News
Former PM Olmert against Iran strike
AP and Ynet
Published: 29.04.12, 23:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
66 Talkbacks for this article
1. This is the right advice
Ludwig ,   Canada   (04.29.12)
Definitely do nothing against Iran. Wait till they are armed to the teeth (by Russia) and then go for it. Ah yes yes, good ol' Olmert. We're just one big happy fleet!
2. Finally some voices of reason
Michael ,   California, USA   (04.29.12)
For dogs, the best defense is an offense, maybe for boxers also, but not for small countries. Messers Olmert, Diskin, Dagan, welcome to the voices of reason. Our numbers are growing, even in Israel.
3. Olmert and the second Lebanon War....
Shalom ,   U.S.A.   (04.30.12)
Is he a competent decision maker?
4. I'm asking myself: what is Olmert's, Dagan's and Diskin's...
Alexander ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (04.30.12)
...true intentions? What are they up to? Is it that they oppose the principle of Israel's right to defend itself or that they don't recognize the Iranian nuclear threat? Or that they fear the Iranian response? Or that they fear the world's reactions to an Israeli strike? Or do they support the principle of Israel having the right to defend itself but either don't believe in Israel's capability to do so or because the time is not right yet? Do they oppose an attack on Iran(an attack that is explicitly meant to prevent the Iranians to acquire nuclear weapons), or do they oppose specifically an ISRAELI attack on Iranian nuclear facilities? Would they prefer a JOINT ISRAELI-AMERICAN-BRITISH attack on Iran? Or do they deliberately create an opposite view inside Israel to confuse the Iranians of Israel's intentions visavi the Iranian military nuclear program? Is this a false show?
5. A HAH! At last. An expert opinion...
Gideon Reader   (04.30.12)
...from a world famous military strat maven. Sort of a fountain pen collecting, double billing, grafting, schnorring Jubalation T. Cornpone. The triad of militaty geniumes of Olmert -IvripPutz Peretz place their dumbassed selves in a sort of parody; Sun Set Bong. Or inhaleing as strategy/tactics.
6. did he get an envelope also from Bambi ?
ab   (04.30.12)
He should have been in jail by now this shyster
7. Olmert does not want us to be kicked in the a$$ again...
Avi ,   Israel   (04.30.12)
8. This is a PLOT against Israel by corrupted ''elite''
(04.30.12)
9. #1 and #2: The advice of foreigners doesn' t interest us !
David ,   Jerusalem   (04.30.12)
10. 4
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (04.30.12)
In deed,what are they up to. Shalom .
11. How did Dagan get out of Israel?
split ,   US   (04.30.12)
Didn't he have his passport confiscated months ago?
12. Hear, hear...How much he gets from the US for saying this?
I care for Israel   (04.30.12)
1 million ? 2 millions ? A safe refuge in the US in case he fails again with his judgement of the situation ? This man just never learns.....
13. actor$!!!
me   (04.30.12)
politician$,religiou$ and militarie$ should go to hollywood to get the o$car$,they are the wor$t actor$,the wor$t movie$,the wor$t performance,the wor$t interpretation,the wor$t photography,the wor$t $inner$ of this film called real life, they got propaganda and deja vu, they are con$tantly over the stage,i mean the media tv,radio and new$paper$!!!
14. When did Olmert join the Iranian Government???
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (04.30.12)
15. I had my doubts
Joseph ,   Maimi, USA   (04.30.12)
I had my doubts against or in favor of a military strike, but If Olmert is against it then I have concluded a military strike is the way to go.
16. Thank God this creep is no longer PM!
Scott ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (04.30.12)
17. Olmert
Jim Brown ,   TN USA   (04.30.12)
Why does the media report stories about this thief? He should be in prison.
18. Olmert NOT in jail??
Dr. Jack ,   Canada   (04.30.12)
What is Olmert doing in NY?? Shouldn't he be in JAIL?? Advise from a crook and a failed leader? Who cares??
19. PM Olmert against Iran strike
jacques ,   nsw   (04.30.12)
unfortunately too many try to be the chachamim and all turning out be a ship of fools. too little too late to target Iran now the window of opportunity is closed . this should have happened 8 years ago.
20. obama pressures bibi with leftist elite
dirty shirt ,   usa   (04.30.12)
I strongly believe that Dagan, Diskin, Olmert, and the rest are pawns being used by Obama to keep Bibi in check, and to create rifts in Israeli society. It is sad to see how lust for power and jealousy have motivated these elitists to go against their country's best interests.
21. These are not officials, but ex or retired
jason white ,   afula, israel   (04.30.12)
officials. When someone retires from public service, he or she should not be allowed to talk to the public. They had their chances to help or hurt Israel. STFU, especially olmert.
22. #3 Shalom
Mark Wilson ,   U.S.A.   (04.30.12)
I take your post as an admission of defeat in the second Lebanon war?
23. Something smells funy .
Lucky ,   USA   (04.30.12)
It could be a very clever diversion.
24. once a fool always a fool. thank g'd he's gone. he should be
ralph   (04.30.12)
off stage everywhere.
25. Disastrous advice from a disastrous former P.M.
Chaim ,   Israel   (04.30.12)
Nothing could be more obvious than the fact that Israel must not let Iran's genocidal Mad Mullahs build nuclear bombs. This is ABC logic. It is hardly surprising that Olmert, who was a disaster as P.M. in every respect, advises us against it. Disastrous advice from a disastrous former P.M.
26. Two things
Vlad   (04.30.12)
I agree an Iran strike is extremely risky. That's why Israel should rely primarily on ground commandos instead of the air force. That way, Israel can destroy Iran's nuclear infrastructure without risking a significant part of the air force, and preventing the US from being able to militarily stop it. When Iran retaliates, send small squads of jets at Iran's missile bases. This will ensure only a few aircraft at the most get downed, while the Arrow and Patriot missile systems will stop most of Iran's missiles. I think that a strike should be postponed until Israel gets a good David's Sling network and the planned number of Iron Domes on all fronts. But Israel should attack if Iran continues unabated, and if there is proof that Iran is about to enter a "zone of invulnerability" or is about to produce its first nuke, the IDF should not hesitate to take Iran's nuclear program out. Secondly, I read a month ago that the verdict was to be announced in a few days. Why is he still free?
27. Ask the people of Shderot
Reuvain ,   Us   (04.30.12)
Now Olmert is an real expert on deterrence. Ask the citizens of Shderot how they sat under daily missile attack with him doing almost nothing for a long time. The most inept PM ever unable to deter daily attacks noe he becomes an expert, get real
28. olmert ..@2
steve ,   chicago   (04.30.12)
really #2, because if you compare 1967 offense with 1973 defense (Meir listening to americans) your theory doesn't work. As for 2006, Olmert was on defense as well. He sent soldiers to an unnecessarty death as he and Halutz futzed around. Olmert is the guy who was willing to give away the Old City and most of Jerusalem. He is a loser who perpetuates loser ideas.
29. Ehud Olmert is Corrupt
random guy...   (04.30.12)
took envelopes filled with cash and is on trial. I would take literally everything he has to say with a large dose of skepticism. Also, his incompetence with Amir Perez's stupidity, lost the war in Lebanon. This guy isnt the right guy to be taking advice from. Let him get back to his pen collection.
30. Loser
Harrybaby ,   Canada   (04.30.12)
Why would anyone quote this loser? He mismanaged everything he touched, and now he is up for corruption. Hey Ynet, why don't you interview the rapist president on his views on Iran?
Next talkbacks
Back to article