News  World News
US: Israel's settlement plans provocative
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 18.12.12, 23:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
63 Talkbacks for this article
1. Why Can't these morons...
Stan Marsh ,   South Park, USA   (12.19.12)
see that the Arabs are not interested in peace at any price and never have been?
2. Forget international pressure
David ,   Israel   (12.19.12)
As much as I am not a fan of settlement construction, we are condemned either way we might as well just ignore it and do what's best for our country. Rockets, bombs on civilian buses, attempted kidnappings of soldiers a checkpoints, attacks of families in their homes when they sleep faces little international criticism. A little construction in an area that may be disputed as Palestinian but was never Palestinian and was actually Jordanian once rightfully seized from an attacking army in war. My only concern is about the safety of the soldiers that will have to guard this area. No sympathy for the Palestinians , they aren't worthy of any when they plot to kill us on a daily basis more then advance themselves in education etc. Truth be told, politics or not, our land or theirs, historic or not, Israel will be far more productive for it then the Palestinians ever would!
3. First and formost
Neomi   (12.19.12)
i want to see the US tackle the massive assault weapons problem they have. I want to see them change their mentality and deal with their own extremists... Then, and ONLY THEN can they give us instructions on how to do what !
4. BUILD-BABY-BUILD...AND TELL THEM TO SHUT-UP!
David ,   NY   (12.19.12)
5. Why can't these morons...
Robert ,   Australia   (12.19.12)
see that Israel is not interested in peace at any price and never has been?
6. the germanic countries britain, france and germany
zinovy   (12.19.12)
lead the way the density of jewish population in palestine incl. israel is 3 times higher than the arab one israeli propaganda is weak
7. Election Ploy
Zechariah   (12.19.12)
It's probably an election ploy like Obamas election ploys in 2008 every democratic election campaign has it.So E1 ought be something better greater in peace making.Neverthe less Israel is surrounded by Jihadi by UltaNationalist Fascists and there are a billion plus .The moderates are in danger like the Nashabis before WW2 who were butchered and tortured in foul barbaric ways.
8. Plymouth Was Provocative!
zelig ,   memphis   (12.19.12)
And Jamestown was unfortunate.And every other square foot of what we call "America" from Prudoe Bay to Tierra Del Fuego was wrenched from the hands of one Indigenous American tribe of Indians or another. And ther "Indians" ? They fought each other for land all the time.And what of our "purchases"? Where did the French effendis get Louisiana from? Did they win it on the Price is Right? And what of the Russian effendis who once "owned" Alaska.Who in the world gave Alaska to them. Who the h-ll was William Seward to buy it,either?The American Southwest was Mexican.The Mexican war was a set up job.. a land grab. What about Hawaii? Or The Phillipines?And And who gave Portugal Brazil? Who gave South America to Spain? But don't ask Nuland.She might get nervous,fall down,hit her head,get a concussion or something. No don't ask "state" anything! Just listen and obey.That's the Obama-Morsi way!
9. us; Deeply Disappointed By DECSION
(12.19.12)
Israel; We are sorry to hear that? Now Get Over It!!!!!!!!!!!!!
