News
Livni: Radical Right promotes violence against soldiers
Moran Azulay
Published: 29.12.12, 13:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. We, of the Centre-Left...
Michael ,   Haifa   (12.29.12)
...have to understand that the thuggery of the right wing is now the normative thinking of the majority of Israeli citizens..it's a pity, but is true
2. Army is to serve t he people
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (12.29.12)
which they haven't done by forcing Jews to leave their home unwillingly
3. 2
zionist forever   (12.29.12)
Soldiers follow ALL orders they do not pick and chose which ones they follow based on their conscience. Where is the difference between soldiers refusing orders because of their conscience the leftists who dodge the draft because of their conscience? What happens if we go to war and a pilot refuses to drop a bomb on a building full of terrorists but one of those terrorists brought his children with them so this pilot decides he can't destroy a building if there are children in it so he doesn't drop his bomb? Do we say forgive and forget to that pilot because he followed his other orders or do we say he broke that one so he will be punished? When we start allowing soldiers to pick orders we lose wars and people will lose respect for the IDF because the majority do not think as Bennet does. If these clashes continue or we do start getting soldiers refusing orders its going to be Livni or Shely as the next PM and I doubt them will protect the precious settlements.
4. Bennett and the settlers...............
Merkaz ,   Tel-Aviv.   (12.29.12)
along with their deranged rabbis showing their true faces. Dont be fooled by the smile of their front man Bennett, they are dangerous extremists.
5. This is the reaction of normal beings
Akiva ,   Maaleh Adumim   (12.29.12)
To eviction. You aren't losing your property, so you don't care.
6. Simply full of sh-t
Ilan   (12.29.12)
Tipi is off the deep end in blaming Bennett
7. They wouldn't do it if they settled the Negev.
Michael ,   California, USA   (12.29.12)
Since the occupation started, Israel is digging its own you know what.
8. 5
zionist forever   (12.29.12)
When they were destroying Gush Katif some residents dug in prepared for a fight but rabbis told them not to fight soldiers so it was a relatively peaceful evacuation even if it did upset alot of soldiers and residents. Rabbi's are now fighting soldiers trying to evacuate the settlements so they can be demolished conveniently just days after Bennet's stupid remark. The people who live in remote outposts were not obsessed with building for the sake of building and they would do the smart thing thing by living in reasonably sized places make them into the next Maaleh Adumim which is to big for any government to destroy ( tactical building no idealism).
9. to Michael@1
Jennie ,   Israel/US   (12.29.12)
You should know by now, that no matter what we, as a Nation do, will never be "approved" by our enemies...They will always strive for our destruction... Therefore, it is our goal to be strong and keep what is ours...There is nothing more rightfully ours, then Yehuda and Shomron, which is not only our Biblical land, but we have deliberated it during defensive wars, our soldgers gave their lives to free our cherished historical treasure... We have earned the full right and duty to own Yehuda and Shomron, Michael ! The Jewish Israeli patriots, who live there, have the full right to dwell on the land of our Forefathers... They deserve to be cherished, not scorned.. If G-d forbid, we give up this strategically important land, Israel will pay a very heavy price..
10. to no. 1
Jennie ,   Israel/US   (12.29.12)
Can you give this board some examples of the rightists "thugery", Michael ? And if the majority of Israelis are choosing to get on the "right" political side, why is this so bad for Israel ? My personal opinion is, that having Livni as the best candidate, the left has to offer, is not an option of choice for the Nation....
11. You of the center-left need some remedial democracy
brian cohen ,   judean peoples front   (12.29.12)
Scyooz me, Michael, but your oversimplistic stereotyping shows that you understand little of democracy. It's like me branding you the danger because the extreme-left calls for soldiers to disobey orders and tries to persuade kids not to enlist.
12. Civil war is the only answer to these right wing holigans
Dovid ,   Haifa   (12.29.12)
13. Livni and the left
MC   (12.29.12)
All Livni can do is criticize. Usually it's Natanyahu now it's Bennett . She has no policy of her own to offer so she has to keep dabbling in attack. All this hot air from the inflated egos of the left will lead to disaster for Israel and it's only the strong right wing loyalty to the country that will assure it's survival.
14. #3 zionist - That's EXACTLY
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (12.29.12)
what the Nazi's had siaid, they were "Following Orders" A soldier is expected to follow orders and use his brains while doing it. Pray tell, sinze you're a Zionist, when was the last ttime your were in the IDF ?
15. Get a grip Livni!!!!
Eyal ,   Yerusahalim   (12.29.12)
Bennet is shomer shabbat so therefore has not lead anyone to a hill or told anyone to do anything.He only just found out about it after shabbat. Very low of you to attack someone with flase accusations who cant even respond for a day
16. If Nazi soldiers would refuse orders against their conscienc
Ali ,   Iraq   (12.29.12)
Holocaust would kill less than 6 million ppl.
17. very cheap livni
Michael ,   Yerushalim   (12.29.12)
Bennett has said nothing this shabbat, i think you forgot hes shomer shabbat. Stop making baseless attacks on people who are honouring shabbat and cant respond
18. 14 Ben Great argument !
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (12.29.12)
19. 14
zionist forever   (12.29.12)
Last time I was in the IDF was about 7-8 years ago. As for your comment about the Nazis how do you compare following orders to commit genocide and following orders to evict buildings for demolition? if you think they are just as bad as each other then you got some real problems. Armies don't function unless the follow all orders short of crimes against humanity they don't pick and chose orders which the will follow based on their conscience or anything else.
20. The true reason for this...
Taz Man ,   USA   (12.29.12)
...is only a small remnant believes in the Abrahamic Covenant...while most Jewish secularists' (godless heathens) could careless about the Promised Land! As God's prophetical Word says: only a small remnant, who finally accepts God's grace, will be saved when the Messiah (Yeshua) returns at his 2nd-Coming! God bless, Israel and his Jerusalem!!! A Christian Zionist
21. maybe policies of left cause problems??
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (12.29.12)
Back to article