Opinion
Xenophobia in Tel Aviv
Daniel Feldman
Published: 27.05.12, 10:17
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
78 Talkbacks for this article
1. Does Mr. Feldman lives in South-Tel Aviv himself?
Berk ,   Amsterdam, Holland   (05.27.12)
If not, he cannot judge.
2. Amazing!
ZIONEST FOREVER! ,   Haifa   (05.27.12)
Thank you Mr Feldman for saying what needs to be said. Couldn't agree with you more
3. RE:Thank you Daniel
Rida ,   New Zealand   (05.27.12)
Please Israel, do not allow your politicians to define you. Right now, the news around the world potrays Israel as a most racist country against black people. This article is well written and well done Daniel
4. What's wrong with brain structure of people like Feldman??!
tom ,   tel aviv   (05.27.12)
Unless there is a fundamental, pathological predisposition in some people to become Useful Tools (in Jews, apparently on a large scale) there is hardly any explanation, for this self-destructive path they're taking. Maybe it's our equivalent of "shahid"?! What the Hell has COLOR got to do with this issue?!!! Even if they were blue eyed, blond Swedes it still would've been the same problem. Soon they'll be made (by our idiotic Left) into brave, political fefugees, that escaped prosecution in their home countries. Feldmans of this World: Get Enlightened !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (by ANY means, be that by reading books or taking pharmaceutical compounds, or smoking crack for all I care) but DO IT !!!
5. Comparison to Jews,Ann frank,Pogroms by people who want to
Alan ,   SA   (05.27.12)
destroy the Jewish people is so cynical...what a joke...millions of $ are being spent by Arabs on MANY PR companies who are the best in the business.
6. Rida,your New Zealand refuses residency to Samoans
ab   (05.27.12)
,even though they or their parents have hold NZ passes. It's only 200.000 of them,no huge Africa looming behind,your country some some 15 bigger than Israel and almost empty . Shouldn't you concentrate on it ?
7. Racism has NOTHING to do with the issue at hand!
Aurora Andersson ,   Malmö, SE   (05.27.12)
Israel is THE ONLY COUNTRY IN THE WORLD who has gone to great lengths to bring over black people, from Ethiopia, not in chains, but to freedom, in Operations Moses and Salomon. The Sudanese in question are Muslims, coming from an enemy Muslim country, and have brought crime, theft, rape, violence, to a place where they have entered ILLEGALLY. They must be sent back without hesitation.
8. The singular flaw
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.27.12)
Everyone seems driven to compare the issue of illegal Africans to that of Jews in Europe. This is intellectually dishonest, and extremely manipulative. The Jews of Europe, six million of whom perished in the Holocaust and millions of whom were massacred in ways too horrible to contemplate for over a millennium prior to the Holocaust, never had a United Nations to look to for aid and assistance. The illegal aliens from Africa DO have a United Nations. There is absolutely nothing wrong with requiring the United Nations to do its job. The U.N.'s High Commission on Refugees is the best funded agency of the United Nations. Why should Israel be villified for the failures of the United Nations? Why should Israel do the job of the United Nations? Israel is not a dumping grounds for disaffected, diseased and sociopathic Africans. It is the job of the United Nations to take them in, put roofs over their heads, see to their medical needs and find suitable work for them. Force the United Nations to do their job.
9. Isn't Israel "the Homeland for The Jewish people"?
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (05.27.12)
These illegals are not Jews, not being a legal resident is still illegal no matter what nation they run to. In America, we deport them within 72 hours. Israel should do the same Editorials are opinions, I doubt whether or not this writer has ever lived in S. Tel Aviv.
10. Israel should show compassion for all refugees
USA   (05.27.12)
Israel must follow Tikkun Olam and allow the Palestinian refugees back to their homes in Israel. They deserve it just as much as the Sudanese refugees. That's what Jewish values are all about.
11. Misplaced embarrassment
Israella   (05.27.12)
Daniel’s studies in conflict research, management and resolution have not taught him the difference between pogroms against the Jews and the unfortunate words, actions and slogans used by those demonstrating the unwanted and illegal invasion of infiltrators/economic migrants into Israel. Pogroms killed. Words shock. I do not believe (and there is absolutely nothing to indicate the contrary) that nationalism or a threatened sense of identity will ever lead Israelis to behave as Europe and Russia did against the Jews throughout the past two thousand years.
