Jewish Scene
'Israel has no right to interfere on Temple Mount'
Ynet
Published: 03.07.12, 14:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
20 Talkbacks for this article
1. Stain
Dan ,   Florida - Tel Aviv   (07.03.12)
That the Muslims were given control of Temple Mount is a stain on Israel that will surely come back to stab us in the heart. While we have tolerance for other religions, the Muslims, 7th century barbarians, have none. The Temple Mount has NO religious significance to Muslims, this I advocate that the next time the Muslims riot on Temple Mount, the IDF must retake this vital piece of land.
2. Tombuktu
Raphael ,   Netanya   (07.03.12)
In the meantime, radical ilsamists of Al Qaeda Maghreb are destroying dozens of mosques, shrines, and moslem sacred monuments, all classified by UNESCO, without the moslem crowds lifting an eyebrow. Why should we allow a dome covered with gold offered by Mussolini to offend our view? Moshe Dayan should have done the work in 1967, instead of playing the do gooder.
3. And Bibi is sitting quivering on his hands
Ralph Haglund ,   Sweden   (07.03.12)
dead scared of showing strength in the face of the Arabs, well knowing their contempt for weakness - but showing it to them all the time to make them happy. Maybe they come to the peace discussions then huh????? The dome on the Temple Mount is NO mosque, al Aqsa is a lightly fixed-up byzantine church that was a church when Muhammed was supposed to have come there on his flying camel. There are lots of israeli police making sure no Jewish-looking person comes too close, but not a single one to stop the muslims from destroying. And it has been so for a long long time showing every muslim that Israel is not the Jewish Land. Bibi must have a special reaon not to show strength. Order from Barak?
4. Why isn't anyone protesting?
M ,   Israel   (07.03.12)
Where are all the haredi now? Isn't this the type of thing that should be enraging them? Or do they only care what the seculars do on shabbat?
5. Israel's police are working for the Wakf
Rafael ,   Yerushalayim   (07.03.12)
Rabbi Yisrael Ariel, one of the liberators of the Temple Mount in 1967 is currently being investigated by the police for the crime of "praying" on the Mount. Meanwhile this desecration goes unpunished. Why do the Israeli police do the bidding of the Wakf, haters of Israel? Are the so-called democratic principles of the state of Israel not worth the paper they are written on?
6. no. dayan made a grave mistake. never should have given up
RALPH   (07.03.12)
up total control. it will be much harder now. but they must be made to share
7. Are they accepting the Jewish character of the Temple Mount?
Joe ,   USA   (07.03.12)
This phrase means to me that the top islamic/palestinian organizations are now accepting the Jewish character of Yerushalaim: (quote) "The Islamic Waqf, Hamas and the Iranian government declare daily that they are working to remove every remnant of the temple and the holy of holies of the Israeli nation from the Temple Mount,"
8. "Palestinian" arrogance feeds off Israeli cowardice.
Chaim ,   Israel   (07.03.12)
Israel should have unequivocally claimed the Temple Mount, and all of our lands, long ago. Our failure to to do, and sick policies of appeasement and retreat, fuel the constant growth of "Palestinian" arrogance. The solution is as simple as the problem. Claim all our lands. Stop playing games with our genocidal enemies.
9. Take STING out=REMOVAL hostile MAGNET buildings Temple Mount
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (07.03.12)
10. Temple Mount
graczek ,   Maryland, USA   (07.04.12)
The Temple Mount was lost to the Israelites in 70 AD because of their ongoing continued sinfulness. This was Divine Edict. They have no right to be there today, nor do they even have the right to usurp the Holy Land, as they did from 1876 until the present. God's Will eventually will be done.
11. Jews need patience
Stephan ,   Munich, Germany   (07.04.12)
and trust in the Lord. Soon there will be a new Temple and the proud eyes (of Arabs) will sink. Right now all predictions of the Prophets are coming true, just look into the world! And when everything has been fulfilled, the new time will begin. And there will be a radical turn in human history to Shalom.
12. Jews simply need to demand the government enforce the RoL
SAD ,   in Israel   (07.04.12)
RIGHT OF LAW. No construction or digging can take place in Israel until the Antiquity Authority assures that no ANTIGUITIES will be harmed. Of course this has never happened on the TM because the people do not protest, rabbis do not protest.... Supreme Court has said: Jews have right to pray on TM but police don't enforce it. People don't care, rabbis don't care.... When the jewish people start to care... theywill understand what they have to do.
