Jewish Scene
Jewish gravestones desecrated in New Zealand
AFP
Published: 19.10.12, 07:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
1. In Hungary
Istvan ,   BUDAPEST HUNGARY   (10.19.12)
no week without desecration of jewish monuments or cemetries.
2. NZ Jews need wake-up call
True Zionist ,   Israel   (10.19.12)
Most kiwi Jews live in a fool's paradise. True it's a beautiful country, but scratch beneath the surface and the writing is on the wall, or in this case on grave stones. Get a real life and move to the true Jewish Homeland now. You're forfeiting a Jewish life in Israel remaining in a land where religion is looked down upon, specially Judaism - you know it and I know it. Do you really want to go down to your graves in a foreign land where even your name will be desecrated?
3. What ?! in the PC Capitol of the World !!
TheUglyNewZealanders ,   Jerusalem Israel   (10.19.12)
4. Desecration
Mark ,   Melbourne   (10.19.12)
It could have just been 1 person or two. You can not assume from that as some have, that NZ is not a good place for Jews to live. There are idiots in every society. Society can not be condemned for the crazy actions of a few
5. NZ should Get tough with Neo-Nazi
Joseph ,   New Zealand   (10.19.12)
The Neo-Nazi supporters move and operate freely in NZ. I hope that the current prime minister who is Jewish will do something about it.
6. #2 move to Israel and do what? take a career dive and pay
Jason ,   Sydney / Tel Aviv   (10.19.12)
100% more for everything in life? grow up true zionist, i made aliyah from australia, biggest mistake of MY LIFE, and living here has made me love my native Australia more than I ever have before. After 3 years here, I'm like whatever.. bye, great for a holiday here but to live here.. simply awful.. (not everything, but almost).
7. Brave grave desecraters
big bad Jew ,   United States   (10.19.12)
they aim for the dead who can't defend themselves. Real heroes, eh? Then, they go home and beat their wife and kids, nice guys.
8. # 1 Security cameras anyone?
big bad Jew ,   United States   (10.19.12)
And how about a few attack dogs to help warn others and to protect the dead?
9. What a pathetic thing to do
ky   (10.19.12)
I feel so sorry for the sad cases that done this They deserve pity for their lunacy but also deserve being brought to justice for a crime when you think of what became of Hitler and his followers. He was not even man enough to face up to the justice that awaited him. . He had to end his life by his own hand . They are jealous of the fact that these people had decent and honest lives and had memorials to mark their lives but their hero does not have a spot or place to remember his worthless life.This was their hero . someone who the world doesn't have a place for even when dead and gone.! Those who done this will also one day come to face the consequences of their deeds.
10. #8: hungary isn't brooklyn
tom ,   toronto, canada   (10.19.12)
it's easy to give pat answers if you don't understand the question. the Jewish community of hungary traces its origins back to roman times. and by 1900 there were Jews in every town and village throughout hungary. 1/3 of budapest was jewish. and then came the holocaust, communism, assimilation, and emigration. in hungary today, there are a lot of jewish graves and a very few jews to look after them. who looks after the jewish cemetery in bogaloosa, louisiana, with "video cameras and guard dogs", once the jewish community is gone?
11. no #2 get real
Tanya ,   New Zealand   (10.19.12)
My husband is an Israeli living in New Zealand, I have often broached the subject of us moving to Israel and he is against it, he earns good money in NZ, our kids have a great life, we own a house and have everything at our finger tips,(except cheap travel) He has never experienced anti Semitism here, and we live a good life. We are in Israel now on vacation and this trip especially have found everything a drama, from getting a phone sim card to work properly or even to find a place to top it up, from the incredibly rude people in stores, petrol stations, boutiques, etc... I am a huge advocate of Israel and love it here, but this time round I really have found it trying at times especially the rudeness of people who are trying to make money who dont think it is rude to smoke and talk on the phone while you are trying to pay for something or ask about something you want to purchase....a smile goes a long way!!! Getting to the graffiti on the tombstones....disgusting to say the least, but this does not reflect the general tone of the population, the acts of one or two idiots does not deem the nation anti Semitic , it just proves there are idiot uneducated thugs in every nation .. including NZ and Israel. NZ is not perfect, like most nations...and as someone here said the PC correct captial of the world or such.....we are all sick of the PC crap that our country assumes ...it does not make us anything other than the same as most other western nations trying to do the right thing by its people and satisfying but a few. Our Prime Minister is Jewish....just a fact you might want to know. the Anti NZ rhetoric is a bit pathetic in context to a few thugs and a spraycan incident...you should be getting riled up at the pro Palestinian marches that happen every time Israel coughs, they happen on a regular basis But that does not deem us Anti Semitic ..... NZ is a multi cultural country with many religions and beliefs, not everyone is going to like everyone or agree with everyones belief system ... thats normal. and there is always going to be thugs and trash trying to put their message across, you will find most NZers will find this desecration disgusting. And by the way, religion is not looked down on in NZ, where are you getting your info? People are free to have whatever belief they choose...if they choose not to. so be it, you should not lose sleep over it.
12. Life in the golus is just grand...
Al   (10.19.12)
then afterlife as a dead body is pure hell.. Wake up the Golus has outlived its expiry date.
