News
IDF documents Palestinian using human shield
Yoav Zitun
Published: 27.05.12, 21:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
59 Talkbacks for this article
31. it all happened in Gaza, not on Israeli land
observer ,   Egypt   (05.28.12)
who is the assailant, the one trying to defend borders? the clue is; were explosives used in defense or offense?, where is Goldstein?
32. to #29, Golda Meir did give damn to whole nation abuse
observer ,   Egypt   (05.28.12)
Golda Meir said: "There were no such thing as Palestinians. little addendum here, Meir only said this in 1968 when she resided in the West Jerusalem Talbalyya house owned by Palestinian Hanna Bisharate. Golda Meir received the house from the Foreign Ministry which was occupying the house since 1948 after kicking out its owner Palestinians.
33. Me thinks the world needs to see
Galut ia ,   Selah   (05.28.12)
these terrorist have been getting away with using human shields far to long ...
34. IDF STUPIDITY EXEMPLIFIED
Netanya ,   Netanya   (05.28.12)
Honest Reporting just published the GROWING negative view on Israel (within the past year even though there were no huge stories like the flotilla.) Countries which are supposedly friends of Israel find more negativity toward Israel This BBC survey found 21% only have positive views of Israel. The media is the problem and the IDF holding this vid does nothing to help the negativity. The only way for Israel to change this view is to start showing the truth, it is the only chance we have. So, IDF why be moronic, show the damn vid, as much as you can. The world has to see what happens and holding the vid till later only makes it become more suspicious and questionable. When the IDF gets vids like this, they must be released IMMEDIATELY and constantly. Learn from the Arabs/Muslims, they really know how to play the media and get attention.
35. Guess what?
rm ,   Amsterdam NL   (05.28.12)
that's what the IDF does at well when it's deemed necesary...don't be so hypocritical about it!
36. # 34 You mention the flottila surley you
ben   (05.28.12)
musr realize there had to be hundreds of cell phone camera footage. Why do you think Israel that confiscated everything on that ship never released the footage. " show the damn vidio The world has to see what happens and holding the vido till later only makes it become more suspicious and questionable". Do you feel this way about all vidio
37. Sarah , do you remember ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (05.28.12)
This "pal" woman who said thet she prefered to go to her son's "shahid" funeral than to his wedding ? That's how they are , sad "people" .
38. Observer , they most likely FLED
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (05.28.12)
in the hope to return when all the Jews would be massacred . This "hope" was given them by the "arab" propaganda . "arab bullets can make the difference between a Jew and an arab" "we will throw all the Jews in the sea" .
39. #21: Israel hasnt reached Canadian standards
jerusalem   (05.28.12)
As israel does not have a basic clear constitution, one cannot declare that (based on its ACTUAL actions, rulings enforced) israel is democratic. sorry. What good is the Supreme Court when it can still be sidelined? There goes human rights down the drain. Gaza or the PA dont declare to the world that they are democratic, so where are you coming from with your comparison? You should have actually compared israel (fairly, as i may say) to other democratic countries. Is it comparable with Canada or the US? I wonder if you seriously know and dare to mention.
40. # 37 Speaking of funerals how many
ben   (05.28.12)
attended the funeral of Baruk Goldstien, and how many have made a pilgramage to his shrine
41. ?????
m.a. ,   canada   (05.28.12)
well, lucky canada ! why deal with the palestinians since they do not have to share borders ! and again, lucky canada...for sharing borders with the usa. you are so stupid !
42. "Noal Shachen" - neighbour conduct
Itsik ,   London   (05.28.12)
To all of you stating that the IDF did not use human shield's etc you are all wrong. I'd like to remind you of Noal Shachen which was routinly used in the west bank arrests uptil 2005. The difference is that the IDF had to start using it well after the Palestinians were routinly using it. The IDF used relatives to enter houses as a result of Palestinians placing explosives in their family homes. This does not justify but just like the war evolved into a worsening conflict so did the IDF counter reaction. Another major difference is that the IDF had to stop these actions shortly after they were reported while the Palestinian use them still without a word against it from their own civilian populations or their courts. This is the difference between Israel and the Palestinian entity. They change the goal posts as and when it suit them like a good ols Arab theorcracy / "Democracy" while Israel behaves in a non ME mentality. This is something Israelis should be proud of. This is something only those who seek Israel's demise, rather than a true peace, will jeer at.
43. #32 observer, egypt
Itsik ,   London   (05.28.12)
Here we go again defencive... They were planting IED's close to the border fence so when an IDF patrol goes meters from it on the Israeli side of the fence they get blown off. That my friend is an offensive war. Israel do not control Gaza so why attack the border patrol? Mind you, you being Egyptian, I guess you know all about controlling borders... Can't even control your own border. The only thing the Egyptian mighty army is strong against is African refugees...
