Opinion
Keep Deri out of politics
Yigal Sarna
Published: 18.10.12, 00:42
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
1. Jail
michael Pielet ,   israel   (10.18.12)
Send deri back to jail.
2. Ok Yigal, so what....
Bluegrass Picker ,   Afula   (10.18.12)
....what punishment and permanent sanctions do you propose for dishonest and unethical journalists?
3. Absurd and Naive
Abdel Karim Salim ,   Jerusalem   (10.18.12)
The minister's first and biggest commitment is always to his country's best interest regardless of emotions . The writer hereby seems to be launching a crusade on behalf of foreigners without bothering to think of the heavy and negative burdens those foreigners would bring to the society and economy . People in Tel Aviv are already demonstrating for social justice . Unemployment and inflation regularly batter the economy . Recent report by the Central Bureau of Statistics predicts a higher level of poverty this year ( 31% of people under poverty line ) . A remarkably-higher level of crime is already plaguing big cities especially Tel Aviv ( theft , murder , rape , etc...) . Native arabs of East Jerusalem ( Arabs born here for generations already ) are still struggling to get more political and social rights ( jobs , voting rights, ...) . And security issues have for the past six decades kept Israel on high alert ( gone are the days of Egypt's Nasser... Now you have HAMAS, Hizbullah, Syria and Iran which have unprecedentedly struck the very depth of Israel )... And the recent volatile socio-political situation in neighboring arab countries ( Arab Springs ) has made our region less secure and stable )... ! Let the writer consider all these facts before shedding any sympathy to outsiders and foreigners. But I give one high mark to him for voicing his opposition to any comeback of any politician who breached the people's trust by trying to enrich himself off our backs... !
4. Deri Niet
TB ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (10.18.12)
Deri, together w/Peres was the engineer of the 'Targil HaMasriach' (Stinking trick) and consequent Oslo Accords that brought Arafat and the PLO to life. Directly causing the deaths and maiming of thousands of Jews and Arabs. He (like Peres) is VERY clever and a menace to mankind. His arrest was a miracle! It is a mistake to support him. .
5. How was Deri moral?
Rachel ,   US   (10.18.12)
Because he sold out Israel for the Oslo Accords? He and Olmert are crooks.
6. So Yishai was promoting himself, was cruel and probably wan-
tom ,   tel aviv   (10.18.12)
ted to shove Sharia (excuse me:Torah-Law) down our throats? On the other hand, we have this virtual Angel of selfless, public sacrifice, who would love nothing more than seeing a plural, free society, where people ride on buses 7 days a week and can get officialy married/buried in any form they choose? Yeah , right!
7. I agree
Norman Gellman ,   Rehovot   (10.18.12)
Letting Deri back into politics is like erasing his past actions and giving him another chance to take criminal action
8. Shas
David Goldberger ,   Cooper City,Florida   (10.18.12)
The real problem is keeping the corrupt parasitic Shas out of any future coalition .Too bad Bibi has no morality.
9. Deri
Sylvia Landman ,   Raanana, Israel   (10.18.12)
We need clean politicians. A new generation not these old corrupt people. Lets ban anyone with a shadow on their character
10. Deri and the hidden agenda
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (10.18.12)
what do you want? his blood? be fair, if the man spent time in jail and now has repented for his miss-actions, and if the law permits him to return to politics, why is everyone screaming? Perhaps they are jealous of his abilties, charm, and popular support? Perhaps they are afraid that the religious will get even more votes? I suspect a hidden agenda in all of this.
11. Olmert
Holyland ,   Jerusalem Israel   (10.18.12)
IF BOTH Olmert and Deri stay out of the election - THEN Agreed Else - is one better than the other?
12. Keep Shas out of politics
Avi ,   Israel   (10.18.12)
13. sad hatred from a sad man
avi ,   Israel   (10.18.12)
Your hatred is apparent in your article.I dont how old you are but mature discourse is clearly not your thing. slandering and badmouthing rarely benefits anyone.People do not have to agree with you ,accept other people ,and their opinions ,you dont have to agree with them...to do otherwise is immature arrogance....I hope you learn to make your point through peace and not hatred
14. Olmert was not acquited!
Daniel ,   IL _ TA   (10.18.12)
Sorry but the nonesense the writer spreads is a waste of tiem. Also stating that olmert was not acquited is a blatent lie. The cangeroo courts of israel let him of because they set the bar for proving abuse of power and fraud much higher for public officials than members of the general public. right smells of bana republic courts. I am certain that deri would have been convicted for life with the same evidence. AND NO I WAS BORN AND RAISED IN EUROPE!
15. Bet u a 1$
Gill ,   MontrĂ©al   (10.18.12)
He will one day be the prime minister of Israel. You people have no idea how intelligent he is.
