News
Israel presents new deterrence policy
Shahar Chai
Published: 05.04.12, 21:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
79 Talkbacks for this article
31. Brilliant
Steve from Raleigh   (04.06.12)
This is what strategic policy IS. thank you.
32. Finally!
Elliott ,   Sammamish, USA   (04.06.12)
Note the circumstances - Hamas is borderline broke, Egypt Spring is turned to Egypt Winter, Sunni/Shiite/Kurd/Alewite means unending sectarian war, Hezbollah is being run out of Lebanon and Iran is on the economic, political and social rocks. Only Israel has survived world-wide turmoil and promises to be thriving indefinitely. Now is the opportune time to eliminate these dying shadows.
33. To: No. 24
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.06.12)
No. But Israel does have the option of repossessing the Sinai, under the terms and conditions of the Treaty.
34. To: No. 22
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.06.12)
Are you absolutely, positively sure that it isn't a very strong message to Iran, warning them to keep their doggies on a leash? By the way -- Israel wouldn't have to "invade" the Strip. A couple of squadrons are more than capable of reducing Gaza to rubble. Hezbollah and Hamas are Iran's terrorist proxies. But they are essentially wusses -- Iran calls the shots. Gantz's message is really only a warning to Iran not to get foolish.
35. Bravo! The first sane response to Global Islamic Terror.
BUTSeriously ,   Australia   (04.06.12)
Israel must realize responding to Islamic terror has nothing to do with Israel, Jews or invented pretend Pals. George Bush's monumental error was going to the Afghan hills instead of the terror factories America calls her allies & national interests. America is paying a high price for this folly and Israel must not emulate. If Mecca or Tehran is paying for killing of Jews and robbing Hebron then no need to go to Afghanistan.
36. Perfect TIMING for Israel to act.
Armand ,   Los Angeles, USA   (04.06.12)
Knowing that what ever Israel wll do will be met by a ''BIASED'' world opinion. Knowing what the ''LEFTS'' and ''useful idiots'' will say on world forums etc... Knowing that Israel and us ''JEWS; ARE, HAVE BEEN AND WILL ALWAYS BE ALONE''. Now the Islamics and Islamists are in disaray (Libya, Tunisia, Egypt, Syria, etc..). Elections in France and USA where Islam is not a friendly word for the silent majorities of Europe and USA. Iran is playing for time and will use its proxies (Hamas, Hizbullah and all the crap..) Israel must pre-empt and can attack IRAN from ''ANY DIRECTION'', and at the same time can ELIMINATE ONCE FOR ALL the proxies. Israel must become the BIG ISRAEL and the hell with world opinion. Jordan = Palestine. Waiting is not an option as it will make the Islamics and Islamists more prepared and united in their fanatic plans and actions against us JEWS and Christians.
37. Attacks on Hamas, Hezb, Iran - does he mean verbal atttacks?
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (04.06.12)
A rocket attack on Eilat is an act of war, so where is the airstrike on the Hamas leadership? Or will this be more of Barak's face-saving bombing of "smuggling tunnels", which is having no results. Israel needs to bring back daily drone strikes on Gaza hitting anything Hamas, and generating a body count in the dozens which the US used to wildly criticize, but which the US now uses themselves every week on Taliban and Alqaidah, including inside Pakistan and Yemen, whether the regimes there like it or not, killing dozens, despite no rockets ever falling on the US . America would never tolerate rocket attacks on its cities anywhere.. And thats why it never happens. Does he think Obama is fool enough to criticise Israel for what he himself is doing? US can zap terrorists inside Pak, Israel can zap terrorists inside Sinai. If Obama doesn't want that, he can pay for a dozen Iron Dome batteries protecting Eilat, and deduct the cost from Egypt's military aid.
