News
MK Michaeli: Most gays were sexually abused
Moran Azulay
Published: 14.06.12, 13:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
47 Talkbacks for this article
1. Tottal rubbish MK Michaeli shows her ignorance
Yonatan ,   Carmel   (06.14.12)
What tottal nonsense, the women is clueless. Being gay is not some alteranative life style choice it is a persons sexual orientation. Her homophobic and uneducated comments not only highlights her stupidity and ignorance it incites hatred and prejudice. Every gay teenager that commits suicide should be on her head. Well im gay, and over 40, have a partner of over 20 years and two wonderfull children and if i say so a great life ! I have no desire to be a women thankyou very much, nothing against women at all we have lots of female friends. Maybe she should make the effort to get to know some gay people she might be surprised to know that we are just like ordinary people, your doctor, dentist, lawyer and so on. How sad in this day and age a women of political power is tottaly clueless of reality.
2. so pathetic
Ami Horowitz ,   Ramat Gam, Israel   (06.14.12)
It is pathetic that such dumb and ignorant people reach positions of power in this country.
3. Disgusting Woman!
Yakov ,   Tel Aviv   (06.14.12)
What kind of representation, do we as Israeli's receive, from such a bigoted MK? "The Homosexual" as she degrades, is a human, a person. All she sees, is a sex act. Her mind is so polluted by hate and bigotry, that she feels this kind of vomit needs to be spewed in an open political forum. I am embarrassed as an Israeli, to have such a "person", in such a high place. I am disgusted by this, and I call for censure, repudiation, and boycott of all her business dealings.
4. ....& when did FM MK Liberman, head of Israel Beitenu...
Jew ,   JewLandia   (06.14.12)
give back MK Michaeli her right to speak out of STUPID and OUT OF TURN again? (yep I remember the water throwing episode in the Knesset & the rest of you should remember it too) This is the 2nd time she's gone against the party's line in a BIG WAY. I have a feeling she won't be on the Israel Beitenu list for the next Knesset because as the party itself says: "Michaeli's statements are her own opinion and do not represent the party" (and of course we all remember what happened to former MK Esterina Tartman -- so very soon we can all say "Bye Bye Michaeli!"
5. The Lady is NO Lady & is out of line!
(06.14.12)
6. please help me...
marco ,   pardes hana, israel   (06.14.12)
Dear MK Michaeli, I am 55, gay, happy, & have a great relationship with my parents. Where did I go wrong?
7. gays 5-8 times more likely to attempt suicide
Michael Redbourn ,   Arad Israel   (06.14.12)
Gay, lesbian and bisexual teens are five times more likely to commit suicide than their heterosexual counterparts, but a supportive environment in their schools and communities can make a difference, new research suggests. I did a quick check on the internet and found the above at livescience dot com. And this on another site. Gay men in Scotland are nearly eight times more likely to have attempted suicide in the past year and four times more likely to have taken drugs than heterosexual men, a survey has suggested.
8. Why do people post without fact checking?
Michael Redbourn ,   Arad Israel   (06.14.12)
It's so easy to fact check things on the web so I don't understand why people don't do. Just spouting what you think must be the case simply makes the person look foolish later.
9. Vile Creature
Gabe ,   Tel Aviv   (06.14.12)
It's not what she says that upsets me, it's the fact that she's merely been 'distanced' rather than thrown out of the Knesset. Comments like this should not be tolerated and she should be dismissed immediately.
10. MK Michaeli and other homophobes:
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (06.14.12)
They should remember that much of their vilification of homosexuals are reminiscent of the same rhetoric against Jews by Dr. Goebbels and Hitler's cohorts! We are all entitled to our opinions though but mines of her would result in me being banned from YnetNews for life! What goes around comes around!
11. MK Michaeli has 8 chldren
don ,   israel   (06.14.12)
MK Michaeli has 8 children. Statistically there's a pretty good chance one of them might be gay. I wonder how she'll cope with it.
12. she expresses out of religious sentiments
ygalg ,   israel   (06.14.12)
that has no place in science or politics
13. @11 below the belt not nice...
(06.14.12)
I see your point. But really we must NOT blame the children for the sins of the mother! And surely we must not place ANYONE'S children into the mix of politics. Children are children and deserve to be respected and protected.
