News
Petition: Yishai's plan to detain migrants 'barbaric'
Omri Efraim
Published: 03.10.12, 22:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
13 Talkbacks for this article
1. the only human rights that don't matter are Israeli ones
zionist forever   (10.03.12)
I am sick of all the human rights do gooders who want to save everybody else in the country except Israelis themselves. These people are here illegally and Israel is not a beach resort for refugees & economic migrants to come to and start new lives. If they are legitimate refugees and its not safe to send them home then why can't they stay in a detention centre designed to hold refugees? Why do we need to provide them all with jobs, schooling and apartments in Tel Aviv? When its safe to send them home we know where they are ( South Sudan is also safe now even if the north is not ). With economic migrants we have them all in one place already so its easy to stick them on the available flight home at their own expense. Detain refugees & deport illegals now
2. #1: well said
Yosi ,   Tel Aviv   (10.03.12)
3. human rights outcry
philimax ,   USA   (10.04.12)
Easy solution: Have the Human rights group fund jobs, housing,education,health care and other amenities to these refugees...preferably at their (the Human Rights Groups) homes.
4. Herzyls vision
Zivron   (10.04.12)
This is far from the princely Herzl vision of a bourgeoise human rights democracy that would have Jews and Arabs settle any where have equal rights and gradually civilise and I'm sure help refugees.Sure Herzyl was a Dreamer and Diplomat not a Warrior faced with feral reality. Still Israel is a spacious land and technology even nanotechnology allows mega cities and a population of fifty million. The Sudanese ought be trained and educated in Israel allowing an enriched return to their birthplaces after the danger subsides.
5. A peace treaty was just signed
Reuvern   (10.04.12)
between the two Sudans. Send these illegals back, before we lose the world's only Jewish nation. Keep them incarcerated until they are returned.
6. I left USA...
David ,   Rishon LeTiyon   (10.04.12)
...to get away from the scenes like the ones in the photo above. Frankly speaking, they are not fit from civilization. In small numbers, they are nice, and quaint. In large numbers, they are loud, obnoxious, and foul up neighborhoods and dumb down schools. Thanks a lot, leftnkiks, for letting these people in. They'll never leave.
7.  migrants
alex ,   ashkelon israel   (10.04.12)
he is doing absolutly right thing and said right thing we do not give a demn about criticisem isral must be jewish state and all those right group can go to hell
8. to #4
philimax ,   USA   (10.04.12)
Ready to accept contributions from you and all well wishers to integrate foreign aliens illegally entering Israel. Surely there is no other place on earth for them to encamp.
9. Irony??
Greg   (10.04.12)
Anyone see it
10. The word 'infiltrators' to describe refugees is repulsive
james ,   london england   (10.04.12)
11. What rights activists never mention is a number limit
Tracy W   (10.04.12)
It sounds very nice to be helpful and humanitarian. But we know that there are millions of Africans who live under oppressive regimes. Climate change is also aggravating the scarcity of food. Do human rights activists have any notion whatsoever as to the number of Africans Israel can absorb? Or do they expect Israel to have an unlimited willingness to take in whoever shows up at the border? Turkey put a limit to the number of Syrian refugees it could take in: 100,000. What would be Israel's limit for African refugees, considering that Turkey is 38 times bigger than Israel?
12. Yishai is a Baboon
(10.04.12)
13. African Illegals~Not Refugees
Nili   (10.04.12)
Refugees apply through proper channels. These illegals sneak across the border. They are not Jewish~many are Muslims. Their contribution is crime, disease and destruction of Jewish neighborhoods. I am fed up with being pushed around and threatened every day by these creeps. What about the rights of Israeli citizens? Ship the lot of the out!
Back to article