Palestinians: Israel demands 15-year lull, Morsi guarantee
Elior Levy
Published: 19.11.12, 03:13
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
72 Talkbacks for this article
1. Hamas is done for.
Miron ,   USA   (11.19.12)
2. Those are reasonable demands
Salim ,   Canada   (11.19.12)
I can't see how any other country would accept anything less from a terrorist entity that has genocide as its principle objective. I would add war crimes trials for the leaders of these terror gangs. Hamas will either have to accept being de-militarized, or face annihilation. There is no other way to solve the problem of these troublemakers. Go IDF Go!! Get rid of this evil thorn in Israel's side forever!!!
3. Gaza War
David ,   USA   (11.19.12)
Mashaal should be targeted for assassination.
4. finally some sense.
Daniel ,   Tracy USA   (11.19.12)
Let's face it, this is and is supposed to be a one sided demand. Israel has sat by while rockets were fired indiscriminately into Israel. Now it is time to clean up this mess once and for all. Hamas will probably not back down, for if the Israel demands outlined in the article are true, then they would not save any face in this deal. My guess is this will be seven to ten weeks of ground work. Soldiers will be in harms way, but it is the only way to clear the Gaza area of arms, rockets, and IDE's. My hope is the Hamas leadership will be dismantled at the same time.
5. good start
Jared ,   Stillwater, USA   (11.19.12)
Sounds good, but Wat is Israel giving in return?
6. Will Israel never learn ?
Nathan Rai ,   bangalore   (11.19.12)
I read in the papers of Israel bombing "a family" , Israel "firing at homes and killing women and children" Israel needs to tell the world repetitively and loudly that Hamas has used homes, schools and mosques for arms caches. Tell the world and now and forever, arms caches, launching pads will be destroyed, whereever they are. Period. Israel holds the jihadis and mujahids responsible for the death of non combatants and women and children under whose homes they have buried arms caches. Tell everyone now. Let Hamas and Hezbollah hear. It will be more useful that telling the world that Israel is going to bomb Gaza back to the stone age.
7. GREAT! Now Move ON!
Joshua ,   USA   (11.19.12)
Now that the bullshit clearly prove that there's nothing to talk about, let the IDF ground operation to clean Gaza begin. It is 7 years overdue. The IDF needs to re-occupy Gaza, clean all the weapon systems and when all that is done - if there are some sane, trustworthy leaders there who would rather serve their people's long term interests instead of trying in vain to destroy Israel, hand them the reins and pull back out. Anything else is nothing but excuses and bullshit.
8. israel's demands
real vision ,   usa   (11.19.12)
I like the 15 year lull and the immediate cessation of arms smuggling and transfer of weapons to gaza...THERE IS NO WAY HAMAS AND THE REST OF THE ISLAMIC TERRORIST SCUM WILL BE TRUSTWORTHY HERE
9. HAMAS..
shimon vega ,   Beer Sheva Israel   (11.19.12)
10. Israel's demands are reasonable
ARI ,   LOS ANGELES   (11.19.12)
deep in my heart i wish hams will denied all of them then we can Overthrown those murders and make some Peace for Southern Israel
11. Obama is flying immediately to Gaza and
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (11.19.12)
postponing his trip to all the communist far eastern nations. He's gonna put a stop to Bibi and his agenda to make Israel safe.
12. 15 yr peace plan
jackie holland ,   sherman texas   (11.19.12)
I am wondering if our President Obama might offer a shorter plan, more like 7 years peace!
13. Bomb them every day
steve from raleigh   (11.19.12)
For 15 years. Twice on Fridays.
14. jew lover
bryan ,   Washington,DC   (11.19.12)
hamas is done for only if netanyahu will stand up for the rights of the nation he was sworn in to protect.
