News
Ex-IDF soldier seeks Palestinian citizenship
Associated Press
Published: 14.06.12, 11:32
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. He's probably one those 100s of Russian anti-Semitic goyim
Chaim ,   Israel   (06.14.12)
who shouldn't have been brought to Israel in the first place.
2. he is an anti-yehudi hatred against goy
pharaoh   (06.14.12)
3. Analyze this : Sick lad in need of professional help
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (06.14.12)
4. I don't agree with him; but if he wants 2 go, good riddance!
Jew ,   JewLandia   (06.14.12)
A pity that hundreds more in Israel and abroad who feel as he does aren't wedded to their convictions enough to boldly do as he has done! At the very least I respect the fact that he's not a hypocrite!
5. renounce
Mike ,   TLV Israel   (06.14.12)
and the first plane back to Tajikistan. END
6. 1 israeli Jew hater less. good
martin ,   uk   (06.14.12)
There are plenty mre who can follow him, such as B'Tselem members
7. Andre Pshenichnikov is a goy from ex-Soviet Union
(06.14.12)
8. Thank you to the Jewish Agency to bring us this kind of fool
(06.14.12)
9. He probably is Shabak spy. Excellent way to get in!
Johnny   (06.14.12)
10. Tajikistan Sunni Islam official religion
ygalg ,   israel   (06.14.12)
11. No surprise
Istvan ,   BUDAPEST HUNGARY   (06.14.12)
In every countries of the world the 1-2% of population is suffering in various mental deseases. This guy belongs to them.
12. goy-boy
Moragh   (06.14.12)
This boy is a clown in army uniform. Help him out of Israel. I don't know where Palestine is, but I hope Israel will help him find his haven. What a clown!
13. Will make world headlines, wait and see...
Esteban ,   Argentina   (06.14.12)
14. one more USEFUL IDIOT
Itzik ,   Jerusalem   (06.14.12)
I wish Oppenheimer would join him
15. Ex-IDF soldier seeks Pal. Citizenship
David Gevint ,   Raanana, Israel   (06.14.12)
#1 Please don't attack all Russians. What about Vanunu who commite treaso and converted to Christianity?he certainly was not Russian What about Tali Fahima who converted to Islam and lives with the head of the Islamic Marters Bigrade somewhere in the West Bank? And, of course what about Amira Haas who lives in the West Bank and writes vile articles about the Israeli "Nazis"? And finally . what abiut Gideon Levi?
16. a man, a man // a word, a word
tiki ,   belgium   (06.14.12)
Now ALL the Jewish leftist advocates for a 'Palestinian State' should follow him. If not, they should forever shut up!
17. We, Jews, have our share of crazy people of course. This is
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (06.14.12)
an example. But, of course, the press will attempt to make this case a "trend" in Israeli society, because otherwise it would not be a "scoop".
18. Don't let the door hit you
steve from raleigh   (06.14.12)
on the way out
19. I feel sorry for his mother.
rebecca ,   Modiin   (06.14.12)
She did the very best she could for him, brought him from Tajikistan to live a better life, and this is the thanks she gets. The life of a mother is not always so great.
20. Let the fool go...freakin' idiot!
Jake Stone ,   USA   (06.14.12)
21. I wish it were the pals going back to Jordan
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (06.14.12)
Maybe they will if Israel weans her from the welfare tit.
22. Arabs haven't lynched him - yet. Won't be the first
PETER SM ,   AUSTRALIA   (06.14.12)
pro activist to be killed by the peace loving neighbours
23. # 19 Hitler had a mother too.
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (06.14.12)
and every other despot -who believed he could rule the world.
24. Strife because of "UNFINISHED" Zionism. BIG ISRAEL=BALANCE.
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (06.14.12)
25. He probably has a pal girlfriend..
Malone ,   Hfx   (06.14.12)
..who can't or won't leave the West Bank.
26.  Former Idf solfier renouncing Israeli citizenship
floria   (06.14.12)
Right on! You would not. believe how Many Goyim the Jewish Agency brings on! No wonder Israel is hardly a Jewish Country.
27. Why the publicity?
Ibrahim El Awal ,   Dearborn, Mi   (06.14.12)
Why is YNET supporting Hamas propaganda? Who cares what one idiot says? Who cares?
28. Send him back to Tajikistan...
(06.14.12)
and from there he can go wherever he wants...
29. In other words, he wants revenge for tough life in Israel
William ,   Israel   (06.14.12)
Quite a few immigrants from ex-Soviet bloc countries arrived expecting a very easy life in Israel, despite some not being tied to Judaism. They arrived with the hope of getting wealthy just like illegal immigrants from Africa do, but couldn't get to the US. Now, they are pissed off they aren't treated special, that not everything in the country is in Russian, and hardships exist here as they did back home - and they want revenge. Many attacks by these immigrants have occurred as a result of this reason alone. If this guy wants to leave Israel and become "Palesitnian" then let him. He will lose ALL citizenship as "Palestine" is not a recognized country according to the ICC. And the IDF should make him understand that the minute he joins the "resistance", he will be a target without haste, and there will be no coming back to Israel, either as a citizen or to visit. Perhaps he can shack up with Amira Hass.
30. 29
zionist forever   (06.14.12)
I think its more like some kind of romantic vision of wanting to be the well trained soldier who had access to the best kit money can buy and who has probably lived a relatively comfortable life in Israel. Now he wants to go join the poor oppressed underdog join who has no money and their weapons are katusha rockets rather than Guided missiles and Merkava tanks. Palestinians though who have grown up with the real hardships would love to come to Israel but can't because they have no romantic ideas of becoming part of the underdog and fighting for a noble cause. Its like the guy who grew up super rich and never wanted for anything but then they start getting ideas about how romantic and fun it would be if he was also poor so he decides he wants to get rid of all his money and come live in the slums be one of the ordinary people. The people who were born in the slums of course probably think he is mad because they would welcome even a fraction of this persons wealth and they don't think being poor is romantic and would rather live in the mansion and drive the Ferrari he has now. Let him revoke his citizenship leave the country and experience a little bit of real hardship as he fights for the jobs that pay peanuts and needs to get special permission to come round visit his family. Once he is living the life he will be saying to himself why did I do such a stupid thing but by then he will no longer have his Israeli citizenship and the benefits that brings and of course he will be considered a traitor so he won't find it so easy to get back. I actually feel sorry for the guy because he is about to blow everything all because he has got some crazy idea into his head he wants to become a palestinian resistance fighter.
Next talkbacks
Back to article