News
Ya'alon: Evacuating Ulpana will lead to government's collapse
Ilana Curiel
Published: 21.04.12, 14:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. Well, you know what?
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.21.12)
If Ulpana is evacuated -- a move which I believe would be a critical mistake, except to the extent that it will bring down the government and rid us, finally, of Ehud Barak -- dynamite those beautiful homes. Nothing left standing for ersatz "Palestinian" squatters. Not a damned thing.
2. Who's the boss?
Robbie Dolev ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (04.21.12)
My understanding of how Goverment works is that there is a PRIME Minister and then below him just regular ministers. Barak is just a regular (albeit irregular) minister. If Bibi can't or won't control Barak, then maybe it's time that we the people had a say in who should be running the show? Early elections might not be a bad thing - it will sift out the chaff from the usefull stuff, and maybe finally we will get a (smaller) Government that does not have to rely on a large coalition (with all associated arm bending) to run the show properly - and hopefully Barak will be sent packing, as he so richly deserves.
3. What politician isn't driven by political considerations?
Mark ,   Elrom, Israel   (04.21.12)
4. The two Jerusalem lap dogs of imperial America
A Very Heavy Stone ,   Florida   (04.21.12)
How sad that Israel's 'just following orders' leaders Ehud and Benji the toy poodle serve a failed foreign agenda against Israel. The enemies of Israel get Barak and Netanyahu to do their dirty work for them. The have the green light to go after fellow Jews and nothing else. That is why Hezbollah and Hamas are stronger than ever. This is why Ehud is back in Washington on his knees getting his orders from the destroyer of Israel by the fake peace scam.
5. #4 Stone, is that all Ehud was on his knees for in D.C.??
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (04.21.12)
6. Netanyahu only has courage to fight Jews
Rachel ,   US   (04.21.12)
Yaalon is making excuses for Netanyahu by blaming Barak. Netanyahu is responsible, no one else.
7. # Irrelevant
Moshe Mountbaun ,   Tel Aviv   (04.21.12)
What you say or think is irrelevant here. We, decent israelis, normal taxpayers, are fed up of considerations like yours. This occupation has gone too far. We just want to live correctly, be respected hutz la haretz, have a border and dignity. Thanks God we have a Supreme Court and an Army that works outside the political realm. Shut up, Sarah, move, go back to the US, leave us alone. Your views are bizarre. Just that.
8. #1 Sarah
A Very Heavy Stone ,   Florida   (04.21.12)
How insane the people of Israel have become to even think of destroying their nice homes to please their pimp gods of no peace on the Potomac and to reward the evil jihadists. The enemies of Israel laugh at the fools who self destruct themselves and the nation for only lies in return.
9. #1 Stupid comment
Ricardo Macher ,   Karnei Shomron IL   (04.21.12)
Shtuyot. And who do you think will come as PM? Benny Begin? Yalon? Lieberman? No, naif woman, this Government is the best in terms of right we can get. Barak follows orders from the USA. They tell us not to settle in E-1. We obey. They tell us to dismantle outposts in private Palestinians lands, we obey. They tell us to stop financing settlements. We obey. When it comest to the WB settlement, we are just the 51 state. No wonder that after 42 years there is only 500 thousand Jews in Samaria. How stupid, ignorant and naif you are Sarah.
10. Which Muslim nation is Barak the Defense Minister for?
Linda Rivera ,   New York, USA   (04.21.12)
Barak could not possibly be the DEFENSE Minister for Israel. Which Muslim nation is Barak the Defense Minister for?
11. # 9
Birdi ,   Israel   (04.21.12)
As of December 2010, 327,750 Israelis live in the 121 officially-recognised settlements in the West Bank. 192,000 Israelis live in settlements in East Jerusalem & over 20,000 Israelis live in settlements in the Golan Heights. Try to get your facts straight before you post here.
12. that Barak clown kicking up ...
Moragh   (04.21.12)
his jigs again. Who is that clown ehud working for... it's certainly not Israel. And what has weakened Bibi so much that he now looks like a fool? I think it's time those two betrayers were given their one-way ticket out of Israel. Barak looks like a little piglet and Bibi like a high-school cowboy!
13. Convincing, if you're Rip Van Winkle
r cummings ,   london UK   (04.21.12)
If you had just awoken from a long sleep, you might nod along at some of the wild claims here about Jewish rights to settle in Palestine. For the rest of the planet, it is a simpler matter. Israel is a temporary military occupier there. Occupiers are, since 1947, prohibited from seizing occupied land or settling their own people on it, this being the world's harsh legal reaction to the German's colonial adventures of WW2. All 121 Jewish settlements in the occupied territory are accordingly illegal and will require to be vacated. It doesn't really matter one shekel what Ya'alon or other Jewish extremists think or want, when the international criminal court gets its hands on the issue, which it inevitably will, Ya'alon and chums will be lucky if they're not serving out their remaining time on this planet behind bars at the Hague.
