Culture  Media&Internet
Einstein letter on God auctioned on eBay
Leonard Carl and AP
Published: 09.10.12, 07:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
8 Talkbacks for this article
1. Even great minds can err
Igor ,   Germany   (10.09.12)
I wouldn't argue with Einstein about physics, but here he's below his intellectual capabilities. "Primitive legends": Torah was written for humans, so that they understand it and emotionally connect to it. It is childish to expect it to be written in relativistic and quantum mechanic formulas. Still, it carries strong moral messages, which were unknown to other peoples of that time. Which brings us to the "chosen people": Somehow it happened that Jews carried these moral messages to other peoples; messages which form the basis of what we today call "civilization".
2. genius, but in what field
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (10.09.12)
Einstein was known as a genius, but his genius was in physics. He seemed to have difficulty in other fields such as human relationships such as politics and marriage. So to take his genius and extrapolated it into religion, is as foolish as taking a doctor's advice on the stock market or going to your stock broker to get advice on your medical ailment.
3. Einstein also said...
ILAN ,   ISRAEL   (10.09.12)
"The INTUITIVE MIND is a SACRED GIFT and the rational mind is a faithful servant..We have created a society that honors the servant and has forgotten the GIFT" SACRED GIFT from whom? From Big Bang? THE INTUITIVE MIND might be his vision of the soul. A letter about his above comment would be worth something,while this for sale letter, is the opinion of a genius in science who has no clue about Jewish religion,and is consequently worthless.
4. he hit the nail on the head!
iselin ,   Oslo, Norway   (10.09.12)
Thumbs up for Einstein! He got it right.
5. Einstein said "GOD doesn't......
Wow! ,   Israel   (10.10.12)
.....play dice" meaning God is deter- ministc, not randomly playing with the Universe, rather fixing his LAWS in it. Of course he wasn't a stupid atheist. But it's high time to differen- tiate the beleve in GOD from the believe in the Deity of the israelites and the Bible, two completely dif- fferent things. GOD is philosophy, Bible is religion, and Philosophy is in an infinitely superior level than religion....
6. Einstein said many things some stupid
FarFromPerfect ,   Jerusalem Israel   (10.10.12)
Einstein came from a very assimilated family and had virtually no religious education this should be part of his religious equation
7. But , at least one rabbi asked for his opinion
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.13.12)
Why if he had "no clue" about the Jewish religion ?
8. Did Einstein know .....
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (10.13.12)
that there was light, and day and night, even before the creation of the sun,moon and stars? That is what we learn in the Parasha from this week: Bereshit.
Back to article