News  Mideast News
Meridor: Iran never called to wipe out Israel
Dudi Cohen
Published: 17.04.12, 00:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
31. Who cares? Iran's nuclear installations will still be hit .
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (04.17.12)
32. why this is a substantial difference
traintalk ,   upcountry Israel   (04.17.12)
I have been hoping for some time that a figure of Meridor's calibre would admit that "wipe" was never used in original Farsi. This was always a disingenuous assertion insofar as direct translation is concerned. We don't like others to make creative translations about what our leaders say according to their agenda either. This is about having enough respect for your enemy to attempt to get the literal literal. Actually, quite a bit to ask for. I trust our PM is aware and supportive and has known this for years regardless of his public comments to the contrary. Sometimes the flat truth is just correct both internally and externally. I hope we will see more of this nature in the future.
33. Miraculous Israel will remain....MIRACULOUS
EZRA THE PROUD JEW ,   USA-ISRAEL   (04.17.12)
It doesn't matter who says what: what matters is unity in Israel which can only be achieved through OUR ways, OUR ETHOS, OUR AHAVAT YISRAEL. It cannot and will not be done by following the ways of the nations who fail left and right; who disintegrate, integrate, homogenize and disappear as did and do all of our enemies. As the US became more anti-Semitic, their economy crashed: the more they blamed the Jews for it...the longer it lasted. And when people STAYED anti-Semitic, Wall street NON-JEWISH executives went back to their ugly ways which WILL wind up causing yet another crash. It will be a decade longer for the US to 'recover' but when they come out the other side, the world will not judge markets on the dollar. The world will have a far more competitive market vying between 3-4 major currencies: a Joint Chinese-Russian-Indian one: The Euro (which will be the weakest) the Dollar and an open market that fluctuates between various currencies including South America. The world is about to change and as usual, when it blames the Jews everything falls apart. Can't be proven but sure is a MIGHTY (ancient) coincidence that most Jews are very familiar with. Hence: we know when to bow out from a country or a market and move on. Only those Jews who hang back with mitzriyim (galut) suffer. Chai Yisrael!!!!
34. Is this how we climb down the tree? Israeli minister to Aqua
tom ,   tel aviv   (04.17.12)
dinejad's defence? Next Yossi Beilin will be explaining to the world, that there is no such individual as Ahmadinejunk- only someone impersonating him.....
35. Thank you 19, he said it indeed.
Israeli ,   Haifa   (04.17.12)
Why is Meridor JUST NOW saying all this? If we cannot pre-emptively defend ourselves, we may as well all just, as a nation, lie down and let radical Islam "remove" us.
36. Cancer?
Joseph ,   London UK   (04.17.12)
So Israel is a cancer that must be removed, that's not a threat? When Ahmedinejad said whatever he said, Honest Repoprting asked his office if it was a reasonable translation to say, 'Israel should be wiped off the map' and his own office said it was reasonable.
37. Either Meridor is SPINELESS
(04.17.12)
or he has his root from IRAN pls check and confirm.
38. Better for us if meridor vanishes from
jason white ,   afula, israel   (04.17.12)
politics. Is he making excuses for our enemy? Is there anyone in the knesset who is sane? In the government? A sane member of the knesset is as rare as hens teeth. Insane, no street smarts, dishonest, disloyal and the list goes on to describe the m.k.s. Israel was cursed with politicians like these.
39. #2 the difference between the words "Israel" and "regime"
Shlomo ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (04.17.12)
Is the difference. Between saying "Iran will be destroyed" and "the Ayatollah's and Ahmadinijad's regime will be destroyed." Big difference.
40. The Ape man has UNEXPECTED friends !
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (04.17.12)
MOST DISGUSTING !!!!!!!!!
41. The sanctions have achieved NOTHING !
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (04.17.12)
They are a trick of Hussein O., to protect his mullah friends !!!!!
42. #2, #9
(04.17.12)
People like Meridor also believed that the trains would bring them to a better place and that they were going into real shower stalls.
