News
Clashes erupt during south TA protest; migrants attacked
Neri Brenner
Published: 24.05.12, 00:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
106 Talkbacks for this article
1. i support the rally not the violence
Golan ,   modiin   (05.23.12)
now instead of making a point over infiltration and government laziness we have to talk about stupid imbeciles who attacked an innocent person! Jackasses!!!!!
2. Oh my...
Amichai ,   Huntsville, US   (05.23.12)
It's no secret that I'm against the illegal immigration of anyone to Israel. I greatly sympathize with the residents in Tel Aviv & support their right to protest. HOWEVER, the rights & safety of the law-abiding must be guaranteed as well. I explicitly condemn the violence perpetrated against the Africans in that car, and any peace-keeping migrant for that matter. I believe in the goodness of my fellow Jews and ask that anyone involved in these protests to please try to exercise restraint and don't let your fears and frustrations turn you into a dangerous angry mob. You're better than that.
3. give me a break
Sanders ,   Earth   (05.23.12)
Are all news coming out of Israel race or war related??
4. What's is your problem?
Tom W ,   USA   (05.23.12)
This is the beautiful realization of the Leftist's dream, so dear to the Obamabots: "Diversity", "Multiculturalism" at its best! Protesting against it amounts to nothing more than "right-wing" xenophobia, "despicable Zionist nationalism" practiced by "Ishrail" and supporters of "Isreal" -- (like Montreal /sarc). We're the "children of the world", let's have all the Arabs, Africans but not the Jews because Jews are not "progressive" enough -- wrote T. Friedman in the N.Y. Times. (/sarc).
5. It's them or us. We gave them shelter and they return ....
(05.23.12)
violence. Besides they are not political refugees they just come for economicall reasons. Israel is to small to be the heaven for African Migrants. Some of them dare to say "this is not your land this is stolen land from Palestinians" It's time for them to leave by good or by force.
6. infiltrators
yosef ,   williamsburg   (05.23.12)
Thes behaviour shows the Satmar Rebbe was right.
7. I think most of these illegals are..
Malone ,   Hfx   (05.23.12)
..economic refugees,looking for a free ride..welfare,meals,housing,etc.without working. Something like the pals. Better get rid of them before the citizens start doing it.
8. Don't we already have refugee camps?
Boris ,   Rehovot, Israel   (05.23.12)
Last I checked, there were nineteen official refugee camps in Judea and Samaria, managed by United Nations Relief and Works Agency. How come those refugees aren't being taken there?
9. Violence is a part of African society ...
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.23.12)
... just look at what goes on, and has gone on since the 1960s. Now they have brought it to Israel (as if we didn't have enough violence just having to deal with the ersatz "Palestinians" and the host of enemies arrayed against us on our borders and beyond). Israel must coordinate with the United Nations a centralized location -- the U.N. has many refugee camps -- and send the illegal Sudanese and Eritreans to the location designated by the United Nations. Israel is not a dumping ground for the disaffected, particularly when violent and anti-social behavior is so demonstrably part and parcel of their "culture."
10. earlier I wrote;
arne ,   chicago usa   (05.23.12)
this can only get worse. it cannot and will not get any better.They must be sent back in the most humane way possible. to delay is only sweeping the problem under the rug.As I wrote earlier--chicago--detroit all of our big cities are crime infested.If Israel is to become the likes of western europe and the U.S it would be ashame.
11. The insane Leftists of Israel
Mike Caton ,   USA   (05.23.12)
For the insane Leftists of Israel, all cultures are the same. This lethal nonsense is certainly proving not to be true in Israel (and everywhere else).
12. Solution: Build Settlements for Refugees in the West Bank
Ari ,   Jerusalem   (05.23.12)
Sudanese refugees should be provided for in the West Bank. Israel should build settlements for them and provide them with care for their needs. If the Palestinians oppose this, then their hostile and vicious character will be revealed for all to see. Building settlements for the Sudanese in the West Bank could improve Israel's demographics there while providing a moral and humane solution to the tragedy of their plight.
13. THE SAME COMMENT HAS BEEN GIVEN TO ISRAELIS LIVING ABROAD AN
ELIAH ,   TEL AVIV   (05.23.12)
"!?the separatist, the chosen, the holly...hohoho." people of Israel ,whom about half of the population is living abroad , legally or not, are showing the world their true color... is this the reason why the world must love them and stand to their(israelis) cause? now you are talking about blacks not white asians and east europe immigrants...long live african refugees
14. #2 Amichal
arne ,   chicag usa   (05.23.12)
unfortunatly the people that be don't hear a wisper so you might have to raise your voice to be heard. this is an old problem only getting worse. Let them shout and really draw attention--It'll work. This is a big problem.
15. Get rid of every single one of them.
Aviva ,   Israel   (05.23.12)
BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE.! What a chutpa they are arriving by the thousands!
16. This is political...
(05.23.12)
Do not raise a hand on any man, Sudanese or not. the solution must be made in the knesset not through violence. These sudanese fled for their lives but now there is a South Sudan, a safe place to REturn. Ship them back but in one piece.