10. Hey b.H.o. Instead of IMPEADING ISRAELI
(12.19.12)
Matter's!!!! And Save A Few syrian innocents from Being Murdered By their dictator's government and army? Bibi Knows Who you are and what you are??????????????????????????? BTW Bibi is 200% more Man Than You will ever be mr president!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
11. RE-JERUSALEM HOUSES
Esther ,   Selkirk Canada   (12.19.12)
FATHER GOD ALMIGHTY GAVE ISRAEL THIS LAND... WHAT GOD SAYS STANDS....PERIOD PALESTINIANS=ARABS HAVE 22 VAST LARGELY EMPTY SURROUNDING LANDS..WHERE IF THEY TRULY WANTED PEACE -THEY COULD GO LIVE IN MUSLIM LOVE & PEACE THAT WOULD BE THE RIGHT-SANE THING FOR PALS TO DO... & NOT TO FORCE ISLAM AGENDA- WILL IN PROVOCATIVE UNILATERAL UNRIGHTEOUS..UNJUST SINFUL UN-WORLD EXTORTION OF MONIES & SYMPATHY SOLICITATION PALESTINIANS ARE FIGHTING AGAINST GOD ALMIGHTY... GOD ALWAYS WINS... VERY FOOLISH OF ABBAS & COMPANY TO CONTINUE STIRRING THIS POT OF SATAN NONSENSE ISRAELI PALESTINIANS COULD BE THE NEXT EGYPT..SYRIA...HELL-OF-A-MESS AT LEAST UNDER ISRAEL..PALS HAVE BEEN RELATIVELY SAFE-PROTECTED....IF ..THEY BEHAVE ABBAS...BE GRATEFUL... FOR WHAT YOU HAVE...FOR THINGS CAN CHANGE REAL FAST
12. #2 And that's why West doesn't want it for Israel
Avan   (12.19.12)
" Truth be told, politics or not, our land or theirs, historic or not, Israel will be far more productive for it then the Palestinians ever would! " And that's why West doesn't want it for Israel, So they will have more advancement and keep Israel dependent on them as much as possible.
13. UNSC '67 borders coming to Jews near you, soon
Steven Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (12.19.12)
14. Condemnation
Paul ,   Vancouver   (12.19.12)
Hypocrites. Perhaps Israel should condemn construction on "Indian land" in the US as an obstacle to peace in the middle east. Absurd. Israel, face it - you are alone. Stand and be strong.
15. Clearly reject monstrous Two State Final Solution!
Chaim ,   Israel   (12.19.12)
The time is long overdue for Israel to stop playing games. Stop pretending we are trespassers on our own land. Stop pretending we accept the monstrous, evil Two State Final Solution. This land is ours now and forever. Let us serve the U.N., E.U., all world governments, media and religious organizations with absolute legal proof.
16. Construction
Stanley Feist ,   Boynton Bch, Fl.   (12.19.12)
Is this not land that belongs to Israel? Who has the right to tell Israel where and how to build on its on land. This will make no difference to the Arabs who want only to push Israel into the sea.
17. Israel builds because PA abandons talks
Bob k ,   Orlando usa   (12.19.12)
The PA abandoned the 'Oslo 'peace' Accords mechanism of land for peace by refusing to hold talks these past 4 years and going to the UN for symbolic statehood. When Israel transferrred Gaza to the PA, the latter were unable to control it and were driven out in gunbattles with hamas. The Gaza terrorists have fired thousands of rockets into Israel. Both the PA and hamas' actions are fatal to the any land for peace process. In rresponse Israel issues 'plans to build' no actuall building yet the world condemns. The world does not condemn the PA's unilayeral moves nor take steps to stop Gaza rockets which threaten Israel's civilian population. In the face of such world hypocrisy, Israel acts to protect its people's defense.
18. PLO takes unilateral actions counter to OSLO in UN
Chaim Ben Kahan ,   Efrat, Israel   (12.19.12)
Regardless of what Israel's enemies do, Israel will always be blamed. Recently, We have seen multiple violations of OSLO by the PLO-Hamas. We have seen rockets fired into our cities, and the PLO went to the UN which is against every agreement signed under OSLO. Meanwhile, Israel develops settlements which are allowed under OSLO and are condemned? This is blatant antisemitism and anti-Israel methodology. Area E-1 was always destined to be part of Israel in any agreement. Rabin made this clear to Arafat and Arafat signed OSLO knowing this, so what has changed???
19. Hey Stan
Kyle Broflovski ,   South Park/Miami, US   (12.19.12)
The problem is that if Israel annexes more land for settlements, two states will be impossible, and Israel will be forced by the world to make the Palestinians full citizens of Israel. As a Jew, I can not let that happen. You're my friend, Stan. Please support 2 states for 2 people.
20. Urban Expansion Is NOT a Settlement
emanon ,   USA   (12.19.12)
Multistory apartments and condos, terraced houses and obviously long term housing is planned urban expansion. A collection of shacks, tents and trailers / caravans is a settlement. What Israel is building are permanent homes. That makes this urban expansion. It is Israeli land adjacent to existing Israeli cities. This is urban expansion. Urban expansion is the sign of a healthy economy and a growing population, What the arabs are preaching is jealousy and hatred. What the United States want Israel to do is irrelevant since Israel is not part of the US.
