News  World News
Obama to rabbis: I'm vilified because of Muslim name
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 30.05.12, 17:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
32 Talkbacks for this article
1. Mr. President
Jorge ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (05.30.12)
There is a big issue here, you have never been in Israel, but you were in Egypt, Saudi Arabia, etc. You talk about giving more than we can give for peace but you never pressed the other side. Putin is visiting Israel, the president of China visited Israel but no Mr. Obama. The above are few of the reasons to believe what you said. We are close to November and a trip to Israel will not help now to improve your image. The Congress pushed you to save Israel otherwise it was not in your administration agenda. Please Mr. President accept the fact that you have created in almost 4 years.
2. Whats in a Name
Jrg ,   USA   (05.30.12)
Wow, could it be he would have to denounce his Sunni Muslim faith at the cost of his life? Obama the coward & thief seems a more accurate tittle.
3. It's his track record in the Islamic world
Galut ia ,   Selah   (05.30.12)
and he has promised that after the election if re-elected to be more forceful with Israel about dividing the land and splitting Jerusalem....and his Islamic sympathies will play a large role in that...
4. Obama: Clueless or Evil?
Joe Kaufman ,   Silicon Valley, USA   (05.30.12)
Americans have a number of reasons to be unhappy with Obama's foreign and domestic policies. He seems hell bent on appeasement be it to America's enemies or big banker bandits. Living in SF Bay, I am appalled by the mindlessness of the blind support Obama enjoys from unaffiliated Jews who cannot even listen to criticism. I think Liberal American Jews are being played as suckers. I don't think the man is clueless. I think he may well be evil. Like Carter.
5. Conservative "rabbis"
david ,   new york   (05.30.12)
its telling that he's meeting with a group that is known for being virulently anti-israel (anyone heard of "rabbis for human rights", also out of the conservative movement). and they ask him about ... the environment??? aren't there more pressing issues for jews. perhaps why is he asleep on iran getting nuclear weapons? he doesn't even want to boycott iran because higher prices might hurt his re-election. also, isn't israel the real problem, not iran?
6. Think Again
Ellen ,   Netanya   (05.30.12)
It is easy and perhaps comforting for Mr. Obama to think that the only reason he is vilified is because of his Muslim name. One wonders why he so easily ascribes prejudice to those who dislike him. Could it be that he judges people by their background and not their actions? Are certain people always right and others always wrong in his mindset? If he would be really honest he would realize that he is disliked because of his ACTIONS. His name could be Yakov Schwartz BUT if he acted towards Israel and Jews the way he does he would still be vilified.
7.  Pollard ,Rabbis,Obama,, Result ? NONE !
Roland Seener ,   London England   (05.30.12)
8. RABBI'S ABJECT FAILURE.
BUTSeriously ,   Sydney   (05.30.12)
At a time when Israel's existence is targeted by Islamic states and most of Europe & the UN, it was ridiculous that a Rabbi should focus on his son's gay issue. The Rabbis should have asked for a declaration Jerusalem will never be divided and all Islamic states must accept Israel as a legally established state which has no more land to give up. Is there anything more atrocious than Muslims having more land than they can measure and demanding more from tiny Israel?
9. Mr. Obama, name does not make a man and you a failure
leo ,   usa   (05.30.12)
as POTUS not because you are Hussein, but because you are inept.
