News
4 Neturei Karta youths implicated in Yad Vashem vandalism
Itamar Fleishman
Published: 26.06.12, 14:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
73 Talkbacks for this article
1. Anti-Israel and anti-Zionist
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.26.12)
Neturei Karta and/or Satmer. They are not Jews. There is no place for them in the State of Israel. They do not recognize the State of Israel, but they sure have NO problem taking money, goods and services from the very entity they do not recognize. What a disgraceful bunch of hypocritical leeches.
2. What are they taught?
Ric ,   Gosport, UK   (06.26.12)
Silly little buggers! Fortunately Israel is robust enough to shrug off such egregious stupidity. It makes you wonder, though, just what they are being taught in their yeshiva?
3. Sarah B is wrong
Maurice Solovitz ,   London England   (06.26.12)
The Anti-Zionists Jews do not generally take money from the state. While i agree with you that their aberrant version of my faith fails - they have lots of fans in the ultra-orthodox community and that is their true threat.
4. Our ultra orthadox friends what a surprise
Haim ,   TA   (06.26.12)
5. Jugde them as TRAITORS
Deena   (06.26.12)
So others will think twice before doing stupid things like these.
6. 2 No rotten apples in State schools?
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (06.26.12)
7. These are Jews?
Yakov ,   Tel Aviv   (06.26.12)
How is it, that these criminals are labelled religious Jew's? How could they be even called Jew's, if they feel it acceptable to desecrate Yad Vashem, then they are not Jew's of any type. Yad Vashem honors the memory's of the six million murdered, for nothing more than being Jewish. It is not political or Israeli, it is not Zionist or promoting a Jewish agenda. It is a memorial. To desecrate Yad Vashem, dishonors themselves as Jew's and as Human's. This is against everything that defines a good Jew. They are criminals, vandals, and antisocial. If they receive public assistance, this MUST STOP!
8. They will be released
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (06.26.12)
PLO flags? Then they are no different than Shalom Achsav, Meretz and Hadash. They will be released with no charges. Maybe they will even become professors at Ben-Gurion University.
9. Where does the infrastructure come from?
Shira Z ,   J'slm, Israel   (06.26.12)
They certainly do take money from the state! Ok I understand that Naturei Karta doesn't actually take cash, but if you live here and use the roads and sidewalks, electric, sewer, if you buy milk and bread or beat a woman for daring to sit in the front of the bus (all subsidized by the State) then you are in effect taking money from the State. And don't try to tell me that they don't use the kupot holim! Or that they won't get into an ambulance or go to the hospital in an emergency! And to the Haredi who spit on me and told me shiklsa get out (while I was on my way to my shabbat meal at my (normal) haredi brother's) - get off the streets that MY taxes pay for ya blondini, ya mamzer ibn cossack!
10. Sadly, typical BTs living in ultra-orthodox neighborhood
Chaim ,   Israel   (06.26.12)
who never got a proper Jewish education.
11. Haredim were not holocaust victims
Susya Bar Dror ,   Israel   (06.26.12)
only Jews have been murdered. But this is not a reason to vandalize our Yad Vashem! It is interesting to note, that in Israel the haredim are the only minority/entity which is acting against the state and against the Jewish population. Fie!
12. #8 Israeli ?
Haim ,   TA   (06.26.12)
Sewing the seeds of hatred i see, guess it distracts from what your ultra orthdox hereos have been up to. A pathetic attempt at the most to down play this act of sheer thoughtless vandalism Please provide solid evidence of Meretz supporters vandalizing Yad VaShem ?
13. If it walks like a duck
Haim ,   TA   (06.26.12)
quacks like a duck, looks like a duck then it must be a duck
14. Take away their citizenship
A ,   Belgium   (06.26.12)
and deport them to gazastan where they can live with their sub-human bretheren.
15. spray painting vandalism should have a harsh punishment
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (06.26.12)
I have noticed that the spray painting vandalism that is some times called graffiti in the states is on the increase here. I think a harsh punishment should be enacted and soon. I feel that those caught spray painting should be chained to the place that the painted and forced to clean it up. There should be signs notifying all that this is the punishment for all spray painting graffiti vandals. Enough!!
16. Twisted.
Mark ,   Toronto   (06.26.12)
If you are against Zionism, then you have an deological dispute with fellow Jews. However, to praise Hitler, and the Nazis who killed all kinds of Jews (including Satmar and Neuritis Karta), is despicable, and an insult not only to my grandparents, but to theirs as well. Enemies of the State - both Jew and Arab alike - must be stricken of citizenship.