14. The unfortunate MK Michaeli
(06.14.12)
To call this woman "stupid" is to actually insult stupid people...
15. If she said it, it must be true
Ethan Schwartz ,   Eilat, Israel   (06.14.12)
16. Pseudoscience
Maks ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.14.12)
Michael, if you quote lifescience then you should also quote the statement from the same article ""When communities support their gay young people, and schools adopt anti-bullying and anti-discrimination policies that specifically protect lesbian, gay, and bisexual youth, the risk of attempted suicide by all young people drops, especially for LGB youth." It's not being gay which makes you suicidal but a non-accepting environment, like those statements of Michaeli.
17. 6 marco,good for you,but you are..
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (06.14.12)
not the rule.
18. MIchaeli and democracy
Jez ,   Netanya   (06.14.12)
Israel really needs to change the voting system so we vote for individuals rather than have baffoons like this woman foisted on us
19. People doing immoral acts are worse than animals!
(06.14.12)
People were created to be on a higher level than animals and the Jewish nation on a higher spiritual level than non-Jews. But if all they do is eat, sleep, and do immoral acts, they're worse than animals.
20. She is not so stupid as you think!
Moshico ,   Jerusalem   (06.14.12)
It really depends in what you believe in. Yes there are many gays who are happy with life, some with a partner others without. Then there is the question of are you “born that way” Well if you think you were not then you may want to find out what happened to make you that way. There are many reasons one can put a finger on, sexual abuse, over weight as a kid and being made fun of, trauma in the school showers well not everyone was born looking the same, those quiet good little boys and mummy’s boys, the list goes on. Those types are normally the unhappy ones that may lead to suicide, these are the ones looking for answers, and these are the ones looking to change. But the happy gay person will tell you he was born that way and tell anyone who tries to explain that you were not will tell you to f*** off. So if you think it’s in your genes then explain to me how you can have a set of identical twins and one is gay and one is not. It’s a bit like saying what came first the egg or the chicken. I met many ex gays who have belonged to groups that helped them change, Journey Into Manhood for one and JONAH. Yes people will tell you it’s a load of nonsense. But I don’t think so.
21. plz, put this PSYCHOPATHIC " woman" OUT of
hot snow ,   tlv   (06.14.12)
the KNESSET. tanx.
22. Homophobia
David Goldstein ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (06.14.12)
Unfortunately, her views are shared by many who grew up in the former Soviet Union. It is not based on religious prohibitions.
23. Is it missing another ingredient?
Keren, IL-BR   (06.14.12)
Homophobic, racist, violent, prejudiced, oppresive, religious fanaticism, occupier, ultranacionalistic... is there another ingredient to this wonderful society we have been converted to?
24.  MK Anastasia totally heterosexual
Amazing ,   Jerusalem   (06.14.12)
Next time LIeberman must think twice when electing MK for his party. How much stupidity is a MK authorized to say?
25. The bible prohibits homosexual acts
Sam ,   Canada   (06.14.12)
Not being able to "cure" homosexuality or feeling sorry for homosexuals doesn't change that. Genetics, other science or politics doesn't change it either. The bible still prohibits homosexual acts. Does Israel choose to disregard the bible?
26. miserable ?
twice blessed ,   toronto   (06.14.12)
yes, many are. I also know many 'straight' people who are miserable. Im 51 gay, common law hoping to make aliyah soon after I marry the bf in Spain
27. Good for her!
Malone ,   Hfx   (06.14.12)
28. Disgsting behavior
Michael ,   West Jerusalem   (06.14.12)
She most likely thinks like that because she grew up in the soviet union, many family members I have think like that too.
29. correlation proves causation fallacy
logic ,   usa   (06.14.12)
Is she implying that their "gayness" causes them to be miserable? She's ignoring a common cause: that we treat gays as second class citizens. One example is the issue of gay marriage. So by the time they're 40, they've realized there's no hope that they can marry like the rest of us and that they have to exist at the margin as second class citizens. You would be happy in that situation, wouldn't you MK?
30. Not the only one
Reuven ,   Herzliya Israel   (06.14.12)
Michaeli is not the only one in the Knesset that is sadly misrepresenting the Israeli public. A change in our voting system is much too long overdue.
Next talkbacks
Back to article