38. Most TBer's don't recognize there had to be balance
EZRA THE PROUD JEW ,   USA-ISRAEL   (04.06.12)
In our responses for a very specific set of circumstances. Israel is balancing two dozen eggs on the head of a pin concerning terrorist groups, anti-Israel NGO's, Leftists, the frayed Jewish Diaspora, the White House, EU, UN and the pals on both (all sides) of the fence. In fact, the Israeli gov't has been brilliant with their responses so far but even they knew it could not last forever. The fuel for anti-Israeli fodder will be crushed once Israel releases a decade long list of terrorist activities which its been gathering if it should come to that: the EU and UN will be sorely humiliated by such revelations which are real and pressing. Israel is not foolish enough (regardless of the Livni's and Mofaz's) Not to have a long-term goal of gathering landslide evidence against all anti-Israel parties, including the Pals, which it will be able to unleash in a pre-cursor to a massive ground assault on Gaza, Hezbollah and even within Judea and Samaria. Its not so simple to please everyone, but just take a look at the ABSURD accusations being tossed at Israel and you'll see that the anti-Israeli/Ant-Semite crowd have been grasping at straws in another reality: they have NOTHING...NOTHING on Israel. It doesn't matter that the squeaky wheels keep screeching: Israel has crushed them with truth so now all they have are inflated exaggerations and lies to go on. It was and is a brilliant strategy and HAS worked incredibly well considering the outlandish propaganda being leveled at Israel and the Jews by so many haters. In the end, Israel will always prevail: it is our survival, not just an ideology. Survival and wisdom always trump emotions and fanatic ideologies. Wait and see; Israel has a long term goal in mind and it will be realized since it is obvious the arabs should and can never be trusted, period. Chag Sameach!
39. finally. the end of rope-a-dope, and untying the arms
JEWISH DOCTOR ,   AMERICA THE BEAUTIUL   (04.06.12)
NO MORE HALF WAY MEASURES, NO MORE ONE HAND TIED BEHIND THE BACK, NO MORE TIT FOR TAT, NO MORE POLITICALLY CORRECT NO MORE PROXIES FOR IRAN... Gantz will HIT THEM HARDER HIT THEM FASTER and FOR ONCE AND FOR ALL, he'll knockout the enemies that for too long has rained death and destruction on innocent JEWISH PEOPLE while the Jewish Leaders were just SITTING ON THEIR HANDS, TRYING TO BE "STYLISH" (AND POLITICALLY CORRECT!!) NOT only "NEVER AGAIN", but now "not anymore!" May the Universe bless and guide Gantz and the mighty IDF.
40. WE SHALL SEE who has the last laugh suckers!
JEWJITSU ,   NYC, USA   (04.06.12)
May the angel of death PASSOVER the Jewish people and bring hell down upon the enemies of the JEWISH PEOPLE. hahaha
41. as long as Barak is DM,it's all empty rhetoric
chaim.s 54st ,   brooklyn ny   (04.06.12)
42. Way to go.
Kurt USA ,   Allegan, MI   (04.06.12)
Thank you IDF Chief of Staff Benny Gantz. May the G-d of Abraham, Jssac, and Jacob give you wisdom, guide your action and bless you in everything you do. My and my family's prayers are with you, the Jewish people, the brave men and women of the IDF and the State of Isreal in your continual war against those who would do you and every other freedom loving person in the world harm. Again, thank you. Your words, bravery, and actions will save a lot of innocent live and will protect the defenseless, both in Isreal and around the world.
43. Israel Presents New Deterrence Policy
ltrail ,   United States   (04.06.12)
IDF Chief Gantz's new policy is excellent. May all Jews worldwide and especially in Israel have a blessed Passover. Shalom
44. Why Lebanon?
Classic ,   Real World   (04.06.12)
What's the point of striking Hezbollah when they're just going to re-arm after the conflict? If Hezbollah attacks, the IDF should completely eliminate the Syrian military before venturing into Lebanon. Cut off the supplier first and then watch how Nasrallah shuts up like a good little kid... Very simple...
45. The slaughter in Argentina,gave them a free pass. The
PETER SM ,   AUSTRALIA   (04.06.12)
Arab first prime Minister of Argentina Menem made sure of that.
46. #22 "life and death" who cares what others think
Dov ,   USA   (04.06.12)
47. Bibi is Not Begin, Shamir or Gurion
Noah Lev ,   LosangelesUSA   (04.06.12)
Assuming Israel hits Iran, Hez/Hamas, then what? Its easy to get into a major war, but what is its exist strategy?. Hez/Hamas will open its poker hand..and start launching missiles. Iran may send a few Shihabs, with b/c warheads. Perhaps fire a few shells into Israel from the sea. It has cruise type missiles and can bombard the coast. Will it send troops/tanks to the border, through Syria. Lebanon, Jordan. Is Israel planning a short/long war? The Arabs will cry collateral damage and excessive to every world group. Turkey wll threatend. Egypt may send soldiers to the Sinai border. Israel is playing chess with its enemies...and this is but the latest meaningless threat. Bibi is NOT Begin, or Shamir, or Golda or Ben Gurion. He is Bibi, all mouth and no bark. The way you stop terrorism is to hit the terrorists hard..hurt them. Make them cower and beg to surrender. Israel is not at that stage. Sorry guys.