43. Meridor is such a wimp, hes a likudnik like the popes Hindu
Hippocrates ,   Earth   (04.17.12)
44. Wake up people! Terminology hides genocidal intent.
Jane ,   United Kingdom   (04.17.12)
To the statements of Ahmadinejad, his audience have responded with cries of "Death to Israel, death to the Jews". They know what he meant and he acknowledged their response. In recent weeks the Iranian supreme religious leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, publicly laid out what he called the 'legal and religious justification to kill all Jews and annihilate Israel'. He highlighted how it would only take nine minutes to destroy Israel, and even specified the civilian and military targets. The Ayatollah clarifying that Tel Aviv, Jerusalem and Haifa contain more than 60 per cent of the Jewish population, which could be hit by Shahab 3 ballistic missiles to easily kill everyone. A simple internet search under 'Kill all Jews and annihilate Israel' will suffice. If Ynet will allow this post to appear that is. The apologists and appeasers forget that a whole new terminology was created during the so-called 'final solution'. Selections, resettlement and other obscene terms were used to camouflage a genocidal agenda. Wake up people!!!
45. telling the truth is antisemitism?
Bill ,   New York USA   (04.17.12)
It's funny reading these comments and seeing Mr. Meridor being called "spineless" and a "wimp" for finally telling the truth. Pretty gutsy on his part, I think. Since truth telling is such an unusual behavior for this crowd.
46. My Sincere Appologies To All Talkbackers
(04.17.12)
For not Knowing All the Facts. But I don't think little bearded monkey has good intentions for the Ancient Home Land of the Hebrew People. ברוך הא שם
47. Stupid Conservative Extremist
Sostuoid ,   Dallas USA   (04.18.12)
That is a seriously stupid comment Thankfully you have no importance in foreign policy on either side Let the emotions go and educate yourself or live your life unexamined - whatever works for you it doesn't matter in the scheme of things
48. #28
jjv ,   phila pa usa   (04.18.12)
What planet are you from? These guys want to nuke Israel!! What a blind bat
49. LOL BREAKING NEWS ????
cyrus ,   note , corsi   (04.21.12)
LOL everybody knew that and since many years the only liars who say that are american zionists or not , crazy born again , dishonest israelian zionists , so called iranians who live in USA et don t like democracy in Iran and want a war against REAL iranian people brainwashed people u live in developed countries and u re not able to think and find the truth by yourselves
50. Great!
EADG ,   LA, USA   (04.23.12)
Phew - what a relief! Now we can all rest easy. Wake up and smell Iran. Clue: It ain't coffee.
51. Who is Meridor working for?
Chaim ,   Israel   (04.23.12)
It is mind boggling that Likud accepts the likes of Meridor as a member. Let alone as a high official. Meridor's ridiculous comments weaken Israel's position and give aid to those who don't want to see Israel save herself by destroying Iran's nukes. Notablly Obama. Who is Meridor working for?
52. Ahmadenijad & "Wiped ff the Map" quote
Abdullahi ,   Kano, Nigeria   (06.18.12)
Mark fro Bondi Sydney Aistralia you seem to have put great faith in one quote from an unamed Iranian source while dozens of others, most literate in Farsi, have stated categorically that Ahmadenijad never said anything about wiping Israel off the map. Maybe it suits your political agenda or supports your unfounded bias or you wish he had said so, but he didn't.
53. wiped off the map
Abdullahi ,   Kano, Nigeria   (06.18.12)
Thanks for your advice Jane. I googled the phrase as you requested and came up with this a little further down the list than those propagated by those who think like you. Unfortunately, for you and them, this little article puts things into their proper perspective, which, as it turns out, doesn't support your thesis at all. http://revoltoftheplebs.wordpress.com/2012/02/08/did-the-ayatollah-really-say-kill-all-jews-annihilate-israel/
54. wiped off the map
Abdullahi ,   Kano, Nigeria   (06.18.12)
To the person who facetiously offered his apologies in advance of his ludicrous statement and insult to the president of Iran, I wish you would learn to contribute ata ahigher level than that you demonstrated with your insulting description of President Ahmadenijad.
55. Re: 44
Eurodude ,   Dublin, Ireland   (05.05.13)
Show me a link to where he said that? It would be a strange thing to say, given that there are Jews in the Iranian parliament. Israelis are brainwashed i think.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article