News
Minister Yishai declares Grass persona non grata
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 08.04.12, 12:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
83 Talkbacks for this article
61. Finally, a smart German who has a backbone
Leon ,   Algonquin Land   (04.08.12)
Despite all the smears, Grass is not backing down from his well thought out and honest statements. Look at how many times Israel has threaten to bomb Iran, Look at how many wars Israel has started. How many countries has Iran invaded in the past 200 years? Zero How many nuclear weapons does Iran have? Zero How many does Israel have? 200+ Israel is far more a threat to world peace than Iran and I commend Grass for stating the truth.
62. #26 Context, Konrad, context.....
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (04.08.12)
You're disregarding the context of ''who wrote'' and ''what was written'' to take a cheap swipe at Sarah B. .......or you're a complete moron.. ....take your pick..... M.
63. 39 David
Ahmet ,   Turkey   (04.08.12)
Look at yourself, you are full of hatred. You are ready to kill anyone who criticizes you. You became just like Iran. You are destined to lose your land and honor. We'll visit Jerusalem after the war that you will lose.
64. Great news
vicky ,   USA   (04.08.12)
I hope reading your comments that every country on Earth will behave like Israel and will be constantly pretending to be a victim with full arsenal of nukes, which are never inspected by anyone. Sure lets start another war since war is big business and that is all we care nowadays.
65. Like you, I'm not singling out the German
(04.08.12)
people, I'm singling out you, Guenter GraSS. You are a disgrace, a Nazi scum who would only be happy to kill us again whilst promoting the real criminals, those who execute their own in public places in daylight, those who help murder thousands in Syria, those who sustain terror and terrorist countries even in your own Faterland. These are the true politicians you support - the Iranian ones ! No wonder why such vile creature like you associates with the Iranian Islamofascism. Birds of a feather flock together.
66. #36 IMBECILE ,NOT EMABCIL
DA URBAN POET ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (04.08.12)
But we get the point of what you are trying to say ,don't worry.My humble suggestion is that all of us ,including you and I and Sarah B too ,should have a day of being polite and civil to each other .We can differ in our opinions of course but we should be polite .What do you say ? do you agree ?
67. 59 - shaking the hands of 14-18 year ,...
split ,   US   (04.08.12)
So what , that doesn't make them grown ups or stop being kids ,... There's a reason why you can vote, being drafted or buy a buzz at 18 ,... Intentionally by omission of facts you're distorting my post - He was a kid, fact, he was drafted, fact, the punishment for refusal was death,...
68. 62 - He have a beef with moderator, moron ,...
split ,   US   (04.08.12)
It doesn't matter who wrote that post , moron ,...
69. It does not matter
mara ,   Vienna   (04.08.12)
how many nukes Israel has or not. The world trusts her on that, as you can see, while the wolrd does not trust the religious nuts of Iran as you can also see. Grasser is an old N azi as everyone in Europe knows and his aim is not to give good advise but to incite hate as the N azis always have done!
70. #67. Don't distort his record!
Tom ,   USA   (04.08.12)
From Wiki: "In November 1944, shortly after his seventeenth birthday, he volunteered for submarine service with the Kriegsmarine,.However, he was not accepted by the Navy and instead was drafted into the 10th SS Panzer Division Frundsberg. The word "volunteered" explains it all and you cannot put a spin on it, bro. He was and remains a Nazi you adore. His only obsession, just like yours is the Jewish nation.
71. Don't be silly!
Mara ,   Vienna   (04.08.12)
Nobody was "drafted" in the Waffen SS, it was voluntarily at all! You weree drafted into the army to fight, but the Waffen SS did not fight, but going with the troops they killed civilians, Jews, slawish people, dissidents, defectors, to put it simple they were murderers!
72. Grass is fine if you smoke it
A ,   Belgium   (04.08.12)
but reading it can destroy your brain.
73. Leon its your brothers that threaten to remive Israel
PETER SM ,   Australia   (04.08.12)
Israel has never threatened to bomb anything other than nuclear facilities in Iran unlike your brothers threats Iran has attacked the British navy on the high seas unprovoked and foreign embassies taking hostages If your brothers send terrorists bomb Israel threaten to wipe it out expect consequences Iran not Israel initiated this confrontation
74. Grass and grass
opinion   (04.08.12)
The poor guy Grass smoked a little grass and said something he didn't even understand himself due to lack of clarity of thought and forced (by may be lack of real talent) complexity of poetic form. Send him more grass: may be he'll calm down. I mean had I said this nobody would even pay attention! The guy became persona non Grata: too much honor! I also want to become "persona non Grata" what do I have t say? )))) Where can I get such good grass?
75. #66 You NICE JEW..Majotity of JEWS..BUT..SARAH..
HAMID ,   Abu Dhabi - UA E   (04.09.12)
A few BAD APPLES...and then what do we have...A WHOLE LOT of them... This Sarah BS is Not even living in the region..She is TOO SCARED... and SHE wants very MUCH to see another Holocaust...You think this coming WAR will be a CAKE walk.. AND YOU KNOW where Sarah will BARKING form her US hideaway...
76. The truth about "Leon" from Canada
Josh Felter   (04.09.12)
I had a correspondence with "Leon" because he gave his mail address before on these threads - only he "forgot" ro reply. Still, it was enough to establish that Leon is an Irish Canadian (or an immigrant from Ireland, who knows?) antisemite, who frequently spews venom here. He is totally discredited by his pathetic antics and nonsense on Israel.
77. Say Spilt, I gots a kweshin fer ya
A ,   somweh in dem heels   (04.09.12)
wat eksakly you en yo kinfolk Benassi an Greyzcak do to that good ol boy when y'all tol' him "now drop them britches an squeel lahk a peeg?" Ah think lots a folk be raht curios ta no.
78. 70 - volunteered for submarine service ,...
split ,   US   (04.08.12)
That's right, pinhead, for submarine service not for SS ,...
79. 59
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (04.09.12)
You are so right.
80. Not a joking matter
Konrad ,   Warsaw, Poland   (04.09.12)
Publication of a call to kill someone is not a joking matter. I would not be surprised, not in the least, if Sarah B. and the Ynetnews found themselves in legal trouble. The fact that the call to kill was made with reference to Mr. Grass does not in itself constitute any extenuating circumstance. Pushing back the limits of what is legally admissible is always risky - and it could become costly.
81. Split not true
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (04.10.12)
Grass was not drafted he volunteered, that makes him a killer as that's what they did. That he remains an anti semite shows that he's never changed his position. Death for him can't come too soon. I'm glad this old nazi will die soon and his disgrace with him.
82. # 57 Split Grass a minor nazi
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (04.10.12)
now, a minor poet.
83. # 63 Turkeys going broke
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (04.10.12)
and her muslim allies are murdering muslims faster than Erdogen can criticize Israel. Oh, the joys of muslim massacres, now Turkey might have to go to war with Syria, wouldn't that be swell?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article