Jewish Scene
Warsaw Ghetto courier dies at 90
Ynet
Published: 26.11.12, 15:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
37 Talkbacks for this article
1. Z""L
mark ,   ca   (11.26.12)
2. What a bad witness about the Poles - felt satisfaction!
Jouko ,   Finland   (11.26.12)
3. here we are again today
jew ,   europe   (11.26.12)
people never change. today also all are indifferent some even satisfied with all arabs against israel and again there is no justice.
4. #3- History repeats itself over and over
Mark ,   Boston USA   (11.26.12)
5. May I add ? ,...
split ,   US   (11.27.12)
She conveniently failed to mention that there was a death sentence (collective punishment) for helping Jews for the one that helped, his/her family and even neighbors in occupied Poland. If they, the Poles were the way she portray them then how did she managed to survive as a courier and weapons smuggler, where did she get those weapons from Germans?
6. To #3
Thomas ,   Poland   (11.27.12)
You are deeply mistaken. I think you haven't been in Poland. In that forum are many people who are the same like you. Only stupid people make fun of somebody's harm. It is very surprising that Jews usually blame Poles especially Christians but they always trying to hide the actions people like Henryk Mandelbaum. Is it unfair ?? I like Israel state but regarding to that case it seems to me that I'm unwise.
7.  We had illegal synagogues, illegal classes, illegal meeting
split ,   US   (11.27.12)
... not to mention a whore houses, restaurants, booze distilleries, loud parties etc. while the less fortunate been dying on the streets from a cold and starvation ,... Google 'Henryk Ross' on images to learn about the other ghetto ,... A war is not a party but to consider the Jews as a sole victims in black and white and blaming others that they didn't risk their own and their loved ones lives to save them is simply too much to swallow for someone having an access to web and google ,...
8. @5 Did you read the article?
Miron ,   USA   (11.27.12)
9. # 6 :To Thomas:
jew ,   europe   (11.27.12)
I am from Slovakia so yes i have been in Poland and i know that like in Ukraina , Slovakia, Hungaria, Poland there were very indifferent with what was going on, and till today people dont like jewish there .. so please who is deeple mistaken is you. of course there were few people who helped even risked lives for helping, hiding but number 6 000 000 (usualy from central and east europe) something proves, right? And everybody know that poland was most "indifferent" ...
10. very easy mathematic
jew ,   europe   (11.27.12)
few 1000s against 6 000 000 (only dead) we dont count survives !! so pleaseee we dont denay people who helped but please dont tell me they couldnt do more i know there were also non jewish victims but still THIS NUMBER.. and we know even before people hated jews .... and please dont let me speaka about people who robbed them all and when they took all they gave theirs name to SS .. and many more stories yes the people were indifferent dont try to change history ! and now it is the same , they close eyes if this (arabs) will happen to germany whole world would fight and help
11. #10
Thomas ,   Poland   (11.27.12)
Why don't you try to understand that Poland was under German's occupation. People were deadly scared. They would be killed. My grandfather was beaten by the gestapo. He almost died. I could say like you did that people were indifferent. Why the whole world was indifferent ? After many so years you dare say tell that most of the people were indifferent. What is your family's contribution against WW2.
12. # 11
jew ,   europe   (11.27.12)
are you crazy?? do u want tell that this happen because people loved jews? it wasnt first time that kingdoms and gaverements persued jews. I dont say that they are guilty but most of them liked this idea of throwing jews away from poland. (i dont say killing because i admitt that they didnt know what was HitlerĀ“s plan) There were goverments that payed to German to come and take them(all documented) This is history that Poland was antisemitic. Your grandfather almost died but 6 000 000 people died and all others suffered in other way. how i said i dont denay for sure lot of poeple helped or wanted but was scare .. but dont tell me that poland loved jews!!!!
13. #11
Thomas ,   Poland   (11.27.12)
How do you explain that fact that Jews were in Poland form XV th century until WW2. Poland was the most friendly country for Jews. Tell me the same about Spain. The Spain is antiSemitic. Compare Poland's history and Spain's history and you find out where lived more Jews. In the Spain or in the Poland. The whole world know about Hitler's plan. Do you even know about Jan Karski. Who he was ?? Don't tell that Poland hates Jews.
14. # Thomas
jew ,   europe   (11.27.12)
anyway i dont understand why you attacked me. what i said in my first comment was that today there are arabs who publicly declere to destroy Israel, Palestina that throw bombs on Israel almost every day and again there is nobody who stood up for Israel. What Poland did? Hungary? Italy? England? where are they AGAIN ??