44. End canadian occupation of native american land
Israelite ,   Barcelona   (05.28.12)
The state of Canada has been built on stollen land and still does not honor nor pay his dues to its original owners. The original owners of the state of Israel were the Hebrews. They took back their land, creating by the way a palestinian national identity that did not exist before, and that decades of war has fortified. Now we need to learn to respect those people if we want them to respect us some day. Only love can conquer.
45. #1
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (05.28.12)
Find the names of the organizations where the wives of Israeli generals are members, and you will have your answer. By the way, who bought Ehud Barak's apartment for 27 million Shekels?
46. #9 please tell me
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (05.28.12)
Why are you condemning Israel with falsehoods? Shouldn't you concern yourself with your own problems, like the 6 children Obama butchered (together with their parents) in Suri Khail, Afghanistan last night?
47. #42 what is wrong
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (05.28.12)
Not once did any Arab get killed or wounded by Nohal Shachen. At the same time, countless lives (Arab as well as Jews) were saved by Nohal Shachen. Please tell me, what is wrong with Nohal Shachen?
48. Ben , 40 even ONE was too much !
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (05.28.12)
49. To: Charles at No. 37
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.28.12)
Well, Charles, I guess to their depraved and diseased souls, killing innocent Jews is a mitzvah. And we are supposed to make peace with such "people." How? What is wrong with them cannot be fixed.
50. To: No. 32
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.28.12)
How many Jews were kicked out of their homes in Jerusalem and Judea and Samaria in 1948? Do you have any idea? Do you know their names? The ones that weren't massacred, that is.
51. #26 - you do know "Palestinians" had terrorists
William ,   Israel   (05.28.12)
targeting Jews BEFORE the fabricated 1967 "occupation", right? It was one of the major reasons for the war in the first place. You do know that "Palestinians" (Arabs) were targeting Jews in massacres BEFORE 1948, when the State of Israel was born, right? You do know that Arabs were targeting Jewish civilians and calling for an ethnic cleansing since 1920, just on the heels of WWI, and their local leader, a firebrand from Egypt, would go on to first ask Hitler to bring his Final Solution to the Middle East against Jews, then leave and join Hitler in the Balkans, right? So you see - the issue of Arab terrorist violence today has years of precedence proving there is no tie to the "occupation", right? If you still believe it does, perhaps you can explain why Arafat signed the Oslo Accords ALLOWING settlements and their expansion, which would remain part of Israel in final land swaps. You're just a duped troll, right?
52. #28 - B'tselem doesn't want to bite the hand that feeds them
William ,   Israel   (05.28.12)
53. #30 - you forgot to mention the bags were from his family
William ,   Israel   (05.28.12)
So he was opening bags which were familiar to him and were property of his own family. Now I ask you - is it right to put your own children in harm's way to kill Jews? It certainly seems that way to "Palestinians" and their supporters. EPIC FAIL, ben!
54. #32 - she was right, there are no such thing as Pallys
William ,   Israel   (05.28.12)
They were fabricated in 1964. We all know that including their leaders at the time who made the decision as a political move against Israel under advice from Pol Pot. They were Arabs who either arrived as illegal immigrants, many from Egypt including Arafat and Al-Husseini, or took part in a genocidal war they lost. Perhaps Hanna Bisharate could have stayed put like the many other Arabs if he had nothing to fear. If he did take part in an illegal war, then his fate is deserved.
55. #36 - plenty of footage was released
William ,   Israel   (05.28.12)
as well as testimonies from Arab leaders on-board like Zoabi and the MP in Egypt. All of that together pointed to a planned altercation against an unarmed military boarding that was deemed by the UN to be legal under Intl Law. Not only did Arabs admit they planned the violence but they boasted about it. Doubtful that a few cellphone videos, taken out of context will help your friends and the biggest war crime in recent history. They goofed and got caught. Notice - no more flotillas.
56. david -a israeli friend in SF
miriam ,   israel   (05.28.12)
57. thats not what the Palywood news agency will say
zionist forever   (05.28.12)
This won't make the slightest bit of difference because it will be ignored and passed off for Israeli propaganda. Don't you all remember Moahmmed El Dura was murdered by Israeli soldiers and in Jenin there are mass gravesof the hundreds of thousands of palestinians Israel murdered.. Not to forget of course 9/11 was an inside job carried out by Mossad and all the Jews who worked in the WTC were told not to come in that day.
58. "palestinians" do not exist
Lauren ,   USA   (05.28.12)
These so-called "palestinians" are nothing but Jordanians, Egyptians, Syrians and Lebanese
59. #43 if Israel can't control its own border,
observer ,   Egypt   (05.28.12)
Egypt is going to take the Negev
60. 58 , egypt can't control her borders and country
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (05.29.12)
So we will need to capture the Sinai .
Previous talkbacks
Back to article