17. TREASON
david ,   switzerland   (06.26.12)
Agree with Deena, the ones living in the State of Israel should be sued for treason!!
18. # 15 Larry great idea
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (06.26.12)
another added punishment could be that these spray painting vandals would have to be 'spray painted' with pro Israeli slogans or, even ones that read, " I am an graffiti anti Zionist terrorist ".. Then parade them all over Israel make a film for a 'keepsake" that's played at least once a week ALL over Israel. Jus sayin'......
19. # 14 A, Belgium, I like it..
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (06.26.12)
Wouldn't that be sweet, I'd pay to see that!
20. The anti Zionist Jews should not be in Israel.
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (06.26.12)
If they knew that G-d also chooses to reside in Zion it is His dwelling. ( it is written in the Torah) That they don't know this shows how little they study the Torah. They are hypocrites of the lowest order, living in a land other Jews died never having seen, "Next year Jerusalem." and, these trash buckets live on the backs of others who've paid with their lives. They are despicable, non Jews who are better suited as cattle fodder. Worthless trash! They live in a nation that fights for her life among heathen savages and act worse than them. Tax the shit out of them and encourage them to leave, they are like fleas on the backs of all others who have earned Israel as their home. How many dead Jews made way for these free loading 'give it to me free' anti semitic 'supposed' Jews? They make my stomach churn, vomit is better than this anti israel shit that keeps poring out of their mouths like diarrhea. end their 'educational' system, it is akin to the pals.......
21. I wonder
Rolly ,   Tampa, US   (06.26.12)
I wonder if the State will have the balls to charge these idiots, make the charges actually stick and send them to jail for the maximum allowable time. Somehow I doubt it.
22. Neturei Karta = part of haredi world
Ze'ev ,   Nbg, germany   (06.26.12)
but funny how that fact get avoided here^^
23. @3 we know she's wrong a great many times...
(06.26.12)
she lives in alternative reality where only she has the complete and real truth. We just ignore her.
24. #6 - rotten apples
Madeleine ,   Rehovot Israel   (06.26.12)
Of course there are rotten apples in state schools. What a stupid remark you made. this is about these apologies for human beings - who were sent to the gas ovens just the same as the most secular of Jews were. the thing is about crime among Haredim is that Haredim see themselves as oh, so much better than we seculars and think they have the right to preach to us about how we shoudl live our lives and are quick to tag every real tragedy with secular failure to keep the mitzvot. So yes, we will point fingers when haredim commit crimes. Get used to it.
25. #11
Madeleine ,   Rehovot Israel   (06.26.12)
How do you make out that haredim were not Holocaust victims? Plenty of footage that include the black coats and hats. do you really think Hitler differentiated between the ultra-orthodox and the barely Jewish?
26. How can "youths" be 18, 26 and 27? (end)
rob zenilman ,   Maale Adumim, Israel   (06.26.12)
27. High time to BAN this CRAZY SECT and KICK THEM OUT.
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (06.26.12)
28. #10 #13 These were haredim who became secular
(06.26.12)
Once they're secular they felt free to whatever they want.
29. To: No. 3
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.26.12)
The Neturei Karta do not take money from the State of Israel? Are you drunk, or on drugs? They bleed the State of Israel like the leeches they are. Neither do they have a great many fans in the ultra-Orthodox community. Certainly not among the Lubavitch, the Ger, or the Bobov, who are the largest Chasidic sects in Israel. The three foregoing sects are Zionist. The Neturei Karta are not, although that has not stopped them from taking their genetically compromised and seriously damaged offspring for treatment at Israeli medical clinics. Nor has it stopped them from taking State-sponsored subsidies to keep the roofs over their heads, and to provide food for their tables. They are leeches; violent leeches at that, and should be evicted from the State of Israel. There are plenty of loyal and dedicated Israelis who can use the millions and millions of shekels that are spent on the Neturei Karta. Israelis that do not attend anti-Zionist convocations in Teheran. I think the whole lot of those disreputable Neturei Karta should be shipped off to Teheran, or Gaza, or Ramallah or anywhere else. Their very presence in the State of Israel is an abomination. They are not Jews, and have no right to live in a country whose right to exist they do not accept. They are truly a pox upon our house, and we need to send them packing.
30. 24 YOU Madeleine are quicker..
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (06.26.12)
than Haredim to point a finger to those that think differently than you. Notice that i do not say :secular are quicker to.... Stereotyping is to low level.
Next talkbacks
Back to article