15. 12 - do u want tell that this happen because people loved je
split ,   US   (11.27.12)
No because they hated and hate you there and everywhere. First. No one invited you there or anywhere you invided them and tried to impose your lifestyle and customs just the way they do today in Beit Shemesh or Mea Shearim in Israel or Postville, Monsey, New Square, Kiryas Joel in US and Outremont in Canada to name few places where they dwell and ripping off local population. It would be much wiser to to take a good look at the roots of hate toward you rather than pointing a finger and bitching at others,... By the way you have to remember that out of those around 3.5 million Jews in pre WWII Poland over 3.2 million were an isolated/parasitic entity (just like the one in Beit Shemesh today) with over 70% that couldn't communicate i native (Polish) language and over 90% read and write despite of 800 years there ,...
16. # 8 - I did ,...
split ,   US   (11.27.12)
Do you really believe that the Poles would sell any weapons, forge documents or hide Jewish kids at the request from someone they didn't know ? ,...
17. no 10
Sasha ,   US   (11.27.12)
This is not a valid argument since one could argue that Christian Poles also were bystanders when other Christian Poles were beaten, imprisoned and killed. Historians calculate that around almost 3 million Christian Poles were murdered by the German Nazis. Could they have been saved by those so you called bystanders? Yes or no?
18. @16 sounds like you missed a part.
Miron ,   USA   (11.27.12)
19. @15 what are you spoiting?
Miron ,   USA   (11.27.12)
How does the Earth bears this sort of people?
20. #10
Ja ,   Poland   (11.27.12)
I am a Pole. My grandfather's brother was arrested by the Germans in 1939. He was arrested because he was a Pole and a small village mayor. Everyone in the village knew that he had been arrested. At that days local teacher and prist were also arrested. It was a so-called Intelligenzaktion carried out by the Germans to exterminate the Polish nation. His wife sneak in at night to bring him something to eat by the window. After a few days he was taken and murdered in the woods, along with thousands of other Poles. Can you say that the other villagers were 'indifferent' and did nothing to save them? What would you do in their place? During IIWW killed more than 3 million Poles. What other nations present in our land have done to save them?
21. #14 Jew Europe
Thomas ,   Poland   (11.27.12)
I didn't meant to attack you. I'm really sorry that Arabs publicly declare to destroy Israel. It is very difficult to stand it for Israeli people. I can ensure you that those countries won't take any actions. It is very sad. Poland had many friends before the WW2 but when the WW2 really started none gave a hand. I can only say GOD BLESS ISRAEL. Israel must be protected by IDF and musts count only on itself .
22. 13 ,...
split ,   US   (11.27.12)
In many ways Spain's history resembles the one of Poland's except for the part of conquest of foreign lands in case of Spaniards and in case of Poles of their neigbors. Both nation's rulers allowed the Jews to run their tax enforcement and financial affairs, as a result of it both ended up with empty coffers, broke and bankrupt, loss of superpower status. At the end got stabbed in the back by Jewish squatters that collaborated with every enemy that showed up at their borders and in case of your country with loss of statehood and independence ,...
23. to all polaks
jew ,   europe   (11.27.12)
if you will read my first comment you will see that i didnt blame poland!! i only said that "people were indifferent" general ... and also i repaeted that i know what was situations. there were also others victims, people died for helping others or for fighting for freedom, o simple becouse they were poles or slovaks or russians... and it should never repeat again.
24. # 15
jew ,   europe   (11.27.12)
there is no need to comment your post you can argue with people who use brain and are sane but with insane it is wasting time only
25. 17 - Historians calculate ,...
split ,   US   (11.27.12)
Try to speculate in case of holocaust the way you just did in case of Poles and you won't see the daylight for a few years in PC Europe ,...
26. 21 - Dude ,...
split ,   US   (11.27.12)
don't like your pinhead, apologetic, submissive ass kissing style. Get some balls if you stand for Poles or take a hike ,...
27. #26 still not worth for comment
jew ,   europe   (11.27.12)
28. #26
Thomas ,   Poland   (11.27.12)
I'm not a pinhead. I told to the "jew, europe" that Poles aren't antisemitic. Many Israeli people and Jews spread very stupid facts about Poland. I don't know why they are doing it. Is it wrong that I like Israel ?? Many Poles live in Israel. I don't like people who denigrate Poland deliberately.
29. 28 - I'm not a pinhead ,...
split ,   US   (11.28.12)
So do me a favor, don't try not to defend Poles by kissing jewish ass ,...
30. # 29 you must have a serious problem with self esteem
jew ,   europe   (11.28.12)
split , i wont even continue to judge maybe you had serious troubles when you was a child or maybe you are still a child... but if you will lokking for help it will be better for your future angry haters neonacist are out ! if you hate jews why are you on this page? ahh you are looking for fight, right? and you are trying express your hate ...hmm dont bother and go play Xbox p.s bthw people were once submissive to monsters like you and it didnt end up good. desapear if u can!
Next talkbacks
Back to article