10. A return to the "charm offensive" yet...
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (05.30.12)
One can't forget - although during elections season some would attempt to suppress the knowledge about it - Obama's first major speech at Cairo University in 2009, one in which the only justification for Israel's very existence given by the president was the Jewish Holocaust in Europe, as though 4,000 years of deeply rooted affinity and sovereignty in Eretz Israel (Land of Israel) didn't exist. And, then, one can't forget either, that the President of the United States of American then proceeded to compare the Shoah to the conditions of Arabs in Gaza....!! One can't forget - although during elections season some would attempt to suppress the knowledge about it - Obama's continuous attempts to insult and humiliate Israel's prime minister, meeting after meeting. And, as if this was not enough, he proceeded to insult other members of Israel's cabinet - including Israel's foreign minister as well as Israel's interior minister. What the president did was akin to spitting at some of the most important symbols of renewed Jewish sovereignty in the Jewish people's homeland of 4,000 years, symbols of the liberal democratic nation-state of the Jewish people, thus putting down the people whose nation-state Israel is, the Jewish people, everywhere. And, of course, one can't forget Obama's continuous demands of Jews, only because they are Jewish, to refrain from moving into certain neighborhoods of their capital city of Jerusalem. And, this, in addition of demanding that Jews, only because they are Jewish, refrain form residing in villages and towns of their homeland; in places like Shiloh, Beit El, Hebron..., and this from a man who has read the Hebrew Bible time and again while "sitting under" the Rev. J. Wright for some 20 years...!! It was, let us not forget, Mr. Obama who denied any commitment by the US former president to the government of Israel, despite the fact that it was US President George W. Bush who made some written commitment to then Israel's prime minister, Ariel Sharon, a commitment that was re-affirmed by the US Congress. Thus, if a President refuse to adhere to written commitments made by the US Presidency, why should one trust verbal ones made by him...?? Mr. Obama is a thinking intelligent man. The above are only samples of the result of his deep thoughts about good and evil in the world; about dos and don'ts, and about how one treats old, close and most loyal allies...!! But, instead of apologizing to the Jewish people, within and without its nation-state of Israel, for his words and deeds, the man has been unleashing Mr. Thomas Friedman to continue to herald Obama's attitude towards Israel and its leaders, while employing other supporters to sing his glory and Messiah quality. This, sadly, is the face of the present President of the United States of America.
11. Mr.H.Obama: your name could be Thomas Friedman for all I
tom ,   tel aviv   (05.30.12)
care, you'd smell the same though.....
12. Any idiot can call himself a "rabbi". It doesn't really make
David   (05.30.12)
him a rabbi!
13. Gee. Who knew is was his middle name
Gideon Reader   (05.30.12)
And here all the time I was under the impression that my loathing for this ignorant incompetent dope smoking socialist was because of his not quite American ineptocracy.
14. It's not your name
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (05.30.12)
It's your actions that have vilified your name, not the other way around.
15. BHO: visit the Mohel, then we'll talk
The Prophetess ,   SC, USA   (05.30.12)
The calendar says it's [re-] ELECTION TIME - therefore it's time to rachet up the Jewish votes. Tell you what, bubbie: pay a visit to the Mohel. Then come talk to us.
16. You are villified because you don't do your job.
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (05.30.12)
It's easier to hang out on a golf course and blame George Bush... or people who think you are better at representing the Muslim countries....rather than the United States..... which pays your wages to represent us. The excuse President...Obama.
17. Obama is an enemy of Israel and Jews
Ron ,   Atlanta, GA, US   (05.30.12)
His first phone call as President was to Mahmoud Abbas, the "moderate" leader of the murderous PLO/PA who share the same goal of replacing Israel with "Palestine." Obama'sd prime directive is the destruction of Israel.
18. he's desperate.
sue ,   jerusalem   (05.30.12)
19. Obama loves the Jews, has a Jewish name....
Ben Ze'ev ,   Panama City Panama   (05.30.12)
What personal connection does he have to Israel...?? He's very conspicuously never been there, He has denigrated Netanyahu along with Sarkozy calling him a liar and complaining aboutn having to deal with him.etc. He is also conspicuously servile and obseqious to perry Arab tyrants, and issues orders strongly opposed by the pro-Israel Congress, which are very detrimental to Israel, and helpful to Israel's enemies. And i'm sire there's lots more. In fact I don't see how this President has avoided impeachment for so long.
20. Me Thinks it's time to be informative on other Jewish blogs
Galut ia ,   Selah   (05.30.12)
Mr Obama Should NOT be allowed to get away with this kind of deceptive propaganda... if everyone is vigilant ..he won't get away with these lies...and half truths
21. obama
Sarah ,   LA, USA   (05.30.12)
Such a liar!