13. #6 then by all means leave..you wont be missed
Al   (10.19.12)
that I can promise you........
14. Jewish gravestones desecrated in NZ
Harold ,   USA   (10.19.12)
Why Jew are disliked by many. Have they done anything wrong.
15. Worshipping Hitler ...
Toby   (10.19.12)
Worshipping Hitler? The loser who had to kill his wife Eva and then himself because he was about to be captured alive while his 3rd Reich was in total shambles costing millions of lives on all sides, and Germany carpet bombed to smithereens! His lapdog Axis partner Mussolini and his wife killed, hung upside and spat on my their own people. The 3rd member of the Axis Powers, Japan —the only nation to be nuked, for it's role in the barbarism of WWII. And these modern day fools worship Hitler? How ignorant can these FOOLS be? All they have to do is to review the horrors, failures and evils of history, but no, they would rather remain IGNORANT FOOLS! Hitler, the etenal loser damned and relegated to an eternity in hell. He deserves it!!! And fools still worship him!!!
16. root cause of anti-semetism
Arnold ,   Montreal-Canada   (10.19.12)
If a survey was taken on the root cause of Christain dislike of the Jewish people it would go back to the execution of Jesus. We Jews have been blamed for his death. I can accept that. I am not happy about it but I can accept it. Now I ask this question. If we Jewish people were responsible for the death of Jesus then that proves we Jewish people lived in Palestine at that time. Judaism was the established religion followed by Christianity. Islam came to Palestine centuries later. Therefore either Jews deserve your hatred for killing Jesus in Palestine or killing him in Russia, Poland, or Germany where it seems you think we Jews originated from. You cannot have it both ways. Science and time lines do not allow it. I can accept your hatred for the death of Jesus in Palestine but then I cannot accept your saying we do not come from there.
17. # 6 &11 Stay downunder
True Zionist ,   Israel   (10.19.12)
What goes round comes round. Funny, but since leaving downunder for Israel, I've had mostly great relationships with Israelis. I guess if you want to judge a few Israelis like Tanya's husband in NZ who cares more about integrating into a foreign culture while the easy life is good, than stay downunder. Israel is the Jewish Homeland to live in, and NZ & Aussie are as good a place to die in as anywhere else. Just feel good that you won't be able to complain when someone writes nasty words against your Jewish soul after you depart. Who knows your kids might become so assimiliated that they may even write a PS on your gravestone. For the record I think most Kiwis are good people, but don't think that Jews pretending to be something else is also so good.
18. explanation for anti-semitism
Michele ,   MInneapolis, MN   (10.19.12)
Try to get a copy of a book called "Why the Jews?" by Dennis Prager. It is a quick read but offers explanations for Jew hatred.
19. #8 Jason - Don't forget to return
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (10.19.12)
all of the Tax Free goodies you got since you're received while here Including tasx free cars & appliances
20. #14 Harold - Graves were disturbed
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (10.19.12)
because cowards like you, didn't have the guts to to mess with living Jews Four Major Israel-Arabs wars & you lost all of them
21. There are NO reasons for antisemitism
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.19.12)
You can hate a person you know , but not a whole population whom you sometimes never met any from .
22. calm down
Jonah ,   Chicago   (10.19.12)
Ok, so a few losers trash some headstones..... but to say this somehow represents the feelings/attitudes of 3 million New Zealanders is lame. Some might call it anti-kiwi-etic
23. When will israel do something against anti-Christian and
Amrican2 ,   USA   (10.19.12)
anti-Moselim attacks. Prehaps tone of the causes of anti-semtic attacks is israeli's treatment of the non-jew. Failure to ctach "price-taggers" The world-wide Jewish communities unwaivering support (righ or wrong, moral or immoral, legal or illegal) of israel.
24. #20
Harold ,   USA   (10.19.12)
I am not a coward but cowards like you were unable to assassinate Hitler and save 6 million Jewsish lives. Just immagine 6 Million did not do anything to avoid the HOLOCAUST.
25. #21 Charles
Melvin Snerdley ,   Wisconsin   (10.19.12)
You and Ben Jabo seem to hate each other, when was the last time you had met?
26. #13 you were never here to be missed, mr CANADA..
(10.19.12)
27. #11 - 100% Tanya!!!
(10.19.12)
totally agree
28. #17 olim come and go, its the weirdos who no ambitions who
Orly   (10.19.12)
stay
29.  "urged New Zealand authorities to bring vandals to justice"
k ,   US   (10.19.12)
Don't Jews get this is why people hate the Jews, because they always "demand" others do something for them Jews need to either grow some balls and either kill the people who commit these attacks (or who allow them to take place), or suck it up and try and defeat these people in your own way, telling others to do the work for you will get people to hate the Jews
30. People enjoy blaming the Jews
k ,   US   (10.19.12)
all of you people who are wondering why are people "anti-semitic" People have a joy out of blaming the Jews, whether it is Israel or the Jews, people get a thrill out of it Jews can not understand because there is no one beneath them and Jews do not get a thrill out of putting others down But for the anti-semites, wether they are Christian, or Muslim or whatever, it is something they enjoy
Next talkbacks
Back to article