15. Brilliant idea.
Peter Morris ,   New Zealand   (11.19.12)
I am sure Hamas would welcome a "lull". That also means a complete non violation of Gaza airspace. i.e. A total ban on assasinations. No civillians should ever have lethal drones or predator aircraft hovering above them. There are many other factors relevant but as far as I can see it has usually been Israeli actions causing a reaction.
16. 'Hudnah' ...Disqualifies truce.
Roland Seener ,   London England   (11.19.12)
17. Arabs
edouard ,   Montreal Canada   (11.19.12)
Even if Hamas agree to evry single point they are not trustable and who will garanty this accord????? Other Arabs !!!! A Muslim brotherhood world figure will protect israel against a Hamas terrorist Sure I feel much better now
18. as long as Barak is DM,hamas has nothing to fear
CHAIM.S 54ST ,   BROOKLYN NY   (11.19.12)
as long as this pathetic cowardly self hating jew hating Barak is defence minister,Hamas has nothing to fear,no harm will come their way, people of Israel,with a traitorous government like this one,you are doomed. make sure,in the coming elections,you vomit them out,or else pack your bags and leave and put out the lights
19. Never Happen
Ezra ,   San Diego USA   (11.19.12)
These agreements will never materialize.
20. Endgame Endgame Endgame
Bill ,   New York, USA   (11.19.12)
Bibi may yet be the best negotiator Israel has ever had. If this is Israel's negotiating position, it is sheer genius. Everybody wants the blockade lifted? OK, but 15 year peace publicly backed by Hamas and Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood. Israel's crossings closed and Egypt's open? Gaza is full detached from Israel and becomes an Egyptian principality. No more of this pause now for jihad later. All totally reasonable negotiating positions and if rejected, the ground forces move. Bye bye Hamas. Bye bye Gaza.
21. GOOD!
Ellen ,   Israel/NYC   (11.19.12)
It is about time that israel starts listing OUR demands and what WE want. I am so tired of the Palys demanding and Israel being the bad one for not giving in. Funny, how they don't like the shoe on the other foot. It may be time to return Gaza to its' natural state.
22. Next In Line
Sasquatch ,   Vancouver, Canada   (11.19.12)
Nazrallah should be watching this closely. Once the IDF has wiped out Hamas - Hez in next in line
23. Finally
Dony ,   Canada   (11.19.12)
Egypt, your little brat brother is calling.
24. Are we serious...we're eating shit!!
You've ,   Tel aviv   (11.19.12)
25. Gaza and Hamas
ltrail ,   United States   (11.19.12)
I believe that it is time for the State of Israel to restore its authority over Gaza and eliminate the hamas host authority. Hamas has proven it cannot peacefully control the territory, nor be a good neighbor. Time for hamas to be disbanded one way or the other.
26. terrorist win again
frank ,   rehovot   (11.19.12)
correct, they will win. Why? because we do not have the stones to complete the mission and the world will not let us. If we cannot completely defeat and crush them, we lose, again. They will cry, oh, our poor crippled orphaned snotty nosed children, look world what those zionists are doing. And the world will look and cry for them and blame us. Completely forgetting that we are defending ourselves and fighting animals that threatened those very same people that are crying for them. Oh we will lose again becasue we cannot defeat the world press and that is what we are most in fear of.
27. the above sounds like something out of "SF" movie!!
tom ,   tel aviv   (11.19.12)
28. Obama interfering
Michael ,   Kokhav Ya'ir, Israel   (11.19.12)
I wish that were the case but Obama is now interfering to save Hamas.
29. What part of 'stop attacking us' does Pali's not get?
Israeli ,   Haifa   (11.19.12)
They stop attacking us, firing upon our communities and soldiers, stop arming, stop terror and no prob! Borders can open and the the blockade can lift. Palli's can't have a lifted blockade as long as they smuggle arms in to fire on our communities. Attacking their fishermen? Has there been arms found in the fish holds? GET A CLUE GAZA!
Cameron ,   USA   (11.19.12)
Next talkbacks
Back to article