22. Obama mtg. with conservative Rabbi's
c.a.leejr ,   PA, USA   (05.30.12)
Article would have us believe that conservative Rabbi's (orthodox Jews) proudly thanked the president for his stance on supporting gay marriage? ....credibility = lacking in this article.
23. Obama will betray Jews in November
Sue ,   Los Angeles   (05.31.12)
Once re-elected, Obama will no longer need Jewish votes or money. He will pursue with a vengeance, his goal to divide Jerusalem and declare the eastern half, capital of a Palestinian state. By then, Hamas will be in Jerusalem and Iran will have the bomb. He's already handed Egypt (& soon, Syria) to his jihadi Muslim Brotherhood friends. Jews who vote for Obama vote for Israel's destruction.
24. Vilified
Frank St. Clair ,   Lexington, KY, USA   (05.31.12)
Mr. President, you are vilified because of your policies, not your name, and not your race. Your policies have failed, end of story. There are no excuses.
25. Yawn
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.31.12)
Another self-serving Obama pity party. Boo hoo. My golden retriever is more presidential than that sorry excuse for an American president. He'd probably make better executive decisions, too.
26. Lord, you knuckleheads do lose your minds over the Pres
Cameron ,   USA   (05.31.12)
He'll be out the door in November. Not enough time for him to bring about the downfall of Western civilization, and the state of Israel to boot. Get a grip & smooth out.
27. What an ungrateful bunch......
Robert ,   Australia   (06.01.12)
......you are. Obama, during his term has supported Israel to the hilt. He has prevented a devastating war with Iran, by talking some sense into Israeli warmongers, which may well have been the demise of Israel. He has presided over an ever increasing amount of aid to Israel, aid that America can ill-afford. If you people regard Obama as being anti-Israel because he tries to be even-handed with everybody, you don't deserve assistance.
28. To: No. 27
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.02.12)
First of all, your facts are all wrong (well, they usually are; no surprise there). Aid to Israel has not been increased -- the United States is very anxious to get its hands on Israel's Iron Dome short-range missile defense system, as there is nothing like it in the American arsenal. You fail to mention the tens of billions of dollars that the United States has poured into the bottomless pits of anti-American sentiment in countries such as Pakistan (hey, didn't they harbor bin Laden for ten years?), Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan (the Taliban is resurgent; the poppies are blooming and their repugnant end product is finding its way to American shores in ever-increasing quantities), Jordan (where there are daily demonstrations against the United States which include burning the American flag) .... Obama has done nothing but bully Israel since he took office. He single-handedly set the Middle East aflame. He has left a mess in Iraq, a mess in Libya and has completely ignored the crisis in Syria. He has -- pardon the expression -- screwed the pooch in Waziristan and Yemen, too -- Americans are dying there daily, while the United States continues to pour money and provide arms to those sworn to the destruction of the United States. Real even-handed. You're a cretin, Robert; an ignorant one at that. Go throw some shrimp (ick!) on the barbie. That's probably the high end of your capabilities, although I suspect you're pretty adept at popping beer cans, too. Stick to what you know -- politics isn't one of them.
29. 28 What Richrar forgot was that Obama
lydia ,   Brisbane   (06.06.12)
was still using the One US veto to circumvent the wishes of the International Community and bring an end to Israel illegal regime and enforce sanctions on your lot of war mongers that would see the end to Israel racist apartheid state and its numerous UN violations.
30. Ignorance and Hate Are Disgusting
Moshe of Rockville ,   Rockville,MD USA   (06.07.12)
Nearly all the posts express a shocking degree of ignorance and hatred of Obama.Let me straighten out this bottomless pit of filth. Obama has provided Israel with the largest amount of military aid in US history.Over $3 billion per year goes to assist the IDF to provide it with the latest in technology and weapons systems. An additional $250 million supplemental aid was provided to develop the Iron Dome missile system, which was praised by Israel's defense leaders for its success in saving the lives of Israelis who live under threat from Hamas' rockets.Advanced weaponry,such as bunker buster bombs and F-35 fighters were sold to Israel. In addition, the US assisted Israel in joint efforts to develop the Arrow and David's Sling missile systems.
Next talkbacks
Back to article