12. Very wrong and based on no knowledge
Ofer ,   Kiryat Ono   (05.27.12)
Jewish communities, world wide and in all times, never planed to take over, to make Judaism the only religion.nevertheess they ware target forthe hunt.in all times. Now the entire world watch the Jihad, the methodology in Islam. The slow and stealth take over by tools of immigration. See Paris, see france, millions of Muslims immigrated and are taking over. They never claimed that France should not exist. No look at Israel. The entire Islamic world claims it should not exist. So you think that we will seat calm and watch edless flow of Muslems into our country? When you try to make the Jews behave like blind it is only because you are racist and you prey for our end, because with 60 - 70% muslems, we will become like othet countries that Islam is sctively cleaning other ethnics. Let me remind you that Democracy is not a receip for self destruction. And let me remind you that the UN resolution in 47 called for the establishment of Jewish State in the land of Israel. We have many worker on temporary visa from China, Thiland, Rumenia, we never opposed them. They came to work. Those Muslems are coming with women, families and they create ghetoes inside Tel Aviv. 600 of them only are refugies in Risks. The other 60000 are illigal immigrants whichwill destroy our country in the ling terms.
13. Tikkun Olam 2012
dia ,   Tel Aviv   (05.27.12)
Great, eye-opening piece. It does not matter whether these people are here legally or illegally, aggression won't solve anything. The government has to take things in its hands and deal with the situation instead of inciting and letting its citizens abuse an already miserable population. While the current events have showed that the status quo is unsustainable, the solution is not as simple as sending them back immediately. Would you like to be sent back to a place where you and your family will suffer and will be in danger? Didn't think so... Most of these people are completely harmless and want to work, just don't have the appropriate licenses. And yes, I have happened to volunteer in that neighborhood for a while and trust me, they are not here to cause troubles, they simply have nowhere else to go for now.
14. #7
Eugene ,   Israel   (05.27.12)
Did you even read the article ? "Moreover, police have said that crime rates among African migrants are no higher than the crime rates of the population as a whole." 70% of the migrants are from Eritrea and not Sudan. what you are saying is racism by definition - stereotyping the whole population while basing this on extremely small number of cases.
15. I HAVE AN IDEA
DA URBAN POET ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (05.27.12)
Let this Feldman fool live side-by- side with thousands of illegals from africa who will make his life a living hell .Then he will change his tune.
16. On point
Shlomo ,   Tel Aviv   (05.27.12)
Mr. Feldman is not arguing the fact that Israel should take these people in or not - he is arguing about the method in which we as a people and community are trying to solve these issues. The South TLV neighborhoods are already in poor condition and are neglected by the gvt.; so it is understandable how something like this can happen when people really feel like their environment is threatened. However, ultimately, people must show their anger towards the gvt. for their lack of a policy on this issue - or rather their lack of confronting the problem before it even started, pre planned policy. It makes no sense how the gvt. is to blame for all of this, yet there are certain politicians leading the etho-nationalist violence in what they say as a way to atone for their lack of doing anything to effectively solve the situation. The people have a right to protest the gvt. 'lack of policy' but when politicians enter the fray in such a virulently hateful way, this is where we are reminded of certain fascist aspects. Instead of trying to lynch the migrants, anger should be directed outside the Knesset and the Ministry of the Interior
17. Propaganda
michael Pielet ,   israel   (05.27.12)
Ridiculous propaganda. Not worthy of a response.
18. Don't vote for racists next time
Yossef   (05.27.12)
vote for educated Jews, with a vision of their history and their future, avoid the racists the xenophobes, the ultra right. Vote for what judaism has been all along the history, the path to freedom of a people of slaves.
19. Short memory
Raphael ,   Netanya   (05.27.12)
"Some of us are no better than our former European and Russian hosts ". You forgot the South Tel Aviv pogroms of 1921, 1929, 1936: they were not caused by a rash of rapes, murders, thefts like now, but only jewish presence and pro nazi incitements. Please avoid amalgams.
20. Ashamed Israeli
Michael ,   Tel Aviv , Israel   (05.27.12)
i was in the old bus central station the other day and i've soon the openly racist attitude of some of the resident there on black people. At the same time most of them are from a very low cultural background, such violence does not represent all Israeli society, but poor educated people and some jews from Europe and America who face huge illegal immigration in their own country. And please, stop this non-sense, black immigrant to Israel are present in an area of 5km sq max... whats the big deal?! All modern country have their own immigrant. its even a pride that people want to live here. All modern country and open economy face illegal immigration problem. Israel can't and won't resolve the problems of African countries, but, has the moral obligation to treat and solve in a gentle, Human and respectful maner the problem of the refugees. After all we are at the crossroad between 3 continent. we have neighbors.We should Stop doing like if we were living on planet Mars, moreover, this would greatly improve our legitimacy and right to live in that region as Jews.
21. #1: This is not about S. Tel Aviv, but about our politicians
Yitzhak ,   Israel   (05.27.12)
Dear Berk of Amsterdam. First of all, you don't even live in Israel, let along south Tel Aviv, so you are the one who shouldn't be judging. Secondly, this is a problem for all Israelis that WE must solve -- humanely and fairly. As an Israeli, not a Dutch, I agree with Feldman completely. These politicians who incite to racism and violence should be removed from office. They are a disgrace.