21.  U.S. State Dept. doesn't speak for the U.S.!
john ,   USA   (12.19.12)
"In an unusually harsh statement, State Department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland told reporters that Washington was "Deeply disappointed..." I'm a U.S. citizen and State Dept. spokeswoman doesn't speak for me or majority of Americans. I applaud Israel building anywhere in Jerusalem, Judea, Samaria, Gaza,Golan-its your land! The Islamics are the imperialist invaders and occupiers.
22. Settlements
Cheryl ,   Chicago, IL   (12.19.12)
We have the right to build as many settlements as we want in our Land. America and the EU can scream all they want. Israel has done everything possible for peace and we are paid back with terrorism. WE WILL BUILD!
23. US & EU are provocative!
Benny ,   Iran   (12.19.12)
The US,EU & cohorts are continuously provoking the Arabs to riot in Israel & attack Israel from within & without. That is the ultimate provocation. These so-called irresponsible leaders are "callous" & are guilty of promoting the most dangerous Islamic cults of Hamas,Muslim Brotherhood & the other terrorists, Fatah, PLO etc. It is time they STOP, or the curse shall be upon them.
24. Screw World Opinion!!!
Jake Stone ,   USA   (12.19.12)
Israel: It's your land, so build as much as you like!!!
25. Israel please build as many as u can & ASAP
(12.19.12)
26. Shameless double standards
Tarbouche ,   Aswan   (12.19.12)
borne out of raging anti semitism . The world has never been more dangerous for Jews. Nazi, Arab, anti religionists have combined to attack the weakest Abrahamic religion. This grouping chose not to hear Iran's calls for wiping Israel off the Map. Mashaal's claim from the sea to the river.. Jews would do well to stay alert and strong
27. Tired of my government
Lee Chabin ,   NY, US   (12.19.12)
shooting its mouth off. There is not enough balance. If the US hopes to be a mediator accepted by the Arab world, appeasement is a questionable strategy. I believe the entire Middle East is better off when the US stands for truth - not all of which is on Israel's side of course. But Obama needs to lead. A big part of the truth is that the PA (not to mention Hamas) hasn't done nearly enough to prepare their people for peace. The truth is that the world holds Israel to a double standard, and the EU, and much of the rest of the world needs to be held accountable. No only has Obama failed to lead in regard to the Middle East, but some of his statements in the past have hurt Israel. I am not proud of my government.
28. The Truth...
Old Solly ,   New Jersey, USA   (12.19.12)
is that Obama is following though on his plans, including appointments for Sec of Defense and State. EU and the world will continue to isolate Israel no matter what it does. There is only one answer, which Israeli Jews want: annex all land within the security wall, maintain a security presence by the Jordan river, and call it a day. US funding will dry up, but that is a small price to pay for independence. The American public (including American Jews) will support this, if it is done soon
29. fair is fair!
ilan ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (12.19.12)
palastinians declare intentions to apply for statehood. they were criticized and condemned. they did it anyways, got what they wanted and now no one gives a damn! now Israel declares intentions to build where Israel unilaterally decided that E1 belongs to them! fair is fair! this is what happens when countries unilaterally declare intentions that affect other countries! pali's got one, now Israel gets one! i don't think it takes a genius to realize that this was done on purpose in retaliation. and that's the point! if each side starts declaring things, we're gonna get no where fast!!! of course Israel is no longer the underdog it was 60 years ago. we worked very hard to get where we are today, instead of milking it!
30. Kol ha kavod-may you act to provoke not only strength
Kerwood Derby ,   Frostbite Falls   (12.19.12)
in your own people by living in the land of your own name, but the admiration of freedom loving people everywhere who love their land. This just in-arubes everywhere have now renounced claims against other peoples and have actualized their potential of self identity and unilaterally enforced their right of return back to the homicidal Hamite peninsular homeland of their own name so they won't have to be killed when they come to kill you when they extort the land of your own name.
Next talkbacks
Back to article