News
Ex-Shin Bet chief slams Bibi, Barak
Moran Azulay
Published: 27.04.12, 23:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
58 Talkbacks for this article
31. He takes his words right out of my mouth
StevieT ,   USA   (04.28.12)
thank you Mr. Diskin.
32. looks like uncle fester is getting too much sun
rick ,   walnut creek   (04.28.12)
so, if Israel hits iran (and there are, to be sure, serious questions about the advisability of this and Israel's abilities), the iranians will speed up their program. and if Israel does nothing, what? does this fool think the iranians will terminate the program? and, uncle fester wants Israel to make more concessions to abbas. why? what can abbas give Israel? and, if he can actually give Israel anything, how long will that last? how long before some rabid demagogue declares that the concessions are null and void. how long will abbas last? not long, by any calculation.
33. I agree with this
Rachel ,   US   (04.28.12)
34. Israel needs Yaalon to handle Iran
Rachel ,   US   (04.28.12)
35. how much USA did pay you Diskin and Dagan to betray Israel
(04.28.12)
36. DISKIN
DA RAP ARTIST ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (04.28.12)
Yo ,DIskin is riskin his reputation for mediation ,he is dissin his boss which is his loss .Diskin is shit-stirring and trying to badmouth " Right-wing " israelis ,which is LASHON HARA ,or bad talkin .Perhaps his aim is to weaken and disarm jews to make them more vulnerable.Whose side is Mr .Diskin on ?
37. YET ANOTHER CRITIC
MR CYNIC ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (04.28.12)
Yet another critic and Tzipi Livni wannabe crawls out of the woodwork .It is facile to criticise but what does Mr. Diskin suggest ? Meanwhile ,under messrs Netanyahu and Barak ,Israel is enjoying tranquillity and economic prosperity.
38. Yes! Yes! He is right!
Israeli 2   (04.28.12)
The Shin Bet leftist opportunist who WAS without a shadow of a doubt boughthook line and sinker by Obama and his conmen with *money* and who made the sharpest U-turn after he consulted - totally unethically, if not illegally, with former (giving his seat up for Gal-On a short while ago) Meretz MK Oron on domestic terrorism suspects concerning criminal law in this country has now opened his worthless mouth! Hide away in shame you clown!
39. Mar Diskin, don't let BITACHON serve you, SERVE BITACHON!
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (04.28.12)
40. diskin on leadership
tomer ,   jerusalem   (04.28.12)
chapeau diskin, at least one former leader who has the balls to say clearly and loudly what clear minded israelis think already a long time.
41. Diskin forgets
Michael ,   Haifa   (04.28.12)
Diskin forgets that he himself played no small role in serving mad messianic masters in their disastrous policies. We all have short memories. Even our great "peace-seeker", Shimon Peres, allowed the mad messianic Levinger to remain in Sebastiya, thus becoming the father of the lunatic settlement Movement. But we forget when it is convenient to do so.
42. General Joshua and Judge Gideon said HaShem is who they
Rivkah   (04.28.12)
serve and who should be served and worshipped to guide and protect the country. If more people served and worshipped HaShem in Israel and America, He can guide the minds of whoever are the elected or appointed leaders of the nations. That is where trust should be, in Hashem. Any human leader will disappoint on some things, but from my perspective I feel more comfortable with a Prime Minister like Benyamin Netanyahu than one like Ehud Barak or Ehud Olmert.