17. #10 oooh dear
RHarris ,   London   (05.23.12)
You really don't like black people do you. All your inferences (Chicago, Detroit) - rather a large proportion of black people living there and not many Zimmermans around to shoot innocent people dead for simply breathing. Why don't you go and live in a country peopled solely by white people? Oops - there aren't any. Perhaps North Korea. I believe the crime rate is quite low. Aren't you ashamed of yourself for writing such obviously racist bits of trash on a public site?
18. Wonderful!
Moshe ,   ny   (05.23.12)
This demo is one of the greatest accomplishments of the Israeli people, equal to the establishment of the state. Jews defending themselves from attacks by illegals.Deport them all. Jews do not behave as these criminal illegals do. Jews do not have the right to change the nature of their country. Politicians, do you hear the people???
19. injustice to children
barbara perkins ,   Los angeles, ca   (05.23.12)
and what about the cruel social workers that commit healthy israeli children to psychiatric hospitals . When will kidnapping and involuntary committment end in the state of israel. The atrocities of the jewish state after the holocaust. This will not be hidden from the world .
20. Philadelphia has similar problem.
bem ,   philadelphia   (05.23.12)
21. Deport these Africans
Yitzchak ,   Florida   (05.23.12)
If this Israeli government doesn't take immediate action and deport these Africans now they will end up destorying Israel like they have already done in Africa.The only thing they have to contribute is violence and crime. The government has an obligation to protect its people and country.Now is the time!
22. Rampent racism
jim ,   uk   (05.23.12)
Well the arab population have been saying it for years but the Israelis kept it under warps. Now its out for all to see. this will really go down well in the US...... Israel delegitimizes itself by the day all by itself
23. am I dispersed?
observer ,   Egypt   (05.23.12)
"In that day shall messengers go forth from me in ships to make the careless Khooshim (Negroes) afraid, and great pain shall come upon them, as in the days of Egypt" (Ezekiel 30:9), "And I will scatter the Egyptians among the nations [of black Africa], and will disperse them through the countries [via the slave-trade]; and they shall know that I am LORD." (Ezekiel 30:26). Once converted to Islam, blacks are considered full-blown Muslims, nothing like born Jew in Islam. Unlike Jews, here is is no racial or ethnic discrimination among Muslims.
24. #3- it seems that's as far as you read
William ,   Israel   (05.23.12)
you missed the story of Naomi Campbell spending her birthday here, of Israel and India setting up an agro-Center of Excellence center, and more.
25. #6 - the Satmar rebbe is never right
William ,   Israel   (05.23.12)
even when choosing which challah to eat. He's a racist hack like the rest of the self-righteous movement.
26. To: No. 23
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.23.12)
First of all, there is plenty of racial and ethnic discrimination among Moslems. Secondly, there is plenty of internal strife in the religion itself -- Sunni, Shia, Wahabbist, Alawite, Salafist -- don't pat yourselves on the back. Moslems are the most divisive people on earth. See what happens when you pilfer without attribution from a website that isn't strictly legitimate? You end up making a fool of yourself. Well, of course, you do that anyway. Did you really think that we don't know when you copy and paste? I don't think you are capable of constructing an original thought.
27. To: No. 19
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.23.12)
Care to document your ridiculous allegations? Are you certain you aren't confusing the State of Israel with Willowbrook (Staten Island, New York)?
28. there are things we can do short and long term
zionist forever   (05.23.12)
Build as many detention centre's as needed to keep them all locked up and off the streets until we can start deporting them in the tens of thousands. Short term convert some disused army bases to keep some of them and also find an empty lot on the outskirts of Tel Aviv and get the army to put up some tents so they have shelter and set up a soup kitchen. That way they are at least some of them are off the streets. We must though start deporting in big numbers and not let the government whitewash it all by maybe deporting a couple of hundred here and there or even a thousand now and again and boast they are doing something as we have abouot 60,000+ here already ( not including the economic migrants ) and there are an average of 3000 new ones coming every month.
29. To: No. 22
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.23.12)
Oh, you have no idea how well it will go down in the United States. Two-thirds of the prison population of the State of California are illegal Mexicans. Texas probably has a similar problem. Prisons in Minnesota are full of Somalis and other Africans (you'd think it would be too cold for them there, but I guess not). The list goes on and on. Illegal aliens in the United States account for a considerable amount of crime and a huge drain on social services and education budgets. As in Israel, they present with a whole host of medical issues, some of them highly communicable. Since you do not know anything about the subject, why don't you keep your silly thoughts to yourself? And I note for the record that your blanket statement about what the Arabs have been saying for years is patently ridiculous. The Arabs have been saying lots of things for many years, very little of which resembles the truth. You may want to do some serious research. A good place to start would be why Israel's Arab population remains in Israel. Do you suppose it might be because they enjoy far more freedom and a standard of living that they could never hope to enjoy in any Arab country?
30. #17 is the article
arne ,   chicago usa   (05.23.12)
about raceism or is it just coinsidental that the imigrants happen to be black?I suggest you take your beef up with y-net, they put the article out there. By the way, what section of London do you live in?
Next talkbacks
Back to article