16. Get with the program
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (10.18.12)
Sarna apparently did not get the party memo: Deri is good. All Sarna has to do is listen to the radio to hear condescending talk of how Deri will return Shas to its warm and fuzzy "Bet Abba" social issues instead of the right-wing Ishai and the evil Ashkenazim. If the Zionists lose the next election, you will see Ministers Deri and Lapid kissing each other while they violently evict Jews from their homes in Judea, Samaria, Golan and Jerusalem. Lapid will tell us of the important work Shas does in educating the underprivileged and how Haredim are unsuited for army service.
17. The Knesset needs more people
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (10.18.12)
like Deri. He is a real "Mensch" If he made a mistake,he paid heavily. Let s move on.
18. Hypocrisy oh Hypocrisy !!!!
S Judah ,   Jerusalem   (10.18.12)
What sin do we see? When it seemed Deri might set up an alternative party and pick up votes from Shas, oh how the non Sephardi seculars lauded and promoted the idea. But now that he is back and will strenthen Shas, the cry babies are out crying foul. There is a foul smell but it doesn't come from Shas or Deri
19. 18 When they give,take...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (10.18.12)
when they take,yell. That is not hypocrisy,that is very human.
20. please keep him out we beg hashem .
alan ashkenazie ,   nyc ny   (10.18.12)
we beg rav ovadia we beg all who we can to get him away from us.
21. What a disgrace
Mark Weisgold ,   Israel   (10.19.12)
How I wqanted to vomit when I saw both men sitting together on the tv. They were like kissing cousins. While underneath it all is pure hatred. Only here can we we a convicted person back in the givernment, I through my hands up.
22. Deri deserves an Oscar!
Alfredo ,   Raanana   (10.19.12)
For looking so pious
23. Deri and the hidden agenda
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (10.20.12)
The punishment that the court gave him Deri served. The state did not forbid him to re-enter politics as part of his crime and punishment. Why all of a sudden comes a cry from the self-righteous to ban him from politics after the court of law allowed him to return? It is just jealousy and hate mixed with fear that he will bring more votes to the 'hated' Shas party. Well hidden agendas are 'treif' in politics as well as miss informed opinion articles too.
24. I agree, Deri should not be in the Knesset.
Susan ,   Kfar Saba   (10.21.12)
But I dont agree that Yishai is a racist. He wants to protect Israel as a Jewishf state. If we are not careful we will wake up sooner that you think and be a minority in our own country. Just because he wants to deport non-Jewish foriegners doesnt make him a racist. Like I always say, Im not against gentiles, Im just for Jews. However, I agree that Deri, as a convicted felon, should never be allowed to serve in public office. I had doubts as to his guilt and the fairness of his trial, but he is a convicted felon nontheless. If he is innocent he should appeal. In my former State of Maryland, we had a governor in the early 70s, Marvin Mandel, who was convicted of some kind of money crimes regarding the horse races. I dont really understand it all as I was a kid at the time. He was convicted and served time in jail. He lost his law license and his pension. After more than 20 years, on appeal he was found not guilty. Unfortunately, Mandel had no choice but to work into his old age because of his lack of pension. If Deri is innocent he should never give up his pursuit of justice, but we can't have convicts in the Knesset and that goes ditto for Olmert.
25. Let's take ALL religious parties OUT of Knesseth
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.22.12)
The most they do is blackmailing the governement to receive more money , to impose their "lifestyle" on everyone . And some are'nt even ministers , only vice ministers , because of their "religion"
26. 17 . A "mensch" does NOT take 155.000 US$ bribes
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.22.12)
Any politician who has comitted a crime , should be barred ad eternum from political life . Those who are suspected [ Olmert , liberman , as the best known ] should leave politics until declared 100 % innocent .
27. The 25 TBer is free of prejudice.
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (10.22.12)
He hates all religious parties equally.
28. 26 A Mensch is somebody who...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (10.22.12)
devotes his life to people in need. The bribes,[which i dont approve] served to help those people. He paid for his mistake.
29. Ora , no , bribes are bribes
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.23.12)
There is NO reason to take bribes , not even to help others . Can you prove that he gave those 155,000 US$ to needy ? that he did take those bribes ONLY to help others ? It was not a mistake , you are not jailed for a mistake , it was a CRIME Regarding religious parties , rabbanim have their place in a beth knesset , not in the Knesset . Why is the charidi vice minister of health only "VICE minister" ? and not MINISTER ?
30. No Ora , bribes are bribes TRY # 2
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.23.12)
There is NO reason to take bribes , not even to help others . Can you prove that he gave those 155,000 US$ to needy ? that he did take those bribes ONLY to help others ? It was not a mistake , you are not jailed for a mistake , it was a CRIME Regarding religious parties , rabbanim have their place in a beth knesset , not in the Knesset . Why is the charidi vice minister of health only "VICE minister" ? and not MINISTER ?
Next talkbacks
Back to article