43. #34 ..I AGREE
joe moor ,   south africa   (04.28.12)
israel needs a brain like bogey yaalon to sort out the problems ..a man with experience ,bravery and honesty..a man with no skeletons in his cupboard
44. Bibi, Barak and Ya’alon know what they are doing
Mladen Andrijasevic ,   Beer Sheva, Israel   (04.28.12)
So Diskin believes that “If Israel acts against the Iranian nuclear bomb, the attack will encourage the Iranians to produce a bomb even faster” . So what does Diskin suggest? This part is not clear. That Israel wait until it gets incinerated? The notion that Iran needs a sense of legitimacy to attack Israel is nonsense. I think Diskin does not understand what Netanyahu, Barak and Ya’alon do and that is that if the ayatollahs obtained nuclear weapons, they would use them. This has become clear from the article in Ha’aretz by Ari Shavit: “A few years ago Netanyahu held an in-depth discussion with Middle East expert Bernard Lewis. At the end of the talk he was convinced that if the ayatollahs obtained nuclear weapons, they would use them. Since that day, Netanyahu seems convinced that we are living out a rerun of the 1930s. “ See MAD is Dead: The crucial piece of the puzzle Barak in contrast to Diskin understands that the Iranians are using the concept of takkiya confuse and deceive the gullible West.: See "Israeli leaders understand the concept of takkiya"
45. Vision
jim ,   uk   (04.28.12)
Who would believe it. Diskin was vilified as the image of Israeli brutality Be that as it may he speaks from experience and reality
46. @ 5
Sheik rattle & roll ,   USA   (04.28.12)
I agree that Israel has to take care of Israeli's, however blaming America for the holocaust is absurd. That is like Americans blaming Israel for the slaughter in Syria now because Israel is watching it's neighbors get murdered by doing nothing. It is America's right to conduct it's foreign policy the way it see's fit and it is not America's responsibility to protect Israel or to go to war on Israel's behalf. America is cautioning Israel not to attack right now because an unprovoked attack on Iran will cause more harm then good and most US military analyst believe that Israel lacks strategic depth to fight Iran successfully.
47. to 39
moray ,   jerusalem   (04.28.12)
is shin bit works under the umbrilla of policy or military .. or do both are in fault . i think Diskin like to serve even if his sight is not clear . the worse is to hurt the people in their intention more than thier doing
48. Another idiot with his head in the sand!
Jake Stone ,   USA   (04.28.12)
I'm not pleased with the Israeli government either, especially, the fools Barak, Perez and Gantz, but to suggest that there is a chance for peace with those who truly despise you with a satanic hate is naive and foolish. There will never be peace with the Muslims--period! Sad to say: prepare for war; that's the only thing the evil culture of Islam understands. Wake-up! The world is at war with Islam; and, all you blind peaceniks' and Israeli haters' will be the first ones they turn on when all is said-and-done). Again: wake-up!
49. Amen !!! May the cool heads prevail ,...
split ,   US   (04.28.12)
Diskin for PM !!! ,...
50. #8
pete ,   uk   (04.28.12)
Indeed Diskin is a very brave man. I am afraid for many Israelis bravery is a fat Neanderthal with a saucer on his head battering a young Dane with an M 16.
51. 46 ,...
split ,   US   (04.28.12)
A rare and refreshing post on this forum ,...
52. # 7 and how is that peace with Egypt:
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (04.28.12)
going these days ?.much better than before the cold peace treaty between Israel and Egypt,yes there is a lot of barking from the new rulers in Egypt,but a barking dog doesn't bite.
53. Another idiot
human being ,   Jerusalem   (04.28.12)
Blind warnik, when do you wake up!
54. # 46 Sheik rattle ! the US is not responsible
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (04.28.12)
for the extermination of European Jews,but the US was a willing accomplice,there was a tacit agreement between the US and Germany,Germany will persecute and exterminate the Jews,and the US will block immigration of Jews to the US,England,Canada,Australia,did the same,they were infuenced by Hitler's and father couglin's Antisemitic propoganda,if Iran goes nuclear,Iran will dictate to the saudis,and the other oil neighbors the price of oil,Iran will own all the oil in the M.E.remember what happened,when Germany was not stopped entering the Rhineland in 1936 ?.
55. 54 - An historicly challenged idiot ,...
split ,   US   (04.28.12)
What the hell makes believe that any Goyim should sacrifise his/her own life to save a warmongering maggot like you ? ,...
56. I would like to propose a toast...
(04.28.12)
Kol Khara to all my Jewish friends...
57. didn't know, he is such a leftist
uli ,   jerusalem   (04.28.12)
btw: we do he thinks the coalition will fall apart when again israel throws vital interests in the mouth of the antisemitich arab monster? maybe because the public has become smarter than he wishes?
58. # 55 Did i say somthing right,that makes you
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (04.29.12)
so angry ?.you are not only hateful,you are also stupid,you did not refute what i said,you just continue spewing your antisemitic venom.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article