22. Refuah Shelema Feldman..
MannyFresh ,   Tel-Aviv   (05.27.12)
There is nothing wrong with Feldmans brain structure. But Israel definitely needs to start deporting these illegal immigrants before it gets worst!
23. Missing the bigger picture
Daniel ,   Boston   (05.27.12)
While the comparison to pogroms is overdramatizing the situation, most of the talkbacks completely miss the point. It doesn't matter if it's as bad as pogroms, what matters is that we remain good people. And good people don't go about destroying property of people they don't know. What happened should make us feel ashamed of those who commited the crimes. And no one is saying that the refugees should stay. I'm not even sure exactly what you feel so threatened by. There are some criminals among the refugees, but how many of the refugees you've met were also criminals? The point is, they are refugees, and Israelis have this irrational fear of the word. They are not Palestinian 'refugees' who may not even be refugees by any reasonable definition. The African refugees won't stay refugees forever and they won't stay in Israel forever. There is no reason to kick them out because they are not here to stay. So just relax. They are guests, even if some of them are bad guests. In the future, when the countries they came from become democracies (and that could happen in a hundred years for all I know), they will remember us well. Israel is indeed a small country with many enemies, so lets not make new ones.
24. Creeping Feldmanism. Potentially...
Gideon Reader   (05.27.12)
...very deadly. Warning: Feldmanism may cause a droolingly stupid compulsion to cheering as the nation is abandoned to unrestricted immigration from an unending source of destructive population pool. Unrestricted and open borders is not exactly a new problem on this globe. Idiotic socialist reflexivity certainly is NOT a positive answer. Geeeez!
25. absoultly u deserve your wisdom with no excuse
estoka ,   tel aviv   (05.27.12)
i believe too,learning is the eye of mind,u know what yossef !,,its true to for security reasons,but ,as i am one of refuges (decades Infiltrators ! ?) i never even dreamed to stay long only for two reasons,hard consider how ultra right ethics and extremist narrow mind could mobilize media circus in naughty.
26. Mr. feldman does not know the map of Africa
Anna M Sedda ,   Rome-Italy   (05.27.12)
Mr. feldman forget how big is Africa and how many people are starving in Africa.Second cannot compare progroms for Jews only",to african illigal immigrants.Africa is starving becouse a "few african dictators" do not rule them,but buy military equipment and not food....Africa got money from everywhere and Africans need to' fight for thir own rights in Afeica,not elsewhere...So i don t get your point Mr,your retoric is blind...
27. What an ignoramus!
Sandra Van Rompaey ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (05.27.12)
Politicians who refer to African immigrants as cancer or ridden with disease should be made redundant immediately, as they do more harm than anything else, by mislabeling the problem. Israel should, however, take its lessons from today's Europe, the old continent in which numerous countries are on the verge of bankruptcy and which is losing its own identity because immigration has been severely mismanaged! Offenders of all sorts (not only the despicable rapists) ought to be sent back immediately to whatever miserable country they came from. Immigrants and their children should be made to learn our language and adapt to our culture before any attempt at integration into our society is made. This, however, requires great effort and responsability, and even then, the always-right, politically correct left will probably complain that their human rights are being violated.
28. #23 WELL SAID , I AGREE
DA URBAN POET ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (05.27.12)
We all have a tendency to exaggerate the problem which is wrong. These guests must be treated with compassion and understanding becuase I am sure most of them are not criminals but merely seeking a better life. And nobody has the right to be violent towards them .
29. "Cultural Marxism" - leftist propaganda again
Tom W ,   USA   (05.27.12)
"Diversity", "Multikultism" "Death of nation-sates", cultures, history and national identity and religion. The new mantra of the international left which now dreaming of a supranational "world gov.ment" which will transform the humanity into a homogeneous mass -- led by the leftist gurus. -- Of course. The modern version of "proletariat of the world unite!" It's has already overtaken the Anglo societies where dissenting voices are labeled as "racists" "bigots" and the PC police stifles free speeches. The goal is to establish warring tribal societies which is easy to control by the leftist elite. "Divide at impera" (Latin) Both A. Merkel and D. Cameron openly stated that "Multikultism" is FAILED. It doesn't stop the hard-left propaganda machine to regurgitate this trite ideology. What kept the Jewish people -- its culture, religion, identity, --its very existence alive for 1000-s of years if not their strong belief in themselves?
30. Xenophobia? Give me a break!
Phoenix ,   Israel   (05.27.12)
Each week a woman is raped by africans. They even threat the police. They mean trouble that we are not obligated to stand. Take a look what blacks made of the USA. Rape, and all sort of crimes. They are savages and they must go! This is the land of the Jews! We will become a minority in our own nation? Are you insane? Netanyahu is useless he will be remembered as the prime minister who let the black plague to our country. Tel-Aviv it's already a garbage can for Africans. They must go in order for us to survive that simple. Our daughter were not rised to be raped by black savages.
Next talkbacks
Back to article