News
MK equates 'Nakba' with Destruction of Temple
Hassan Shaalan
Published: 15.05.12, 19:03
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
31. To: No. 29
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.15.12)
It's good to wake up every morning as if your hair were on fire. Once I stop laughing at your tired, old rhetoric, I'll remind you of just how badly you have acquitted yourselves against the IDF. Can you take the heat and all, what with your head ablaze?
32. Sorry for winning a war which you started...
(05.15.12)
If they had won, they would have killed all of us.
33. #29: cut the BS. you refused a state in 1947
(05.15.12)
You wanted A:LL of the holy land to yourself. That was an injustice and you paid for that. When you'll be willing to compromise on a land which was never yours, let us know.
34. Most Israeli-Arabs are traitors
Maurice ,   Los Angeles, USA   (05.16.12)
They should be stripped of their citizenship if they hate Israel so much and go live in Syria or Jordan. They'll never know how good they have it until they lose it.
35. Nakba Day
Ameridane ,   Aarhus, Denmark   (05.16.12)
Why doesn't Israel start by giving back land to the Palestinians. You can start by re-drawing the border around Umm Al Fahm- simply by moving the border demarcation a few miles to the west, Um Al fahm will be back in Palestine, the world will be happy to see that Israel has withdrawn from Palestine and ALL the population of Umm Al Fahm can enjoy the free benefits of UNRAW.
36. look...
SA ,   USA   (05.16.12)
No one's DENYING the Nakba, that it was a catastrophe for the Palestinian 'people' (unlike how many Arabs deny that the Holocaust ever happened). It is true that many families suffered, losing their property, and many of whom were probably innocent. The fact remains that many Arabs in Israel were complicit in fighting against the nascent Jewish state and their expulsion was justified in the face of war against the Arab states. The Palestinians are justified in observing Nakba day if they want, it just should be forbidden for institutions like TAU to do it, and they sure shouldn't throw stones as part of the protest. If you read the article from last week on ynet, you will see that many of the Palestinian protestors on the TAU campus decry Israeli apartheid, yet they are studying at an elite Israeli university. What a load of crap.
37. I am not sure if I laugh or if I cry with 35's comment
Keren ,   IL-BR   (05.16.12)
"the world will be happy that Israel has withdrawn..." Oy... How silly one can be??? Do you think we REALLY care about if the world is happy or not about us,Ameridane?
38. 2
john Darren ,   cairns-Austraalia   (05.16.12)
What you post is true but of course wasted words-Ersatz "Palestinians" are here to stay because Israel's leaders don't give a damn.
39. 3
john Darren ,   cairns-Austraalia   (05.16.12)
Good post Fad.How on earth could Israel have allowed Arabs to be in the govnt is beyond me.I hope that there is a war over Jerusalem and only then Israel will be free of the Arab squatters.
40. 10
john Darren ,   cairns-Austraalia   (05.16.12)
Bibi is a pro politician but a bad Leader.
41. 29
john Darren ,   cairns-Austraalia   (05.16.12)
Obviously you are teen-Ynet should not let children post.Lay off the comic books and get some sense.
42. 35
john Darren ,   cairns-Austraalia   (05.16.12)
I sincerely hope that there are more educated Danes than you.Don't you know that there is NO Palestine.There are a lot of Arab squatters in Israel but that does not mean that they are a "country ".
43. Time for Israel to answer
Nathan Rai ,   Bangalore   (05.16.12)
There is lot said about the next Intifada by Israel and the Jihadis, as if it bring about the end of the world. Id suggest that the Israeli Leadership unanimously make it clear that the next Intifada will be much shorter than the last one and that it is not something Israel will sacrifice Israels interests to avoid.
44. #10 les
Moshe of Rockville ,   Rockville,MD USA   (05.16.12)
Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the other forms. Freedom of opinion is a very basic right, which supports the people's voice in a democracy. Despite the disgusting support that some Israeli Arabs,particularly the MKs,have for the enemies of the Jewish State,who seek its destruction, one must uphold such freedoms and equal protection under the law.Such is the burden of justice in the Jewish State, and one reason for not drafting Israeli Arabs into the IDF.
45. Nakba Day and State of Israel Flags
Jon ,   Niles USA   (05.16.12)
The Iranians trampled 64 Israeli Flags today. Hopefully an Israel Company manufactored the flags and they were retailed at a nice profit. Each year the Palestinians refuse agreement with a reasonable settlement of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict means an addtional Israeli flag must be obtained for their Nakba ritual. Thanks to Palastinian intransigence, the Israel flag busines is on a roll. JFI
46. nakba
harry weiss ,   staten island new yo   (05.16.12)
wow they compare nakba to our temples .they finally admit that we were in jerusalem 2500 years ago. now admit that this a jewish land and thaen we can negotiate
47. #24 - return by "Hizbullah power"? Just take a plane.
