Damn all these small minded, scared Israeli "Artists" !

you do not know the truth stupid. The land of Israel belong to the jewish people!! If you don't believe me look into every history book there is and you surly be convinced!

You need a reality check.Were you in a coma, living under a rock, on drugs, or living on another planet when the Palestinians were murduring thousands of Israelis with their suicide bombings as well as the thousands of rockets fired from Gaza at civillians in Israel.You are one sick puppy and need to get back on your meds.

What ''nation" are you talking about? Gaza is not a nation. As for the rest of your post, you are completely off your rocker & should be ashamed of yourself for comparing us Jews in Israel to the nazis. Shame on you Stan.

Wrong. Israel built the wall not to take more land but to keep the terrorists out & I am delighted to tell you that the wall works.

It is very difficult, if not impossible, to return to “negotiations” when the other side refuses to negotiate until you give them everything they want, no exceptions. Negotiations mean compromise but the “Pals” will have none of it. What planet do you live on?

This criticism is essentially correct. It does not really analyze 'The Gatekeepers' film and explain why six people who dedicated their lives to Israel's security should engage in a process which works to undermine it. It is Egoism of course, but it is also a misguided Idealism , and petty resentment which led them to put themselves above the political echelon they served under. One more seemingly small point. Where does Hagai Segal live that he writes an article in which he writes about 'goys' with contempt? Is there no respectable way of talking about non- Jews, but this pathetic galuty- one?

come from within. Why didn't they make a film about all of the Israelis killed or maimed by the "Palestinians", with or without a wall?

Oscar Winning Shoah Film Or Two Next Year. Maybe even in black and white for effect. Or maybe Tarrantino can do another Jewish porn film about murdering Nazis with even more ultra-violence. Whatever it is I'm sure "Hollywood" can do it.

"The six former Shin Bet directors who are interviewed in the film give a moral boost to goys who like to vilify Israel." "Goy"? Did a single editor look over this article before it was published?

Most people do not vilify Israel but object strongly to the positions of the current right wing government. Under Netanyahu Israel has and will continue to be self-destructive until its people wake up and find the entire world against their policies.

You are hysterical ! I did not mention Nazis and I did not mention Gaza.

most people villify Israel, Jews and Zionism, and use politics as a cover. What is self-destructive about self-defense? What is self-destructive about actually listening to what Hamas, Hezbollah and the PA say?; they will not accept Israel and want to kill the Jews. I guess you are hard of hearing...very hard of hearing.

What nation are you refering to in your post # 21? At whose hands did our people suffer most ? Try to answer these 2 questions Stan, if you can!

Did you think we were born yesterday, and missed the international villification of Israel that preceded Netanyahu under Labor, Kadima, and Likud governments? I guess you "forgot" that until recently, Tzipi Livni could not travel to the UK due to an arrest warrant against her, and Ehud Olmert was heckled and abused during all his speaking tours in the US.

of French pilots who conducted aerial bombings of Libya or Mali. Only anti-Israel, foreign-funded "Israeli" films and doumentaries win awards in the West.

The so-called wall (mostly fence) has protected the Israeli nation by seriously reducing the numbers of peoples killed on both sides:Israeli for being Israelis and Palestinians for attempting to kill the former.

It's remarks like yours that make people believe Israel is not a democracy. And technically, these critics are right

No, Stan, Your screaming in caps does make you hysterical! You have no concept of reality at all. There is no "Palistinian nation" and never was. And your insinuation that Israel is treating the Palis like they were treated over hundreds of years...who were you referring to: The Catholic church, Martin Luther and his gang, the French aristocracy in the 19th century, the Slavs, Estonians and other Baltic people...and others INCLUDING THE NAZI-GERMANS... they all had a crack at the Jews. And to accuse Israel of their behaviour is hysterical confabulation, lies, dementia and denial of reality worthy of any radical Muslim. You act like an ignorant baby whose knowledge is infantile!

Good shpiel.

Afraid of the truth, afraid of you. Simple

YOU deserve an Oscar. Thank You.