14. To: No. 9
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.21.12)
Oh, I am the furthest thing from naiive (note proper spelling) that you can imagine. I think it is time that Israel told the United States to take a hike. They can stop their funding, which carries too much of a burden in terms of stringent conditions. I note for the record that no other country which receives U.S. aid, including in amounts far greater than Israel and with absolutely no return benefit to the United States, which is decidedly not the case with respect to Israel, is forced to adhere to any conditions. In return, we can withhold all that we so generously share with the United States, including our advancements in technology and medicine. Lieberman will be the next PM, I hope. Finally, someone who is not a self-hating Jew, and will tell the United States to stick it when the U.S. tries to tell us where we can or cannot live in OUR land. Oh -- by the way -- Judea and Samaria are beautiful. All we have to do is repatriate the Jordanian trash to Jordan, and just WATCH how many people will flock there to live.
15. #13 r cummings, wake up and go back to sleep, silly man.
(04.21.12)
16. To: No. 13
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.21.12)
Using your logic, why is the U.K. still illegally occupying six northern counties in Ireland? Israel acquired non-sovereign Judea and Samaria in the course of fighting a DEFENSIVE war against Jordan. Judea and Samaria are Israel's to settle, retain and annex. Annexation is the inevitable solution, and when that happens all of the illegal Arab squatters in Judea and Samaria will be repatriated to Jordan, country of their citizenship. Honey bunny, here's a newsflash: No Israeli will serve time behind bars. The ersatz "Palestinians" don't have much currency with The Hague, having been rebuffed dozens of times. Neither does Jordan, whose attempts to revoke the citizenship of all those West Bank Arabs have met with failure each time. By the way -- after the UK quits Northern Ireland, you might want to visit the issue of your illegal occupation of Wales and Cornwall. Up until the current Iranian crisis with Iran, the worst criminals in history -- even worse than the Nazi Germans -- were the British. Look at what you did in so much of Africa. Look at what you did on the Indian subcontinent. Look at what you did in Malaysia and Singapore. Most especially, look at what yu did in Australia. Who the hell are you to be lecturing Israel? Clean up your own house, first, before worrying about ours.
17. Simple solution - demolish
Rain   (04.21.12)
What's the issue? You build illegally on land owned by someone else, you have to demolish the building. Illegal buildings with no permits are demolished all over Israel and the world. Why should this one be any different?
18. Too funny
Rain   (04.21.12)
Whether I agree or not. Calling the holocaust "German's colonial adventures" definitely hits a low note
19. I ask again - was this land sold to Jews or not?
rebecca ,   Modiin   (04.21.12)
Are the Arabs again trying to sell their land and keep it?
20. EVACUTE THEM!
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (04.21.12)
21. Evacuate barak to gaza where he belongs.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (04.22.12)
22. To: Rebecca at No. 19
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.22.12)
The land was either sold or did not belong to anyone to begin with, and therefore available for construction! But you make a very telling point -- Arabs have a long and sordid history of selling land and trying to keep it -- and even of selling land which did not belong to them in the first place! I think all those passionate "defenders" of ersatz "Palestinian" causes should all spend one year in Israel. See what they are really like.
23. Stop legalizing settlements!!!!
Kevin ,   USA   (04.22.12)
When will it stop......when it does, you will be I better shape to talk peace.....it's not that complicated
24. Ya'alon you failed
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (04.22.12)
Ya'alon had his chance: he could have run against Barak's boy in the Likud elections. Unlike Feiglin, Ya'alon would have won or threatened Netanyahu enough that he would be forced to dump Barak.
25. SARAH @ 16 B RA V O ! ! !
Jennie ,   Israel/US   (04.22.12)
AND THANK YOU ! JUST LOVED READING, HOW ELEGANTLY AND AT EASE, YOU HAVE "KNOCKED" OUT THIS LITTLE PAMPEOUS BRITT.... YOU MADE MY DAY...
26. # 7 Irrelevant Moshe
Bad Ased Jew ,   United States   (04.23.12)
If you want to live in Israel SUPPORT THE SETTLERS!!! They are heroes to all Americans. the arabs have left a trail filled with the blood of their own people. Leave Sarah B alone she speaks more eloquently than most on this site, including you. ( and I suspect you are not a Jew )
27. Give it a rest
Bad Ased Jew ,   United States   (04.23.12)
you're somewhat confused, aren't you? You mention palestine and Israel not seeming to know the difference. perhaps I can help you, There is no palestine but, there is ISRAEL. And she will continue to BUILD BABY BUILD!!!!!!
Back to article