William ,   Israel   (05.16.12)
There's atleast 2 flights daily from Beirut to Mecca - your holy land.
48. #29 - sure, ok. Meet you at the border.
William ,   Israel   (05.16.12)
just watch your back. The LAF had itchy trigger fingers last year and shot up some Lebanese protesters.
49. Bring it
Mike ,   Israel, LOD   (05.16.12)
We will send all of you to meet 72 vergins that all of you so much desire. Too bad those vergins are the rest of your Muslim friends that died with you. Pathetic bunch of savages. Why are we even dealing with these apes. Let's press a red button and send them all to their Satan they call Allah
50. #37,you misunderstood "ameridane",it 'd be greatest punishme
ab   (05.16.12)
nt for Um -fahm pals to finally join their "palistine" instead of staying in the hated Israel.And hypocrites of the EU would be at loss how to react at Israel fulfilling their wishes of "liberating the opressed"
51. I also cry for the Germans
Ilan   (05.16.12)
Was it fair that they lost the war and also could no longer exterminate Jews
52. Nah, Nah, Nakba!!! There, I said it, I deny it.
Steven ,   Teaneck   (05.16.12)
53. than what about arabs kill other arabs before
ghostq   (05.16.12)
1948, I reckon if they ignor their own past torment than others just as easily should follow, there is no such think as Nakbe. according to them anyway.
54. #35
Paul Sheaf ,   Liverpool   (05.16.12)
It just doent work, the days of land for peace are over, it is a ploy by radicals to take over Israel bit by bit. Israel has on numerous occasions returned land that was taken after being attacked and the payback is more terror.
55. Arabs out
Maruni   (05.16.12)
back to your filthystans, get the hell out of here already.
56. Persistent losers.
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (05.16.12)
Too bad they can't join in the celebration, the liberation of Israel from the hands of the heathens After a while the pals have become a sad joke on themselves for refusing to recognize reality. The kings of denial.
57. To: No. 35
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.16.12)
Why should Israel give back anything? They started all the wars; we won them. Ship their sorry Arab asses out -- I'm all for that -- but shift the borders? I DON'T THINK SO. There are consequences to waging war, and visiting terror. The ersatz "Palestinians" need to understand those consequences. Think of it as "tough love." Israel will not move its borders to accommodate ersatz "Palestinian" claims any more than Denmark will move its borders to accommodate German claims. And Germany is a sovereign state, with a legitimate right to even bring such claims. The ersatz "Palestinians" hardly constitute a state, do they? But that would be their fault, too, wouldn't it? Until you acquire an education, best shut up, okay? Your igorance should be embarrassing to you.
58. To: No. 27
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.16.12)
Thank you, Harris haw-haw. So -- exactly when is the U.K. planning to award independence and land to the six northern counties in Ireland? Hmm? Oughtn't you keep your ignorant trap shut until then? Teach by example, not by lecture. That usually works best, doesn't it? Exactly how many wars against Ireland did Britain win? Yet, the British remain in Northern Ireland. Israel has won six wars, all started by the Arabs and intended by those same Arabs to eliminate the State of Israel. They lost. All six. Too, too, bad. Are you saying there shouldn't be consequences, Mr. Stalin? Shall we address British war crimes throughout the world? And the resultant messes that continue to this day, Mr. Stalin? Or should I call you Mr. Hitler, given your obvious proclivities? Clean your house, Mr. Hitler, before you address mine. May both the names Stalin and Hitler be cursed throughout eternity. P.S. Would you like to discuss the Nazi collaborationists among British aristocracy? We can start with the current monarch's "Uncle Edward." Shall we do that? I can, you know. Shall we? Please respond. Then we can look at the assortment of leeches that call themselves members of the "royal family," and examine what THEY did during the war. Most practically flew Nazi flags. The record is clear. Come on, Mr. Adolf -- talk back. I'm dying to chew you up and spit you out. I can do it, too. Please -- just give me a chance. Just a tiny little chance. Answer my questions, you sod. Answer them.
59. we3macs@verizon.net
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (05.16.12)
WE WON, THEY LOST, ALL THEY HAVE ARE TEARS, LIES AND TERROR. WE HAVE THE LAND. BUILD BABY BUILD!! annex baby annex. Jerusalem as Israel's capitol.
60. 27
john Darren ,   cairns-Austraalia   (05.17.12)
Oh dear, got knocked for 6 by Sarah B . Stupid twit!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article