 million for a missile defence system to protect their populace is but a particularly sharp reminder of that essential reliance. Israel needs the US like a drowning man needs a life preserver. Without the US, the world would collectively begin to squeeze Israel like a nut on every level, and this every Israeli is all too well aware of.
55. #2 Sarah B
(04.05.12)
What are you Sarah B? American or Israeli? If you are a Jewish Israeli, then shut the eff up. You have no right to speak on behalf of Americans...
56. Another waste of Americans tax money
Haim ,   TA   (04.05.12)
The fact of the matter is the Israeli govement has plenty of cash to build an infrastructure for the settlers in the occupied west bank and to pay the harideem to live a life of luxury while not working a day in their holy lives yet begs the US goverment to pay more and more US tax payers money while at the same time slaps the US in the face by delibratley going against US foreign policy and hindering every peace effort made by the US.
57. #55 And you have no right
Gary ,   US   (04.05.12)
To silence anyone on this site. Sarah has obviously gotten under your skin. Maybe you need a break from Ynet.
58. #7 - Per Janes - an Iron Dome battery
spyguy ,   Seattle USA   (04.05.12)
consist of .. - An EL/M-2084 multimission radar (MMR) from Elta Systems - A fire control centre (computers) from mPrest Systems, - Three launchers, each carrying 20 Tamir interceptor missiles from Rafael. Since typically two Tamir (~USD 35k each) are fired at each attacking missile, once the enemy fires 30 concurrent missiles that are judged to be "dangerous," the battery becomes useless. Note, the battery does not fire unless the incoming missile is determined to be "dangerous," so for all practical purposes the enemy would need to either fire 30 very accurate missiles at real targets or fire more than 30 missiles. Note that during a massive war, each battery would very likely be attacked with far more than 30 missiles. Per the IDF, there are many more than 50k missiles targeted on Israel at this moment (I do not believe the 200K+ figure the IDF said a few months ago)
59. "Sara B."... Oh lord, enough already. #1 right on!
A.O. ,   Lexington   (04.05.12)
60. #41 actually
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (04.05.12)
Actually, it is the Saudis who are putting the most pressure on Obama to attack Iran. Because Obama was so preoccupied with hating Jews, he supported Ahmadinejad against the Green Revolution, letting the Iranians get to the point of no return we are at. The reason he is supporting the Jihad / Brotherhood takeover of Syria is because that is the cheapest way to neutralize Syria, and the only one that won't cost him reelection. He is losing in Syria (making a very bloody war against Iran inevitable) because he wasted all his credits in the useless attack on Libya which served no American interest.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article