13. 10 graczek, read your scripture again...
mary_of_bethanys ,   singapore   (07.04.12)
And it shall come to pass in that day, that I will seek to destroy all the nations that come against Jerusalem. And I will pour upon the house of David, and upon the inhabitants of Jerusalem, the spirit of grace and of supplications: and they shall look upon me whom they have pierced, and they shall mourn for him, as one mourneth for his only son, and shall be in bitterness for him, as one that is in bitterness for his firstborn. Zechariah 12:9-10 all verses that prophecize that Israel will return to her homeland has been fulfilled. now awaiting the fulfilling those saying Israel will be strengthened by G-D Himself against the enemies nations. Zechariah 12:2-6, Zechariah 8:20-23, Zechariah 8:20-23 the problems with you leftists are you choose what verses that suit you,then spiritualize away the actual meaning to mean something else as you like. if it is not G-D Himself who help, how can the Nation of Israel not extinct since 70 AD disperse into the whole world? and long before that, during Babylonian captivity? you speak freely of G-D's Will, show from scripture where did it say HE is finished with Israel!
14. World Heritage Site?
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (07.04.12)
Is the Foundation Stone in the Dome a UNESCO World Heritage site? Has UNESCO been involved? Have the Mekublim been consulted? Is this desecration a sign that we are lessening the Kedushas HaAretz by accepting Reform rabbis in our established Orthodox religion? By threatening to draft those who study Torah 'day and night'? When the Temple stood,only the holiest person entered the holiest spot and pronounced the holiest Name on the holiest Day of Atonement.
15. 10 graczek, read Rev 7:14
mary_of_bethany ,   singapore   (07.04.12)
"And i heard the number of them which were sealed, and there were sealed an hundred and forty and four thousand of ALL the TRIBES of the CHILDREN OF ISRAEL". Revelation 7:4 the tribes of Israel is liberality the 12 tribes, don't dare to spiritualize it away to mean something else. no other nations in this world, no even Americans or Brits or Chinese or Germans are mentioned here, only one Nation: Israel! such is the uniqueness of G-D's love for these people. ynetnew, kindly post, toda.
16. al-Aqsa mosque is the third temple
Joe ,   Australia   (07.04.12)
Muslims worship the same god of Abraham, Ismael, Ishaq and Yaqob, ..., Jesus and Mohammed. al-Aqsa mosque is the temple where they worship that god. Pity, it will be too late before we understand.
17. The Temple Un-mount
ik ,   USA   (07.04.12)
It's time to send in the IDF to protect the heart of Israel and Judaism.
18. Temple Mount
Syd Chaden ,   Palermo Calif USA   (07.05.12)
All over the world, mosques sit on the sites of demolished Jewish temples. Today, in Muslim countries, and in non-Muslim countries, synagogues are frequently attacked by Muslims. The UN, little more than the voice of the Muslim World, has nothing to say about this. Europe could care less. The politically correct crowd in the US either ignores it or blames it on Israel. And so, what about Israel? Israel is giving de facto approval to this thousand-year old attack on the Jewish religion, by virtue of its passiveness and silence regarding the Temple Mount. The rationale is that Israel is showing respect for all religions, including Islam. But, the the fact is that all religions do not show respect for Judaism. The Quran, in fact, calls for death to the Jews. Israel should announce that if another synagogue is attacked by Muslim activists, the Temple Mount will be closed to Muslims, as it is to Jews. And, if Israel is attacked again, whether it be by Iran, or Syria, or Egypt, or any other Muslim country, its first reaction should be to demolish the mosque on the Temple Mount.
19. Number 18 Reply
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (07.05.12)
There have only ever been two Jewish Temples, and they were both on the Temple Mount. I assume you mean synagogues. Muslims have also built mosques on the sites of Christian Cathedrals like Haga Sophia, but then Christians 'converted' pagan temples like the Pantheon into churches. The Mosque and the Dome will be replaced in Messianic times, when 'My House [Jerusalem] will be called a House of Prayer for ALL peoples.'. It's not for us to destroy.
20. Herod was the worst vandal
Tzimmes ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (07.05.12)
When Herod wanted to expand the second temple in order to create a larger platform he flattened the top of Mt Moriah. This proberbly destroyed any of the remnants of the true temple,that of King Solomon. The second Herodian temple was a status symbol with over 300 High priests and well fed retinue. We should not place too much romance on the Herodian edifice ,suffice to say the Mountain and spot where our Jewish King Solomon built his temple has not moved. P.S. I love Sarah B.
Back to article