48. #12 do you realize what you said?
sk ,   USA   (04.06.12)
If Mecca and Medina is destroyed, do you know what that means? It means that the Islamic version of "allah" does not exist —why would any real allah allow their "holiest" places to be destroyed by nukes? It means that they will have nowhere to face and bow down to pray to. It means eventually the end of Islam. Unlike Judaism and Christianity who don't need "idols" to worship, taking out those two Islamic city "idols" will mean the end of Islam.
49. #12 - the worst idea I have read on this site.
Henry from New York ,   USA   (04.06.12)
Attacking any Muslim holy city would result in the entire Islamic world declaring war on Israel. That includes Pakistan. I prefer having Israel around rather than having all of its citizens die in a massive war.
50. Since he'll do nothing I'd prefer he'd say nothing!
tom ,   tel aviv   (04.06.12)
51. NOTHING NEW at all
BA ,   Sweden   (04.06.12)
Words. Just words, as usual. With such as wicked Minister of Defence like the traitor Israel has been blessed with there will be no either Strategical or tactical changes against the enemies.
52. IDF...GO FOR IT!!!
KB ,   US   (04.06.12)
You have my support!!!
53. Gants reponse statement
Ikese ,   Abuja Nigeria   (04.06.12)
Now the world should know since the damn UN had never had Israel's interest in their mind.those who thinks the IDF cheif maybe a joke now better tame their mad dogs cause all F15 are warming up.
54. This is the best policy!
Reuven   (04.06.12)
55. to Sarah no. 23
E. G. Marsch ,   Nahariya, Israel   (04.06.12)
What you say is legally correct; however, the chances, for the time being, that Israel will act in Sinai are nil, for fear--for better or worse--of cutting the slender threads by which the peace treaty still hangs. Hence Gantz's warning about hitting Hamas elsewhere; he knows we're not going to act in Sinai.
56. Empty Jewish bravado as usual...
(04.06.12)
57. Wonderful new policy
Devorah   (04.06.12)
I'll believe it when I see it.
58. #51: Its only words...and words are all
Israeli 2   (04.06.12)
Israel needs to melt their hearts away. Iran will have no chance against Israel, let alone Egypt. Russians and Chinese to the rescue? I doubt it. They too will loose against Israel. The Russians know it...they already did.
59. Excellent solution!
TaylorT ,   Earth   (04.06.12)
Because after you attack these various groups, they're just going to sit there and take it. And the world, especially the UNSC (with the power to sanction Israel and indict Israeli leaders) will not do a thing. Go down this route and I give Israel 10 years. Which may, admittedly, be a few more years than if Israel doesn't go down this route. Bottom line is the occupation is going to cost you your nation. But you're used to not having a state, so it shouldn't be that big a deal when you're all fleeing by plane/boat/whatever in a decade or so. Listening to their far right ruined Germany, you would think others would have learned from that.
60. To: No. 59
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.06.12)
See, your problem is that you have absolutely no conception of what the words "Never Again" mean to the Jewish people and the State of Israel. Basically, it means "Never Again." We will NEVER AGAIN be herded into our synagogues which were then set alight. We will NEVER AGAIN be helpless in the face of violent pogroms. We will NEVER AGAIN file passively into gas chambers or their twenty-first century equivalent. We will NEVER AGAIN not have our own State. And should something terrible come to pass and we feel we have no recourse, we are going to take as much of the world as we can with us, and render the rest of it uninhabitable for the next one hundred thousand years. And we have the nuclear capability to do it, too. Your mistake would be in questioning our resolve. NEVER AGAIN. NEVER AGAIN. Two simple words to you, perhaps, but to us -- everything. We're not fleeing ANYWHERE. You, on the other hand -- well, that would depend on your country's attitude towards Israel, now wouldn't it? Tiny little Israel has an extremely long reach. You would do well to keep that in mind.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article